Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask what is better for undergrad economics? Cambridge or LSE?

84 replies

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 10:49

If MNHQ want to move this to higher education that is fine with me.

Fortunate that DS has offers from both unis and I know they are both excellent (no issue cost wise with us thankfully). Anyone has any information as to what has the better undergrad course?

We've both looked at as much info as we can online. Apparently LSE has a new economics curriculum (and that interests DS very much) but Cambridge has a mix of maths and essays. Rankings wise Cambridge is higher up in the UK subject rankings but LSE is higher up in the global rankings for economics. If anyone has any DC currently doing economics, relaying their thoughts would be great.

I know that Cambridge is excellent but DS has heard of some cases where people turn down their Cambridge offer to go to LSE.

OP posts:
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 20:31

@CrowFriend what course did ur DD's friend study? Glad she's happier now at Oxford. Seems lots of people have bad experiences with LSE. Makes me wonder why so many people apply there then.

OP posts:
CrowFriend · 07/02/2022 20:19

Yes a very different student experience anecdotally. One of my DD’s friends went to LSE and declined Oxford offer but disliked LSE enough to drop out and start at Oxford the following year. On her course, the majority were foreign students who tended to just socialise between themselves and in their own languages. It was tricky for her to socialise with the wider student community as the facilities were so spread out and she didn’t feel comfortable going back to her hall ( plush student rooms above shops in central London, £££ poor parents!) late at night. She was lonely …
Best of luck to your son!

HappySM1 · 07/02/2022 20:06

Cambridge, every time.

Crimesean · 07/02/2022 19:59

Definitely Cambridge over LSE! At Cambridge you make friends within your college from across all academic disciplines. At LSE they all tend to be economists, statisticians and mathematicians. Cambridge is loads more fun!*

  • I went to Cambridge so possibly biased, but I had way more fun than DH who was at LSE!
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 19:54

DS is quite confident about firming Cambridge now! Had a great talk with him. He's not so sure where to insure. He does want to have fun when at uni (I want him to have fun as well).

OP posts:
HousePlantNeglect · 07/02/2022 19:39

@rainyskylight

London is sprawling and there’s very little community in the big London universities as there’s no campus. Cambridge for sure. He will have closer friends, there’s more investment pastorally. The name also means more internationally for an undergrad course. LSE is mainly lots and lots of foreign students working hard with no hobbies.

(UCL undergrad, Oxford postgrad, many of my friends did the opposite).

Would agree with this. I went to another London university and found the student life extremely dull compared to my friends at other universities. London is expensive and spread out so the living circumstances are just much less set up for fun.

In addition, the banking internships was a massive thing at my London university too. Half my course are in banking and it’s nothing remotely to do with economics!

Bunnycat101 · 07/02/2022 19:27

I would totally go for Cambridge as the experience as a student will likely be better. I’ve done some post grad courses at LSE and it didn’t have anything like the atmosphere of other city universities I’ve studied at. London will also be expensive. I also personally found there were lots of international students on my course whose English was poor and who struggled to contribute in seminars etc. Cambridge he’d get the smaller tutorials which would be a massive benefit. I felt LSE went for the model of ‘pack them in’ to rake in the cash.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 07/02/2022 19:20

senior members in the economics dept say 'LSE is better for economics. We rank higher on global statistics

No one other than academics cares about their global ranking.

Go to Cambridge, do a Master's at the LSE. Cambridge will open far more doors.

Ajl46 · 07/02/2022 19:13

I'd agree with PP who've asked which city would suit him better to live in. Eg my friends that went to London unis lived a long way out of the centre & had to commute in which had quite an impact on their social lives. Everywhere in Cambridge is max 10mins away by bike...

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 17:27

After chatting with DS he seems very excited about Cambridge now. He was considering LSE as it too is a good uni for economics. In the virtual offer holder days senior members in the economics dept say 'LSE is better for economics. We rank higher on global statistics'.

@rainyskylight mind I ask why you are against Nottingham (and what you studied? (Was it social science related?) Did you enjoy oxford more than UCL?

OP posts:
rainyskylight · 07/02/2022 17:12

Nottingham is a terrible idea.

rainyskylight · 07/02/2022 17:11

London is sprawling and there’s very little community in the big London universities as there’s no campus. Cambridge for sure. He will
have closer friends, there’s more investment pastorally. The name also means more internationally for an undergrad course. LSE is mainly lots and lots of foreign students working hard with no hobbies.

(UCL undergrad, Oxford postgrad, many of my friends did the opposite).

TatianaBis · 07/02/2022 16:03

Nottingham the town is a dump, however, and no match for the historic beauty of Cambridge or the multicultural metropolis of London.

Students have a laugh wherever they are.

I think your idea of Cambridge for undergrad and LSE for postgrad is ideal.

Flammkuchen · 07/02/2022 15:57

If he wants to be a top academic and do a PhD in the US, the LSE course may be better. Otherwise, Cambridge every time. Job-wise, there's nothing in it, but the social life and experience at Cambridge would be much better.

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 15:08

DS also has an offer for economics at Nottingham and he does feel his social/party life would be better there. But he is hesitant to chose Nottingham as he thinks he would be making a mistake career wise and missing out on having a 'world-renowned' university on his CV. I've told him that Nottingham grads still do well.

OP posts:
puffyisgood · 07/02/2022 14:13

LSE has a better choice of specialist economics modules [e.g. labour economics etc] and if you take the very hardest available options at each step it's a overall harder, more rigorous course, that gets you a little closer to PhD research. The Cambridge base course used to be way tougher than the LSE base course [i.e. if you chose all the easiest options] but this is a lot less true now - quite far into the 1990s it was possible to get onto LSE's BSc (Econ) without A level maths even, whereas now you need an A* .

Cambridge still has the tutorials/bits of small group teaching, but I'm not sure how valuable some of this is. Cambridge has loads more marked work/essays, which is a bit of a mixed blessing. Cambridge gives out more 1st class degrees and probably puts you at a small edge applying for funded postgrad courses and a slightly bigger edge applying for city jobs etc.

Cambridge is much cheaper [often possible to 'live in (halls)', paying for 24 week academic years only, which is a fair bit harder at LSE].

Being in London, LSE is that bit closer and more convenient for city job interviews & so on [though a fair bit of early round stuff does happen on man university campuses].

Social life at both is fairly dire by UK undergraduate standards. LSE is smallish & so dominated by foreign students and/or non-WASP types who don't drink etc that the modest number of white British undergrads end up mostly knowing each other & hanging around the one union bar loads. The lack of arts etc students generally means less interesting/diverse people. Cambridge is bigger and college centric, most kids there are so either bookish or hooray-ish, and the workload's so great, that there's not really a normal social scene in the way that you're recognise it from a modern campus university.

Overall I'd recommend Cambridge, on account of the lower cost and higher prestige.

starfro · 07/02/2022 13:51

Definitely go to Cambridge.

interferingma · 07/02/2022 13:34

Son went to Cambridge, DiL went to LSE, Neither did economics, but here is what they've told me:
LSE's undergrad population is relatively small so socially it can be a bit isolating. Cambridge will be more fun! DiL always said it would be better to be a post grad at LSE.
LSE grads however have at least as good job prospects as Cambridge grads. They always top employability tables. This is possibly however because they don't do subjects like English which are notoriously not great for employability!

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 13:31

Thank you all for your help. DS is now thinking of perhaps doing his masters at LSE (if he feels further study is for him) in a way to 'get the best of both worlds'. Experiencing Cambridge and LSE.

OP posts:
Elliephant23 · 07/02/2022 13:14

He should definitely go to Cambridge. The terms are short and intense but most students there find time to have lots of fun, too, and the range of societies and things to get involved in is brilliant. The college experience is special, the city is gorgeous, and he can experience big city living for the rest of his life if he wants. Don't hesitate!

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 13:03

Isn't C known for academic rigour and also the shorter term lengths? Is LSE competitive on academics itself (as in the course material) or more so on the 'lets get into banking' job application side?

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 07/02/2022 12:12

I am a maths-heavy STEM academic and I agree with @irregularegular, he really cannot go wrong. It comes down to a set of preferences about curriculum, location and lifestyle.

However I find it interesting that your DS is concerned that C might be more brutal. I share the impression of @Backstreetsbackalrightdadada that LSE is super competitive. As for reputations, the C name will generate more respect at posh parties, but within relevant professional spheres LSE has at least an equal reputation

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 11:39

@Backstreetsbackalrightdadada might I ask why they regret going to uni in London? I know LSE has quite a few commuters. DS would obviously be in LSE halls (if he choses LSE).

DS has worries about the 'brutality' of the Cambridge term lengths. From what he has heard (at least in Year1) there are essays due every week AND mathematical problem sets. He is worried he'd have little free time to enjoy being at Cambridge. Is it actually that bad? Or more of a case of 'just manage your time well'?

OP posts:
AtLeastPretendToCare · 07/02/2022 11:34

LSE is great but I would pick Cambridge. It opens many more doors.

irregularegular · 07/02/2022 11:34

Both will give him a very high quality education and a very well respected degree. He should choose on the environment, lifestyle and teaching style, which would all be very different.

(I'm an academic economist)