Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 12am too late to be hanging around outside for 15 year olds ?

285 replies

GreekGod · 07/02/2022 20:30

Over the weekend, four of our DD friends all 15 years old were involved in an awful accident and two of the girls are still in intensive care and they are in a critical condition. This has shook our community to the core and I just can't stop thinking about the parents who we know really well. Basically a car driven by an 18 year old at a great speed who just got his license hit two of the girls and the other two had minor injuries. The accident happened outside a coffee shop that is full of teenagers every Saturday night (13 to 16 year olds). My DD was also going to go out that evening to the same place but cancelled at the last minute as we were invited out to a family birthday meal. The accident happened at 12am on Sunday morning and today at the school there was a general discussion by some of the parents saying that they would never allow their children out that late and that the accident would never happened at an earlier time. They talked about attacks and rapes, joyriding and all sorts. We do allow DD out that late. She is a good kid, achieves excellent grades and is very respectful. She is also mature for her age. But it got me thinking. Are we wrong in allowing a 15 year old out at 12am in a group outside in a town with other 15 year olds? My DD could have quite easily been in intensive care herself and I now feel awfully guilty in giving her this freedom that could harm her ? I am so confused. AIBU in allowing a 15 year old to stay out till after 12am ?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 13:16

DrivelandNonsense, yes, I have all those things as does my DH but it doesn't really have anything to do with going out in an age appropriate way as a teenager. I'm not talking about at a superficial level which is what home ownership and good jobs are, I'm suggesting that forging out your own identity is paramount to a happy life. Being shoe horned in to a superficially 'good' life according to what your parents think is good is not going to achieve that. The Op was about a coffee shop and being at a coffee shop, how is that hanging around pointlessly?

This controlled fun (parents' notion of fun) is no fun when you are 15+. Every kid at uni with parents like that were the worst when it came to drugs, alcohol etc. As they could do what they liked and didn't opt for the late night cinema viewing! Are you for real, it reminds me of that Alan Partridge sketch when asks what his older teenager son is doing in bed at 12 o'clock on a Saturday, why is he wasting his life, it transpires his son is in bed with his girlfriend!

Beautiful3 · 08/02/2022 13:03

Yes that is too.late. I'd expect her back by 10.30pm

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 12:44

This is based on statistics not just oh I’m fine so it’s all good @Bolets

Alcohol use during the teenage years is related to a wide range of health and social problems

Drinking alcohol can damage a child's health, even if they're 15 or older. It can affect the normal development of vital organs and functions, including the brain, liver, bones and hormones.

Beginning to drink before age 14 is associated with increased health risks, including alcohol-related injuries, involvement in violence, and suicidal thoughts and attempts

Drinking at an early age is also associated with risky behaviour, such as violence, having more sexual partners, pregnancy, using drugs, employment problems and drink driving

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 12:42

@Bolets it’s not normal to be out drinking till 1am at 13 years old.

Bolets · 08/02/2022 12:40

@DrivelandNonsense I think my parents were great. Hanging out at the houses of friends my own age that I knew, with some experimentation with alcohol, was a very normal experience. We were all nice, working-class to middle-class kids, this was the early 2000s and my high school group I'm still in touch have close relationships with their parents, professional jobs, and most married by now. I'm not going to lie and say it was some horrific parental ordeal when it was very much the norm and turned out well adjusted adults.

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 12:39

@Goldenbear gosh yes I wonder how I have a successful career, own my own home, lovely family and friends and am highly educated when my parents didn’t let me wander around the streets after midnight 🙄🙄

Children can become well rounded by doing activities with their friends within normal hours
, by having hobbies and after school activities with exceptions as they get older for a late movie, a concert etc. Letting them hang around the streets after midnight is not good parenting in my opinion.

AryaStarkWolf · 08/02/2022 12:39

Bit late for 15 I think

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 12:33

DrivelandNonsense, you don't own your children, they are people in their own right and it is not great parenting in my opinion to stop them from establishing their own identity. Part of becoming an adult is about exploration and being in command of your own life, a big part of understanding that in the mid to latter teenager years is being around people your own age, having a depth of friendship that challenges notions of yourself and your character. You just can't get that from hanging off the apron strings. I actually think it is stifling to the imagination and ultimate success in a person's life. My DS is trusted and you can see he is very much in command of his own life already. He is really bright and does well at school, super confident, well liked and sociable. I don't want him to be a nervous wreck at home, gaming until his eyes pop out of his head and being scared of human interaction because of what 'might' happen, it is unhealthy to live with that fear and it is misplaced love in my opinion.

hopperrock · 08/02/2022 12:32

a 24 hour garage is a safe place after midnight for young teens?

I don't think a garage is a particularly dangerous environment for a group of teenagers, no, even after midnight. She's not what I'd call a young teen, she's 15 and Y11.

Honestly if I was at a late night garage at 1am and a group of teens were hanging out there

They go to the garage to buy snacks, not to hang out.

I don’t see why your daughter needs to be out all night anyway.

She's not out all night.

I’d wonder why they are so keen to be down on a deserted beach in the middle of the night.

I assume it's because beaches are nice places to be, and it's not deserted, there's a prom with restaurants, a cinema and people also live there. It's a busy place.

She comes home happy, sober, having had a good time with her friends. We live in a safe area. She's close to home. She's not out by herself. We know where she is and check in with her. I'm not trying to be contrary, I really can't see what's so controversial about it.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/02/2022 12:21

What did you think they were doing for hours? We have a McDonald’s nearby where teens hang out in cars - issues are vandalism & litter, drug or nitrous oxide use (and litter from it), sex in cars (condoms litter), reckless driving young teens racing often with passengers in car or stood nearby. And it’s a nice area! No knife issues etc.
As an aside it’s why teenagers insurance is so expensive as they tend to injure other teens not just themselves - assuming the girls live but with life hanging injuries those are massive claims for an insurer - 24 hr lifetime care for a 15 year old x 2.

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 12:14

@hopperrock a 24 hour garage is a safe place after midnight for young teens? A dark street is a safe place? Honestly if I was at a late night garage at 1am and a group of teens were hanging out there I would just assume their parents couldn’t care less about them or where they were.

It’s a very different scenario to being at a gig or late movie or late dinner with friends - all of which don’t require young teens to be out after midnight. I don’t see why your daughter needs to be out all night anyway. Can she not socialise with her friends during the day or in the evening? I’d wonder why they are so keen to be down on a deserted beach in the middle of the night.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/02/2022 12:09

Mum of just turned 16 year old and it would be a no for me. Too late. Hanging around for hours surely leads to no good.
As a one off eg a concert fine but just hanging around at a cafe no. I’m on the more lax end none of her friends would be allowed either.

hopperrock · 08/02/2022 12:09

of course no man would ever attempt to attack a girl out wandering the streets in the middle of the night when she has the protection of eh some other young girls.

She is with a group of boys and girls. I do think it's unlikely a man would attack her as a member of a group of people, some of whom are 6ft+ lads.

If you believe that why not let your 15 year old go to nightclubs, sneak into pubs and get drunk, go back to random people she doesn’t know houses for house parties, watch porn? All also exposures and risks.

You've missed the bit where I said assess the risks and benefits. The benefits of going to a nightclub / pub / getting drunk / going to strangers' houses / watching porn at this age do not outweigh the risks. Whereas imo, the risks of being out in a safe place close to home with her friends are very low, and she is gaining independence, having shared experiences, deepening her friendships, getting out of the house, spending time out in the world instead of watching tv or being online, becoming herself away from us, growing up and having fun.

The downside for us is as a PP says, having to stay sober so that we can pick her up, but for such a short time it's worth it. Especially as my saintly DH volunteers most of the time Smile

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 12:07

@Bolets and do you think being out until 1am at house parties drinking at 13 was a good example of parenting?

Bolets · 08/02/2022 12:02

@DrivelandNonsense I'm trying to remember more exactly - I think I went to first house parties around 13 or 14, I imagine curfew about 1 am (not school nights) and getting picked up. Not especially rowdy although there was drinking. 14+ I would go by train to the nearest big city with friends to see bands, the venues would let you in but not serve you any alcohol. Parents would come and pick us up after the gig, later we would get the train home.

16 was pretty much where it became free range - yes, I could say "I'll be home before 3am" and that would be okay, but usually we would stay over to not walk in the cold or dark. Always had the "if you need to get out of a situation you can call for any reason" as a backup. For the reference I lived in a pretty small and sleepy town, and my group of friends was quite sensible? Nothing more than 40 minutes walk away, or less on a bike. But we were also able to do day trips to other cities by train... I really enjoyed the level of independence we had.

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 11:42

Arguing that a teenager will be an adult in 3 years time is hardly a propesterious argument- surely it is about slowly allowing freedoms so when they turn 18 they can navigate their own lives with a good sense of risk assessment. How are they going to do that if they haven't been out past 7pm before turning 18!

I would say a 16+ is a young adult and many aspects of society support that idea; things like being able to join the army, the age of consent, the age of consent for medical procedures, joining clubs like the council gym or private gyms, being able to engage in paid employment etc. A 15 year old is one year away from the notion of a young adult. If you have a 13 year old it is not comparable IMO as they change hugely ime from 13 to 15. My DS will want to play football after school and in the summer evenings and he does occasionally got to Burger King in the evening although he has been to Five Guys with his cousin for a proper sit down meal at 7ish. They got back at 9 after that. I don't think these thing are particularly shocking or age inappropriate. My DS does play online Fifa with his cousin and friends but he's very sociable and would much rather see friends in person. IME of this age group it is quite immature to be gaming all night still and being happy with that. That was more the 13 year old stage. I really don't think Macdonalds at night time is something an 18 year old would be doing, not around here anyway! I do agree about girls and being exposed to men that are predatorish in nature at home time but I'm not sure that changes for an 18 year old girl as opposed to a 15 year old. My experience at uni, post uni, commuting home from London in my 20's, I had harassment quite regularly. It is something that doesn't suddenly become easy to navigate at 20 and I was always rubbish at dealing with it. Of course I should not have had to but i had friends that would tell these men to F off but i was terrified of doing that, this didn't change until 30s really where i became quite bolshy and assertive. I will always be available to pick my DD up when she gets to the teen years and when she is living with us as will my DH. I make myself available to pick up DS now as it is part of the rite of passage of bringing up a teenager. No wine for me now whilst my kids are tucked up in bed on a Saturday night. My friends with older children said this is what will happen and it has so I absolutely do not agree that a teenager is not old enough to go out if they are not older enough to get home on their own.

User1412 · 08/02/2022 11:31

My son is nearly 15 and I would not allow him out that late. However I certainly wouldn’t judge other parents that do.

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 11:28

@hopperrock of course no man would ever attempt to attack a girl out wandering the streets in the middle of the night when she has the protection of eh some other young girls.

Kids don’t need to be exposed to the risks of being out on the streets after midnight. That’s ridiculous. If you believe that why not let your 15 year old go to nightclubs, sneak into pubs and get drunk, go back to random people she doesn’t know houses for house parties, watch porn? All also exposures and risks.

hopperrock · 08/02/2022 11:14

[quote megletthesecond]**@hopeerock* @ducksuprise* no, he hasn't. He's out with mates all day at the skate park or playing football. There's no gigs around here and they aren't the type to hang around macdonalds in the evening. He's 15, not 18.[/quote]
I'm guessing we live in quite different places - a 15 year old who had never been out after 7pm would be very unusual here. Lots of them are out and about in the evening, especially in summer when the weather's nice.

hopperrock · 08/02/2022 11:09

Re safe area - no rapists / sexual offenders / criminals in your entire area and surrounding area? You’ve vetted the entire population? No visitors allowed to the area or people allowed to drive through?

I'm sure there are rapists and criminals here, and there are definitely visitors because we have those ourselves. But I don't think they pose a great risk to a group of teenagers walking along the street.

No pubs with drunken men spilling out at midnight to see young girls walking the streets?

We do have pubs and I'm sure people emerge from them drunk and some of those people will be men. I don't think that drunken men seeing DD walking along a street is a risk, and feel that she's safe in a group.

Kids are exposed to risk all the time and they need to be, if they're going to learn to manage risk by themselves. IMO parenting is about assessing the risks against the benefit and then mitigating them. And teaching the DC to do the same. But again, it's all contextual, I am saying this from a safe area with a sensible DD. I would be making different decisions if I lived somewhere more dangerous, or if she was less trustworthy. It's not out of the blue either, she has gradually built up to this from when she was younger, starting to walk to school or to the corner shop by herself etc.

megletthesecond · 08/02/2022 10:56

@hopeerock @ducksuprise no, he hasn't. He's out with mates all day at the skate park or playing football. There's no gigs around here and they aren't the type to hang around macdonalds in the evening. He's 15, not 18.

DrivelandNonsense · 08/02/2022 10:39

@hopperrock there is a happy medium between out in the dark walking the streets after midnight and having to be home at 4! So I don’t see why you’re using that example to justify your own crazy parenting! Re safe area - no rapists / sexual offenders / criminals in your entire area and surrounding area? You’ve vetted the entire population? No visitors allowed to the area or people allowed to drive through? No pubs with drunken men spilling out at midnight to see young girls walking the streets?

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 08/02/2022 10:37

[quote EmpressSuiko]@Hrpuffnstuff1 my mum was very strict with going out and I tried to challenge it without success! All my friends were allowed out until 8/9pm.
Once I turned 18 I had no restrictions, my parents only asked that I let them know I was safe and if I was staying out etc.[/quote]
I was a little more relaxed however, once the eldest began working she could decide for herself what to do.
She had my number on speed dial, I always said to her ring me at anytime and I'll come a lick you up if your in a situation that she felt was uncomfortable.

My parents were hyper religious, my dad was a nightmare, quoting scripture after scripture to subdue my teenage yrs.
A tad too controlling.

hopperrock · 08/02/2022 10:30

[quote DrivelandNonsense]@hopperrock sorry you’re saying your 15 year old daughter and her friends are out at midnight just wandering around the streets in the dark - and you’ve no issue with this? Madness.[/quote]
Yes - they often spend a Saturday evening together, usually at someone's house in the winter but often out for a trip to the shop or to relocate to someone else's house, or for a walk in the dark. In the summer they spend time at the beach or in the park and stay out late. I don't have a problem with it, no, as long as it's not a school night, she's in a group, I know where she is and she responds to texts from us checking on her. But we do live in a safe area and she's sensible. I wouldn't let her out alone late at night but she's quite risk averse and wouldn't want to be, she asks for lifts instead of walking home alone. I also don't have a problem with kids being "exuberant and daft" on the way in to school, as a PP describes, I don't think that's a sign that parents have relinquished control. And I certainly wouldn't have a curfew for a 15 year old of 4pm in winter and 7pm in summer unless supervised by an adult. That seems crazy to me.

EmpressSuiko · 08/02/2022 10:18

@Hrpuffnstuff1 my mum was very strict with going out and I tried to challenge it without success! All my friends were allowed out until 8/9pm.
Once I turned 18 I had no restrictions, my parents only asked that I let them know I was safe and if I was staying out etc.