Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
Laiste · 10/02/2022 15:08

The majority of people know that there are medical reasons for being fat but they also know these days majority of fat people are fat because of their diet.

Brutally honestly this is my thought process:

Could be medical, but probably isn't. Especially if the parent/s are fat as well.

Is this ''judging''? I don't know. What would make it ''judging''?

catscatscatseverywhere · 10/02/2022 14:52

If parents are overweight/obese, I do judge. Sorry.

Octopus37 · 10/02/2022 14:41

@Sowhatifiam

How is feeding your child chicken nuggets, chips and beans not lazy! There is zero nutritional value to any of the meals you stated in your previous post

baked beans count as one of your veg portions so there's plenty of nutrition in them.

You need a long hard look at people's lives, the cost of food, the cost of fuel (which is going to get even worse), the time people get home from work etc. etc. Sometimes a freezer meal is as good as it's going to get. You should perhaps try living other people's lives and see how you feel about setting to and cooking a meal from scratch when you walk in or batch cooking on a weekend when you have a thousand and one other things to do. I do a mix of freezer, from scratch, half jar/half fresh meals because there's just me and I work full time, and part time, and seasonally part of the year as well. You can't describe me as lazy, that would be wholly in appropriate. I am a realist and do my best with the life that life threw at me. Sometimes I just need to throw my shoes off and take the path of least resistance.

Well said, I dont do quite as much work as you, but I'm very busy. The other thing to consider is that kids might not necessarily eat what you serve them. Its totally soul destroying cooking a lovely healthy meal and have them refuse to eat it. Its time and money down the drain and you still need to give them something else. Its all very well to say if they're hungry enough they'll eat, but it doesn't always work like that.

For what its worth, my boys are not overweight and both walk a lot and play football. I dont drive so unless my DH gives them lifts, they make their own way to places (they are 12 and 14). Because I dont drive I normally do a lot of walking. I'll admit that I've put on a bit of weight recently, about four pounds, combination of Christmas and not moving enough. I'm 5ft5 and just over 9st, so not skinny but not overweight recently. I grew up with a Mum who struggled with her weight, food was associated with guilt and tbh I ended up with a borderline eating disorder in my teens/20s. I'm not saying that my relationship with food is perfect now, but its better and I never wanted my boys to think in terms of food being banned etc. My Mum kept cake downstairs (we lived in a townhouse) so she couldn't eat it as easily herself), I grew up with the food guilt association. I remember visiting my bestie's house when we were in our teens.They always had a huge tine of chocolate biscuits and I used to ask her how she stayed so skinny cause I knew I wouldn't be able to control myself. She probably weighed between 6 and 7 stone whereas I was up and down between 8st and 9st. To some extent I think if you get used to having food around, it isn't so much of a novelty

Also, I think life's too short for constant guilt about food and healthy eating etc. My Mum still died when she was 58.

Gwenhwyfar · 10/02/2022 14:30

"You have to actively look though, rather than just pick up a standard pack. Right?

(I know cos I've done this).

You are making a conscious thinking choice in checking. The whole point is lots of people won't do that thinking."

Depends. Some of them have the calories on the front, others you have to look at the ingredients and check they're not for just 100g or half a pack or something. It's at least much easier than eating out, work canteen or food cooked by someone else in that you can at least find out if you want to.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/02/2022 13:33

So I am very overweight and I have 2 daughters. One is comfortably in normal weight range and always has been. One is overweight and has been getting there since she started school. She grew without gaining weight through lockdown 1 and was getting to a healthier weight but has reverted since. With both children I was very careful about what they ate when smaller. I ensure we always have 3-4 veg in dinner they can help themselves to with a portion of potato/rice/pasta and a portion of stew or chicken or fishfingers or whatever we are having as the protein element. We generally have snacks of fruit, oatcakes, veg sticks & baby bell. A couple of times a week we will have a puddding or sweets/crisps as a snack and a couple of times a month we get takeaway pizza or go out for a meal. Differences I notice between my kids are that one will sometimes eat dinner, sometimes not and if there is pudding will leave her main so she can eat all the pudding. Overweight one pretty much always eats all her dinner and often says she is hungry and asks for more. This is fine at home as we just direct her to the vegetables and tell her she can have as many as she likes. It’s not fine in other situations (asking for more food at school, at friends house if invited for tea, at her grandparents who won’t accept they are hurting her by giving her whatever she asks for, at birthday parties with a buffet etc). I really don’t know how to fix it. God knows we have tried as I was also an overweight child and it’s not something I want for her but short of banning her from doing anything with her friends, making a huge fuss at school, falling out with my parents horribly what else can we do? I can’t make her not ask for food and if I try and explain people should say no it’s all gone now &/or only offer more greens etc then they think I’m being mean and in some cases make a point of offering her crap because she’s so deprived by me. It’s not like she is sedentary either. We always walk to/from school, swim twice a week, she does sports session as after school care once a week, goes out on long bike rides with her dad and we are regularly out for long walks and go to play park or play out in the street. I know people judge me but honestly suspect they assume she eats nothing but junk or is constantly being offered snacks/allowed to do nothing but watch tv. I really sympathise with her as I always used to feel hungry when I was a child as well. I’ll be reading back through to look for any helpful suggestions someone has left but suspect it will be the usual pile of comments about how people can’t help not knowing how to feed their kids as they are poor/ill educated (I’m neither) and accusations of abuse (always nice to read)

SilverDoe · 10/02/2022 13:05

no guilt*!

SilverDoe · 10/02/2022 13:01

Yah portion size is a big thing. I'm starting to calorie count for my kids because my boy is very athletic and slim and I want him to eat a little more and my girl is a bit chubby but still active.

I don't think there's anything wrong with a balanced moderately healthy diet, I certainly feel my guilt over what I feed my kids. it sounds like a stealth boast but it's not as I never intended it to be this way or did anything IMO to make it come about, but my kids just don't like oven/ready food very much. They'll smash a McDonald's, KFC or Chinese takeway but it's not in my budget to offer these more than a few times a month.

So mine eat for dinner a mix of home cooked from scratch meals, as close as I can get to an oven meal once or twice a week (they will have certain oven pizzas and sweetcorn for example) and then when I cba to cook they have a healthy picnic style meal - fruit, veg, dairy, meat, a sweet and savoury treat. Have no guilt or shame over this whatsoever and feel like all their food groups are met without too much rubbish.

Need to cut down on the post school snacks, but it's difficult as he was a very deprived/neglected child so he absolutely loves buying them something after school. Interestingly though, I was a spoilt child from a family with a comfortable income and he was an orphan who ended up in an abusive home, but he is slim and athletic whereas I am chubby. I thought childhood deprivation could lead to overeating but I guess there are a whole host of bad habits one can pick up around food.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 12:31

Its not about being superior. Fuck knows, Macdonalds has its place and I'll happily eat one. Ditto supermarket pizza.

I don't think you have to cook from scratch daily.

You just can't eat the equivalent of supermarket pizza daily AND have a school dinner AND breakfast AND two snacks in between AND a snack when you get home and expect to be a healthy weight if you are 8.

The maths don't work.

This isn't moralising. This is being blunt about reality and people's perceptions of whats normal being utterly warped over the last generation.

Puffalicious · 10/02/2022 12:29

5128gapyou make some excellent points.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 12:27

Here's a good example:

Asda, bog standard pizza
groceries.asda.com/product/boxed-pizza/asda-cheese-tomato-pizza/1000225889789

1/2 a pizza = 331kcal.

Who eats just half a pizza?

If you eat the whole thing, then if you are small, that realistically can be half your daily food allowance.

Something has to give.

The funny thing is that 'slim people who can eat anything' share one magic common thing - overall they aren't eating too much. So they are 'giving' somewhere else if they do have an occasional binge.

5128gap · 10/02/2022 12:15

@Sowhatifiam

How is feeding your child chicken nuggets, chips and beans not lazy! There is zero nutritional value to any of the meals you stated in your previous post

baked beans count as one of your veg portions so there's plenty of nutrition in them.

You need a long hard look at people's lives, the cost of food, the cost of fuel (which is going to get even worse), the time people get home from work etc. etc. Sometimes a freezer meal is as good as it's going to get. You should perhaps try living other people's lives and see how you feel about setting to and cooking a meal from scratch when you walk in or batch cooking on a weekend when you have a thousand and one other things to do. I do a mix of freezer, from scratch, half jar/half fresh meals because there's just me and I work full time, and part time, and seasonally part of the year as well. You can't describe me as lazy, that would be wholly in appropriate. I am a realist and do my best with the life that life threw at me. Sometimes I just need to throw my shoes off and take the path of least resistance.

It doesn't matter what experiences you share, as some posters appear to be on this thread with the sole purpose of shaming and feeling superior to other women. You will merely be told how you could do better, because that is what they appear to enjoy about this discussion. It's all given a veneer of acceptability as its in the jnterests of children, but the post you have quoted was directed at something I did decades ago and the children concerned are now as old as the poster herself. I can hardly pop back to 1992 and put a lentil stew on, so the comment was clearly intended to do nothing more than belittle. It was obvious to me before posting that it would prompt the odd reaction like that from a certain type of person, but I felt I wanted to make the underlying point anyway . And yes, it is hard work.
RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 12:13

@Gwenhwyfar

"You then look at the calorie count on any standard ready meal. Again, any woman below average size would have to either skip meals completely or not eat a whole portion."

I used to eat a lot of ready meals and there were loads under about 450 calories. Really not that difficult to find.

What surprised me was reading on MN that people add things to ready meals. That would of course up the calories.

You have to actively look though, rather than just pick up a standard pack. Right?

(I know cos I've done this).

You are making a conscious thinking choice in checking. The whole point is lots of people won't do that thinking.

Gwenhwyfar · 10/02/2022 12:06

"You then look at the calorie count on any standard ready meal. Again, any woman below average size would have to either skip meals completely or not eat a whole portion."

I used to eat a lot of ready meals and there were loads under about 450 calories. Really not that difficult to find.

What surprised me was reading on MN that people add things to ready meals. That would of course up the calories.

Canaloha · 10/02/2022 12:04

@RedToothBrush

What I find most frightening is how people get offended when you state the bleeding obvious link over what people eat and their weight.

The deliberate cognitive dissonance to avoid the truth is telling.

I agree, and its not helpful to anyone.
Gwenhwyfar · 10/02/2022 12:02

"Advice was pretty much to try to eat 5 a day"

We didn't talk of 5 a day 30 years ago, did we? We knew that fruit and vegetables were good and people would say 'eat your greens'.

SilverDoe · 10/02/2022 12:01

How is feeding your child chicken nuggets, chips and beans not lazy! There is zero nutritional value to any of the meals you stated in your previous post

Oh FGS there is not "zero nutritional value" in a meal containing beans chicken and potatoes. Honestly..

Sowhatifiam · 10/02/2022 11:55

How is feeding your child chicken nuggets, chips and beans not lazy! There is zero nutritional value to any of the meals you stated in your previous post

baked beans count as one of your veg portions so there's plenty of nutrition in them.

You need a long hard look at people's lives, the cost of food, the cost of fuel (which is going to get even worse), the time people get home from work etc. etc. Sometimes a freezer meal is as good as it's going to get. You should perhaps try living other people's lives and see how you feel about setting to and cooking a meal from scratch when you walk in or batch cooking on a weekend when you have a thousand and one other things to do. I do a mix of freezer, from scratch, half jar/half fresh meals because there's just me and I work full time, and part time, and seasonally part of the year as well. You can't describe me as lazy, that would be wholly in appropriate. I am a realist and do my best with the life that life threw at me. Sometimes I just need to throw my shoes off and take the path of least resistance.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 11:50

What I find most frightening is how people get offended when you state the bleeding obvious link over what people eat and their weight.

The deliberate cognitive dissonance to avoid the truth is telling.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 11:48

@ClariceQuiff

The smaller bars are much worse value so people end up getting the bigger bar or sharing pouch for a pound or whatever!

It's only worse value if you can be confident you'll eke out the larger bar/pouch to save you buying several small bars in the long term. If you're going to eat the big bar in the same time frame you'd eat the small bar, it's not worse value.

If you go for the eking out route, a good tip is to portion it when you get home and put it in the freezer, so you won't end up having 'just one more piece'.

I currently have a massive box of Hotel Chocolat.

I got it for Christmas. Its one of my favourite gift which my inlaws have got me now for several years.

I think the normal mentality is to scoff the lot in a day or two. I've had to mentally make a conscious decision not to do that.

Instead, I've made a mental think to have one a day (to last through last years January/Feburary lockdown) or to encourage me to do a minimum daily exercise as I've got about a stone to lose atm (I've really struggled with motivation this year).

Its the 10th February. I still have half a box left. I am getting my nice treat, but I'm also not over doing it.

It does require you to make the effort and think about it though. You have to have will power.

Ultimately I think a lot of people just can't be fucked and would rather just eat the chocolates without thinking about it. For me though, its not just about the chocolates, its about doing something else positive whether it be for my mental health or for my physical health and to remove the guilt factor.

The bottomline here, is that our lifestyle and the fact we no longer do huge amounts of physical labour nor walking means we HAVE to think about it. We don't have a choice, if you don't want it to affect your health.

If you want a piece of cake daily, then you need to think about how you make allowances to do that - you ultimately have to give up something else to do it, whether it be to do an hours intensive exercise or to skip another meal or have another restricted calorie meal. Its not a 'no cost' equation.

5128gap · 10/02/2022 11:47

I think there's quite an interesting parallel at play with the gap between our attitudes to children's diets in the 90s when compared with today, and how the future may pan out. Ironically after our poor starts, we are now whole food vegans, and more and more people are starting to believe that this is the healthy and ethical choice. It makes me wonder if in another 30 years today's parents will be harshly judged by the current generation for their choice to feed their children animal products. This is not to start a discussion on the merits of veganism, but merely to highlight the changing priorities and opinions on diet throughout the ages, and that the advice you are following today was different from yesterday, and will likely be different again tomorrow.

ClariceQuiff · 10/02/2022 11:36

The smaller bars are much worse value so people end up getting the bigger bar or sharing pouch for a pound or whatever!

It's only worse value if you can be confident you'll eke out the larger bar/pouch to save you buying several small bars in the long term. If you're going to eat the big bar in the same time frame you'd eat the small bar, it's not worse value.

If you go for the eking out route, a good tip is to portion it when you get home and put it in the freezer, so you won't end up having 'just one more piece'.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 11:30

I actually think the healthy eating thing is problematic for just the reasons you mention.

As long as you are burning through what you eat and you haven't got bloody scurvy or rickets, then its generally better than if you were 'eating healthy' but were significantly overweight.

5128gap · 10/02/2022 11:26

@Puffalicious

The plethora of advice on diet and the almost obsessional concern with what children eat was not a feature in the past. While people ate home cooked meals, this didn't matter as they would be fairly healthy by default. With the rise in unhealthy options and an absence of the education available today, habits were set in motion that have cascaded down the generations

This is really interesting 5128gap Do you think that's why you chose the particular diet for your DC? 30 years ago is a different experience to my childhood 50/40 years ago, and to my own parenting, starting 17 years ago, so the ideas/ influences would have been very different.

I think there were various factors at play. Firstly, there was nowhere near the level of focus on the importance of healthy eating. Advice was pretty much to try to eat 5 a day, and certainly all the dire consequences of not eating healthily were not typically a part of our collective awareness. Secondly, obesity was not under the spotlight as it is today. I recall my major concern for DD being the opposite, that in the heroin chic days of the 90s, she didn't feel any pressure to under eat. DD was an extremely fussy eater, so I just followed my GPS advice when I raised concerns about the limited range of food she would consider, (with the alternative being she wouldn't eat at all) to 'give her what she fancies. If she'll have milk and orange juice, just give her whatever else she'll eat'. Thirdly, as I said, the food they ate were normal amongst their peers, and none of us gave it anywhere near the headspace parents do today. If our children weren't over or underweight and were well, we didn't see an issue. Certainly we weren't lazy. As people have pointed out, it's not much more effort to prepare healthy food than not. While I was making a white bread cheese sandwich I could have made a healthier one. I suppose the difference was we knew what our children would eat and what would end up wasted, and provided accordingly, as it simply didn't seem a huge issue.
Blackmagicqueen · 10/02/2022 10:58

I hate how supermarkets have large pouches and huge chocolate bars on deal plastered on ends of aisles. The smaller bars are much worse value so people end up getting the bigger bar or sharing pouch for a pound or whatever! Supermarkets aren't doing anything to help this country's obesity issue whatsoever. I remember being a child and the little bars being cheaper and the larger bars more expensive. There wasn't half as many bulk buy sweets as there is today which was a great thing.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 10:34

@Gwenhwyfar

"You don't need that biscuit. Refuse the office cake thats passed around at least once a week. Don't grab that tasty treat with your Costa or Starbucks. Etc, etc."

Total deprivation like that can lead to the opposite. These things are fine if not every day. My office doesn't have cake once a week, just birthdays, but even then a small piece of cake once a week is not what makes you fat.

The trouble is that it is rarely 'once a week' thats the problem.

Its the normalisation and creep where its a biscuit today, cake tomorrow, oo i didn't have cake today therefore i can have a packet of crisps etc etc.

I'm 5' 1". If i look at how many calories I should have for me height /weight on a daily basis even with some exercise, I need below the 2000 recommendation for a woman. Thats a problem. If i eat 3 meals a day, there isn't really room for eating anything in between. With the best will in the world. Unless you are strict with yourself it will eventually catch up with you. Because you can't change reality as much as you go into denial about how a piece of cake doesn't make a difference.

You then look at the calorie count on any standard ready meal. Again, any woman below average size would have to either skip meals completely or not eat a whole portion. Thats harder than cutting out snacks. Especially because these products are designed to be moreish.

Now think about how this applies to 6 or 7 year olds. And how that sets up their understanding of food for life.

We need to be honest and transparent about this. None of the advise about diet, exercise, medical issues etc etc is relevant when you look at the cold hard numbers of what you actually stuff in your gob.

Most people vastly underestimate what they are eating too because of the lack of proper understanding of what a normal portion size is. Even simple things like the increase in the size of plates in the last 30 or 40 years has played tricks on our brain. If you have a 9inch plate you will put less on it. You will still feel full. If you have a 12 inch plate you feel like your plate is half empty for the same quantity and that tricks your brain into thinking you are still hungry.