Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be hugely offended

232 replies

Queenie6655 · 07/02/2022 17:47

Hello

Prepared to be told off guys but really bloody peeved

So as talked about on other threads fleeing dv and ended up back with my parents for a while

Lovely house
Old
Warm
Needs some paint
Stairs are rickety
But otherwise absolutely fine

Anyway
Health visitor here earlier and she was so so rude about the stairs
Said they were unsightly and it was a concern to her !!!!

She knows my situation
Knows we are stuck for cash

I just burst into tears and she left shortly after

So annoyed now
Don't have the money to get a painter in but rest of house is 100 per cent fine
Warm and safe !!!!!

OP posts:
Goooglebox · 09/02/2022 10:23

I am at a loss to understand a PP saying we are basically strangers dragged in off the street.

You wouldn't be if you had a string of them visiting and heard the breadth of ridiculous and conflicting advice.

Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 21:30

Just to say thanks all

No way was this meant to bash HV

I was just needing to rant about a bad experience

I loved the First Lady who helped me through so much in so many ways

Will just ignore any more comments that are made and I will go ahead with the next check up and make it clear I want no further involvement from her following this

Thanks again xxxxx

OP posts:
Ilovecreepycrawlies · 08/02/2022 19:08

The health visitors in my team, are all highly qualified health professionals. We are also supported by two registered children's nurses. We run two child health clinics a week, which are drop in. Babies can be weighed and measured and parents can seek help and advice.

Many of us are also nurse prescribers. Parents on my caseload come to the health visitors for prescriptions, as they moan that it's virtually impossible to get a GP appointment these days.

I am at a loss to understand a PP saying we are basically strangers dragged in off the street. To even access the intense training, you have to be a registered nurse or midwife. Two of my health visitor colleagues hold a joint nurse and midwife qualification. .

We always try to do an ante-natal visit, so that when we visit after the baby is born, we are already known to the parents.

I fully accept that there must be some bad apples in our profession but I can confirm what a PP has said, we have very few complaints.

kittensinthekitchen · 08/02/2022 19:04

Ffs

We as in my immediate family

What is with the FFS? I asked a question. If you had got back with your ex, that could - quite rightly - influence the HV into certain opinions on your ability as a safe person for your children.

I didn't realise you had another child, initially, as you hadn't mentioned them in this thread.

Did you have that attitude with the HV?

Bornlazy · 08/02/2022 18:01

The training to become a health visitor is very intense. I'm not sure why people are suggesting that they are untrained as it's simple not true.

Like every profession you get good and bad ones but like a pp says people only talk about the bad ones.

I too don't like the encouragement, on here, to refuse their services as they are often the first professional to pick up on neglect in a young child's life. They pick up a lot of the slack from the GPs so by not engaging with them the burden on GPs increases.

OP was the health visitor not worried about your other child on the stairs as opposed to the baby?

Huntswomanonthemove · 08/02/2022 16:24

Which is exactly why actual professionals like a GP exists

Health visitors are fully qualified registered nurses and or midwives, who have done extra training. GPs value the support and input from the health visiting team, as they recognise the knowledge and expertise HVs have.

It's such a shame that posters' individual experiences and anecdotal evidence is being paraded on here, as if they are experts.

The actual truth is, complaints about HVs are rare. As with any internet forum, keyboard warriors are attracted here to spout their anonymous opinions. My only reason for responding to these posters is to try and give a sensible balance.

People tend only to post when they have a grievance. All the other families up and down the country, who are happy with the HV service don't seek out these types of threads.

Migrainesbythedozen · 08/02/2022 16:10

Just think of all the money the UK wastes by the Gestapo sending out these strangers to intrude and judge mothers. Perhaps the NHS wouldn't be in such a mess. Many hours ago, when I first read this thread, that was my first thought. And I forgot to put it down. It was 'what a waste of money! when the NHS is so badly in need of resources.' Just flushing money down the toilet. And it's irresponsible because it will be disincentive for mothers to actually visit an actual GP. So it's a hindrance on a few levels. It's an horrendous and unforgiveable waste of money and resources that could be put to better use. I cannot believe that waste and ill treatment of mothers is allowed to happen in the UK.

Migrainesbythedozen · 08/02/2022 16:05

@Huntswomanonthemove

Most parents do, so your point is irrelevant.

That mother wouldn't do anything the Health Visitor suggested anyway, so again, your point is irrelevant.

Most parents have no clue what goes on in the land of child protection and safeguarding. Unfortunately child neglect and abuse is much more common than most parents would think.

The parent who refused to take her child for a hearing test, was referred to a child protection social worker. Subsequently, the child was taken for a test and was found to have hearing problems. She was fitted with hearing aids and was referred to a speech therapist. All this happened because a HV visited the family and picked this up.

@Huntswomanonthemove

have no clue what goes on in the land of child protection and safeguarding. Unfortunately child neglect and abuse is much more common than most parents would think.

Which is exactly why actual professionals like a GP exists. Nothing is solved by a stranger who barely finished High School intruding into your home to judge you.

The parent who refused to take her child for a hearing test, was referred to a child protection social worker. Subsequently, the child was taken for a test and was found to have hearing problems. She was fitted with hearing aids and was referred to a speech therapist. All this happened because a HV visited the family and picked this up.

Yet a nursery school, child care staff etc would have eventually found this and a child protection social worker would have still been called. Same result. HV not needed and simply superfluous. Basically you are suggesting, by your reasoning, ANY stranger can come to your house, even a neighbour, and report the child.

Same result. Clearly a HV stalker/intruder is not needed.

And you've failed to make any reason substantial or tangible argument for why someone should be forced upon vulnerable new mothers when 99% of mothers automatically go to the GP anyway. Nothing you have said has even slightly justified forcing an ill-trained quack (basically stranger off the street) to stalk/intrude on a vulnerable new mum. They are not professionals. Going to see a GP (or birthing/baby clinic) is the only responsible thing to do. And funnily enough, 99% of mothers in countries all around the world manage this without any problems.

Huntswomanonthemove · 08/02/2022 15:58

Most parents do, so your point is irrelevant.

That mother wouldn't do anything the Health Visitor suggested anyway, so again, your point is irrelevant.

Most parents have no clue what goes on in the land of child protection and safeguarding. Unfortunately child neglect and abuse is much more common than most parents would think.

The parent who refused to take her child for a hearing test, was referred to a child protection social worker. Subsequently, the child was taken for a test and was found to have hearing problems. She was fitted with hearing aids and was referred to a speech therapist. All this happened because a HV visited the family and picked this up.

Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 15:53

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius

I had a health visitor tell me that SHE had to think of what was best for my baby, when I wanted to persevere with breastfeeding and didn’t want to supplement with formula (past experience told me this would spell the end of breastfeeding). I asked her how she dared suggest she cared more for my baby’s well being than I did, and told her to get out of my house.
See this infuriated me to read this Many do not do this

But some are so out of order

I was shamed

OP posts:
Migrainesbythedozen · 08/02/2022 15:46

@Huntswomanonthemove

Is this serious? Are you genuinely saying a mother would never take her baby to the GP for a checkup, not get it's vaccinations, etc? A mother will see plenty of health professionals in the first year. She has absolutely no need, whatsoever, for someone coming to her home to check up on her! None whatsoever!

Yes serious. In the shiny shiny world of Mumsnet, everyone is a caring parent who regularly sees a GP, get a child vaccinated and attends all health appointments.

One example that comes straight to my mind, is the mother who refused to take her child for a hearing test, despite the child having no speech at all at age two. I was desperately concerned about this child but the mother wasn't.

@Huntswomanonthemove

Most parents do, so your point is irrelevant.

That mother wouldn't do anything the Health Visitor suggested anyway, so again, your point is irrelevant.

Neither of them is a justification for a 25 year old intruding into a 33 year old mum's home (as in a PP above) and judging things like stairs or gait or speech or telling them it's 'bad for the baby' to breastfeed past a year. Read the thread. HV's seem to be a bunch of very dangerous quacks with no experience or training. I wouldn't let a HV look over my cat for 30 seconds. Then again, I only would have actual trained medical professionals - ie a GP, look at my baby. I'm responsible. I certainly wouldn't have some silly kid intrude into my home and life when she knows less than me.

Huntswomanonthemove · 08/02/2022 15:36

Is this serious? Are you genuinely saying a mother would never take her baby to the GP for a checkup, not get it's vaccinations, etc? A mother will see plenty of health professionals in the first year. She has absolutely no need, whatsoever, for someone coming to her home to check up on her! None whatsoever!

Yes serious. In the shiny shiny world of Mumsnet, everyone is a caring parent who regularly sees a GP, get a child vaccinated and attends all health appointments.

One example that comes straight to my mind, is the mother who refused to take her child for a hearing test, despite the child having no speech at all at age two. I was desperately concerned about this child but the mother wasn't.

cupofdecaf · 08/02/2022 15:35

I once had a health visitor tell me I needed to stop breast feeding at a year. Apparently it's not good for the baby . That was 2019. Hmm

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 08/02/2022 15:33

Please don't let your poor experience of a HV discourage others from using a service that may actually save a child's life, or at least give support where it's needed. You might be doing just fine without the service but what about the child who is being tortured or murdered?

Those people will already be refusing to see the HV and anyone else in a professional capacity.

Quite a lot of the posts about the behaviour of HVs on here could be the catalyst for PND or OCD or any number of other MH issues because of the vulnerability of being a new mum and the stupidity of some HVs and their ridiculous opinions.

Migrainesbythedozen · 08/02/2022 15:30

They run child health clinics

And the mother can GO to one of those child health clinics, when she needs to!

Migrainesbythedozen · 08/02/2022 15:29

@Huntswomanonthemove

Again Mumsnetters are encouraging parents to refuse the services of the health visiting service. This, despite a health visitor usually being the only health professional parents may see when their children are young. Health visitors are trained in child protection issues so could be the only professional to see a child, if their parents are struggling.

Safeguarding children is paramount, as recent cases of horrific child abuse and deaths show.

You might not need or want a HV but how would you feel if your post encouraged someone to refuse services when they were struggling and their child was at risk of abuse? Whenever there's a case of child abuse the first thing everyone wants to know is; where were the professionals?

Not all HVs are rubbish, although reading the threads on Mumsnet you would think they are. All HVs are fully qualified Registered Nurses and or Midwives, who have gone on to do extra training.

The HVs of today are educated to degree level and have completed training in child growth and development, breastfeeding, child nutrition, sleep, toilet training, childhood diseases, immunisation, maternal mental health, safeguarding, issues surrounding drug and alcohol misuse, domestic violence and living with deprivation. They run child health clinics and most are now nurse prescribers.

Please don't let your poor experience of a HV discourage others from using a service that may actually save a child's life, or at least give support where it's needed. You might be doing just fine without the service but what about the child who is being tortured or murdered?

This, despite a health visitor usually being the only health professional parents may see when their children are young.

Is this serious? Are you genuinely saying a mother would never take her baby to the GP for a checkup, not get it's vaccinations, etc? A mother will see plenty of health professionals in the first year. She has absolutely no need, whatsoever, for someone coming to her home to check up on her! None whatsoever!

Huntswomanonthemove · 08/02/2022 15:26

Again Mumsnetters are encouraging parents to refuse the services of the health visiting service. This, despite a health visitor usually being the only health professional parents may see when their children are young. Health visitors are trained in child protection issues so could be the only professional to see a child, if their parents are struggling.

Safeguarding children is paramount, as recent cases of horrific child abuse and deaths show.

You might not need or want a HV but how would you feel if your post encouraged someone to refuse services when they were struggling and their child was at risk of abuse? Whenever there's a case of child abuse the first thing everyone wants to know is; where were the professionals?

Not all HVs are rubbish, although reading the threads on Mumsnet you would think they are. All HVs are fully qualified Registered Nurses and or Midwives, who have gone on to do extra training.

The HVs of today are educated to degree level and have completed training in child growth and development, breastfeeding, child nutrition, sleep, toilet training, childhood diseases, immunisation, maternal mental health, safeguarding, issues surrounding drug and alcohol misuse, domestic violence and living with deprivation. They run child health clinics and most are now nurse prescribers.

Please don't let your poor experience of a HV discourage others from using a service that may actually save a child's life, or at least give support where it's needed. You might be doing just fine without the service but what about the child who is being tortured or murdered?

Anonymous48 · 08/02/2022 15:14

@Migrainesbythedozen

I don't know why you people there in the UK put up with this (in Australia we don't have health visitors, here it is GP or women's clinics or one off home visitors if there is a housing check up requirement). It sounds so intrusive. I understand it's not compulsory? So, in that case, she sounds like a nasty judgemental bitch that does nothing but feel worse, so in that case just tell her you no longer require a health visitor. I could never live like that with someone 'checking up on me' - and thats what it is, when it's not required and they only make you feel worse, not better. Terminate her. You need her like a hole in the head.
I agree. The whole thing seems very strange to me too, having had my children in the US. I can't imagine a health care professional coming to my house to check up on me!
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/02/2022 14:50

I had a health visitor tell me that SHE had to think of what was best for my baby, when I wanted to persevere with breastfeeding and didn’t want to supplement with formula (past experience told me this would spell the end of breastfeeding). I asked her how she dared suggest she cared more for my baby’s well being than I did, and told her to get out of my house.

Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 14:03

@Migrainesbythedozen

I don't know why you people there in the UK put up with this (in Australia we don't have health visitors, here it is GP or women's clinics or one off home visitors if there is a housing check up requirement). It sounds so intrusive. I understand it's not compulsory? So, in that case, she sounds like a nasty judgemental bitch that does nothing but feel worse, so in that case just tell her you no longer require a health visitor. I could never live like that with someone 'checking up on me' - and thats what it is, when it's not required and they only make you feel worse, not better. Terminate her. You need her like a hole in the head.
Shaming me

And yes those words so true 'intrusive'

I'm bloody trying my best yoh judgmental wagon 😢😢😢😢😢😢

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 08/02/2022 12:35

As been said numerous times op you dont have to have her back at all-just cancel the appt

RosesAndHellebores · 08/02/2022 12:17

I think much of the problem is that the HV is imposed. When I had my first more than 27 years ago, I had carefully researched the GP I registered with, the maternity unit I chose for the birth (could have chosen: St George's, Queen Mary's, Chelsea &Westminster or Kingston), but the HV was just a random who turned up when the baby was 10 days old. No introduction, no choice, etc. Never in a million years would I have chosen a 23 year old as a 35 year old ftm.

Queenie6655 · 08/02/2022 11:21

@PissedOffNeighbour22

Don't let her back in. We moved to an old house and it's in need of renovation. I feel like I have to explain myself everytime a health visitor or midwife comes as to why it's in a state (not just rickety, there's still stuff everywhere since we moved in and it's awful). They honestly don't seem to care and tell me not to worry. I'd be gutted if they made nasty comments. It's not helpful to you OP so just ask them to leave and decline any further visits.
Very true

Sorry when I say rickety meant old, flakey paint needs TLC
Not falling down

She commented on appearance

No time spent praising how far we came
Baby is doing so well

She asks all the time if baby is anxious ffs

She's an idiot

I'm going to bite my tongue
One more visit and that's it

OP posts:
Moonbabysmum · 08/02/2022 09:21

Ok, having a look, maybe this is about your older daughter more than your 3mo, although if its just that the stairs aren't well painted, I cant see why that matters.

I don't get the feeling we have the full story here. You have repeatedly mentioned your 3wo, but not your 4yo, and whilst I am delighted you managed to get away from your abuser, your posts very much implies that this house is where youve escaped to, not a place you are living in 4 years later. It makes me wonder whether theres anything else about the setup of these stairs that you haven't mentioned, which are the root of the hv remarks.

Merryoldgoat · 08/02/2022 09:12

It’s not just about less able, it’s about not being a judgemental presence in the home of a new parent at their most vulnerable.

It doesn’t take a genius or highly trained professional to understand tidying up would come pretty far down the list.