Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
KittensTeaAndCake · 07/02/2022 22:10

I want my son to love the things his body can do.

But is he overweight or obese? If he is then there will be things his body can’t do, surely?

DiddyHeck · 07/02/2022 22:10

@knitnerd90

This thread is classic MN! Some of you need better hobbies.

I'm overweight and have PCOS. One of my kids is overweight (she's a teen, about size 16 and 5'9"). One is right on average and one is underweight. Weight is massively more complex than just diet--there's genetics and other environmental factors.

None of them are particularly sporty (nor am I or DH) but they all get physical activity and home cooked meals. Lockdown was hard on DD as her activities were shut. Underweight DS does not care about food and has to be reminded to eat.

to be quite honest I really don't care that much about their weight. I know far too many adults who still remember their parents making a fuss over how much they ate and they say it set up bad eating habits for them. I think we'd all be a lot better off if we stopped thinking other people's weight was any of our business.

to be quite honest I really don't care that much about their weight. I know far too many adults who still remember their parents making a fuss over how much they ate and they say it set up bad eating habits for them. I think we'd all be a lot better off if we stopped thinking other people's weight was any of our business.

Are you saying you don't think parents should care that they've made their kids fat? Seriously?

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 22:06

@nodogz

I think this generation of kids are more accepting of size. Bigger kids don't automatically get picked on. I think that's really positive in thinking that there are a range of sizes. I like it when my son looks in the mirror and describes himself as a big chungus (no, don't know what it means)

I was very surprised at just how many of my son's classmates had got fatter over lockdown.

I know mine had become less fit (doing football in the garden with me and the occasional joe wicks was nothing to x7hours of extra curricular sport a week). I did have some moments of internalised "oh no, my child is getting fat" which surprised me as I think I'm soooo nonjudgmental

I do think fatness is now a moral judgement and lots of people have very ugly views about it which wouldn't be tolerated for any other characteristic. The correlation between fatness and poverty is extensive. Shaming or judging doesn't help so why are people doing it? I don't want little kids internalising their bodies are wrong and getting on a self destructive path.

As an example I never talk about my hate of my body around my kids. I talk about stretching it or how much weight it can lift. We talk about nutrition and pleasure from food as well as balance. I hope they will go in to the world and not harm themselves or others with prejudice.

Exactly this.

I want my son to love the things his body can do.

Im very thankful that he won’t be subject to Slimfast shakes aged 7 like I was (because a teacher mentioned to my mum that I was getting ‘chubby’ and the school nurse would be having a talk with her and mum thought that meant she was being judged so I had to lose the weight quickly).

KittensTeaAndCake · 07/02/2022 22:06

@knitnerd90

The research is, basically, that only a small minority of diets result in long term weight loss. The vast majority of people, over 90%, will regain it in time. It's quite amusing when you look at studies claiming "success". One was that 30% of people managed to lose 10% of their body weight, and keep it off, for 18 months.

The exception is weight loss following bariatric surgery--which can still be regained, but has much higher long term success rates.

Also, yes, they tell you to lose weight for PCOS. But they haven't actually figured out a way for women to do that.

But that’s because the people on the diets go back to their old habits. The diets work at the time.
LexMitior · 07/02/2022 22:05

Fat is not like race or any other immutable characteristic protected by law - it is gained or acquired.

You can expect people to judge it because of that alone.

pikapikapukachu · 07/02/2022 22:02

@knitnerd90

The research is, basically, that only a small minority of diets result in long term weight loss. The vast majority of people, over 90%, will regain it in time. It's quite amusing when you look at studies claiming "success". One was that 30% of people managed to lose 10% of their body weight, and keep it off, for 18 months.

The exception is weight loss following bariatric surgery--which can still be regained, but has much higher long term success rates.

Also, yes, they tell you to lose weight for PCOS. But they haven't actually figured out a way for women to do that.

Which is why it's so so important to help our children to be healthy and maintain a healthy weight. If not they are stuffed from the outset.
nodogz · 07/02/2022 22:01

I think this generation of kids are more accepting of size. Bigger kids don't automatically get picked on. I think that's really positive in thinking that there are a range of sizes. I like it when my son looks in the mirror and describes himself as a big chungus (no, don't know what it means)

I was very surprised at just how many of my son's classmates had got fatter over lockdown.

I know mine had become less fit (doing football in the garden with me and the occasional joe wicks was nothing to x7hours of extra curricular sport a week). I did have some moments of internalised "oh no, my child is getting fat" which surprised me as I think I'm soooo nonjudgmental

I do think fatness is now a moral judgement and lots of people have very ugly views about it which wouldn't be tolerated for any other characteristic. The correlation between fatness and poverty is extensive. Shaming or judging doesn't help so why are people doing it? I don't want little kids internalising their bodies are wrong and getting on a self destructive path.

As an example I never talk about my hate of my body around my kids. I talk about stretching it or how much weight it can lift. We talk about nutrition and pleasure from food as well as balance. I hope they will go in to the world and not harm themselves or others with prejudice.

pikapikapukachu · 07/02/2022 21:58

I went to a UK holiday park a few years ago, and I'd take a guess that 50% of the kids staying there were overweight or obese. Most of them had overweight/ obese parents. The stark reality was quite shocking. What percentage of those kids really had medical conditions that caused them to be so big at a young age?
A parent starting a MN thread about how they've been told that their child is overweight but they disagree etc etc is a fairly common occurrence. As is people asking advice about clothes for a late primary / early secondary child who needs an adult small size now.
I honestly think we have got blind to what is overweight and what is normal.
When I was at primary school we had one overweight boy and one overweight girl on my class. That was it. They grew up to be obese adults.
Biology / metabolism/ development means that it will be pretty much impossible for the 10yo boy with breasts and who's thighs rub together to ever become but even more stay a normal healthy weight.
It's very very sad.

LexMitior · 07/02/2022 21:58

Its an interesting one because gluttony and sloth are old sins - to live a good life, you had to restrain yourself. Its a very old idea but not one with much traction these days.

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:57

@knitnerd90

The research is, basically, that only a small minority of diets result in long term weight loss. The vast majority of people, over 90%, will regain it in time. It's quite amusing when you look at studies claiming "success". One was that 30% of people managed to lose 10% of their body weight, and keep it off, for 18 months.

The exception is weight loss following bariatric surgery--which can still be regained, but has much higher long term success rates.

Also, yes, they tell you to lose weight for PCOS. But they haven't actually figured out a way for women to do that.

They have in Sweden! The dietary advice for women with PCOS and patients with t2 diabetes in Sweden is to eat a low carb, high fat diet. They also routinely prescribe metformin for the treatment of PCOS for the same reason.
SuPerDoPer · 07/02/2022 21:57

I was an overweight child. My brother was as skinny as they come. We were given the same food, same home life, same treats, same opportunities. My brother loved sports and was always running, biking, playing football, cricket, anything sporty. I loved books, drawing and baking. I also used to sneak treats from the cupboards and extra food from the fridge. This was harder and harder for my parents to control the older I got. There's no way me being a fat child was their fault, it was my personality and love of sweets and sedentary activities. We weren't poor either - we had home cooked meals every night and self catering holidays to Europe twice a year - so it wasn't all nuggets and Mars bars like people seem to think.

It didn't affect my friendships at all. I was hugely confident, funny and bright, good at school. Hated PE and sports day and used to always find ways to avoid activity but had a big group of close friends.

Obviously obesity isn't ideal - and I've struggled with my weight all my life- but neither is it the fault of my parents.

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:55

Isn’t it just. It’s why this idea that being overweight is an issue of morality is so deeply flawed.

Porcupineintherough · 07/02/2022 21:55

I dont think anybody who hasn't been obese really can understand how truly hard it is to change

Yes and this is why it's such a terrible thing to wantonly inflict on a small child.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 21:54

@knitnerd90

The research is, basically, that only a small minority of diets result in long term weight loss. The vast majority of people, over 90%, will regain it in time. It's quite amusing when you look at studies claiming "success". One was that 30% of people managed to lose 10% of their body weight, and keep it off, for 18 months.

The exception is weight loss following bariatric surgery--which can still be regained, but has much higher long term success rates.

Also, yes, they tell you to lose weight for PCOS. But they haven't actually figured out a way for women to do that.

I didn't realise it was as high as 90%? That's depressing.
OP posts:
DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:53

No one ever does lose weight on diets - 95% of people who lose more than 10% of their body weight gain it back in 2 years. Of the 5% who keep it off, 80% of those will regain the weight in 10 years.

LexMitior · 07/02/2022 21:53

The thing is to not even start really - adults need to model a good diet for their kids and then the kids are healthy and not overweight. This is key. By the time you are trying to manage your own diet by reducing it or looking at the percentage of potatoes you eat and theirs then things are really difficult for everyone.

Adults would do well to manage themselves in terms of weight before having kids. You have to run after them anyway, makes it easier to conceive, and they are healthier too. Win win.

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 21:51

The research is, basically, that only a small minority of diets result in long term weight loss. The vast majority of people, over 90%, will regain it in time. It's quite amusing when you look at studies claiming "success". One was that 30% of people managed to lose 10% of their body weight, and keep it off, for 18 months.

The exception is weight loss following bariatric surgery--which can still be regained, but has much higher long term success rates.

Also, yes, they tell you to lose weight for PCOS. But they haven't actually figured out a way for women to do that.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 21:49

@knitnerd90

There's quite a lot of research saying obesity is a complex medical issue, but it makes people feel better to blame others for putting cake in their mouths.

Every news article on obesity will have researchers talking about how diets don't work and about complex feedback cycles controlling appetite and metabolism, and the comments will be full of "But diets work!"

If diets didn't work no one would ever lose weight...? I'm clearly missing something 🤷🏼‍♀️ think this thread has finally frazzled my brain.
OP posts:
DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:48

Everyone here has been saying there are many reasons outside of illness that a child might be fat - just that not all of them are because the parents are abusers.

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 21:47

There's quite a lot of research saying obesity is a complex medical issue, but it makes people feel better to blame others for putting cake in their mouths.

Every news article on obesity will have researchers talking about how diets don't work and about complex feedback cycles controlling appetite and metabolism, and the comments will be full of "But diets work!"

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:45

No one is saying you don’t have a choice - just thst people don’t actively choose to be fat. I think it’s far more patronising to treat all fat people like they live on greggs and cake, personally.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 21:44

@KittensTeaAndCake

Obesity in adults is no more a ‘choice’ than being poor is.

🤣😂

There are so many people with their heads in the sand. Reporting this thread because you don't like what you read?

I don't judge fat kids but I feel bloody sad for them and angry at their parents for letting it get that bad (obviously not if they have medical problems).

I'm just waiting for this thread to go poof, OP. I'm surprised it's lasted this long...

It's turned into something so bizarre and ridiculous, just a handful of very offended and aggressive people shutting down conversation because they can't accept children can be overweight and there could be reasons outside of illness for that...

I think I'm beginning to see where a lot of the issues start, put it that way!

#Headinthesand

OP posts:
ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 21:44

Making it seem like people don't have any choices over their own actions is patronising.

Very much so.

Anything to try and excuse the vast vast vast majority of people are overweight because they overeat deliberately/with no care for health.

And when it's a child, shame on the adult making that decision for them.

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 21:43

This thread is classic MN! Some of you need better hobbies.

I'm overweight and have PCOS. One of my kids is overweight (she's a teen, about size 16 and 5'9"). One is right on average and one is underweight. Weight is massively more complex than just diet--there's genetics and other environmental factors.

None of them are particularly sporty (nor am I or DH) but they all get physical activity and home cooked meals. Lockdown was hard on DD as her activities were shut. Underweight DS does not care about food and has to be reminded to eat.

to be quite honest I really don't care that much about their weight. I know far too many adults who still remember their parents making a fuss over how much they ate and they say it set up bad eating habits for them. I think we'd all be a lot better off if we stopped thinking other people's weight was any of our business.

DollyDingleberry · 07/02/2022 21:43

@ReadySteadyTwins

Did I know I would get it if I worked in a mine though? Yes.

Or are we pretending now that we don't know cake makes us fat...

"I just wanted ten cakes. I didn't want to get fat "

Jesus wept.

Yes, people worked in mines well beyond the discovery of coal miners lung. My grandad was one of them. By your logic, they actively chose to get sick and die because they continued to work down a mine knowing it would cause them health problems.

Most people know cake makes them fat, they don’t know however that so does potato, pasta, rice, low fat products and even fruit. That’s because our NHS healthy plate advice tells them that the majority of their diet should be grains, potatoes and carbs. That goes for their kids diets too.