Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you judge the parents of overweight children

893 replies

PaddleBoardingMomma · 07/02/2022 17:24

At school pick up today I noticed a new girl in my daughters class was in the line waiting to be collected.

She is a very heavy set little girl, they are all in year 1, so still very young but this particular child looked far bigger and sadly really stood out. I found myself feeling so sad, wondering if she will settle in OK and then irrationally annoyed at her parents for putting her in that position.

I was quite a chubby child for some of my school years and recall the taunts vividly, it made my school experience pretty horrible so I think I have quite a skewed view on this in fairness, it hits a nerve.

I had a word with myself for being judgemental and not knowing the situation and I know it's non of my business, but I wondered if I'm just a horrible person or if anyone else feels a pang of sadness for these kids and (rightly or wrongly) finds themselves blaming/ judging the parents.

OP posts:
Chichimcgee · 08/02/2022 18:22

My point was that in a surgery of 40 people who were waiting for a clinical consult for back surgery then it was clear obesity was a very significant factor in needing surgery.

Interesting that you assume obesity is the factor in needing a job surgery and not that needing back surgery leads to obesity due to being unable to exercise.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 08/02/2022 18:21

@Arsewangry

This thread is disgusting. One of the most self congratulatory, self righteous I have ever read on here. I can't believe it's been left to run. I've seen threads zapped for far less, but hey it's fatties and porkers getting a bashing but that's ok.
Wanting a thread "zapped" because it makes you uncomfortable to talk about a very real problem faced by many children in the UK says more about you than any body else.

Anyone who wishes to scroll back through the comments will see that the vast majority of unsavoury language and nasty jibes are coming from the people who think there's nothing wrong with childhood obesity... take from that what you will.

OP posts:
LexMitior · 08/02/2022 18:16

@Rockhopper81 I think I'm trying to make is that weight is a factor in the injury you received and why you did have that injury. It doesn't have to have caused it alone of course - I don't actually know you or whether you are obese or not. However, obesity is a well documented aspect of needing knee surgery earlier in life, barring accidents.

My point was that in a surgery of 40 people who were waiting for a clinical consult for back surgery then it was clear obesity was a very significant factor in needing surgery. Medical advice was to lose weight (plus point being obese is dangerous in surgery also) These people would have been in serious pain to even be there, and yet, the obvious thing for most of them would have been to lose weight and avoid the knife. That was the advice their surgeon gave them on the basis of the current guidelines for this kind of surgery.

Severity of treatment such as surgery or the clinical outcome can only be improved by losing weight or maintaining healthy weight. Why is it so contentious to you for me to say that? The evidence is that excess weight affects you as you age, that is not contentious either.

Your knee injury is of course something you will have to take care of - does that not prompt you think about the future?

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 18:15

@Goldenbear

The thing is though I can't imagine bringing my dc up to be so judgmental of others and thinking I was a good Mother for encouraging such unkindness. Like I said previously, we have the opposite at the schools my DCs go to many more girls with the very very thin legs, so many skinny girls, it seems to move in that direction by year 6. I have had to move away from one of DDs friend's Mum as she wants to talk about how much all the girls eat all of the time, as my DD is thin she thinks I'm on board with this low level nastiness but I think she's pretty shallow and don't think itnos coming from a place of concern at all.
Who is bringing up their children to judge others on their weight or encouraging unkindness, the people pointing out the truth if which you have no idea what they say to their children? Yes pressure to be very slim is also an issue, and I imagine most people would acknowledge its a problem that could have implications for children down the line and be keen to try and find and support solutions. The same isn't true for children who are overweight, it's always mind your own nothing to see here.
Goldenbear · 08/02/2022 18:12

The thing is though I can't imagine bringing my dc up to be so judgmental of others and thinking I was a good Mother for encouraging such unkindness. Like I said previously, we have the opposite at the schools my DCs go to many more girls with the very very thin legs, so many skinny girls, it seems to move in that direction by year 6. I have had to move away from one of DDs friend's Mum as she wants to talk about how much all the girls eat all of the time, as my DD is thin she thinks I'm on board with this low level nastiness but I think she's pretty shallow and don't think itnos coming from a place of concern at all.

KittensTeaAndCake · 08/02/2022 18:12

@funinthesun19

I’ve just been watching 10 year old DS do his swimming lesson. He’s overweight but he eats a well balanced diet. I honestly don’t know why his weight has shot up. Could I possibly be puppy fat?

Everyone in his class is skinny, so he definitely sticks out like a sore thumb and no doubt everyone is judging me (and him). I’m skinny and all his siblings are skinny, so it’s not a family thing.

Could be, if he wasn't like it before. Mine put on a bit of chub at that age just before shooting up.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 08/02/2022 18:11

@Arsewangry

This thread is disgusting. One of the most self congratulatory, self righteous I have ever read on here. I can't believe it's been left to run. I've seen threads zapped for far less, but hey it's fatties and porkers getting a bashing but that's ok.
I really don't think this is the case overall, this is a discussion about a very real health issue that many people are in complete denial about. As a nation we are getting bigger and unhealthier and if we don't talk about it because it might offend then how will things ever improve.
Chichimcgee · 08/02/2022 18:10

You don't judge any parent for anything? You don't think that there is a minimum acceptable standard of care for children?

Why is it your business to judge parents?
You’re happy to take a 2 minute snap shot of what you see and judge away.
If there’s genuine neglect/abuse or anything going on then it is up to the school/doctor/people who know the family, even yourself if you know details to get help for the child rather than just sitting by judging the parent to be shit.

Whereohwhereohwhere · 08/02/2022 18:09

I'm so saddened by this. I have a child with SEN, they are definitely overweight, due partly to some medication they take and not helped by underlying health conditions. We work really hard on not making it worse and have been literally begging for help. Judge away. I'm too tired to care.

Chichimcgee · 08/02/2022 18:08

I can't help but feel intense sadness for the kids being doled out mars bars and a can of pepsi everyday after school when they waddle to meet their parents. Poor kids.

Obviously that’s wrong and nobody is saying that is right.
The question is do you judge

You have no idea of anyone’s circumstances, health issues or whatever and it’s disgusting that you would see an overweight child, judge the parent assuming they dole out Mars bars and Pepsi’s. Maybe they do, maybe they don’t but it’s not your place to judge.

Chichimcgee · 08/02/2022 18:06

I know that if I crack down on my kids eating and activity for a six to 12 months they'll be fine, because I know how to do that

I’m so pleased your kids are little robots who do as they’re told who don’t have choices at school/other parents/grandmas house.

FrecklesMalone · 08/02/2022 18:04

There is so much denial it is sad. Of course there are some conditions that cause children to become fat but that accounts for barely any. I can't help but feel intense sadness for the kids being doled out mars bars and a can of pepsi everyday after school when they waddle to meet their parents. Poor kids.

azimuth299 · 08/02/2022 18:02

@GreekGod

No, I don't.

I don't judge any parent

You don't judge any parent for anything? You don't think that there is a minimum acceptable standard of care for children?
Rockhopper81 · 08/02/2022 17:59

@LexMitior

A good clinical outcome is not one you can claim, is it? That's on your surgeon's skill.
As I initially said, I twisted it standing up - it was a simple case of my knee twisting in a way it's not designed to, a 'freak accident' if you like. My weight had no bearing on the accident that caused the injury, or the extent of the injury.

And whilst no, I cannot claim a good surgical outcome, the clinical outcome overall (as in, restored mobility and much reduction in pain) was somewhat down to following the post-operative advice, so that part I can claim part of it.

I feel like you're looking for a way to make this about my weight - when I have a explained carefully, and in more detail than anyone is owed, how it's not - because it suits your argument...would you be as keen to hear how my cousin tore her ACL? Or does it not matter, because she's not fat? I shall save you the trouble of asking - she too did it in a 'freak accident' kind of way, bending down to pick something up in her work vehicle and it popped on the upright movement. Again, not related to her weight, but that doesn't matter, does it?

GreekGod · 08/02/2022 17:59

No, I don't.

I don't judge any parent

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 17:58

@Arsewangry

Ah I see - You're being deliberately obtuse, when that's how overweight people have been referred to on this very thread.

It is not possible by looking at children in a playground, to differentiate between those who are being over-fed or fed a poor diet and those children who are impacted by other physical and mental health issues that cause weight gain, so by my book, judging and shaming all parents of overweight children, and throwing words like abuse and neglect around willey-nilley is pretty damned unhelpful at best, and actually pretty cruel.

Like I said, you're clearly enjoying it so crack on. I'm off to make dinner for my family and I will be hiding this thread, it's just disgusting.

I have said anything about abuse or neglect, so perhaps address the posters that have if you're going to mention it. Good job you've flounced if you can't be bothered to read it properly.
Arsewangry · 08/02/2022 17:54

Ah I see - You're being deliberately obtuse, when that's how overweight people have been referred to on this very thread.

It is not possible by looking at children in a playground, to differentiate between those who are being over-fed or fed a poor diet and those children who are impacted by other physical and mental health issues that cause weight gain, so by my book, judging and shaming all parents of overweight children, and throwing words like abuse and neglect around willey-nilley is pretty damned unhelpful at best, and actually pretty cruel.

Like I said, you're clearly enjoying it so crack on. I'm off to make dinner for my family and I will be hiding this thread, it's just disgusting.

Giraffesandbottoms · 08/02/2022 17:49

Also lol at the “my children are fat hit otherwise I’m a good mother” = “my children have a poor diet and don’t do enough exercise and will almost certainly be bullied and suffer all manner of health concerns but that pales in comparison to the other benefits of my mothering”?!

Giraffesandbottoms · 08/02/2022 17:47

I know that if I crack down on my kids eating and activity for a six to 12 months they'll be fine, because I know how to do that

But you won’t fix it. And it won’t be fine. Because this is exactly the mentality of every dieter ever/and that’s why people are fat. “Yes yes I know I can lose the weight easily and be slim. I’ll do that in a bit”. Never fucking happens.

My mother was a size 24 for YEARS. She was in extreme denial I saw it all and her looking in the mirror and thinking it was fine/absolute body dysmorphia. Eating a salad with an entire baguette. Drinking bottles of wine or eating a trough of spaghetti. Absolute lack of awareness. She only lost weight due to illness - she never, ever would have lost it otherwise.

People saying their children eat fine and don’t understand how they are gaining weight need to actually properly examine what they are eating - it all adds up. It seems like a packet of crisps or two and a couple of biscuits or three but actually it’s probably more than you think.

I am gobsmacked by the denial on here! But then the majority of women in the UK are fat and therefore people are on this thread who don’t want to see it, like my mother didn’t.

Lampshading · 08/02/2022 17:45

@Arsewangry I'd never refer to people like that even to prove a point, but you do so perhaps not quite as pleasant as you're trying to make out. I just find it frustrating how a lot of people won't acknowledge basic facts which is partly what stops progress being made.

LexMitior · 08/02/2022 17:43

A good clinical outcome is not one you can claim, is it? That's on your surgeon's skill.

Arsewangry · 08/02/2022 17:42

@Lampshading

Also the only people using language like 'fatties' and 'porkers' on this thread are posters like yourself who have come on to say how horrible the thread is.
I made no assumptions on any posters weight.

I contributed further up the thread, but because it doesn't fit the with the overwhelming narrative of the thread it has been largely ignored.

Carry on and fill your boots, you're clearly having a great time.

It reflects worse on you than it ever could on me if that's the kind of person you are.

LexMitior · 08/02/2022 17:41

Because if you were severely overweight, or obese, that could have been a significant contributory factor as to how you sustained your injury; how did it happen?

LexMitior · 08/02/2022 17:40

How did you sustain your injury, may I ask?

Rockhopper81 · 08/02/2022 17:38

[quote LexMitior]@Rockhopper81 - I don't know if you are obese, you have said here that you are overweight.

However, if you were obese and had required knee surgery due an accident, the excess weight would have likely contributed to the severity of your injury. Being obese would have contributed to the need you had and the degree of pain you felt.

But what is "physics arguing with your body". If you stood up, and were obese, this could have meant the injury was far worse than if you were a healthy weight. Obesity means your body breaks more readily because of the greater weight being carried.[/quote]
Physics arguing with my body - it wanted to turn one way, physics (gravitational pull) and the limits of human connective/'cushioning' tissue tried to put a stop to it. Needed surgery to repair a buckle tear in my meniscus, surgery being the optimum choice due to locking of the joint, severity of the damage, and my age (34 at the time). A brief medical overview for you there.

No, my weight had no bearing on the cause of the injury, or my recovery from surgery. In fact, my recovery was text book, because I'm actually quite capable of following the standard physio advice given for post-operative care.

As an aside, my athletic, average weight cousin sustained a significantly worse knee injury - requiring ACL reconstruction, a much more involved surgery, with a significantly longer and more in-depth recovery programme - than I did, but I guess that's okay as she's slim and average weight, right?

My point is, for neither injury was the weight of the person who suffered it a contributory factor. It just wasn't. When I had my knee surgery, there were two other people having total knee replacements - both were slim and appeared of average weight, so it's doubtful their weight had contributed to the joint degradation. You have no idea what those people in the waiting room had experienced or why they were there, you've just decided it was self inflicted because they were fat.