Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be hugely offended

232 replies

Queenie6655 · 07/02/2022 17:47

Hello

Prepared to be told off guys but really bloody peeved

So as talked about on other threads fleeing dv and ended up back with my parents for a while

Lovely house
Old
Warm
Needs some paint
Stairs are rickety
But otherwise absolutely fine

Anyway
Health visitor here earlier and she was so so rude about the stairs
Said they were unsightly and it was a concern to her !!!!

She knows my situation
Knows we are stuck for cash

I just burst into tears and she left shortly after

So annoyed now
Don't have the money to get a painter in but rest of house is 100 per cent fine
Warm and safe !!!!!

OP posts:
Huntswomanonthemove · 08/02/2022 09:04

On the bigger question of HVs, many of them are hugely dedicated, work tirelessly and with little reward in a high stress environment with massive caseloads. But yes there will be some who are just not very good. A big part of the problem now is funding - funding has been slashed and so they are more stressed, stretched dangerously thin and given less training. Many good HVs are leaving the profession and will be replaced by less able junior staff - if replaced at all.

This is so true.

Just to mention that as HVs have direct contact with families with small children, they are well placed to pick up on any difficulties some parents face. I would urge posters to consider this, especially the child protection issues. There have recently been some horrific cases of child abuse, so perhaps we should encourage families to engage with services rather than the opposite.

Rumplestrumpet · 08/02/2022 08:45

OP I'm sorry she made you feel like crap you've clearly done so well to get yourself and kids to safety and should be praised.

In future if faced with shitty comments like that (if you're able to hold it together!) I would ask for specifics : "oh is there something you think is dangerous?" That way you can pin down the fact that she's commenting on aesthetics and either a) raise an eyebrow, b) point out that's really not relevant or c) make a complaint if you want to.

On the bigger question of HVs, many of them are hugely dedicated, work tirelessly and with little reward in a high stress environment with massive caseloads. But yes there will be some who are just not very good. A big part of the problem now is funding - funding has been slashed and so they are more stressed, stretched dangerously thin and given less training. Many good HVs are leaving the profession and will be replaced by less able junior staff - if replaced at all.

If we want better HV provision we need to demand more investment in ante natal and post natal care - look at who you're voting for and what their record is (hint: massive cuts in the last decade have happened under the same party).

UserBot9to5 · 08/02/2022 08:03

Well, dc2 was not a newborn when i left. He had turned one. It took me a long time to process that there was only one option.

UserBot9to5 · 08/02/2022 08:01

Mine were lovely. Really validated my decision to leave x. He was taking his anger, low self-esteem and inadequacies out on me. I was getting to the point where I was scared to be on my own with him and I felt more scared with a toddler and a newborn. I felt a fool that Id got in to the situation. Well, my hv and the ones at the gp clinic showed me so much kindness and understanding. Many know what to say to a woman leaving an abusive situation.

I know that wasnt yr experience op. Im so sorry. I also lived with my parents when i escaped. You're amazing that you got away with such a young baby. I admire your strength and decisiveness. Xx

camperqueen54 · 08/02/2022 07:41

This is the definition of rocketry:

(of a structure or piece of equipment) poorly made and likely to collapse.

So do they just need paint or are they unsafe?

whymewhyme · 08/02/2022 07:16

What is it with health visitors?! Do they employ arseholes on purpose! I'd put a complaint in personaly

phishy · 08/02/2022 06:19

@Lorieandrews

I had the most awful HV. Weirdly was talking about her just a few hours ago....

Anyway. I remember she was so fucking cruel. I had to take my child to be weighed every 2 weeks or she would tell me she’d report me.

It ended when my amazing paediatrician rang her and told her to stop telling such incorrect information. My pead said most HV don’t know left from right. Most don’t have children and most don’t have knowledge of anything baby related. She was harsh. But I’d lived on a knife edge for months and I’d just broken down to her.

Most don’t have children

How could he know that?!

This thread is really nasty.

phishy · 08/02/2022 06:16

@Kelly7889

Why is this "health visitor" even poking about in your personal and domestic life at all? Yet when I've been nursing a desperately person at home (more than once) and am desperate for help with catheters etc, they aren't fucking interested in coming out! Effing useless.
Health visitors are for mums with children between 0-5 years.

Maybe get a carer instead of calling HVs fucking useless.

MotherOfWhippets · 08/02/2022 05:53

You're doing really well and you've got yourself and child to a place of safety.

Vast majority of HVs I saw were idiots but I was too anxious at the time to tell them to do one. I completely would now.

I was in the same position - we were living in a relatives flat when I had DS and only had one bedroom. First visit she just went on and on about how he would need his own room when he was older. He was days old (and the funny thing is he's now 7 with a beautiful room of his own that he refuses to sleep in so is currently next to me still).

I had comments that his head was too big, he wasn't walking quick enough. It's like they HAVE to justify their job by finding SOMETHING to comment on every time they see you. So to be honest if the only thing she could find was your 'unsightly' staircase you must be doing ok.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 08/02/2022 05:40

Don't let her back in.
We moved to an old house and it's in need of renovation. I feel like I have to explain myself everytime a health visitor or midwife comes as to why it's in a state (not just rickety, there's still stuff everywhere since we moved in and it's awful).
They honestly don't seem to care and tell me not to worry. I'd be gutted if they made nasty comments. It's not helpful to you OP so just ask them to leave and decline any further visits.

Moonbabysmum · 08/02/2022 05:37

I'm a little bit confused where you mention your first health visitor who was great, but has since retired, but your baby is 3w old.

Is there an older child as well, which might explain concern about the stairs?

Migrainesbythedozen · 08/02/2022 05:30

I don't know why you people there in the UK put up with this (in Australia we don't have health visitors, here it is GP or women's clinics or one off home visitors if there is a housing check up requirement). It sounds so intrusive. I understand it's not compulsory? So, in that case, she sounds like a nasty judgemental bitch that does nothing but feel worse, so in that case just tell her you no longer require a health visitor. I could never live like that with someone 'checking up on me' - and thats what it is, when it's not required and they only make you feel worse, not better. Terminate her. You need her like a hole in the head.

howtoleaveit · 08/02/2022 05:00

She’s a twat and shouldn’t be in that job. I had one of these. She told me that giving my baby a bottle and not breastfeeding her would make her obese. There should be a way to complain about these people.

Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 04:22

@Norgie

I had a HV like her when I had my first born. She was in the house ten minutes before my DH frog marched her out again. Tell her to take a hike op. There's nothing wrong with your home as far as I can tell. Enjoy your baby and forget about the idiot HV.
See this is what I wanted to do

I wish I had

Thanks but no thanks
See yourself out please

OP posts:
Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 04:07

My daughter and I

OP posts:
Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 03:58

@kittensinthekitchen

Slightly off topic, but you've mentioned an extra person that doesn't seem to be your parents? I.e. "our bedroom is downstairs", "WE are building a house soon"... You haven't got back with your ex have you? Or got into a new relationship? Does your health visitor know the full situation?
Ffs

We as in my immediate family

OP posts:
Goooglebox · 08/02/2022 03:24

I opted out after a certain point. There's just no need for it really, is there. If you're lucky and experienced.

Goooglebox · 08/02/2022 03:23

Yes also optional in Northern Ireland.

Goooglebox · 08/02/2022 02:54

Ask for a different one as you're considering making a complaint about her abrasive manner since it has reduced you to tears. I suspect you'll see someone different then.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 08/02/2022 01:27

Mate the baby is 3 weeks old it won’t be going up the stairs for ages 😂

I only got a stair gate last week and my baby is 11 months old … I just closed the door up until now so she couldn’t go up.

Absolutely ridiculous thing to say -

My health visitor came once to my house and then I went to her at the health centre next time and that was it never contacted again.

When she came to my house we lived in the tiniest 1 bed flat - place was a mess and she didn’t even comment tbh 😂

Guess you just got a shit one

kittensinthekitchen · 08/02/2022 00:57

Slightly off topic, but you've mentioned an extra person that doesn't seem to be your parents? I.e. "our bedroom is downstairs", "WE are building a house soon"... You haven't got back with your ex have you? Or got into a new relationship? Does your health visitor know the full situation?

Goldenbunny · 08/02/2022 00:07

I've had a few health visitors over the years with my dd I had 2 one was great the other was horrible and her advice was outdated.
With my son I had 2 health visitors again both was great in there own way if it wasn't for them my DS would never if got the help he needed.
This time I've one health visitor and she's lovely only recently become a health visitor so far she's been a great help.
If I was you I think I would still see them but only at clinic they could end up being helpful in your situation. I'd also ask for a different health visitor.

Merryoldgoat · 07/02/2022 23:46

And can I say to all the HV bashers - we aren't all shite, there are some of us who enjoy our jobs and feel we make a real difference. Please don't tar us all with the same brush.

The thing is that you don’t have long to build a rapport and you invariably meet people at a time of high stress and big upheaval. The service needs to be better. I have no doubt some are great but too many aren’t.

I have two children with autism and have had numerous contact with HV with DS1, less with DS2.

I’ve been told:

Baby is too big (wtf? He was 11lb, 60cm at birth - literally nothing I can do about that)
Baby feeds too much (but don’t let him get hungry - wtf?)
Toddler doesn’t show signs of autism (is autistic)
Baby has Sickle Cell Disease (he doesn’t - he has HbC trait)
Baby just has wind and it will settle and rash is unrelated (he’s lactose intolerant with absolutely classic symptoms)
Tidy up the house (days after being hospitalised post partum with a hypertensive crisis and recovering from a CS)

These are all different health visitors. I cannot believe this is chance. Training needs to be better across the board if there is to be any confidence in the service.

It’s not bashing HV to share sub standard experiences.

You need to be calling for better standards across the board. Being 1 good HV in a sea of sub-standard ones isn’t good enough.

Norgie · 07/02/2022 23:32

I had a HV like her when I had my first born. She was in the house ten minutes before my DH frog marched her out again.
Tell her to take a hike op.
There's nothing wrong with your home as far as I can tell.
Enjoy your baby and forget about the idiot HV.

justasking111 · 07/02/2022 23:08

First and second babies health visitor amazing. The third one was scruffy, unkempt, drank cups of tea and ate lots of biscuits. Waste of time