Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if if you had an interview candidate who said something incredibly stupid

83 replies

saltedhotchoc · 07/02/2022 19:11

would it negate the rest of the interview?

Totally frazzled. Had important interview, was supposed to be in person but am COVID+ (symptomless) so we had to do online. DD9 not ill, but very worried about being ill as she also tested positive so being very clingy. Had a million one tech issues including my laptop going stone cold dead whilst I was introducing myself and I had to run and get my husbands iPad.

Interview went perfectly, everyone nodding happily as I answer, until we get to one question where I give the wrong answer. Interview asks me again, as he clearly wants to give me a chance to get it right. I get it wrong. We move onto further questions, and a different panel member butts in a asks me again, saying just want to give you a chance to redeem yourself (in friendly way), I give the wrong answer Blush Every question after that went well, but I felt like I was on autopilot.

It is something very very basic, they had praised my skills in this area based on my existing work, but it was like my brain was broken, I knew the answer but was saying it wrong. I am mortified. I feel not only have I wrecked my chances, but made a total idiot out of myself in front five very important people in my field.

AGH. I keep muttering IDIOT to myself which I know isn't helpful but I cannot believe my brain.

The worst thing is I think the panel genuinely wanted to hire me and I've made it impossible to do that, and it's going to so embarassing explaining to people why.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
curiouscatgotkilled · 09/02/2022 20:01

Hurrah!! Well done!
Good luck with the negotiations, aim high!

2018SoFarSoGreat · 09/02/2022 19:51

great news, well done! Now negotiate hard. Go in high (but within reality realm!), tell them why you are worth it and what you will bring that makes you worth more. Then pause. Say nothing. Let him fill the silence. If he says 'well we were thinking this #, ask him if that was before or after finding you.

I have hired many, many people, mostly lawyers, and the men always ask for much more than the woman. ALWAYS. Don't be that woman.

crosstalk · 09/02/2022 18:23

Congratulations OP. Don't mention the problem while negotiating the salary. And make sure you start high on the negotiating. They've already decided you're the one so go in hard and FORGET THE QUESTION YOU DIDN'T ANSWER. They will balance this against the costs and time of hiring and interviewing people. And see if you can find out more about the wage structure including the manager negotiating with you.

oreosoreosoreos · 09/02/2022 16:38

I once interviewed someone who was young (so probably not much interview experience) and clearly very nervous. She interviewed terribly. At the end I asked if she would like some feedback and she said yes, so I gave her some. Then asked if she would like to come back tomorrow and try again with a clean slate. She did much better, and was one of the best people I ever hired!

amusedbush · 09/02/2022 16:11

Congratulations! I'm so pleased for you. There's nothing worse than your mind going blank in an interview, the panic is unreal.

I once inadvertently called the hiring manager old during an interview, and another time I said that trying to coordinate academic staff is like herding cats - to the academic on the panel. I got the job both times and now, many years later, I'm the flaky academic constantly apologising to the course administrator so the joke's on me Blush

TheKeatingFive · 09/02/2022 15:38

Yay, well done 🎉

Undecidedandtorn · 09/02/2022 15:35

@Mermaidwaves - I did not get the job

Fossie · 08/02/2022 23:57

@TheSunIsStillShining

look on the bright side: It's not that bad... you had everything else nailed. You actually have a chance,

Here's 2 stories to cheer you up.
I moved here for a job, but decided not to extend contract after 6 months, so started interviews. I am bilingual hungarian/english. I speak some german, but more kitchen german than anything else.
Went to an interview with a design agency and the interviewer had a german name. From that point on half the words came to me in german. He didn't speak german and I looked like an idiot and kept searching for the most basic words. This was a client facing role of course.

Another interview few years later ... went well, panel of 4 ppl, 2 never said a word, totally forgot their names too. Going out I walked into the door frame. You know, when you turn and the bloody thing teleports there. swore slightly in hungarian under my nose. Then got told off by the 4th man that it is not professional to "swear as a soda carriage driver". In perfect hungarian. Using the perfect hungarian phrase for it.

Those are great. Thanks for sharing.
SpiderinaWingMirror · 08/02/2022 23:49

I interviewed someone who told me he had targets but didn't take any notice of them!
Another who said proudly he hadn't had a fight in his latest job.

IlkaDoxie · 08/02/2022 23:46

Congratulations, SO happy for you as I recognised myself in this thread. I am shit at interviews thanks to congenital brain freeze - it's incredible I have ever found anyone to employ me at all, but somehow am in permanent employment most of the time. High five! Star

HaveringWavering · 08/02/2022 23:25

Brilliant news, congratulations!

FirstAconite · 08/02/2022 23:18

Well done, that's such good news. And at least you didn't peel anyone's nose Grin

Mooloolabababy · 08/02/2022 23:05

Yay, congratulations 🎉
Agree with @Rodion I would address the incorrect answer in a informal kind of way.

Rodion · 08/02/2022 22:50

Huge congratulations!

You could always add in something along the lines of "I thought I'd blown it when I gave the silly answer of X for the third time - i so badly wanted to correct my answer but was worried the wrong one would slip out again if I brought it up! Interview nerves are the worst!"

saltedhotchoc · 08/02/2022 22:42

WELL I am pootling back onto the thread to say I was offered the job Blush

The managing director emailed to ask if I wanted to negotiate regarding the salary! So I am meeting him tomorrow and not sure if that's an appropriate time to address the elephant in the room of my stupid brain, or if I should just pretend it never happend Grin

Huge thanks to everyone who shared anecdotes of candidates far worse than me, it did really help with my immense feelings of idiocy!

OP posts:
Aubree17 · 08/02/2022 17:31

One question wouldn't determine the outcome of the interview.
I had a candidate who totally blundered the technical interview questions once but I knew they were the right person for the job. 3 years later they are doing the job perfectly.
Chances are the interviewers had made up their mind before they even asked that question ....

AlternativePerspective · 08/02/2022 16:02

i was part of an interview panel interviewing candidates for a head teacher position.

As part of the interview they had to do various exercises, assembly, teaching, that kind of thing, and obviously had breaks between sections when they had a room available to them where they could get tea and coffee etc. I was in the room with one of the other members of the panel and we were talking about areas in the town, which were the nice areas around where the school was etc, when the candidate who was with us at the time said: “ah, but is all very well, but they’ve put a load of housing association in there and well, you wouldn’t want some of the types of parents who go to the school where I teach being moved in next door if you lived there.” Shock

It wasn’t officially part of the interview process, but she didn’t get the job.

FirstAconite · 08/02/2022 15:58

Sorry - pressed posted rather than preview! Here it is sans typos:

Hope today's interview went well OP. If it makes you feel any better, I once interviewed after coming back from holiday. I'd caught the sun a bit and unfortunately my skin was a bit flaky and dry as a result.

We interviewed one woman, who did ok during the interview. We all stood up at the end to shake hands. The interviewee leant forward and peeled a flake of skin off my nose.

My boss was all for giving her the job anyway Hmm but I soon disavowed him of that idea Grin

FirstAconite · 08/02/2022 15:54

Hope today's interview went well OP. If it makes you feel any better, I once interviewed after coming back from holiday. I'd caught the sun a bit and unfortunately my skin was a bit flaky and dry as a result.

We interviewed one woman, who did ok during the interview. We ask stood up at the end to shake hands. The interviewee learnt guests and peeled a flake of skin off my nose.

My boss was all for giving her the job anyway Hmm but I soon disavowed him of that idea Grin

Wasitworthita · 08/02/2022 12:23

My biggest cringe is oversharing, knowing that nobody cares or wants to hear about the minutiae of my life, somehow my brain still blurts it out anyway. I’ve have to put a “no personal info” filter on my brain now.

Wasitworthita · 08/02/2022 12:07

@FedUpOfLighteningCrotch

I had an interview where the company director asked “if I offered you the job today would you take it?”

My brains said “don’t act too keen” (wtf?!)

So I said “hmmm.. well I guess so”

He was quite taken aback and said “you don’t seem so sure, why the hesitation?”

I apologised and told them exactly that, my brain told me to act cool 🤣

I got the job.

I actually got a snot bubble laughing at this!

Re:- accents, I grew up in an inner city where everyone spoke a certain way (jafaican). When I moved people kept asking me about my accent. What accent, I said, completely obliviously. So the lady with that accent may not have realised she was doing it 😁

AnnaMagnani · 08/02/2022 11:46

I interviewed someone who thought it would be a good idea to show us her wedding photos in the interview.

So, at least you didn't do that! I and the other interviewer sat afterwards just going WTF just happened? On paper she'd been the best candidate as well.

Personally I've managed not to be appointed out of a field of one Blush So it happens to us all. Fingers crossed for you.

TheKeatingFive · 08/02/2022 11:43

Email them. You've nothing to lose. Just say you've had time to reflect on this point and what you really think is xxx. Keep it very polite and to the point.

justhereforthecraic · 08/02/2022 11:36

i feel your pain OP. Interviews are so nerve-wracking. I interviewed a woman before who was already working for our company, she was wanting a change to a differant department. She knew nothing about the company (even though she worked for us already) and when i asked her about the usual policies/values etc. she couldn't answer anything about them. I asked her about dealing with emergency situations at work,(social care sector)she said she would ask the onsite senior staff for assistance..... had to remind her that the post she was interviewing was for the onsite senior staff...I was dying inside for her!! I thought it was nerves and we gave her ample opportunity to recover, but in the end, she put her hands up and said, she didn't know the answers.
I heard through the grapevine after this that she was not happy about not getting the job and blasted the company for not allowing career development or progression into other departments. Think she just thought she was an automatic shoe-in for the job as she already worked for us. We ended up hiring someone that had done their research and actually read the job description Grin

MorningStarling · 08/02/2022 10:17

Try not to let the previous experience cloud your current interview. At least you've had time to think of a good answer if they ask you the same question!

TBH it's difficult to know whether what you said would have put them off. You can have a perfect interview and still not get the job. You could think you had a shocker and still be the best candidate.

I've had a few idiotic comments from candidates I've interviewed. One who admitted he didn't get on with his colleagues at his last job, one who opened with "I want more money and less hours" and one who argued with me for my direction being wrong (which they weren't, they were convinced a street was one-way, which it wasn't). All of them were immediately crossed off my list.

Generally I'd be more favourable with people who forgot something or stumbled over an answer or made a silly mistake because in interviews you expect the candidate to be nervous. One guy I hired told me he was convinced he'd messed up the interview because he said the company name wrong (similar to BWM instead of BMW). To me that wasn't really a problem, he was clearly nervous and it was just a slip of the tongue.

The interview process is just there to give the hirer an idea of who the best candidate is. Some have a points system, others go with their instincts. But the thing to remember is, no matter how well or badly you think your interview went, you have no control over how the other candidates fare.