Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if if you had an interview candidate who said something incredibly stupid

83 replies

saltedhotchoc · 07/02/2022 19:11

would it negate the rest of the interview?

Totally frazzled. Had important interview, was supposed to be in person but am COVID+ (symptomless) so we had to do online. DD9 not ill, but very worried about being ill as she also tested positive so being very clingy. Had a million one tech issues including my laptop going stone cold dead whilst I was introducing myself and I had to run and get my husbands iPad.

Interview went perfectly, everyone nodding happily as I answer, until we get to one question where I give the wrong answer. Interview asks me again, as he clearly wants to give me a chance to get it right. I get it wrong. We move onto further questions, and a different panel member butts in a asks me again, saying just want to give you a chance to redeem yourself (in friendly way), I give the wrong answer Blush Every question after that went well, but I felt like I was on autopilot.

It is something very very basic, they had praised my skills in this area based on my existing work, but it was like my brain was broken, I knew the answer but was saying it wrong. I am mortified. I feel not only have I wrecked my chances, but made a total idiot out of myself in front five very important people in my field.

AGH. I keep muttering IDIOT to myself which I know isn't helpful but I cannot believe my brain.

The worst thing is I think the panel genuinely wanted to hire me and I've made it impossible to do that, and it's going to so embarassing explaining to people why.

OP posts:
kleew1 · 07/02/2022 21:11

I did this during an interview, no excuse. And it was an economic answer to be given with a business/finance consultant mind. My answer was to do free parking and put furniture shops into city centres as people don't want to buy furniture online so that would create footfall and offer free coffee.

Still cringe. Hopefully this makes you feel better.

Isonthecase · 07/02/2022 21:07

Just email them and say the correct answer, covid is a great reason to have struggled!

Hayisforhorse · 07/02/2022 20:57

If it's public sector then there's usually a strict scoring system, which can mean they have to mark you down on that. OTOH if you scored overall high marks then you could still be ok if the other candidates scored less.

It sounds like they liked you and wanted to give you that chance. It might be worth emailing and giving the correct answer. If I wasn't using a strict scoring system and you were otherwise great then I might give you the benefit of the doubt. Having had Covid brain myself I can completely see why you struggled today.

I interviewed someone who said my profession's equivalent of 'I want to work in your butchers, but I don't like or approve of meat', or 'yes I'd love to be a teacher, I dislike children'. It's a bit of a niche job so can't give the real example, but it was truly jaw droopingly bad, and they did genuinely want the job. It cannot be worse than that interview. As a PP said it rendered them unappointable immediately.

pitterpatterrain · 07/02/2022 20:50

Ah. I must admit it made me think of the candidate when I asked him at the end of the interview if he had any questions for me (about the role / company) he started asking whether he could get a higher salary offer as he was having his first DC and was planning for private school …

He didn’t get the job

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/02/2022 20:46

@Tunnocks34

Yes, once in a teacher interview I had to teach a lesson, I ended up doing area of rectangles/squares and I drew a square on the board, labelled it square and gave it the measurements 6m and 4m 😳. I have an a level and a degree in maths.
I'm sorry but I'd pay money for a video of that! Grin
GrumpyTerrier · 07/02/2022 20:44

I did this once. They'd asked me what I could use ie spreadsheets, Word etc. I kept saying 'I can do databases, ie Excel'. They asked me again which program I used for databases, obviously to see if I would correct my mistake and I said Excel again! Then afterwards I realised. Nerves just got the better of me. The annoying thing was that I could use both Excel and Access! But I sounded like I was lying.

Tunnocks34 · 07/02/2022 20:24

Yes, once in a teacher interview I had to teach a lesson, I ended up doing area of rectangles/squares and I drew a square on the board, labelled it square and gave it the measurements 6m and 4m 😳. I have an a level and a degree in maths.

TheSunIsStillShining · 07/02/2022 20:18

look on the bright side: It's not that bad... you had everything else nailed. You actually have a chance,

Here's 2 stories to cheer you up.
I moved here for a job, but decided not to extend contract after 6 months, so started interviews. I am bilingual hungarian/english. I speak some german, but more kitchen german than anything else.
Went to an interview with a design agency and the interviewer had a german name. From that point on half the words came to me in german. He didn't speak german and I looked like an idiot and kept searching for the most basic words. This was a client facing role of course.

Another interview few years later ... went well, panel of 4 ppl, 2 never said a word, totally forgot their names too. Going out I walked into the door frame. You know, when you turn and the bloody thing teleports there. swore slightly in hungarian under my nose. Then got told off by the 4th man that it is not professional to "swear as a soda carriage driver". In perfect hungarian. Using the perfect hungarian phrase for it.

vickyc90 · 07/02/2022 20:06

Good luck OP if you don't have to get a minimum score on every question you might still be the highest scoring

MyBoysHaveDogsNames · 07/02/2022 19:50

I once interviewed someone who started speaking with a Jamaican accent. She wasn't Jamaican That was weird.

saltedhotchoc · 07/02/2022 19:45

@Imsittinginthekitchensink

I interviewed recently and a candidate gave such an alarmingly bad response to a question that she rendered herself unappointable immediately. Otherwise as pp says, it goes on a points basis in our place and you just will have got a bad score for that question.
Oh gosh, I am worried I am that candidate
OP posts:
saltedhotchoc · 07/02/2022 19:45

@YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp

I interviewed a man for a senior position, he started by slamming an A4 lever arch file full of paperwork on the table and saying that these were all the jobs he’d applied for. Then he said he hadn’t told his wife or children he was at the interview (he lived at least 200 miles away), they’d have to put up with moving when he got this job 😳 It didn’t get any better. I honestly couldn’t believe my ears, and he was very unpleasant when I phoned him later to say that he hadn’t been successful!
Well at least I know I didn't do this Grin
OP posts:
saltedhotchoc · 07/02/2022 19:44

@CorrBlimeyGG

Is there anything in your application that shows you know the right answer? When I've interviewed, I'd look at the application in this scenario, and try to find something to justify meeting that descriptor from there.
Yes all of it Blush

I can't in my COVID addled brain think of an example, but the questions were designed to test skills that I am really experienced in, and I was probably expected to score highest out of their candidates, and they had previously complemented me on my expertise in it

Sort of like a doctor forgetting what goes into calculating BMI?

OP posts:
Snakeplisskensmum · 07/02/2022 19:44

Definitely email, admit nerves got the better of you as you want the job so much. I did this when I completely cocked up a presentation. The fact that I acknowledged my mistakes went in my favour as I was seen as someone humble 🤷‍♀️

RedChapter · 07/02/2022 19:42

I'd echo that it's worth emailing them. I've interviewed people for years, points based and have occasionally had someone really nervous for example but o can see their experience would be valuable. So I've given a second chance.
You have covid, you think you have no symptoms but brain freeze might just be the one symptom you haven't realised. Not as an excuse but worth a bash. Good luck!

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 07/02/2022 19:41

I interviewed a man for a senior position, he started by slamming an A4 lever arch file full of paperwork on the table and saying that these were all the jobs he’d applied for.
Then he said he hadn’t told his wife or children he was at the interview (he lived at least 200 miles away), they’d have to put up with moving when he got this job 😳
It didn’t get any better.
I honestly couldn’t believe my ears, and he was very unpleasant when I phoned him later to say that he hadn’t been successful!

neverbeenskiing · 07/02/2022 19:40

I agree with PP you have nothing to lose by emailing them.

If it makes you feel any better, OP I once interviewed a woman who thought it was appropriate to get her phone out and show us a picture of her cats midway through the interview.

CorrBlimeyGG · 07/02/2022 19:39

Is there anything in your application that shows you know the right answer? When I've interviewed, I'd look at the application in this scenario, and try to find something to justify meeting that descriptor from there.

Merryoldgoat · 07/02/2022 19:36

@MrsTerryPratchett

Bloody hell - really?! Some people just astonish.

Merryoldgoat · 07/02/2022 19:35

@Imsittinginthekitchensink

I want to know what they said!!

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/02/2022 19:32

@Imsittinginthekitchensink

I interviewed recently and a candidate gave such an alarmingly bad response to a question that she rendered herself unappointable immediately. Otherwise as pp says, it goes on a points basis in our place and you just will have got a bad score for that question.
That's different. If it was safety or equality stuff, we wouldn't be hiring. Like the man who repeatedly referred to me as 'dear' after being asked not to. Hmm
Imsittinginthekitchensink · 07/02/2022 19:31

I interviewed recently and a candidate gave such an alarmingly bad response to a question that she rendered herself unappointable immediately. Otherwise as pp says, it goes on a points basis in our place and you just will have got a bad score for that question.

saltedhotchoc · 07/02/2022 19:29

@MrsTerryPratchett

We use points. If it was close a wrong answer might push someone else higher. You wouldn't 'fail' but they might get more points.

Golden golden rule. Do not ignore if they ask the same question. Breathe, think, wrote it down the give yourself time. Ask to come back to it. Don't give the same answer.

Yes I imagine they use points too, and I suppose it depends on whether others gave them a perfect score on everything.

AGH.

Totally - and I knew I was wrong, can't believe myself!

OP posts:
Clymene · 07/02/2022 19:28

I'd email them. What have you got to lose?

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 19:28

Sometimes the brain does let us down!

When doing my nursing degree, I was doing a Viva (oral exam). I was given a scenario and was asked what I would do first - I began to explain the assessment I would do on my patient. We would have to give a rationale for everything so I went to say the name of the organisation that gave the guidelines I was following. And my mind went blank. I knew this off by heart but I sat there for what seemed an hour umming and ashing!

I agree, email showing you do know the answer. It can't hurt. Good luck!