Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry with comment from A&E doctor

161 replies

whethertheweather · 07/02/2022 17:41

DD is 18 and anorexic with BMI of 14.5. After months and months of delays she is just starting to be dealt with by an NHS eating disorder clinic. They called her in for the first in person appointment to do a blood test and physical exam, where she fainted. Blood tests were apparently off, they said O2 levels were at 80% and blood pressure was really low. The doctor at the clinic was very concerned and walked her over to A&E across the road for more tests with a letter explaining her position and the results of their own tests.

Nurse at triage says she needs a blood test so to wait and that O2 levels are hard to check with a pulse oximeter as DD's circulation is so poor in her fingertips. 3 hours later a doctor calls DD in, says he doesn't need to check her O2 levels "as I can see you're breathing". He then went on to say to her that people can exist quite well on 500 calories a day and that it's the constant going up and down with calories from one day to the next that is doing her body harm. He did an ECG, said it was OK and sent her on her way.

AIBU to feel incredulous that anyone would tell an anorexic it was OK to eat 500 calories a day? DD is trying so hard to eat but she's lost 45kg in a year and the scales are still going down.

I tried to complain to PALS, but they've said as DD is over 18 she has to authorise the complaint and I feel she's got enough on her hands. I'm sure the doctor's doing his best in extreme circumstances, but I want him to understand the potential impact of his words on vulnerable patients.

OP posts:
PrivateHall · 07/02/2022 20:29

The sats could appear low due to anaemia or other reasons, the doctor is correct that it clearly wasn't accurate given that she was not out of breath and functioning normally.

As for the comments, if they are indeed true then of course it needs addressed. You know your dd best, if you believe her then so do I. I would just go ahead and write out a letter and ask your dd to sign it if she is happy to. Good luck op Flowers

MayThePawsBeWithYou · 07/02/2022 20:27

I think telling a relative what a doctor may have said and meant is extremely unlikely and a massive confidentality breach

surreygirl1987 · 07/02/2022 20:22

I think that's abysmal

Louisianagumbo · 07/02/2022 20:19

We could also tell you that yes, the doctor said this but he meant x y or z.

But couldn't that give away medical information about the patient? Say a patient lied to a relative to put them off the track off what really had been said, wouldn't the trust telling a third party what had actually been said, risk compromising a patients confidentiality and even safety? This makes me quite concerned. Don't discuss me, my treatment or any conversation I have with an unknown person.

lemonsorbetinthesun · 07/02/2022 20:13

I don’t want to scare you in anyway, and I’m glad she has the support of a specialist ED service.

But ED is so dangerous - I’m not saying this to upset you (and now she finally has an ED service she’ll be supported properly by people who understand her needs) but more because you have to complain about that Dr.

That’s a terrible thing to say to anyone!! It’s not just about how many calories someone can live off. ED is much more complicated than that!
500 calories and then some excessive exercise etc, would be no where near enough and the attitude of the Dr is dangerous.

Reinforcing those thought patterns is a dangerous thing to do!!

Imagine if someone without an ED service is taken to A&E by a friend or relative, just to be told - the same thing. Only, without the specialist support, which may not be sought because some idiot dr at A&E told them it’s ok!

LidlMiddleLover · 07/02/2022 20:12

I don’t believe he said this She can pursue it-if he really did but she won’t because he probably didn't You could cause a lot of trouble for heresay

ASeagullShatInMyEye · 07/02/2022 20:10

OP, I am a former anorexic who still has tendencies in that direction. My first thought was that 1,100 calories is a lot of calories. Is that what your DD says she is consuming? I would have thought that was a lot. Is it possible she said it was 500 (which might be closer to the truth), and this apparently elicited the doctor's response that this is enough to survive on (because it is, just)?

The fact that you didn't hear the whole conversation is a big problem, as you can't possibly know the truth (and anorexics don't tell the truth). You could very well ask to have this investigated, but you definitely shouldn't jump into wanting to have the doctor disciplined/advised as to how to handle this kind of conversation in future.

Some facts need to be established, first.

That aside, I am sorry your DD is having to deal with this (and that you are, too - but anorexia is a selfish illness. I remember overhearing my mum crying at the height of my anorexia. I thought she was being selfish because I was the one who couldn't eat, not her. This is anorexic thinking).

Wrongkindofovercoat · 07/02/2022 20:09

This will have been a really tricky time for your DD, first face to face appointment with the ED team, her anxiety would probably have been off the scale. Was she able to complete the appointment or has it been re-scheduled or was it just a quick physical examination initial booking in sort of appointment ?

TabithaTittlemouse · 07/02/2022 20:09

You can complain, I’m not sure who told you that you couldn’t.

How has your dd been since the appointment?
Did you tell her team about the alleged incident?

BeanyBops · 07/02/2022 20:05

This is awful. Unfortunately I have had similar experiences with doctors. When I was in eating disorder treatment, that my doctor was fully aware of and had been told the details, she told me I could lose more weight if I cut out carbs. As an adult woman I felt capable of making a complaint to PALS and it was completely dismissed.

LucyOrli · 07/02/2022 20:05

If you know the name of the doctor, you can write to them at the hospital saying exactly what you’ve said here: explaining the impact of his words on your daughter but without making a formal complaint. I did that once to a GP who made unhelpful remarks about my medication - I didn’t want to get them into trouble but I did want them to understand the effect of their words, otherwise they’d never change.

TatianaBis · 07/02/2022 20:05

@FOJN

AIBU to feel incredulous that anyone would tell an anorexic it was OK to eat 500 calories a day?

No you are not being unreasonable but I'm doubtful that your daughter was told that and certainly not in the context it's been presented to you. You've had some excellent advice here from people who have experienced an eating disorder. I had a friend who battled with anorexia for quite a few years. She was a lovely person but was rarely honest about anything to do with food or her body image, it's the nature of the illness not the person.

Every anorexic is different. My friend was unusually honest about food and body image - although she couldn't always see your pov on her food intake. Once she was hospitalised she accepted she was too thin.

It depends a lot on personality, the particular complexion of their illness and where they are in the illness/healing process.

Lorieandrews · 07/02/2022 20:02

@Tigandgab

I work in complaints for a mental health Trust. Anyone can raise a concern through pals, or make a complaint, without the consent of the patient. It will still be passed onto the service, and we will still respond in writing if a complaint. What we can't do is share clinical information that the complainant is not aware of. In this case we could reference the appt, as you are aware of it. We could also tell you that yes, the doctor said this but he meant x y or z. We would not be able to tell you any info about what your daughter said or details of her care and treatment eg. Medication. So,, definitely worth raising this with pals and then you can escalate to a complaint if you're not happy with the response
You would confirm that he said that.? Wait. What? How could you divulge what a doctor said to a patient in a confidential setting?
privateandnhsgp · 07/02/2022 19:55

@Tigandgab

I work in complaints for a mental health Trust. Anyone can raise a concern through pals, or make a complaint, without the consent of the patient. It will still be passed onto the service, and we will still respond in writing if a complaint. What we can't do is share clinical information that the complainant is not aware of. In this case we could reference the appt, as you are aware of it. We could also tell you that yes, the doctor said this but he meant x y or z. We would not be able to tell you any info about what your daughter said or details of her care and treatment eg. Medication. So,, definitely worth raising this with pals and then you can escalate to a complaint if you're not happy with the response
You would divulge to a third party what a Doctor said to a patient in a confidential setting (with clarification about what they meant) without patient consent?

Shocking, and a clear breach of confidentially. SMH if you really work in complaints handling.

Soffit · 07/02/2022 19:50

If you didn't actually hear it for yourself then be wary of escalating it to medical negligence. They would try their luck with any case on nwnf regardless of whether they believed it or not. If something was said, it was probably an unhelpful casual comment which should not have been made, not a personalized plan of action. I remember going to the GP when I was pregnant from when DP and I had only been together one day in three months while he worked abroad. He said to me that I had no chance of being pregnant and that I should go out get drunk and party hard (not that I had ever done any of that!)
I was taken aback but I knew that he was wrong. Your DD recognises that the doctor was wrong and raised it immediately. Of course, he saw me a year later when I attended baby clinic and looked like he had seen a ghost!

Tigandgab · 07/02/2022 19:48

I work in complaints for a mental health Trust. Anyone can raise a concern through pals, or make a complaint, without the consent of the patient. It will still be passed onto the service, and we will still respond in writing if a complaint. What we can't do is share clinical information that the complainant is not aware of. In this case we could reference the appt, as you are aware of it. We could also tell you that yes, the doctor said this but he meant x y or z. We would not be able to tell you any info about what your daughter said or details of her care and treatment eg. Medication. So,, definitely worth raising this with pals and then you can escalate to a complaint if you're not happy with the response

Lorieandrews · 07/02/2022 19:45

Medical negligence is one of the hardest things to claim for and this wouldn’t qualify. That’s bad advice to those saying it

  1. I’m sorry but you werent there. You can’t make a complaint based off hearsay.
  1. If she wants to complain your first step is PALS
  1. Whomever said the dr wouldn’t be without a chaperone. That’s completely incorrect. She is 18. Unless he needed her undressed. There would be no need for one.

Huge amounts of incorrect information on this thread.

lljkk · 07/02/2022 19:40

DD's BMI is currently 16.4 (ish).
I assume that every word out of her mouth is a lie or massive distortion of truths, tbh. At least with regard to her eating, weight, etc.

Fine to raise your concerns but don't be surprised if you hear a very different well-documented & evidenced account from the other side.

That principle would apply if it was other health conditions, actually. Friend's mother insisted that she'd had no advice about her X health condition. Friend's brother kicked off about the appalling health care their mother had received. Cue doctors producing heaps of letters which showed them trying to advise on X, and hardcopies of same letters were found in the mother's household. I don't know why some information doesn't sink in.

LifesABotch · 07/02/2022 19:38

OMG that is awful, and also inaccurate! What severely underweight person would be ok on 500 calories per day? Or any young person? Or any person at all?!

Definitely complain, and you can post feedback publicly on:

https://www.careopinion.org.uk/

Hope your daughter wasn't too upset or thrown by what the doctor said Sad

Clymene · 07/02/2022 19:38

Anorexics lie. They lie like any other addict does. In any event, you can't complain as you weren't there and your daughter is an adult.

I'm really sorry, it's an absolute bastard of a disease and terrifying watching someone you love waste away before your eyes. I hope the clinic helps to get her back on track.

MayThePawsBeWithYou · 07/02/2022 19:36

Would your daughter agree to having another doctor examine her with you present.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 07/02/2022 19:32

So the letter from the ED clinic states she is eating 1100 calories every day or that is the goal ? , and yet 500 calories came up in conversation ? Is that not a little odd ? Why would the Doctor mention 500 calories ?

Wendybyrdesmissingconscience · 07/02/2022 19:30

I would complain to the hospital, the health authority and the general medical council.

Louisianagumbo · 07/02/2022 19:28

A qualified doctor said that we can all live on 500 calories a day as long as we keep that number consistent? I'd be reporting him, not for upsetting a patient but for his questionable medical knowledge. I find it quite difficult to believe, to be honest. It's not that I'm saying your daughter didn't hear that, just that I wonder whether the doctor actually said it.

MacauliflowerCulkin · 07/02/2022 19:21

@incognitoforthisone

Were you there when the doctor said this? Or is this just what your daughter reported back to you?

Because this sounds an awful lot like the sort of thing someone with anorexia would claim had been said to them when it actually hadn't. I had a close friend who was anorexic and she claimed more than once that medical professionals had told her that what she was doing was OK 'if she was careful' or 'if she just made sure she took multivitamins', but it was invariably either a conscious lie on her part or her convincing herself that she'd heard what she wanted to hear and not what was actually said.

I agree.
Swipe left for the next trending thread