Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
DiddyHeck · 08/02/2022 22:34

@user2908143823142536475859708

Smacking is illegal for a reason. There is no valid reason to smack a child.
There's no 'valid' reason to overfeed a child and not see they get enough exercise either (medical issues aside). There's also no valid reason not to deal with their weight as soon as it becomes a problem, rather than sticking one's head in the sand and praying for a growth spurt.
user2908143823142536475859708 · 08/02/2022 22:30

Smacking is illegal for a reason. There is no valid reason to smack a child.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/02/2022 22:02

"You have no idea what causes their weight to be what it is."

You have no idea why some people smack their kids either...

scaredsadandstuck · 08/02/2022 21:57

@TheOrigRights

It's interesting to read the thread about the teen setting up a tuck shop at school. Most are applauding his ingenuity, without a thought to the junk the kids might be buying and eating at school.
I had the exact same thought!

I'm also wondering about the response to this thread if the title had been "to judge parents who formula feed"

TheOrigRights · 08/02/2022 21:32

It's interesting to read the thread about the teen setting up a tuck shop at school. Most are applauding his ingenuity, without a thought to the junk the kids might be buying and eating at school.

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 21:25

My kids are really slim but I'm unsure if it is anything to do with my active parenting. My eldest is nearly 15 can and does eat all manner of junk without putting 1lb on. My youngest will.just stop eating if she is full up whatever it is- so cakes, junk in general! It is tricky with young adults as you have zero say over them spending £15 on burger King - an example of a recent conversation we had as I worry about how unhealthy the food is but it has absolutely nothing to do with weight whatsoever. Outwardly, if you didn't know me I wouldn't be judged as my kids are very thin but I know I'm not the best at limiting rubbish food so yes I do feel.it would be massively hypocritical of me to be judgmental about an overweight child's parents' decisions on food they buy. Judgmental means to be overly critical so of course it is a negative thing to do.

Refrosty · 08/02/2022 21:03

@Ottolin3

It’s such a shame, but here lies the problem, no accountability taken. If you aren’t able to see that you have created the problem by feeding your children unhealthy food, how on earth can you expect change. There is a serious lack of Education towards the benefit of exercise and a nutritional diet. A poor diet will no doubt be contributing to their children’s lack of desire to exercise.
That goes for all kids, not just the overweight ones. Many slim kids eat poorly, and many overweight kids eat plenty of nutrient rich foods.
ChocolateMassacre · 08/02/2022 20:58

Chips every day won't necessarily make you fat. The portions must be too big

I find it odd that some posters can't see why a child might need to eat more chips to feel full than they would other food if given a high-quality diet with plenty of protein and vegetables.

And of course a child fed mostly on chips (because that's what the parents can afford) will have much less energy to run around and engage in physical activity than children whose parents can afford a decent diet.

But rather than bothering to examine the link between obesity and food poverty, which is obviously too difficult for some people to comprehend... just let them eat (less) chips Hmm!

user2908143823142536475859708 · 08/02/2022 20:48

Slim doesn't mean fit or healthy either.

I was heavily judged by everyone when I was younger for being chubby, having autism and adhd. I would only eat the same 5 things.

I only judge parents who smack kids.

I would never judge a child for being overweight and I think it's absolutely awful people are admitting to this. You have no idea what causes their weight to be what it is.

lambchop81 · 08/02/2022 20:39

[quote Chichimcgee]@lambchop81

How old are your kids? Are they with you 24/7?

You cannot physically force a child to exercise if they don’t want to.
You can not stop a child eating unhealthier at school or the other parents house or when out with their friends etc

It’s easy to blame everything on the parents but at the end of the day there are a lot of other things going on in a child’s life.[/quote]
12 and 6 and no of course they are not.
I'm no perfect parent and I never claim to be. Eating unhealthy at school or anywhere else can be counterated by meals at home.
Its my opinion that ultimately it is down to the parents unless there is some kind of mental or health condition.
I've seen first hand what happens when a child comfort eats to an unhealthy weight for their age and height.
I also feel that it's the parents that need educating and help. It's cheaper to buy less healthy food than it is healthy.
There is a growing obesity in children issue in the UK.
PS my son put on a lot of weight in lockdown and we have since worked on getting it off

YvanEhtNiojYvanEhtNioj · 08/02/2022 20:32

@DiddyHeck

I work with disadvantaged children. Often tea, 5/6 times a week is a portion of chips.

That's not going to make any kid fat if they're not overfed and they run around enough. They won't be healthy but they won't be fat either.

Yes, Chips every day won't necessarily make you fat. The portions must be too big. If you are poor, feeding your children large quantities of unhealthy food isn't saving you money.
lambchop81 · 08/02/2022 20:31

Let's be honest we all judge others in some way or another. My judging is all in my little head so no harm done.
Who's judging now saying I would produce a bully. My children are very kind.

Rockhopper81 · 08/02/2022 20:27

You know what, I'm out.

I've explained specifically how a knee injury was not caused by my weight, but am now basically being told I'm wrong and that it somehow was. Even though my slim, athletic cousin sustained a more serious injury in not totally dissimilar circumstances. Even though not one medial professional - and trust me, I've encountered enough who are willing to say your weight contributed to an earache, they're not backwards in coming forwards - attributed my injury to my weight. Even though my injury was caused by an excessive twisting of a joint, but it was actually the 'cushioning' part of the joint that gave, and there is no evidence of osteoarthritis now (or before, for that matter - and whilst we're at it, fat or not, osteoarthritis can and does affect anyone).

Nobody wants to be overweight, by either a few pounds or by being obese. But judgement for it - adults or children - does nobody any good. What you end up doing is creating a proliferation of disordered eating, rather than education of healthier eating habits. Judgement gets nobody anywhere fast, unless you're the one judging right? Because then you get to say how terrible people are for being fat. You may not like or agree with it, but fat people are allowed to be fat and not feel absolutely terrible about themselves ever second of the bloody day.

When you're told everything is because of weight, even when you know it's not, there's no point in discussion anymore, because what you have to say isn't heard any longer. It doesn't fit with what people believe, so everything is turned around. I shouldn't have had to give the medical details of an accident I had to prove it wasn't caused by my weight, but I did, and it still wasn't believed! Incredible!!

So yeah, I'm out. You can continue to claim it's entirely parents fault if their children are even a pound overweight, you can continue to claim it's 'from concern for the child', but you can do it in the echo chamber you want, because honestly there's no point presenting another opinion here.

Ottolin3 · 08/02/2022 20:26

It’s such a shame, but here lies the problem, no accountability taken. If you aren’t able to see that you have created the problem by feeding your children unhealthy food, how on earth can you expect change. There is a serious lack of Education towards the benefit of exercise and a nutritional diet. A poor diet will no doubt be contributing to their children’s lack of desire to exercise.

azimuth299 · 08/02/2022 20:21

[quote GreekGod]@azimuth299 - you are now asking about something being bad rather than judging

of course hitting a child is bad

anyway, this thread is going off topic as the OP asked about judgment and overweight children and we are no longer commenting on this[/quote]
I may need to bash my head against something.

Judging means deciding whether you think something is good/bad right/wrong acceptable/unacceptable. That's what people mean when they talk abo judging. What do you think judging means if not that?

GreekGod · 08/02/2022 20:18

@azimuth299 - you are now asking about something being bad rather than judging

of course hitting a child is bad

anyway, this thread is going off topic as the OP asked about judgment and overweight children and we are no longer commenting on this

Canaloha · 08/02/2022 20:15

Thanks @PaddleBoardingMomma and @LexMitior - I don't talk about it often but it has played a huge part of my life in many ways but its not something that ever really feels the right time to discuss. Self realisation is a good way of putting it, as I didn't ever know any different I just believed the ah big boned, it's just puppy fat, you'll grow out of it- i just thought I couldn't ever be slim, I was just fat if was who I was; ironically I suppose the only people who were honest were the bullies.

Giraffesandbottoms · 08/02/2022 20:10

MN is this weird place where being judgemental is seen as something extremely bad rather than natural, and judgement on this face being equated with allowing your children to be overweight with all that entails is bananas.

Refrosty · 08/02/2022 20:08

@5128gap

Lampshading, I think it would be very difficult for any averagely intelligent and moderately well read person not to know there are health risks to obesity, for children and adults. We all know this. I haven't seen a single post that has denied this. I've also not seen a single one saying its fine that children are overweight. The debate isn't the pros and cons of obesity, as that would be short and one sided. The debate is whether its OK for us to sit in judgement of parents of overweight children. I think it isn't, because it discounts many important contributory factors, but also because it is entirely unhelpful, lacks empathy and emotional intelligence, and won't help a single overweight child become any slimmer.
Yup. And it's interesting how people believe their own judgemental attitude could never lead to their kids fat shaming/judging others. Many are quick to point out a parent's role in child obesity, but won't take a look in the mirror as regards their own faults and potential influence over their kids judgement/attitude. Who is winning with this kind of judgement?

And I feel I can speak out about this because I have worked with parents of overweight kids for years. The parents do blame themselves, even if they don't admit it to anyone. Take your faux concern, it's not helpful and could actually be harmful to your own kids.

KittensTeaAndCake · 08/02/2022 20:03

I'm really seeing that it's the people who justify obesity or are offended it's being spoken about are the ones being the most horrid and bullying on here.

Agreed, OP.
It's just a way to shut down discussion so they don't have to face up to what they are doing to their kids.

5128gap · 08/02/2022 20:02

@ChiefWiggumsBoy

And as for defensiveness, well what do you expect when people make gratuitous attacks on the way they raise their children and refuse to accept there can be any issues that prevent the problem being easily resolved?

Is it attacking to see an overweight or obese child and internally wonder what the hell the adults are feeding that child? @5128gap

I notice you say you have no skin in the game as a slim adult - well, I'm a fat parent of normal sized kids. I'm sure people look at me and wonder why I can't eat the same as my kids and not be fat. Sure it's not as simple as I overeat, but I don't actually care to police other people's thoughts. I don't like actual fat-shaming, it's upsetting when people call you a fat cunt for simply daring to exist in a large body. That's not what is happening here.

Of course its not attacking to see something and think something in the privacy of your own head. It becomes an attack when you make the person aware of your thoughts and those thoughts are overly hostile or cruel. Like the posters who suggested parents with overweight children don't love them and neglect them and likened it to physical violence. Or the example I gave of seeking to blame a woman for their own injury. Just because something is couched more delicately than a stream of expletives, doesn't make any less malign in its intent.
LexMitior · 08/02/2022 20:01

@Canaloha - brave post. Good to hear of the life you have now built for yourself and the self realisation you had.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 08/02/2022 19:59

@Canaloha

I agree judgement doesn't help, but I wish there was more support for parents (and thus children) and it wasn't so taboo to talk about.

I was overweight as a child, it started with just basically eating crap meals and escalated into binging on whatever I could get my hands on. I remember eating butter out of the pot with a spoon until I was sick in the middle of the night, it was an uncontrollable and overwhelming desire I couldn't fight- I was only 7 or so. My parents knew this but would still buy junk and I'd happily eat it. A pasty after school, sometimes bowls of grated cheese; they didn't know any better and there wasn't the wealth of info there now is online, I wish someone had judged them and made them seek help or tell me no. As soon as I was old enough to go the shops I'd spend all of my money on sweets and chocolate and hide the wrappers, if we had a takeaway we would have fish and chips and a family size chocolate bar; I was 12.

I was bullied throughout school and I don't even think it was because of the attitudes of other parents, its because clothes didn't fit in shops that were popular, I didn't look as good as my classmates (harsh but true), my confidence was rock bottom, and this made it worse as PE for example I was too embarrassed to take part in so they would write me endless notes. I carried on piling on the weight, my knees were sore, I'd be out of breath easily and I wasn't even huge, but definitely and visibly overweight.

When I moved away to uni and bought my own food, gained confidence in myself and made a supportive bunch of friends the weight melted off. I felt the best I had ever felt, I also found the courage to seek support for what turned out to be binge eating disorder. I have to work hard to maintain a healthy weight now, but for me it's worth it, and not passing down an unhealthy attitude to food (either restrictive or excessive) to my children is a priority.

I love my parents, they did the best they could I don't doubt but its shit being exposed young to junk, unhealthy habits and people turning a blind eye to obesity in children who don't know any different and cannot get their own food and meals.

I could have written this, it's very similar to my own experience. I'm sorry you struggled too, it was a miserable time x
OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 08/02/2022 19:59

@PaddleBoardingMomma

You have hit a nerve and that’s all there is to it!

PaddleBoardingMomma · 08/02/2022 19:57

@Ottolin3

Ha! Bullies, I can assure you that won’t happen. Its appalling that so many people are making excuses for allowing their child to be obese!
I'm really seeing that it's the people who justify obesity or are offended it's being spoken about are the ones being the most horrid and bullying on here. I've been called all sorts for starting this thread, it's shocking. I understand I may have hit a nerve but the absolute aggression and defensiveness tells me so so much.
OP posts: