Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
anon12345678901 · 07/02/2022 21:42

@KittensTeaAndCake

Obesity in adults is no more a ‘choice’ than being poor is.

🤣😂

There are so many people with their heads in the sand. Reporting this thread because you don't like what you read?

I don't judge fat kids but I feel bloody sad for them and angry at their parents for letting it get that bad (obviously not if they have medical problems).

I'm just waiting for this thread to go poof, OP. I'm surprised it's lasted this long...

Same here. Reporting it as fatphobia because people are having a discussion and it's clearly hit a nerve. The statistics of 1 in 4 children obese speak for themselves, 25% of primary school children and if you add in overweight it's another 15.4%. So 40.9% of children are overweight or obese. They aren't all medical issues.
azimuth299 · 07/02/2022 21:40

@DollyDingleberry

If you choose to work in a mine, did you choose to get coal miners lung?

Same logic.

Making it seem like people don't have any choices over their own actions is patronising. You are not passive in your own life - you make choices and those choices have consequences, good and bad. Sometimes making healthy food choices is really hard for people, some people in particular. It doesn't mean that you have no agency over your choices. Unlike children, who have little control over their own lives.
ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 21:39

Did I know I would get it if I worked in a mine though? Yes.

Or are we pretending now that we don't know cake makes us fat...

"I just wanted ten cakes. I didn't want to get fat "

Jesus wept.

JayDot500 · 07/02/2022 21:39

I've family and friends who have DC who appear overweight but really don't eat more than what's required (because they have mums quite like some people here who obsess over correct food portions). Despite this, their DC vary in weight and I can see it's a source of shame and embarrassment for some. Two mums I know have been told by health professionals that their kids should eat less. Both happen to be related to me and omg if they cut down their food any more, that'd be cruelty! Such a pity, kids aren't all made the same, and the examples of McDonald's etc isn't true for many of these kids (although I acknowledge there are many parents who do overfeed crap to their kids, I've got them in my family too). My son is a super fussy eater, doesn't go near most veg or carbs... Including biscuits, cakes, chocolate, fast food etc). I wish my son was a better, more varied eater, quite like these DC who I now know will be judged by other mums.

I find it appalling, what do you know about them, and what should they think about you?

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:34

If you choose to work in a mine, did you choose to get coal miners lung?

Same logic.

ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 21:32

@DollyDingleberry

No, you wouldn’t be choosing to be obese, you’d be choosing food to make you obese. Being obese wouldn’t be the goal there would it? There would need to be other reasons why you were choosing to eat those things in such quantities (also the narrative that that’s a typical diet for a typical overweight person is really inaccurate and damaging). Those reasons would need to overrule your fears of becoming obese.

Unless of course you genuinely were choosing to be obese because you wanted to be fat - but I doubt that’s very common.

Fucketh me.

I chose to eat the food that knowingly makes me obese. But I didn't choose to be obese. Grin

Anything other than acknowledge the grotesque diet, that I know the effects it will have on my body are, is the reason I'm obese, eh.

Satingreenshutters · 07/02/2022 21:32

There is a show called It’s Your Fault I’m Fat on MTV and in every episode…it’s the parents fault!

LexMitior · 07/02/2022 21:30

@DollyDingleberry

It actually doesn’t take a lot of food to become obese. The equivalent of 1 apple per day above the calories you’ve burned will lead you to gain 4 stone in 7 years.
This is slightly misleading because the nature of obesity generally engages with a life that is not sufficiently active. You do not burn enough calories to maintain a healthy weight, and you have to maintain that weight with a lot of calories or do very little.
DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:30

Also, the NHS ADVICE for what to eat if you’re trying to lose weight is a high carb diet.

The advice given to families on what to feed their kids to keep them healthy IS A HIGH CARB DIET.

As you rightly identified, high carb diets CAUSE metabolic disease especially in those predisposed to it.

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:28

It actually doesn’t take a lot of food to become obese. The equivalent of 1 apple per day above the calories you’ve burned will lead you to gain 4 stone in 7 years.

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:27

No, you wouldn’t be choosing to be obese, you’d be choosing food to make you obese. Being obese wouldn’t be the goal there would it? There would need to be other reasons why you were choosing to eat those things in such quantities (also the narrative that that’s a typical diet for a typical overweight person is really inaccurate and damaging). Those reasons would need to overrule your fears of becoming obese.

Unless of course you genuinely were choosing to be obese because you wanted to be fat - but I doubt that’s very common.

LexMitior · 07/02/2022 21:21

@DollyDingleberry

I think you have every choice whether you are obese or not. I don’t think anyone actively chooses to BE obese.

Those 2 things are very different.

Yes but the point is that adults may make their own choices regarding diet. Children may not.

It takes a lot of food to get obese. It is certainly lot more easily done if you eat a high carb, low fat (means high sugar) diet. The thing is, adults are responsible for their choices and what they eat. Metabolic disease has increased due to high carb diets but these are a function of people choosing to eat it. For thousands of years they did not. While there are some who have genetic predisposition to putting on weight, they can literally manage the effect of their genes by changing their diet.

It is better that children understand that not all food is equal, that some of it actually bad for them. In days past it was parents who did this task, now we have people who will talk of metabolic disease but not admit that their diet is key to their poor health and that of their children. There are exceptions but not enough to generate the kinds of problems we see with obesity.

For what it is worth I think there is a very cynical exercise with the use of takeaway food in shops and town centres. It is absolutely everywhere and people are eating in public. A few generations ago that would have been regarded as very poor behaviour. One of the striking things about the UK and the US is people eating in the street away from a table, on buses, at desks etc. Walking places. You often see children snacking with their parents. All of this is about how we are taught to consume food as children and what to consume.

KittensTeaAndCake · 07/02/2022 21:20

Obesity in adults is no more a ‘choice’ than being poor is.

🤣😂

There are so many people with their heads in the sand. Reporting this thread because you don't like what you read?

I don't judge fat kids but I feel bloody sad for them and angry at their parents for letting it get that bad (obviously not if they have medical problems).

I'm just waiting for this thread to go poof, OP. I'm surprised it's lasted this long...

ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 21:20

@DollyDingleberry

I think you have every choice whether you are obese or not. I don’t think anyone actively chooses to BE obese.

Those 2 things are very different.

Ok. So.

If I decide to eat a king-size fry up every morning for the next year. A McDonald's meal for lunch. Fish and chips for tea. Chocolate bars throughout the day for snacks. Let's say 3 a day. All that, I choose to eat, every day for a year. And put on 4 stone.

You would say I hadn't "actively chosen" to be obese. What hell did I think was going to happen? I didn't choose it?

QualityTweet · 07/02/2022 21:16

5128gap

I am completely to blame for being overweight - I did it to myself. I was a very skinny child/teenager and it has crept up on me. (I’m also very tall so I can carry it, but I’m not denying I do need to lose weight) I can honestly say my family have a good balanced diet. I just love the biscuit tin.

Very overweight children are fed by their parents and can develop a lifelong unhealthy relationship with food.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 21:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

DickMabutt73962 · 07/02/2022 21:13

@Hospedia

I've been given loads to think about because I'm capable of listening to others!

Sure you have...

Can't believe OP had to create a judgemental post to be able to learn some basic things like the many reasons a child may be overweight Hmm
lovescaca · 07/02/2022 21:10

Yes

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:10

I think you have every choice whether you are obese or not. I don’t think anyone actively chooses to BE obese.

Those 2 things are very different.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 07/02/2022 21:08

Believe me I have tried giving 're a better diet,seen nutritionists etc. But she will only eat a few things (ASD). Luckily she does have some veg (lettuce, carrots) and a little fruiting not much. I try....

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:08

[quote Porcupineintherough]@DollyDingleberry so you think that rates of metabolic disease have soared over a generation and account for the rapid rise in childhood obesity? Give over.[/quote]
YES. Exactly this. The predisposition to metabolic disease has not changed, but our dietary changes since 1964 have meant a massive increase in symptomatic metabolic disease (t2 diabetes, PCOS, dementia etc etc) because when our diets were largely low carb, lower in sugar and higher in fat the manifestation of metabolic diseases was far less prevalent.

You need to research Ancel Keys, the 7 countries study and how flawed it was at the time and now. You also need to look at how our diets changed based on it and what a terrible decision that was.

Honestly, read up. It’s really interesting stuff and you’d really benefit from better understanding how metabolic disease causes obesity and vice versa.

Ottolin3 · 07/02/2022 21:08

@Mariposista

I judge without shame. It's disgusting when an adult buys and eats junk and does no exercise and ends up with health problems that the good old health service has to mop up, and potentially leaving them vulnerable to covid too so we healthy people all have to shield them, but to allow a child to get fat is unforgivable. YOU buy the junk as the parent, YOU allow screens, YOU allow TV, YOU are to blame.
Agreed! It’s utterly shameful!
ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 21:03

[quote Porcupineintherough]@DollyDingleberry so you think that rates of metabolic disease have soared over a generation and account for the rapid rise in childhood obesity? Give over.[/quote]
I know, she also thinks you have no choice whether you are obese or not.

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:03

@azimuth299

What I’m saying is the CAUSES of weight gain are wide ranging and not all due to moral failings or personal ill discipline, and that judging people based on their weight is grim, not that there aren’t solutions.

But I don't think that anybody is blaming the child's moral failings, just saying that 99 times out of 100 a child is overweight because they are overfed. Nobody is judging the child, they are judging the parent who is overfeeding the child.

But that’s exactly the point - you have no idea if the child is over fed or not and your assumption that 99% of fat people are just over eating is wildly inaccurate. 1 in 4 people are affected by metabolic diseases at some point in their lives and they are genetic. Largely, weight directly correlates to the level of reaction in the production of insulin in response to the consumption of carbohydrate. Those who produce more insulin in reaction to the consumption of carbs are genetically predisposed to put on more weight. This was researched and irrefutably proved in the 1930’s, 70’s and again in 2010, 2015 and more recently in 2018. It was on the cover of Time. Our modern, carb rich diets are killing us.

What do we tell parents to feed their overweight kids? High carb, low fat diets. Calories are only a very small part of the problem, hormones are the rest.

Seriously, Taubes.

TheVolturi · 07/02/2022 21:02

Some children are actually overweight due to medical reasons. I know of two in my children's classes. One is on medication that is keeping them alive and weight gain is a side effect. I wouldn't judge to be honest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread