Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
5128gap · 09/02/2022 19:20

@Ottolin3

Sounds like extremely lazy parenting to me
It wasn't.
Ottolin3 · 09/02/2022 19:15

Sounds like extremely lazy parenting to me

5128gap · 09/02/2022 18:55

@Ottolin3

I am 30 and this is not what I ate, and not remotely normal for any child i grew up with to eat!
Well clearly I haven't outed myself as your mum then! Smile
Blackmagicqueen · 09/02/2022 18:40

'18:28KittensTeaAndCake
I have struggled all my life with my weight.. however, we have good, happy lives and are healthy enough to not have any illness or ailments etc...'

'You may both be in fine fettle now but who knows how long that will last? How can you keep giving your young DD so much food because she 'has a big appetite' knowing she is overweight and that you're storing up health problems for her future? I don't get it.'

Exactly this ^
And the risk of type 2 diabetes in later life will be greatly increased. Also more likelihood of joint issues etc. You can't just say 'oh I'm fat but healthy' as that is shorterm and ignorant of increased risk of future issues.

Giraffesandbottoms · 09/02/2022 18:36

With healthy, nutritious food becoming increasingly out of the reach

What a load of shit.

And yes, children who are underweight with no medical conditions are just as bad. I stopped being friends with someone with a daughter who was at 1%, couldn’t be fucked to see a doctor thought it was “lucky” her 2 year old was so thin and thought a bucket of chocolate buttons was a great way to fatten her up. I think that’s more unusual though.

KittensTeaAndCake · 09/02/2022 18:28

I have struggled all my life with my weight.. however, we have good, happy lives and are healthy enough to not have any illness or ailments etc...

You may both be in fine fettle now but who knows how long that will last? How can you keep giving your young DD so much food because she 'has a big appetite' knowing she is overweight and that you're storing up health problems for her future? I don't get it.

Drinkyourweaklemondrink · 09/02/2022 18:28

Even though I try to take into consideration any medical issues, it's hard to not judge the parents of children who are very overweight.
One child I know would regularly rock up eating a king sized mars bar at 8.35am

I do really feel for some as lockdown really affected the health of many children.

Puffalicious · 09/02/2022 18:22

CHIRIBAYA We have self-determination! We're not a mindless, homogenous lump: we can look at our environment and make our own decisions. There's loads of healthy eating/ living/ cooking taught in secondary schools, the simple fact is that adults choose what they eat, the kids have little control and it's not fair on them.

Puffalicious · 09/02/2022 18:17

@Blackmagicqueen

"We also walk, alot, and swim and dance, she also has a big appetite, as do I.,"

Than you have to shrink your appetite by controlling portion size and the amount of calories you both eat per day. This isn't an excuse to overfeed your child.

This.

You're both consuming too many calories, you can't surely just give in to the fact that you have a 'big appetite'. I would love to eat 2 pieces of salmon with twice as many potatoes and broccoli, but at 400 calories a salmon piece I just ate one with a few potatoes and plenty veg. I'm 50 and my weight slowly crept on over the past 5 years. I've lost 2 stone and have 1 to go. It seems that these days I can't eat very much at all (1100ish calories) if I want to lose weight and 1500ish to maintain. I'd need to do lots of exercise every day to up the calories significantly.

I judge, I do. There's a young girl- about 10-11, I see at the gate who is significantly overweight. Her mum is her exact shape but a much bigger, adult version. I judge, I definitely do as that young girl will struggle: perhaps with exercise, or appearance issues or, perhaps, bullying.

Canaloha · 09/02/2022 18:16

A lot of healthy ingredients are cheaper than ever though, the issue is a lot of junk food is also cheap but quicker and easier to cook as well.

Ottolin3 · 09/02/2022 18:15

I am 30 and this is not what I ate, and not remotely normal for any child i grew up with to eat!

Ottolin3 · 09/02/2022 18:13

@MrsSkylerWhite

With healthy, nutritious food becoming increasingly out of the reach, this will become more commonplace.
How is it out of reach? This is completely untrue!
anon12345678901 · 09/02/2022 18:12

@IzzyD0ra

My young child is overweight, but she unfortunately has the fat gene coming at her from both ends, she eats a very healthy and varied diet, as do I. We also walk, alot, and swim and dance, she also has a big appetite, as do I. I have struggled all my life with my weight.. however, we have good, happy lives and are healthy enough to not have any illness or ailments etc... But it's good to know there's mums like yourself out there at the school gates secretly judging us behind our backs

Wow. So you know your daughter is overweight but refuse to do anything about it because..fat gene? You've struggled with your weight so why don't you want to prevent your daughter from suffering the same? If she's overweight it's because she is consuming more calories than she needs.

IMO that's really poor parenting. To know your child is overweight from over eating and just brush it off.
CHIRIBAYA · 09/02/2022 18:10

No I don't. While there is of course, a place for parental responsibility, our culture and in particular our food culture is geared towards convenience and profit for a very powerful food lobby. We are bombarded from birth by processed food, junk and foods with fat/sugar ratios highly detrimental to our health. Go into any supermarket and it will be predominantly processed foods on the shelves. Cooking healthy food also takes time. Not just the cooking of it but the planning, purchasing and packing; it can be hard to find the energy and focus when you are constantly stressed and busy and once again, modern life is organised to generate ongoing stress -obesity is recognised as having a correlation with inflammation, i.e stress. We also live hugely sedentary lives. Our environments are geared up to driving, we send kids off to school to have them sit down for most of the day and then often parked up at home in front of screens; they do not enjoy the freedoms that people from earlier generations enjoyed. So I would say we need to look at our environment and attend to that before we blame and judge individuals.

Blackmagicqueen · 09/02/2022 18:07

"We also walk, alot, and swim and dance, she also has a big appetite, as do I.,"

Than you have to shrink your appetite by controlling portion size and the amount of calories you both eat per day. This isn't an excuse to overfeed your child.

Canaloha · 09/02/2022 18:03

@MissMaple82

My young child is overweight, but she unfortunately has the fat gene coming at her from both ends, she eats a very healthy and varied diet, as do I. We also walk, alot, and swim and dance, she also has a big appetite, as do I. I have struggled all my life with my weight.. however, we have good, happy lives and are healthy enough to not have any illness or ailments etc... But it's good to know there's mums like yourself out there at the school gates secretly judging us behind our backs.
No she doesn't, she is eating too much or not active enough, things like 'fat gene' are what people said to me and it made me feel hopeless like I was destined to be fat and couldn't change it.
IzzyD0ra · 09/02/2022 17:38

My young child is overweight, but she unfortunately has the fat gene coming at her from both ends, she eats a very healthy and varied diet, as do I. We also walk, alot, and swim and dance, she also has a big appetite, as do I. I have struggled all my life with my weight.. however, we have good, happy lives and are healthy enough to not have any illness or ailments etc... But it's good to know there's mums like yourself out there at the school gates secretly judging us behind our backs

Wow. So you know your daughter is overweight but refuse to do anything about it because..fat gene? You've struggled with your weight so why don't you want to prevent your daughter from suffering the same? If she's overweight it's because she is consuming more calories than she needs.

KittensTeaAndCake · 09/02/2022 17:32

Also, would you feel sad for the underweight kids? What size or shape do you consider to be a happy healthy kid that you needn't feel sad for???

I feel sorry for any kid who gets left out because of what they look like, yes.

RedToothBrush · 09/02/2022 17:18

I tend to think that when healthy eating is work that you have to learn to do, there will be a good number of people who don't. It has to be easy and normative.

What you are saying there, which won't go down well, is that some fst people are simply just lazy.

I think there is a reality, that staying thin and/or eating healthy (as the two are not necessarily the same) requires effort and self discipline at some level, even if its to turn down a biscuit when offered at work or to think about what you eat better.

The abundance of choice isn't necessarily one thats good for people.

SantaClawsServiette · 09/02/2022 17:05

@RedToothBrush

Generally speaking when it comes to your own kids class, you know the parents who are uninterested dicks and the ones who are engaged and involved with their kids.

Kids who are SEN you know. You also know whether the parents are the type who doing whatever they can, or whether they cannot be arsed.

I don't think its hard to spot.

Where I've judged is when Ive known over a period of time, how much of a dick the said parent is. I would rather my child played with the difficult sen kid with the parents who cared than the fat kid whose mum is in complete denial of a fairly obvious problem (which you can see manifesting in numerous ways and causing the child multiple issues). Why? Because its not what the kid is thats the issue, its whether the parents are taking appropriate steps and trying to help their kid in the best possible way. Its the neglect / denialism that I take particular issue with. Not beige food etc. Not with being fat alone.

Its about the attitude that goes with it...

I would agree you often have a good idea what's going on.

But I'm not sure the line's always around parents trying or now.

My daughter's friend is overweight, and her parents are very much so. It affects their health. They are nice people and adore their daughter. They don't really cook at all, they mostly eat microwave food. Both hate cooking and don't seem to have any desire for nicer food.

For whatever reason they don't seem able to grapple with eating healthily or even just a little more moderately. They aren't neglectful in any ordinary sense. They aren't overly intelligent but are aware of what others consider healthy eating.

I tend to think that when healthy eating is work that you have to learn to do, there will be a good number of people who don't. It has to be easy and normative. It's always weird when you look at old beach photos from the 50s or kids in playgrounds etc. There are no fat kids and few if no fat adults - possibly some older women but they are as likely to be very thin. To me that says that there has been a change in the environment around eating and also physical activity.

MissMaple82 · 09/02/2022 17:03

My young child is overweight, but she unfortunately has the fat gene coming at her from both ends, she eats a very healthy and varied diet, as do I. We also walk, alot, and swim and dance, she also has a big appetite, as do I. I have struggled all my life with my weight.. however, we have good, happy lives and are healthy enough to not have any illness or ailments etc... But it's good to know there's mums like yourself out there at the school gates secretly judging us behind our backs.

lightisnotwhite · 09/02/2022 16:59

I was a parent nearly 30 years ago. A typical days diet for my DC was coco pops, cheese sandwich on white bread with crisps and a mini roll, an apple that was brought home untouched, then chicken nuggets chips and beans for tea. Pretty much what every other DC ate too. We went almost everywhere by car, and had just stopped letting children play out much, after some fairly high profile child abductions. Few children hadn't had their first happy meal by the age of two. I'm sure that's not everyone's experience of parenting at that time, but i readily admit it was mine, and that of my circle. And you're right, kids weren't as overweight as they are now, despite what you'd no doubt consider some pretty poor parenting by today's standards. So, I don't know what the issue is, but its certainly not as straightforward as harking back three decades to some golden age of excellent nutrition that didn't exist.

This is true but the 80’s were the start of that sort of diet. 30 years ago would be early 90’s and even then food wasn’t available like it is now.. The supermarkets weren’t 24 hours or even open late. There were less people and less families in urban centres.Kids might have been fed rubbish but it was limited.
Sharing bags size wasn’t a thing.
Take away deliveries weren’t a thing.
It was rare to find people drinking Coke by the litre everyday.
At the end of the 80’s there were 300 MacDonalds, 900 at the the end of the 90’s and today there are 1,270. That’s a lot more kids and a lot more consumption.

MissMaple82 · 09/02/2022 16:53

You have absolutely no idea about the home life or history or genetics regarding why they may be overweight so yeah you're a judgmental #$@% ... Also, would you feel sad for the underweight kids? What size or shape do you consider to be a happy healthy kid that you needn't feel sad for???

KittensTeaAndCake · 09/02/2022 16:35

I would rather my child played with the difficult sen kid with the parents who cared than the fat kid whose mum is in complete denial of a fairly obvious problem (which you can see manifesting in numerous ways and causing the child multiple issues).

That's not nice. I feel really sorry for the fat kids, why wouldn't you want your DC playing with them? It's not their fault.

Cameleongirl · 09/02/2022 15:49

@MingeofDeath. I’m not sure after 31 pages. But, I will say that some people are naturally more “well covered” than others, even when eating healthily and exercising regularly. My DD has always had more padding than bony old me, for example, despite being a school athlete and very health conscious food-wise. She’s a voluptuous hourglass and not overweight at all, but I’m a slighter build.

I’d say I eat worse then she does as I enjoy wine calories, whereas she’s teetotal and drinks lots of water. Blush