Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
LexMitior · 08/02/2022 14:53

The judgmental aspect is one that people in the past routinely exercised. It was normal. Being obese is now common, but that does not make it normal, or indeed healthy. Human beings are not designed to carry excess weight.

A few years ago I had a serious back injury after a road accident and went to see a surgeon. In the waiting room all the other people who were there were obese. Their bodies were breaking because of the weight that they carried. It was absolutely grim. They would have surgery to ensure that they did not have crippling pain - pain they could have avoided if they had been a healthy weight.

That is what happens to your body long term if you are obese. It breaks when it does not have to.

scaredsadandstuck · 08/02/2022 14:46

@Refrosty

I'd largely say there are some very unhealthy attitudes peddled by parents particularly the Mum's that the girls parrot and it is worrying.

X1000

Indeed. I do wonder whether the children of some of those posting here will suffer other long term damage as a result of their parent's attitude towards food and weight. Like I said in my post above, I can fix my kids weight in the space of a year. I wonder how long it takes to fix a child who grew up with a parent who is so judgemental about other people's appearance and perceived health?
Refrosty · 08/02/2022 14:31

I'd largely say there are some very unhealthy attitudes peddled by parents particularly the Mum's that the girls parrot and it is worrying.

X1000

potniatheron · 08/02/2022 14:31

A lot of high emotions on this thread. Weight and food are incredibly personal things and influenced by countless external and internal factors.

I was a normal sized slim healthy kid until the age of 10 and I then suddenly ballooned aand became morbidly obese. I was shamed for it at school but no one bothered to look deeper. The reason I gained weight so suddenly was that my mum had met a man who was abusing me. Food was my self-medication. Later lost it all, now slim and a keen runner. But it took a long time to sort out my relationship with food and weight.

Obese children usually become morbidly obese or supermorbidly obese adults and it is a miserable life, especially at the supermorbid end of the scale. So many other comorbidities creep in and accelerate as life goes on. Children are innocent and don't deserve such a tough start in life. I'm tlaking about extreme childhood obesity here which is becoming more common.

It would be wonderful to think that every very overweight kid has someone looking out for them, scrutinising what else is going on in their life, checking if they are ok. Sadly I guess that is not the case.

Stumpedasatree · 08/02/2022 14:26

@Satingreenshutters

I don't think it is fat shaming children that is going on here but judging parents who allow their kids become overweight by eating shite.

Not judging kids who have medical conditions. Not judging kids who are overweight but judging parents who feed their kids crap which in turn, makes a child overweight. Therein lies the difference. It is NOT the child's fault. Again, the absolute DENIAL going on here is unreal and THIS is why we have so many overweight kids.....parents are in fucking DENIAL! It IS abuse to let a kid get to that size from overeating same as it would be to restrict food.

Not my fault!
He won't eat anything else
She is big boned.
He won't eat anything else.
He raids the cupboards when we are in bed.
His Dad is big.
We all eat like that in this house.

Half the time the parents don't address it because it means they will have to change their OWN eating habits...and they don't want to.

Medical issues, SEN etc are different scenarios but THE VAST MAJORITY of overweight kids are that way because they are fed crap. END of.

I couldn't agree with this more.
Satingreenshutters · 08/02/2022 14:18

I don't think it is fat shaming children that is going on here but judging parents who allow their kids become overweight by eating shite.

Not judging kids who have medical conditions. Not judging kids who are overweight but judging parents who feed their kids crap which in turn, makes a child overweight. Therein lies the difference. It is NOT the child's fault. Again, the absolute DENIAL going on here is unreal and THIS is why we have so many overweight kids.....parents are in fucking DENIAL! It IS abuse to let a kid get to that size from overeating same as it would be to restrict food.

Not my fault!
He won't eat anything else
She is big boned.
He won't eat anything else.
He raids the cupboards when we are in bed.
His Dad is big.
We all eat like that in this house.

Half the time the parents don't address it because it means they will have to change their OWN eating habits...and they don't want to.

Medical issues, SEN etc are different scenarios but THE VAST MAJORITY of overweight kids are that way because they are fed crap. END of.

Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 14:17

I agree with that and this notion of overweight DC not being bullied at school due to every kid being overweight is simply not true. At secondary school my eldest tells me that the kids who are overweight always get some nickname associated with it. He goes to a fairly middle class state school and I have found the other extreme of incredibly thin girls. It starts at primary school here and I'd largely say there are some very unhealthy attitudes peddled by parents particularly the Mum's that the girls parrot and it is worrying. My year 6 girl is only 20 percentile but when they got weighed in school the girls were particularly competitive about it all asking for each other's stats. I've had to detach my DD from.one friend a bit as her Mum is like this and very judgemental on kids that aren't skinny let alone that are overweight.

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 14:17

@BuddhaForMary

But for the majority it is exactly that. There's a lot of denial which doesn't help anyone.

@Lampshading and how is that any of your business or anyone else's business?? It isn't. And faking concern doesn't cover the fat shaming that's gone on on this thread.

That's the sad thing, because it's always no one else's business children are left to it.
BuddhaForMary · 08/02/2022 14:05

@Stumpedasatree and the same here.

But it seems some people on this thread think it's their business to judge whilst knowing absolutely nothing about the families they're judging.

Of course overeating can lead to weight gain, but so can other things. When people blanket judge any child who's overweight, they do so without knowing the situation. It's attitudes like this that get passed on to their children and then we wonder why overweight children get bullied in school.

Stumpedasatree · 08/02/2022 14:02

@BuddhaForMary it is not my business, and I would never outwardly judge. All I am responsible for are my children and raising them the best I can.

BuddhaForMary · 08/02/2022 13:59

@Stumpedasatree and I'll reiterate. How is that any of yours or anyone else's business? It isn't. So who are you to judge?

BuddhaForMary · 08/02/2022 13:58

But for the majority it is exactly that. There's a lot of denial which doesn't help anyone.

@Lampshading and how is that any of your business or anyone else's business?? It isn't. And faking concern doesn't cover the fat shaming that's gone on on this thread.

Stumpedasatree · 08/02/2022 13:55

@BuddhaForMary overeating is more than likely to be the cause of overweight in at least 90% of children. Yes there are other issues that can contribute. With some health issues or medication you may need to adjust food intake to remain a healthy weight. But the majority of fat people eat too much.

Rockhopper81 · 08/02/2022 13:48

@KittensTeaAndCake

If i was as angry as some people appear to be by the fact that some people and their DC are overweight, I'd probably want to do some work on myself to discover why it was such a trigger for me, before I deliberately or inadvertently passed my issues around weight onto my own children

It’s a concern for me, the same way it would be if I saw a kid with obviously dirty matted hair, or cuts and bruises, shoes that don’t fit etc etc. It’s neglect and I am concerned for the child to be living like that (medical reason excepted) with the parents doing absolutely nothing to address it. I don’t have any issues around food, thanks.

It's the same as a child being covered in cuts and bruises? Really?? Really really?!?

Wow...I'm not saying that education wouldn't go amiss with some parents, but wow...comparing giving a child a donut with giving them a beating...just when I think I've seen it all...

Rockhopper81 · 08/02/2022 13:46

@Gwenhwyfar

"Being slim doesn't automatically equal being healthy

True.

" the same way being overweight doesn't automatically equal being unhealthy."

Not true. It's unhealthy to be overweight.

"It's still a dick move to judge people in general though"

Everybody judges. You are now judging people who judge.

Overweight people are always unhealthy? Always??

What are your markers for health? Blood pressure? Resting heart rate? Cholesterol levels? Respiration rate? They can all be within normal levels for overweight people.

I accept the point about judging people being judgemental (even though I think that sounds a bit playground-esque to be honest). So no, you're right, judge away, just be honest with yourself why you're doing it - it's not because you care about the health of children generally, it's because you have an easily recognisable visual for what 'unhealthy' looks like, and you don't like it.

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 13:46

@BuddhaForMary

Christ on a bike despite some posters explaining that weight gain in children isn't always down to poor diet and over eating, it's going straight over some of your heads isn't it!
But for the majority it is exactly that. There's a lot of denial which doesn't help anyone.
BuddhaForMary · 08/02/2022 13:44

That's true @Refrosty and this thread has just given judgemental posters a chance to fake concern whilst fat shaming kids. They're not even interested in the notion that being overweight doesn't always come from overeating.

Refrosty · 08/02/2022 13:40

@BuddhaForMary

Christ on a bike despite some posters explaining that weight gain in children isn't always down to poor diet and over eating, it's going straight over some of your heads isn't it!
They won't see it any other way, until they themselves experience it, or their kids end up feeling the pressure to remain a healthy weight despite life challenges. Because, according to many here, maintaining a healthy weight is as easy as 'dont eat McDonalds.'

Eating disorders/undereating is also a thing.

BuddhaForMary · 08/02/2022 13:40

Mumsnet - By parents for parents. Unless you're fat or have a fat kid, then you can fuck right off

Exactly this. All this faux concern but this thread is just a covert way of fat shaming kids and judging families about whom the majority of you know nothing.

Satingreenshutters · 08/02/2022 13:31

@scaredsadandstuck

Both my children are overweight. One of them significantly so. I can guarantee that even the most judge-y of you on this thread (and wow some of you really are, aren't you) will still not be judging me as much as I judge myself.

For context - I was a very healthy weight for my whole life until 4 or 5 years ago (I turned 40, started taking an anti depressant and the weight piled on). I did two pregnancies barely gaining any extra weight and quickly returning to my pre-pregnancy size 8-10. My husband is also a healthy weight.

My children were a healthy weight - pretty much tracking the centiles they'd been on since birth until a few years ago. My children's weight now is a combination of factors, but mainly my mental health and terrible marriage have taken a huge amount of my energy. This means I am not effectively parenting them when it comes to food and activity levels.

I am however doing a good job in lots of other areas. They are lovely, happy, kind children. They do well at school, have good friendships and a range of interests (including doing sports outside of school).

I know that if I crack down on my kids eating and activity for a six to 12 months they'll be fine, because I know how to do that, I'm not lacking the skills, just the emotional bandwidth right now. However the vitriol on this thread towards me and my kids is somewhat motivating me to find it, I have to say! Blush Sad

That is the most honest post I have read here in a long time. You will get there @scaredsadandstuck and so will your kids. You are aware of it and you are going to do something about it. Your kids are loved and happy and that is the main thing. Fair play to you for such an honest post.
SexyLittleNosferatu · 08/02/2022 13:30

@BringBackCoffeeCreams

Mumsnet - By parents for parents. Unless you're fat or have a fat kid, then you can fuck right off.
Exactly.

This thread is disgusting.

Nobody actually gives a single shit, it's the often seen 'concern trolling'. They're all just loving the opportunity to put the boot into the lazy fatties, whilst shoehorning in their own clothes size.

BuddhaForMary · 08/02/2022 13:27

Christ on a bike despite some posters explaining that weight gain in children isn't always down to poor diet and over eating, it's going straight over some of your heads isn't it!

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 13:26

@tigerpants800

I also judge women who have their faces stuffed full of Botox and smoothers. I think it's a kind of mental illness. Rejecting ageing. Maybe there's a bit of that on this thread- the inability to accept the sometimes grotesque imperfections of being human.

Not that fat is grotesque to everyone. Fat models are always the most beautiful to draw in life drawing.

But back to the point- children shouldn't be over fed and under-exercised. Let them enjoy good health until they're old enough to neglect themselves.

Botox and the like isn't harmful to physical health though, whether it has roots in mental health is a different matter. Being overweight does, lots of people seem to assume people are focused on aesthetics, but it's not. You are correct many beautiful people are overweight, many slim people are ugly- but that doesn't change the fact that your physical health is affected.
MingeofDeath · 08/02/2022 13:22

Yes I do judge. My poor nephew was 6 stone by the time he was 5, He has been obses all his life and has an appalling relationship with food. It is entirely my sister's fault.

tigerpants800 · 08/02/2022 13:17

I also judge women who have their faces stuffed full of Botox and smoothers.
I think it's a kind of mental illness.
Rejecting ageing.
Maybe there's a bit of that on this thread- the inability to accept the sometimes grotesque imperfections of being human.

Not that fat is grotesque to everyone. Fat models are always the most beautiful to draw in life drawing.

But back to the point- children shouldn't be over fed and under-exercised. Let them enjoy good health until they're old enough to neglect themselves.