Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 10/02/2022 10:18

"You don't need that biscuit. Refuse the office cake thats passed around at least once a week. Don't grab that tasty treat with your Costa or Starbucks. Etc, etc."

Total deprivation like that can lead to the opposite. These things are fine if not every day. My office doesn't have cake once a week, just birthdays, but even then a small piece of cake once a week is not what makes you fat.

BaconAndAvocado · 10/02/2022 09:59

RedToothBrush
I completely agree with you re snacking.
Growing up in the 70s a packet of crisps was definitely a treat and eating the 3 standard meals a day was the norm.

ufucoffee · 10/02/2022 09:59

My diet was chips with everything in the 60's and 70's. Hardly any vegetables. But I was very skinny. I think due to no snacking, walking everywhere and playing outside for hours everyday. We had lots of freedom so used to cycle to parks miles away during the holidays from the age of 10. I didn't start putting on weight until I learned to drive in my 20's, discovered takeaways and snacking.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 09:50

@Puffalicious

The plethora of advice on diet and the almost obsessional concern with what children eat was not a feature in the past. While people ate home cooked meals, this didn't matter as they would be fairly healthy by default. With the rise in unhealthy options and an absence of the education available today, habits were set in motion that have cascaded down the generations

This is really interesting 5128gap Do you think that's why you chose the particular diet for your DC? 30 years ago is a different experience to my childhood 50/40 years ago, and to my own parenting, starting 17 years ago, so the ideas/ influences would have been very different.

Don't diet. Just don't snack constantly.

It would make a huge difference to the health of the country generally.

You don't need that biscuit. Refuse the office cake thats passed around at least once a week. Don't grab that tasty treat with your Costa or Starbucks. Etc, etc.

Puffalicious · 10/02/2022 09:45

The plethora of advice on diet and the almost obsessional concern with what children eat was not a feature in the past. While people ate home cooked meals, this didn't matter as they would be fairly healthy by default. With the rise in unhealthy options and an absence of the education available today, habits were set in motion that have cascaded down the generations

This is really interesting 5128gap Do you think that's why you chose the particular diet for your DC? 30 years ago is a different experience to my childhood 50/40 years ago, and to my own parenting, starting 17 years ago, so the ideas/ influences would have been very different.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 09:42

The problem is the 'creep' on how portion sizes have increased over the years without us noticing and how snacks have been normalised.

We didn't used to have snacks in the house. We certainly didn't have them daily. Crisps were a treat. We didn't have snack at school.

Now, DS's school has a snacktime in the morning and kids can take in their own in the afternoon. This is used, partly as a pacifier to reduce difficult behaviour. Its normalising eating 5 times a day though.

The average person who is overweight is only eating a couple of hundred calories per day too much. But over the course of time that builds up. A hundred calories is literally one snack - a slice of toast, a packet of crisps or a small chocolate bar.

These are foods which are now being designed to be addictive too.

Once you wrap your head around the idea that being overweight can come from a single snack too many during the day, it does give you pause for thought.

5128gap · 10/02/2022 07:15

@Ottolin3

How is feeding your child chicken nuggets, chips and beans not lazy! There is zero nutritional value to any of the meals you stated in your previous post.
You're not a nutritionalist then I take it? You do understand that if a child's diet has 'zero' nutrional value, they could not survive, never mind grow into healthy adulthood as my children and their peers have assuredly done? Of course it wasn't a great diet, that was my point, but really, there is no need for such dramatics.
Rivermonsters · 10/02/2022 07:09

Yes I do. The parents are setting them up to a life of hardship, plus don’t have a child if you’re just gonna feed it crap

5128gap · 10/02/2022 07:03

@LexMitior

No not everyone ate Coco Pops and McDonalds and mini rolls. My mother cooked food. So I do I now. Seriously, don't claim its a generational thing to eat stuff like this - its a choice. One that you don't have to make on behalf your kids. But its on you if you do.
You have your lived experience, I have mine. I stated in my post that not everyone will have experienced the same. I gave an account of the diet of my children and those of our peers at the time. It was almost 30 years ago and things were different for some of us then. I could go into details about the reasons that may have been, but it would appear defensive, and truth be told, when I consider the outcome, two strong healthy adult DC who have been slim fit and athletic all their lives, with less than average illness, who now make physically and mentally healthy dietary choices, I feel it is somewhat irrelevant. That said, I do think the root of the current eating patterns lies with my generation of parents. The plethora of advice on diet and the almost obsessional concern with what children eat was not a feature in the past. While people ate home cooked meals, this didn't matter as they would be fairly healthy by default. With the rise in unhealthy options and an absence of the education available today, habits were set in motion that have cascaded down the generations.
5128gap · 10/02/2022 06:44

@Ottolin3

‘coco pops, cheese sandwich on white bread with crisps and a mini roll, an apple that was brought home untouched, then chicken nuggets chips and beans for tea’ 🤯🤯🤯🤯

I feel sorry for your children!

There are only two people whose opinion on my parenting I am remotely interested in. Yours isn't one of them. However if you feel your comparatively recent experience gives you the authority to judge something I have already successfully completed, then at least it means you may be leaving the women who are doing it now alone for a time.
Tynetime · 10/02/2022 00:35

I am 50 from a w/c family. My dm was an excellent cook and I had FSM. We had healthy home cooked food at home but school not so much. In Primary you weren't allowed to leave anything even pudding but at least it was balanced. In secondary it was a vile cash cafeteria. All hamburger and chips etc. I wasn't overweight though but than we rarely had money for snacks etc. Very occasionally we would have 2OZ of sweets

IzzyD0ra · 10/02/2022 00:02

DS is 10. He genuinely eats a good diet. DH used to be a chef. 95% of our meals are home cooked. Snacks on fruit etc

Just because his meals are home cooked and snacks he snacks in fruits does not mean your son isn't consuming too many calories for his needs.

Cut the portion sizes, snack (if a snack really is necessary) on vegetables.

RedToothBrush · 09/02/2022 23:26

Think Wayne Rooney type chubby (did you know Wayne Rooney wa Everton's academy goalie till he was 16!)

Errr Wayne Rooney has been pulled up on being overweight during his career and how its been a problem...

Oldtiredfedup · 09/02/2022 22:32

No I don’t. I havd two children (half siblings) - one has always been rake thin and the other bordering on overweight (the other parent has always been on thd chubby side) . I worry and do my best, but they live 50% of the time eith the other parent who rarely takes dc2 out anywhere, getting dc2 to exercise is nigh on impossible without tears and meltdowns, we’ve never lived in school catchment so friendships have been nigh in non existent.

And in that basis I ding judge - you have zero idea what’s going on snd surely you've got enough going on in your own life?

Gwenhwyfar · 09/02/2022 22:22

"Those commenting about being in their 40s and everyone ate like that- no they didn't. I've just turned 50 and in my working class house we had home cooked food every night with lots of vegetables; fruit always available and limited snacks. I didn't know what a takeaway was until I was in my teens."

Nobody said everyone did. We were talking about everyone we knew. explained it was everyone except one family that I knew.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 09/02/2022 21:35

This gets me really annoyed. My Dd was a bit chubby aged 7. Turned out she was building up for puberty which arrived aged 10. She's now 13 and very slim.

DS is 10. He genuinely eats a good diet. DH used to be a chef. 95% of our meals are home cooked. Snacks on fruit etc. He also plays academy level and grassroots football at least 5 days a week. Cycles to and from school. Active with friends etc. yet he remains chubby. I think he has my metabolism which is rubbish. It's so unfair. What more can we do?! I'm just hoping he doing same as Dd and will shoot up. He is tall for his age (he's a goalkeeper). DH and I are both short but there is a tall gene in the family (and a relative used to be the welsh and Leeds goalkeeper.

Think Wayne Rooney type chubby (did you know Wayne Rooney wa Everton's academy goalie till he was 16!)

LexMitior · 09/02/2022 21:25

No not everyone ate Coco Pops and McDonalds and mini rolls. My mother cooked food. So I do I now. Seriously, don't claim its a generational thing to eat stuff like this - its a choice. One that you don't have to make on behalf your kids. But its on you if you do.

Puffalicious · 09/02/2022 21:20

Those commenting about being in their 40s and everyone ate like that- no they didn't. I've just turned 50 and in my working class house we had home cooked food every night with lots of vegetables; fruit always available and limited snacks. I didn't know what a takeaway was until I was in my teens.

My own DC are 17, 15 and 10 and none of them had McDonald's or any other fast food before they started school. We've always gonr to local cafes instead. DC1 was invited to a party age 6 and didn't realise McDs was a thing, just thought it was a cafe. None of them to this day would touch a nugget.

It IS poor parenting. Ingredients for soup cost very little and fills kids up at any time of the day. Pastas/ rice dishes are very economical, esp.if vegetarian.

Meatshake · 09/02/2022 20:19

I used to until my nephew got a catastrophic form of epilepsy as a young baby. He had to go on drugs which made him absolutely balloon in size until recently. They also reduced his muscle tone giving him a lower than average BMR, while also making him ravenously hungry. He has brain damage relating to the epilepsy which hit during his very formative months while he was learning how to eat, as such he has a limited diet because he doesn't recognise most foods as food.

He's 7 now and I'm thankfully recovered well mentally but those physical effects of medication will stay with him for life. Looking at him he looks completely normal when playing with his friends you'd never be able to tell. Except he is fat.

That's why I don't judge any more, you've got no idea what someone has been through.

Gwenhwyfar · 09/02/2022 20:13

"I was a parent nearly 30 years ago. A typical days diet for my DC was coco pops, cheese sandwich on white bread with crisps and a mini roll, an apple that was brought home untouched, then chicken nuggets chips and beans for tea. Pretty much what every other DC ate too. We went almost everywhere by car, and had just stopped letting children play out much, after some fairly high profile child abductions. Few children hadn't had their first happy meal by the age of two. I'm sure that's not everyone's experience of parenting at that time, but i readily admit it was mine, and that of my circle. And you're right, kids weren't as overweight as they are now, despite what you'd no doubt consider some pretty poor parenting by today's standard"

I'm in my 40s and this was definitely how we eat when I was growing up. The only ones of my friends who didn't eat like this were the children of a doctor and a nurse and we thought those parents were cruel not giving them easy access to sweets.
The reason why we weren't overweight was the portion sizes I think. We didn't eat very healthily, but we weren't overeating as well.

Stroopwaffle5000 · 09/02/2022 19:48

Initially I do judge, yes, but I also try to remind myself that there could be a medical reason behind it and to not be so judgey. I would keep my opinions to myself though.

BaconAndAvocado · 09/02/2022 19:48

I probably would judge if the parents were huge too.
As many have commented, adults can make choices about what they put in their mouths but their children can’t.
Very sad.

Ottolin3 · 09/02/2022 19:32

‘coco pops, cheese sandwich on white bread with crisps and a mini roll, an apple that was brought home untouched, then chicken nuggets chips and beans for tea’ 🤯🤯🤯🤯

I feel sorry for your children!

Ottolin3 · 09/02/2022 19:30

How is feeding your child chicken nuggets, chips and beans not lazy! There is zero nutritional value to any of the meals you stated in your previous post.

KittensTeaAndCake · 09/02/2022 19:22

@Giraffesandbottoms

With healthy, nutritious food becoming increasingly out of the reach

What a load of shit.

And yes, children who are underweight with no medical conditions are just as bad. I stopped being friends with someone with a daughter who was at 1%, couldn’t be fucked to see a doctor thought it was “lucky” her 2 year old was so thin and thought a bucket of chocolate buttons was a great way to fatten her up. I think that’s more unusual though.

Yeah what is it with the healthy food is too expensive shite? No one's believing that nonsense are they? When you can get a bag of carrots for 40p, pasta for 20p, and tinned tomatoes for 28p. Oh but it's too expensive to cook it (even though they manage to cook the pizza, burgers and nuggets just fine). An individual banana is 14p in Tesco but some people prefer to give their kid a share bag of skittles for £1 instead.

It's just excuses.