Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
MingeofDeath · 09/02/2022 15:19

Haven't RTFT but has "having big bones" been used as an excuse yet?

LexMitior · 09/02/2022 14:33

Its also not just McDonalds; other chains do this. Look at Zizzi, Pizza Express, Gourmet Burger Kitchen, Nandos. If you look at portions they are big. Too big. And "good value" which means a lot of carbs for you and a lot of profit for them.

Yes they will talk about a "range of options" and a balanced diet but of course, they make the most money from the high fat, high carb, high sugar stuff.

These places are designed subtly for you to eat more and more - even perhaps a nice big chair for you so you don't feel uncomfortable. And yet maybe as an adult its not bad to feel a little uncomfortable, perhaps so that you change and get healthier? For the children's benefit?

LexMitior · 09/02/2022 14:22

Its easy to forget just how unusual it was to be overweight 40 years ago. It has been totally normalised in the UK, but I remember the jokes about the Americans and the Germans. Augustus Gloop as the boy who could not stop eating and was punished.

You see other new problems too - eating out is one.The portion sizes are bigger and bigger. People actually eat all of what is on their plate; that's likely to much more than you need. What is the purpose of these places?

Get you fat, you will come back.

That is literally the business model of McDonalds, dunkin donuts, KFC et al. They know. They know that most of their business comes from repeat customers. Not a few people that have takeaway as a treat. Regular customers of these places end up with fatty livers, like foie gras. No you can't see it but it is inside you. It exploits people but once you know about it fast food should be shunned. Its designed to exploit people, really.

1forAll74 · 09/02/2022 13:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TheCountessOfGrantham · 09/02/2022 13:02

I do judge. Not in a "you terrible parent" way, but in an "ahh, that's why" sort of way. My son's mate knocks for him to walk to school every morning. He lives a mile away from us and he is just getting fatter and fatter. He was a stocky lad anyway, but now he actually waddles and his neck rolls over and partially obscures the knot on his school tie. Noticed a few days ago that his mum drops him off at the end of our road rather than him walking and my son told me that this lad always has MASSIVE bags of pick and mix sweets with him and all he ever eats is sweets or pizza. His mum is the manager of a local cinema, skinny as a rake, but literally gives her son over a pound of pure sugar to take to school for a snack every day. We're on a chat group together. She shares that he eats no fruit or veg, he refuses. He eats pizza, chips, those sweets which she doesn't mention in chat, and occasionally some lasagne. That's it.

Goldenbear · 09/02/2022 12:56

I agree with the above post, my childhood had fishfingers in it, shop bought pie all with veg but sometimes chips rather than potatoes, jacket potato and there was a point when stuffed pasta started to be sold in supermarkets that we seemed to live off this. My mum was fairly formal about meals so always at the table, usually veg or salad in a serving dish in the middle to help yourselves but that often meant not helping myself to much veg! We always had a dessert and yet we were thin. My DCs diet is more interesting so I will cook stuff like Thai curry or seafood pasta dishes basically more variety but they do also have junk and snacks as my teenager is always hungry! He will also eat stuff out and about that is not great for him. Despite this they are both very thin. I do think other environmental factors must come in to play as I know what my DC eat and it doesn't include Kale smoothies. I would say often my dishes from scratch ar never finished. Thw other night my DD described it as looking like slugs on a plate. After the rejection there is no dinner 2 but later she will eat things like buttered crumpets, cheese straws, chocolate biscuits so there isn't a calorie deficit of sorts.

5128gap · 09/02/2022 12:41

@RedToothBrush

30 years ago, kids weren't as overweight as they are now.

I do not believe that there are more kids with medical issues or bad genes in that time frame.

Its lifestyle, parenting and fucking shit excuses.

I was a parent nearly 30 years ago. A typical days diet for my DC was coco pops, cheese sandwich on white bread with crisps and a mini roll, an apple that was brought home untouched, then chicken nuggets chips and beans for tea. Pretty much what every other DC ate too. We went almost everywhere by car, and had just stopped letting children play out much, after some fairly high profile child abductions. Few children hadn't had their first happy meal by the age of two. I'm sure that's not everyone's experience of parenting at that time, but i readily admit it was mine, and that of my circle. And you're right, kids weren't as overweight as they are now, despite what you'd no doubt consider some pretty poor parenting by today's standards. So, I don't know what the issue is, but its certainly not as straightforward as harking back three decades to some golden age of excellent nutrition that didn't exist.
PleasantBirthday · 09/02/2022 12:37

Even just the acceptance that there is a problem though is key. The doing something about it comes after, with or without help but the blatant ignoring it and setting a child up for all kinds of problems is what gets my goat. The denial.

It is frustrating. It is. And it's damaging and I believe a form of child abuse. I feel the same way when I people smoking around their children too (and several other things!). But I don't - can't - believe that people think it's honestly OK. I think they feel powerless and hopeless and don't believe that they personally can change anything in their lives and it troubles me that so many people feel so powerless in their own lives and in the lives of their children.

There is something very wrong with how society operates in general.

MondayYogurt · 09/02/2022 12:36

We live in an obesogenic environment. If adults struggle with weight what hope do children have?

Satingreenshutters · 09/02/2022 12:36

@RedToothBrush

The magic fat kid who doesn't have a medical issue, eats healthy sized portions of home cooked food and does the appropriate level of exercise.

Hmm.

Yes. There's an epidemic of them that didn't exist 30 years ago.

Snacks have a lot to answer for.

Bang on.
RedToothBrush · 09/02/2022 12:34

The magic fat kid who doesn't have a medical issue, eats healthy sized portions of home cooked food and does the appropriate level of exercise.

Hmm.

Yes. There's an epidemic of them that didn't exist 30 years ago.

Snacks have a lot to answer for.

amusedbush · 09/02/2022 12:32

As much as some people like to reduce weight to "too much food = fat", it's more complex than that. Weight is impacted by caloric intake, yes, but also hormone regulation, genetics, socioeconomic status.

Everyone on my mum's side of the family is fat. Before even getting to the genetics of weight, there's a large psychological component; every single family member has yo-yoed in weight their entire life, on constant diets, in and out of slimming groups, etc. My mum perpetuated the cycle with me, monitoring my food and attaching SO MUCH emotion and guilt to it. She sent mixed signals by shaming me for asking for a piece of fruit between meals, but then I'd find empty containers in the bin from the Chinese takeaway she had eaten while I was in bed.

I was 10 stone (and 5' 5, same as I am now) at 12 years old. Hilariously, I have never been anywhere near 10 stone again in my entire life - the closest I ever got was 12 stone in 2017, which I achieved through overexercising and starving myself for months.

I have always gained weight at the drop of a hat so when I was a child and people saw my chunky frame standing next to my slim friends, they had no idea that I ate a similar diet to them (packed lunch every day, few snacks, rarely a takeaway), I cycled everywhere, rode horses, did gymnastics and karate, spent my time running around the beach and climbing trees with my friend. There was no obvious reason that I was fatter than them, not until I started becoming really aware of "bad" food (in my mother's eyes) and binge eating in secret as a teenager.

Satingreenshutters · 09/02/2022 12:30

@PleasantBirthday

As I say, *@Satingreenshutters*, I completely understand your point and largely agree with it. I suppose my issue is that maybe I'm just an oppositional person and the tone makes me instinctively hostile to the substance.

I'm not sure that bluntness helps people to change because I think that the lifestyles you describe could possibly be mental health issues, people self medicating with food who are really depressed and I think the tendency to try and prod or provoke people to change terrible habits without any coping mechanism or support for the underlying issues isn't ultimately helpful.

I understand what you are saying, I was nicer in my other posts lol, I am just getting frustrated.

Even just the acceptance that there is a problem though is key. The doing something about it comes after, with or without help but the blatant ignoring it and setting a child up for all kinds of problems is what gets my goat. The denial.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 09/02/2022 12:20

Yes, sorry.

A balanced, nutritious diet and plenty of exercise is vital for children. Letting them over/eat or serving big portions or fatty desserts does them a life long disservice.

PleasantBirthday · 09/02/2022 12:19

As I say, @Satingreenshutters, I completely understand your point and largely agree with it. I suppose my issue is that maybe I'm just an oppositional person and the tone makes me instinctively hostile to the substance.

I'm not sure that bluntness helps people to change because I think that the lifestyles you describe could possibly be mental health issues, people self medicating with food who are really depressed and I think the tendency to try and prod or provoke people to change terrible habits without any coping mechanism or support for the underlying issues isn't ultimately helpful.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 09/02/2022 12:17

@LimeSegment

OP what do you say to the many people on here, including me, that are aware of the issue and follow all the "rules" (healthy home cooking, no beige oven foods, no snacks, no treats, water only to drink, hours of exercise daily, no screen time) and have one overweight dc and one or more normal/thin dc. Do you think we are abusing that dc alone? Do you think we force food down that one kids throat, but give salads to the other? Do you think we take thin dc out for a bike ride and leave fat dc at home alone?

I am not critisizing you for starting the thread, I totally agree it's such an important issue. And of course I know my kid isn't outside the laws of physics. But it's just so tough, you know.

I don't know anyone else who doesn't allow their kids snacks, or bread, or restricts milk to 100ml of skim per day. I do, but my kid is overweight.

Well I'm not a medical professional but I would say that it what you are stating is true, then you need to consult a GP because the basic facts are that if a child is receiving a balanced diet and encouraged to keep active as you say provide then there must be an underlying issue for them to continue to gain weight.
OP posts:
Satingreenshutters · 09/02/2022 12:12

[quote PleasantBirthday]@Satingreenshutters, I agree with the substance of what you're saying but your tone is very offputting and actually I feel my hackles rise when I'm reading it. Instinctively, I find it hard to agree because it's so strident and unkind. While not everyone has medical issues that affect their weight, people can have all kinds of problems that we may not know about. They may not, they may be as bad and awful as you are saying.

However, all of us have weaknesses and blind spots. All of us are only human and all of us are trying to cope in various ways.[/quote]
I am not trying to be unkind. I am being blunt. I have posted a lot on this thread and the same old excuses keep being churned out.

Yes we are all human and we all struggle with parenthood, it's hard. It's bloody hard. Am I the best mother in the world? Not by any stretch of the imagination. Have I made mistakes? You better believe it.

The point I am trying to make is that medical issues do not come into it. That is for another thread. THIS thread is about parent feeding their children shite and the kids getting fat and the parents denying it, ignoring it, excusing it and allowing it.

Kids do not get fat for nothing. Kids do not become overweight with no medical issues. Kids are not meant to be fat. Kids are not meant to eat a fully processed diet and a load of junk on top.

The crux of this is not about blame, it is about awareness. These children will grow up to be fat teengers and in turn become even fatter adults and then have kids of their own who will become fat because they know no other way of eating. Fruit and vegetables are foreign objects, as we saw with Jamie Oliver, some kids can't even name them. There are such repercussions with letting a child get overweight and doing nothing. It is such a disservice to them. Setting them up for a life of obesity and problems. That is what I cannot get my head around. How you can willingly allow a child to get fat, do nothing and know what problems lie ahead for them, what disadvantages and stumbling blocks. It's all so avoidable and if it has become a problem it is changeable but a lot of parents don't want to change their own diet so won't make an effort to do it for the kids. So everyone stays fat.

HeyMoana · 09/02/2022 12:09

I do think you have a responsibility to make sure that your children are as healthy as they can be but no parent is perfect.
There are plenty of parents who don't hear their children read, don't engage with plans to support children's behaviour and don't spend time with them. This is easily brushed aside as a result of working hard and being very busy......but God forbid they are fat!
I have two slim kids. One is slim despite eating everything she sees. It takes a lot of parenting energy to keep the other slim because of her love of delicious foods, her motivation to be in involved with food and her body type.

CoffeeChocolateWine · 09/02/2022 12:08

Yes, I do judge, I admit. I am aware that there are sometimes other factors involved though, not just poor diet, lack of physical activity etc. Mainly I feel sad for the children because chances are they might be bullied, suffer from self-confidence issues, and just have a battle with it. And I don’t think it’s right for a child to have to go through that because of poor parenting.

I have 3 DC aged 13 to 3. They have a reasonable diet with plenty of fruit and veg but also plenty of sugary crap! They are also reasonably active - walk to school and do a sport as a hobby - but they also laze around a lot. But they are all very slim so it does make me wonder about the diets and lifestyle of kids who are really overweight.

LimeSegment · 09/02/2022 11:51

OP what do you say to the many people on here, including me, that are aware of the issue and follow all the "rules" (healthy home cooking, no beige oven foods, no snacks, no treats, water only to drink, hours of exercise daily, no screen time) and have one overweight dc and one or more normal/thin dc. Do you think we are abusing that dc alone? Do you think we force food down that one kids throat, but give salads to the other? Do you think we take thin dc out for a bike ride and leave fat dc at home alone?

I am not critisizing you for starting the thread, I totally agree it's such an important issue. And of course I know my kid isn't outside the laws of physics. But it's just so tough, you know.

I don't know anyone else who doesn't allow their kids snacks, or bread, or restricts milk to 100ml of skim per day. I do, but my kid is overweight.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 09/02/2022 11:32

@Unicornspirit

My child is overweight, do I over feed her, no. She has standard child portions, I scratch cook, she goes swimming and judo and I try and keep her active. I noticed the weight going on when we ended up living in a flat and there is no garden like so many housing association places now. There is not even a communal area here and so because she spends more time indoors after school she has put on weight. Too many people judge without knowing the reasons why. Not all of us are lazy bad parents!
I obviously don't know the ins and outs of your situation, but as someone also living in an apartment without access to a garden... I'm not sure I can fully buy into that as a reason.

We walk everywhere, she goes to ballet, swimming lessons and tennis. If it's not raining on the walk home from school we stop by the play park, during the summer it's straight to the beach after school. I know I'm fortunate to have access to those things, but even without the ones that are financially or geographically dependant, play parks and walking everywhere is attainable and doable for most, I'd have thought.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 09/02/2022 11:22

30 years ago, kids weren't as overweight as they are now.

I do not believe that there are more kids with medical issues or bad genes in that time frame.

Its lifestyle, parenting and fucking shit excuses.

Tynetime · 09/02/2022 11:20

@RedToothBrush I wouldn't be so sure you know. My ASD/ARFID child was diagnosed at 14..

Silversprinkles · 09/02/2022 11:16

@IsAnybodyListening

Re your sons diet

Pasta = white carbs
Crisps = white carbs
Jacket potato = starchy carbs
Cereal = (sugary?) carbs

He may suit a LCHF diet much better. It's worth a try. I know many people who have been overweight for years and once they dropped the carbs down (low carb not no carb) they easily lost weight and maintain well. Similar calories but in a form their body can utilise better and it stops the cravings. Keeps their blood sugar and mood much more stable. It's worth investigating. Not something I'd say for a child as they need carbs for growth but at your son's practically adult age, it could work for him.

Unicornspirit · 09/02/2022 11:16

My child is overweight, do I over feed her, no. She has standard child portions, I scratch cook, she goes swimming and judo and I try and keep her active. I noticed the weight going on when we ended up living in a flat and there is no garden like so many housing association places now. There is not even a communal area here and so because she spends more time indoors after school she has put on weight. Too many people judge without knowing the reasons why. Not all of us are lazy bad parents!