Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 08/02/2022 00:56

@furballfun

Depends just how overweight we're talking - one of DD's friends (Y4) is on the heavy side, though definitely not obese. She will always eat if food is offered, and finish it. At one point I picked her up sometimes, and her mum would give me a carrot or apple as an after school snack while my own daughter was having cookies, but that was because my DD was eating virtually nothing at lunch time (this was when they were in KS1 so free lunches) as she's really fussy whereas her friend was eating everything (and possibly seconds). The friend's brother is really slim; it's hard to see what the parents should be doing that wouldn't seem discriminatory (between the friend and her brother).
I’ve been told on MN it’s pathetic to say this but scientists are finding that obesity and unhealthy food cravings are linked to gut bacteria. There’s a lot of refined carbs that people eat these days that aren’t healthy, and can lead to insulin resistance and all sorts of problems. Also, fat doesn’t make you fat. There’s a lot of corruption in nutritional data. The NHS recommendation of eating a lot of starchy foods as a basis for diet is not healthy. Some people can deal with it better for longer due to better metabolism and gut bacteria but it catches up with everyone.
LaurenKelsey · 08/02/2022 00:53

I’m a retired teacher. I often noticed what children brought for snacks and lunches, and the very overweight children often had several desserts and much larger portions than was typical. One very overweight girl from a very overweight family would bring baked goods every day, since her dad worked in a bakery. The girl wasn’t teased at that age but in the following years she was. I did silently blame the parents because it was all avoidable. Very sad.

JustSomething · 08/02/2022 00:49

No, of course not. That would be nasty.

Who knows what's going on there? I think most parents (though I'm aware that's not all) love their children and want what's best for them.

Seeing how difficult it is to get DD to eat (anything) I can easily imagine that other parents might struggle to get their kids to eat healthily or stick to sensible portions.

I wonder if people judge us for DD being so thin. Maybe they think we are starving her on purpose.

BigValue · 08/02/2022 00:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

pikapikapukachu · 08/02/2022 00:13

@knitnerd90 we know that being overweight or obese puts you at a higher risk of developing a range of conditions such as type 2 diabetes. We also know that overweight / obese children are highly likely to become overweight / obese adults. So no not every obese child will develop diabetes, but their risk is much higher than that of a. Gild that is a healthy weight. To deny this is just sticking our head in the sand.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4408699/

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 23:33

2/3 of mine are autistic, and that has a great deal to do with why I don't see myself as having a huge amount of control. I can certainly refuse to give them certain things, but that's as far as it goes. If they decide they're not eating something, it's not getting eaten. Children can gain weight even without eating chips and cakes. One of mine went through the white diet phase.

KittensTeaAndCake · 07/02/2022 23:14

My response and the one I was replying to was in response to someone implying that an overweight or obese person can't be proud of what their body can do because they probably have lots of things they can't do which is not necessarily so

Except that’s not what I said. Of course their bodies are still amazing. I said there must be things an obese child can’t do.

azimuth299 · 07/02/2022 23:11

Really? You control every meal your children eat? They don't get school dinners, food from grandparents? They never take anything out of the cupboards? I have teenagers at this point; they know how to cook.

I control what's served at dinner. I don't control every bite that goes into my children's mouths.

Thinking about it, I actually do. They don't have school dinners because one has autism and extreme sensory issues to do with food (which I manage, I don't just shrug my shoulders and let him eat whatever he wants) and one has the choice and chooses a packed lunch.

We live very far from their grandparents. When they see them of course they spoil them but it's rare enough that it wouldn't affect their weight. If they saw them all the time and were constantly overfeeding them then I would put a stop to it.

No they never take anything out of the cupboards, they always ask for a snack if they're hungry. If they ask for a snack I usually say yes but if they had already had a sugary snack that day I would offer something healthy. If they took food from the cupboards without asking then I would tell them off. If it kept happening I would find the root issue and attempt to tackle it (Making meals more filling maybe? Maybe a healthy snack box always available? Depends on the underlying reason.).

When they get older they will of course have more control over their meals but my children are primary school aged, and it's primary school aged children that we are talking about.

blameitonthecaffeine · 07/02/2022 23:10

I feel sad for extremely overweight children because I know they are likely to be facing problems - but whether those problems are ill health, bullying, neglectful parenting, emotional problems, poverty, difficult family circumstances, abuse, disability, food addiction or something else I obviously have no idea. Whether feeling sad for the child equates to judgement of the parents, I'm not sure. I hope not but possibly.

My oldest daughter was diagnosed with anorexia at 11 (she's an adult now and still not entirely okay). Another of my children has what I would call significantly disordered eating if not an actual eating disorder. So I feel I'm in no position to judge anyone else for the weight or diet of their child!! But I definitely feel sad for children at both ends of the weight spectrum.

KurtWilde · 07/02/2022 23:10

Can't be bothered to rtft but in answer to OPs question, no, I don't judge because I have no idea what factors may be at play.

I was a very overweight child. It had nothing to do with overeating, neglect or bad parenting. I had to take medication for a health issue that wasn't openly evident. The medication caused severe fatigue and low mood. I had no interest in PE or riding a bike etc because it knackered me out in the first 20 minutes. So I gained weight during the 8 years I needed the medication (8yo-16yo) but was able to lose it after that.

2 of my DC have also had weight issues as a result of health problems. And people can stick their judgment up their arse.

So no judgement from me.

KittensTeaAndCake · 07/02/2022 23:09

The food our children eat is largely down to us as parents. They aren't fat because on Saturdays, Jean next door gives them a donut.

Exactly! It’s always someone else’s fault. If your DC is obese (without a medical issue) then it is your fault, stop making excuses, putting your fingers in your ears or reporting threads and do something about it.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 23:03

[quote Tynetime]@PaddleBoardingMomma no not an advantage but it doesn't have to restrict you in terms of sports and activities.
My response and the one I was replying to was in response to someone implying that an overweight or obese person can't be proud of what their body can do because they probably have lots of things they can't do which is not necessarily so.[/quote]
I'm with you now. That's fair enough.

OP posts:
DiddyHeck · 07/02/2022 23:02

Oh come on @knitnerd90. Parents have enough control over their children's eating and exercise habits. If a child is not overfed and home and is given enough exercise, having dinner at granny's house is not going to make them obese, ditto school dinners.

ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 22:58

Really? You control every meal your children eat? They don't get school dinners, food from grandparents? They never take anything out of the cupboards? I have teenagers at this point; they know how to cook.

I control what's served at dinner. I don't control every bite that goes into my children's mouths.

It must be "everyone else" making these kids fat then. You're just being contrary now. OP was talking about a primary aged child. Not a 17yr old, far more capable of their own food choice. As you well know.

The food our children eat is largely down to us as parents. They aren't fat because on Saturdays, Jean next door gives them a donut.

TheSoapyFrog · 07/02/2022 22:58

I don't, probably because I am one of the mothers with a severely overweight child. I'm sure people look at him and look at me (I am obese) and assume it is my bad parenting which has affected him.
He has a twin, who is exactly the right size and weight for his age. He weighs nearly twice as much and is half a foot taller.
He is autistic with learning disabilities and also has been diagnosed with a genetic disorder which is the cause of his accelerated growth.
Both of my boys eat a fairly healthy diet and both are active. So I know the truth and everyone else will just think what they want to.

Susiesue61 · 07/02/2022 22:55

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Susiesue61 because she needs a different amount of calories to maintain her body weight? Boys do have a higher metabolism than girls and there are individual differences also.[/quote]
Absolutely, but you try giving 2 children supper or a snack after football because they're hungry, and telling one they can't because they're too fat?! Especially when she's the only girl. It's not as simple as people think, when they don't have that problem.
I'm not making excuses for her, she loves food, but at one point she was doing 10 hours plus of training per week - she was still overweight

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 22:54

[quote pikapikapukachu]@knitnerd90 what research is showing childhood obesity doesn't have an adverse impact on health? [/quote]
What I'm saying is that we have a lack of good evidence, not positive evidence against. There's a significant difference.

Tynetime · 07/02/2022 22:53

Not had a chance to read the whole thread but an outsider who did not know my kids had ARFID/ASD/ADHD would see one and think I was starvig them and that I was overfeeding the other. They would not see the constant battles and stresses which have impacted on my own weight too
This is the problem with judging people you don't know. .so I would love someone to paraphrase how this was dealt with.

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 22:53

@azimuth299

As well as moral judgment t's about wanting to believe you have control of the situation.

When it comes to what your small children eat, you DO have control of the situation.

Really? You control every meal your children eat? They don't get school dinners, food from grandparents? They never take anything out of the cupboards? I have teenagers at this point; they know how to cook.

I control what's served at dinner. I don't control every bite that goes into my children's mouths.

pikapikapukachu · 07/02/2022 22:51

@knitnerd90 what research is showing childhood obesity doesn't have an adverse impact on health?

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2022 22:49

"
Right. But you're tediously glossing over that the number of reasons is borderline irrelevant, because one reason causes 95% of the overweight population.
No one's applying this thread to the genetic/disability/medical etc, 1000 other reasons that make up in total, the 5% minority.

The. Exceptions. Do. Not. Make. The. Rule."

So there's a lot of assumptions packed into this: that it's all about the input/output equation, and that we control both halves of it through consumption and exercise. I'll ignore the statistics as they're purely made up.

Metabolism is a dynamic equation. Our expenditure isn't just dependent on how much exercise we do. Our bodies will actually adapt our metabolic rate. Our consumption is partly under our control (I decide if I'm going to put butter on my toast or not) but is influenced by multiple environmental factors, plus the hormones that determine hunger and satiety. One reason that bariatric surgery is effective isn't just that it shrinks your stomach; your hormone levels change. People report their taste buds changing, too.

azimuth299 · 07/02/2022 22:48

As well as moral judgment t's about wanting to believe you have control of the situation.

When it comes to what your small children eat, you DO have control of the situation.

ReadySteadyTwins · 07/02/2022 22:47

@Tynetime

No one's applying this thread to the genetic/disability/medical etc, 1000 other reasons that make up in total, the 5% minority.

How about autistic children who have eating disorders related to it? How would you know? Many on here would just judge straight away. Same with medical conditions which aren't always obvious.

Please go back and read the thread where this has already been addressed
Porcupineintherough · 07/02/2022 22:47

@Susiesue61 because she needs a different amount of calories to maintain her body weight? Boys do have a higher metabolism than girls and there are individual differences also.

WorstXmasEver · 07/02/2022 22:46

Fat kids are fat because they're eating too much & being given portions which are too large.

It's down to the parents. All the fat kids at school have fat parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread