Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
5128gap · 11/02/2022 09:38

@RedToothBrush

The problem is they aren't going to address it if we just say 'oh yeah no problem it doesn't matter big is beautiful' though either are they? And thats what is creeping in. The normalisation of what is a real problem.

What are adults who have an interest in child welfare and health supposed to say? Nothing?

Seriously?!

We don't have a choice but to tackle it head on and to have a zero tolerance type attitude to shit excuses.

Many will ignore it, but quite frankly thats a conscious decision to bury your head in the sand.

Either engage or quite rightly be questioned as to why you are ignoring your children's wellbeing.

It doesn't need to be one extreme or the other though. There is a middle ground between ignoring an issue and wading in with a verbal sledge hammer. Like it or not, it is a complex area with a great deal of emotional and psychological factors at play. Sticking your caps lock on and yelling at people about how straightforward it is if they weren't so lazy/neglectful/stupid as some posters have done will alienate them, and the content of the message will be lost in the delivery.
Sinuhe · 11/02/2022 09:23

My nephew (now 12) is overweight or better described as obese.
He has been conditioned that he needs to have snacks available at all times. There are no underlying health issues.

I used to take him to the park for a few hours to play with DS (same age) when younger... he always came with a backpack full of chocolates, crisps, sweet drinks & co. He wouldn't go off and play properly, he would literally take one walk around the playground and be back snacking.

I stopped taking him as the snacking stopped him from playing and my DS didn't really like him after a while.

(This also means it stopps him from socialising)
Obesity in children IS the parents fault in the majority of cases. (Exemptions are underlying health issues/ certain medication that will increase weight)

RedToothBrush · 11/02/2022 09:05

You only have to look at threads from parents who get a letter age 5 saying their kid is overweight and the reaction they have to it.

There is a duty of care to point out the problem. And that is apparently offensive or shaming. Its nonsense. No one is shaming by doing that. Just identifying there is an issue you should be following up. If you don't take action to follow it up, you have to start asking why.

The reality is that if your kid has no known underlying medical issues and their bmi is significantly north of where it should be, you need to act before the problem spirals. Once they are a teenager it becomes much more difficult to change their habits and life style. Before age 10 there are no excuse unless properly diagnosed by a doctor.

Having seen the reaction of parents to this letter (and having seen their eating habits) there isn't a great mystery going on here.

Diqgeneration · 11/02/2022 08:59

I think a lot of it is genetic- eg high or low metabolism. Babies are born with a certain build/muscle tone etc which can change but on a general level, is pre set. So chubby active kids with a good diet, no. Hugely obese kids I feel sorry for- they didn’t choose that life for themselves. They will miss out on so much because of weight.

Tynetime · 11/02/2022 08:58

Not hard enough if you have an overweight child under 10 is the answer.

@RedToothBrush I don't/didn't

Curlygirl06 · 11/02/2022 08:41

@Thymeout

I don't know if anyone else has seen the ads for On the Beach holidays? Family of four, 2 kids, girl about 8 and brother probably around 10. Girl is slim. Boy obviously overweight, but focus is on him. They show him practically drooling over the free buffet in the private airport lounge. Double chin. Then in the next ad, his sister drops her ice cream and he's rubbing it in by making a show of how much he's enjoying his, right in her face. Parents are a bit overweight but not as much as the child, and when the mum strips off to jump in the pool the dad has a look in his eye to show he still fancies her.

I thought they were going down the Dove route, not choosing the most photogenic family, with perfect physiques, but the way it's coming across is that the boy is overweight because he loves his food, but that's OK because he's got a great personality and isn't self-conscious about how he looks.

Can't help thinking they've got this wrong. That's going to be a v unhappy teenager if he's allowed to carry on like that.

Yes! Why did the advertising agency think this was a good idea?
RedToothBrush · 11/02/2022 08:28

The problem is they aren't going to address it if we just say 'oh yeah no problem it doesn't matter big is beautiful' though either are they? And thats what is creeping in. The normalisation of what is a real problem.

What are adults who have an interest in child welfare and health supposed to say? Nothing?

Seriously?!

We don't have a choice but to tackle it head on and to have a zero tolerance type attitude to shit excuses.

Many will ignore it, but quite frankly thats a conscious decision to bury your head in the sand.

Either engage or quite rightly be questioned as to why you are ignoring your children's wellbeing.

5128gap · 11/02/2022 08:10

@RedToothBrush

Its cowardice and yet another excuse.

"i cant do anything because of other people"

Utter rot.

If people started just getting on with it and confronted the problem it wouldn't be a big deal. There would be a network of people all doing the same thing and over time, support for those doing it.

The fact remains that these parents don't want to do something that might be a bit difficult.

The very act of doing nothing is the issue here. Parents who continue to do this are putting their feelings before whats in the best interests of their kids.

Its like other taboo things, someone has to break the ice and get on with it.

We have a health timebomb thats ticking here. Which will leave the next generation with a reduced quality of life and life expectancy. If your first thought is 'what if people judge me' in that context, all it proves is the selfishness of these parents.

I have maximum respect for anyone who does take responsibility.

Stop justifying the unjustifiable. Cos thats what you are doing.

I'm not justifying anything. I have no personal investment in this. My children were slim and have grown up slim and healthy, despite my own crimes against nutrition, and we are all now wholefood vegans. I was making a wider point that if people feel they will be blamed and berated for something they are often more likely to minimise it. Which isn't a matter of opinion, but of fact. Surely anyone concerned about the problem shouldn't want to exacerbate it.
RedToothBrush · 11/02/2022 08:05

Not hard enough if you have an overweight child under 10 is the answer.

Tynetime · 11/02/2022 07:55

I was referring more to adults TBH and my personal experience over the years where my weight has fluctuated based on how challenging life is and how good my Mental Health was at the time.
Currently overweight but working on it and my Mental Health through exercise mainly. Including teens in this too as much as possible. More difficult for the one do anxious and depressed she barely leaves the house.
My kids were not overweight as little children ( my youngest definately isn't now) but as teens the weight has crept up due to a plethora of reasons.

Nobody knows what is going on in others lives and how hard they are trying.

RedToothBrush · 11/02/2022 07:44

Also. Stopping having snacks in the house doesn't involve much effort.

The issue (again) is the parents doing want to give up the snacks and they don't want to have to deal with children hassling them for snack because they want an easy life rather than to parent their children.

Sorry done with excuses.

RedToothBrush · 11/02/2022 07:42

Its cowardice and yet another excuse.

"i cant do anything because of other people"

Utter rot.

If people started just getting on with it and confronted the problem it wouldn't be a big deal. There would be a network of people all doing the same thing and over time, support for those doing it.

The fact remains that these parents don't want to do something that might be a bit difficult.

The very act of doing nothing is the issue here. Parents who continue to do this are putting their feelings before whats in the best interests of their kids.

Its like other taboo things, someone has to break the ice and get on with it.

We have a health timebomb thats ticking here. Which will leave the next generation with a reduced quality of life and life expectancy. If your first thought is 'what if people judge me' in that context, all it proves is the selfishness of these parents.

I have maximum respect for anyone who does take responsibility.

Stop justifying the unjustifiable. Cos thats what you are doing.

Tynetime · 11/02/2022 07:42

Yeah people generally change and are best able to look after themselves, make good choices etc when their self esteem is good and things are fairly settled.
Having lots of randoms on the Internet (perhaps snerry looks in real life or comments) telling them how easy it is and how lazy, stupid and neglectful they are and I am so much better than they are is hardly going to put them in a frame of mind to change

5128gap · 11/02/2022 06:51

@RedToothBrush

What I find most frightening is how people get offended when you state the bleeding obvious link over what people eat and their weight.

The deliberate cognitive dissonance to avoid the truth is telling.

But you must see the link between the blame culture and minimisation/denial? The more stridently people berate othes with accusations of abuse, laziness and neglect, the more likely they are to disengage, and any valid points hidden beneath all the hyperbole are lost. Obviously some are on here just for the fun of it, but for those genuinely concerned, I mean.
ReadySteadyTwins · 10/02/2022 20:28

@Gwenhwyfar

"You then look at the calorie count on any standard ready meal. Again, any woman below average size would have to either skip meals completely or not eat a whole portion."

I used to eat a lot of ready meals and there were loads under about 450 calories. Really not that difficult to find.

What surprised me was reading on MN that people add things to ready meals. That would of course up the calories.

This is something that really bugs me. The "average" as if that's making it ok. What happens in a few more years when the average size of a woman is a size 18. Then it's fine right? I mean, I'm fat but everyone else is. If we're all obese, we can call normalise it under the phrase "average" and then it's fine
To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children
Canaloha · 10/02/2022 20:23

It frustrates the hell out of me but people (including school) just assume it’s fine for her to have (for example) another half jacket potato with beans because if she wasn’t hungry she wouldn’t ask and it isn’t unhealthy and it would be awful to refuse her food when she’s hungry.

I think some people are scared of being a bit hungry, as seen by the amount of snacks some people take when only out for a short while! DS' childminder we had to put notice in as although we would pack a lunch and snacks and not adverse to food like chocolate now and again; it was being used as a reward tool, which is behaviours around food I struggled with and didn't want to repeat. Nursery was great though, plenty of nice food so never went hungry, but it wasn't have some buttons for getting in the car, crisps at the park to keep you occupied, loads of breadsticks as they're 'like air basically'. It was balanced meals and then fruit and veg sticks available whenever. Again, no issue with chocolate and crisps, but not associated with praise or regularly.

KittensTeaAndCake · 10/02/2022 20:12

Yeah I’d imagine it would be harder with Grandparents, they all like to spoil the kids don’t they? But the school should be on your side, definitely worth a little talk, I’d say. Good luck.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/02/2022 19:45

Yep. My parents are in total denial she’s overweight and complain about how ridiculously small they make children’s clothes or how she’s gearing up for a growth spurt. I probably need another discussion with school to see if they’d be more prepared to ensure she only ate what was in her packed lunch if we started sending one. It would at least reduce the meals where we had no idea what she was eating

KittensTeaAndCake · 10/02/2022 19:37

It frustrates the hell out of me but people (including school) just assume it’s fine for her to have (for example) another half jacket potato with beans because if she wasn’t hungry she wouldn’t ask and it isn’t unhealthy and it would be awful to refuse her food when she’s hungry.

I assume you’ve told the school, her friends’ parents, Grandparents etc not to give her seconds?

Giraffesandbottoms · 10/02/2022 19:27

@whatkatydid2013

Apologies, I totally understand. Very, very tricky situation in that case!!!

whatkatydid2013 · 10/02/2022 19:18

@Giraffesandbottoms. I don’t think it’s mean to say no to seconds and say she can have extra veg if still hungry and as I said in my post that’s exactly what we do at home. The issue is if you ask others to do the same they think it’s mean. She is at school 5 days a week for breakfast club and lunch. She is at a friends house for tea or a party once most weeks. She’s with her grandparents one evening a week when they pick up. That’s not the odd time she’s not eating with us it’s probably at least half her meals over the course of a year. We have talked about balanced eating and stopping when full. We have talked about having a glass of water before eating and slowing down. It frustrates the hell out of me but people (including school) just assume it’s fine for her to have (for example) another half jacket potato with beans because if she wasn’t hungry she wouldn’t ask and it isn’t unhealthy and it would be awful to refuse her food when she’s hungry. I’m debating switching to packed lunch and just sending her with a sandwich, some fruit and a bottle of water every day but I worry if I do she will just eat part of one of her friends meals and the packed lunch. That aside short of giving up my job and losing the house we couldn’t afford to live in without two salaries or having a massive falling out with my parents and another likely unproductive discussion with school who both assume it’s nothing to do with what they give her and must be us feeding her junk I’m out of ideas. The last time I tried talking with school was when they’d checked her BMI and it came back overweight and they were totally dismissive of our concerns and said how active she was (she is).

Giraffesandbottoms · 10/02/2022 18:25

@whatkatydid2013

You are worried about being “mean” etc so just enabling. When your daughter says she is hungry and wants more she can have an apple or that’s it! More greens aren’t “mean” and surely you would rather she eat out with her friends etc and therefore she needs to cut down at home. It’s “mean” to allow her to eat seconds or more after dinner and continue gaining weight. You need to need to have a realistic discussion with her about calories and weight gain.

ReadySteadyTwins · 10/02/2022 16:38

@RedToothBrush

What I find most frightening is how people get offended when you state the bleeding obvious link over what people eat and their weight.

The deliberate cognitive dissonance to avoid the truth is telling.

Amen.

Anything, literally anything is trotted out, rather than admit "yes, I give my child too much food, usually within their snacks, because it's easier than saying no."

Like PP said, suddenly there's all these "magic fat kids" who eat small portions of healthy food and exercise plenty.

Yes, your DC might walk to school every day. But what good is that when they've got a chocolate bar on the walk home.

"She only has a bowl of cereal for breakfast" well I'm sorry, either you're lying and it's a bowl the size of a bucket, or you need to get your kid to the doctors, because with what you claim you feed them, they shouldn't be obese, so there must be an underlying medical reason.

Funnily enough, these parents don't take their kids to the doctors. Because they know they're making their kids fat. They can't pretend they're not accountable if a doctor tells them they're entirely to blame with the kid's diet and lifestyle.

DogsAndGin · 10/02/2022 15:15

Of course it’s sad - it’s child abuse. I have seen some morbidly obese children too, it’s shocking. Their lifelong health will be affected by their start in life; childhood health is important. I’ve heard parents say, ‘it’s just puppy fat’, when their child is clearly obese!

catscatscatseverywhere · 10/02/2022 15:10

@Laiste

The majority of people know that there are medical reasons for being fat but they also know these days majority of fat people are fat because of their diet.

Brutally honestly this is my thought process:

Could be medical, but probably isn't. Especially if the parent/s are fat as well.

Is this ''judging''? I don't know. What would make it ''judging''?

I agree.