Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask what is better for undergrad economics? Cambridge or LSE?

84 replies

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 07/02/2022 10:49

If MNHQ want to move this to higher education that is fine with me.

Fortunate that DS has offers from both unis and I know they are both excellent (no issue cost wise with us thankfully). Anyone has any information as to what has the better undergrad course?

We've both looked at as much info as we can online. Apparently LSE has a new economics curriculum (and that interests DS very much) but Cambridge has a mix of maths and essays. Rankings wise Cambridge is higher up in the UK subject rankings but LSE is higher up in the global rankings for economics. If anyone has any DC currently doing economics, relaying their thoughts would be great.

I know that Cambridge is excellent but DS has heard of some cases where people turn down their Cambridge offer to go to LSE.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 23/02/2022 18:12

What draws DS to London is that fact that that many times there are joint society events with LSE,KCL and UCL. (Many of the political socs do this).

However DS and I have had a chat and he's apply to do a masters in London in the future.

OP posts:
urbanbuddha · 23/02/2022 17:41

I think your idea of Cambridge for undergrad and LSE for postgrad is ideal.

^This.

puffyisgood · 23/02/2022 17:34

@downtonabbeyfan1234

DS feels the LSE course has more flexibility and better choice of optional modules. I'm guessing for the core modules they learn almost the same thing?
It is true that LSE has a bigger, in some cases better, range of applied economics courses to pick from in the third year. LSE doesn't have core/compulsary third year micro/macroeconomics papers in the way that Cambridge does. But this is IMO only really classable as a strong benefit for someone who really knows what they want to specialise in after university.

The first & second years are more similar.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 23/02/2022 16:40

@downtonabbeyfan1234

A PP mentioned someone hating LSE and then dropping out. But I've heard of people who unfortunately hate their time at Oxbridge and drop out of that too.
There are people who drop out everywhere. It is worth mentioning that the Tripos structure at Cambridge makes it quite straightforward (although not guaranteed) and quite common to switch subjects after your have completed your Part 1.
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 23/02/2022 15:20

@Fuuyf5677 LSE does have an offer holder day in April

OP posts:
Fuuyf5677 · 23/02/2022 13:46

Not sure where you're currently based. I think the point is he'd be choosing the city as much as the uni. Would it be possible for him to spend three days by himself in Cam and then London - to see where he feels happiest? Something to think about as a student in London is that he will spend a lot of time by himself - it's a major city after all. Some love it - I did and was always inspired by walking across the river. In fact, I still do that very same walk every evening and just love it. However, lots of my friends found it difficult and hated it. Similarly, I found Oxbridge too small as a postgrad and moved to London half way through and commuted in while lots of my friends thought it was the best. There is no wrong and right answer here, just a personal preference

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 23/02/2022 13:39

A PP mentioned someone hating LSE and then dropping out. But I've heard of people who unfortunately hate their time at Oxbridge and drop out of that too.

OP posts:
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 23/02/2022 13:32

DS feels the LSE course has more flexibility and better choice of optional modules. I'm guessing for the core modules they learn almost the same thing?

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 23/02/2022 12:08

I’d put Cambridge #1 and LSE as an insurance if it’ll drop a grade.

Cambridge would be a lovely city in which to be a student - London can feel too big, isolating and lonely. Loads of international students at LSE who’ll fly home to HK etc on graduation, whereas Cambridge will be more mixed.

My DH went to Oxford- I’d advise Oxford or Cambridge every time; so many good employers only look there for their graduates, and the other people he meets there will go on to great things, so very worth knowing (more so than at LSE).

He can always move to London on graduation- which if he does economics he’s likely to anyway.

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/02/2022 11:58

@Fuuyf5677 Well, we all have our prejudices and yours are clearly quite different to mine.

I will add one further point which I think is little-discussed but in retrospect probably my favourite thing about an undergraduate experience at Oxbridge: the college system means that you live and work with students across the full range of academic disciplines. The LSE student body is undoubtedly a more global demographic and the specialism in social studies might suit OP's DS if he wants to immerse himself in this field. Conversely if I think of my own friends from university they comprise physicists, chemists, lawyers, art historians, doctors, etc etc, and I really value the different perspectives that they all bring (especially as only one of them lives in a three-bedroom house in the Home Counties Wink).

I suppose you could try to replicate this by living in intercollegiate halls in London but it is harder, especially now ULU / Student Centre on Malet St has gone.

FeelTheRush · 23/02/2022 11:30

I also went to LSE and did economics and another subject (joint degree) - I loved it but I wanted the experience of living in London, the whole “dreamy spires”, debates in the common room and cycling to lectures feel of Oxbridge didn’t appeal to me.

Best of luck to your DS in his decision.

Fuuyf5677 · 23/02/2022 11:04

@ThanksItHasPockets it's just a very small stuffy bubble. And a bit boring and dare I say it British. But I am not British and as an undergrad, I loved getting back into a global bubble. Oxford frankly felt small and a bit parochial after that. Both places are elite bubbles - the main question is which one would you rather be in and what do you aspire to do afterwards and where. LSE students will be much more focused on getting their first job in London and then moving onto to Zurich, New York, Frankfurt etc etc etc rather than living in a three bed house in the home counties, which to me is boring. But thats a personal preference.

We are talking about elite universities here - so it's not like students or staff at one are better or worse than each other. Personally, I dont think the tutorial system is all that good. It doesnt teach you enough about working in a team, managing social relations etc, too focused on the relationship with the tutor, which doesnt prepare you for the workplace which are usually much more diverse. Lots of PhD students teach tutorials so it's not like you get top profs doing it all the time.

Either way, most graduates from both end up in London afterwards so whichever one he picks, he will get to experience London.

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/02/2022 09:57

[quote downtonabbeyfan1234]@Fuuyf5677 might I ask what you studied? Econ as well?

DS likes the fact that with LSE being in London there's lots of 'political' stuff going on. Some people he has spoken to have called Oxbridge a bubble.[/quote]
But what’s wrong with a bubble if that bubble is filled with some of the greatest minds and world experts in their fields, and a community of peers all engaged in study, thinking, discussion, creativity, sport etc etc? I have never understood why ‘bubble’ is used so sneeringly. It doesn’t mean you don’t engage with the world, or travel. Cambridge terms are so short that you can go and work in the ‘real world’ every vacation if you so wish.

ferretface · 23/02/2022 09:36

I did law at LSE (my choice was between Oxford and LSE) - I chose it specifically because I loved London. They are very different experiences, I made many lifelong friends at LSE and had a fantastic time but it suited my personality. I think the quality of the teaching is likely to be better at Cambridge, LSE has a bad habit of using PhD students for tutorials, some of them are excellent but others just aren't good teachers. It's nothing like the tutorial system at Oxbridge and from what I can tell it hasn't changed since I was there (despite this being an area where LSE repeatedly falls down on student surveys).

Basically I'd choose LSE over Cambridge if like me the experience of living in London is a big draw in of itself. Otherwise, i'd choose Cambridge.

StellaOlivetti · 22/02/2022 14:14

A friend of mine went to the LSE (law, not economics) and found it very difficult socially. Very intense and very competitive, hard to make friends (she’s a normally gregarious and friendly person) and eventually left. I think London was too much for her; she started again elsewhere and did fine. My daughter went to Cambridge and loved every minute (despite all the worried stereotypes about everyone being richer/posher etc. So that’s my two penny worth; good luck to your son.

Fuuyf5677 · 22/02/2022 14:06

I didnt do econ but another similar subject. I would say that both our bubbles - Oxbridge for me was a much more British bubble than the LSE but you have to be prepared to live in a massive city. Lots of my British friends at the LSE were a bit overwhelmed with how big it was. Something to look out for is that most of my friends no longer live in the UK - they were mostly internationals and after doing a few years in the city left. To be fair, I did the same but that tells you something. Everyone at the LSE was totally focused on internships right at the start but again am assuming thats not too different at Cambridge, Oxford or Imperial at undergrad level.

What I wouldnt do is go anywhere else other than Oxbridge or top London unis. It's just not worth it. So I would say - maybe he should pick according to where he'd rather live. Students are studies and fun loving everywhere. I do remember when LSE went 24hr - I was really really happy about it. Equally i also remember visiting my best mate at Cambridge and being really jealous of her library key.

Personally, I do think that Oxbridge terms are just unnecessarily short. You cover the same amount of material in a much shorted timeframe. However, it does teach you to be able to digest and produce copious amounts of information in a very short space of time. Thats a useful skill in itself though its a lot less pleasant while you're doing it

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 22/02/2022 14:05

@SeasonFinale good point.

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 22/02/2022 13:50

The people who call Oxbridge a bubble are usually those who didn't get in though so always take what anyone says with a pinch of salt.

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 22/02/2022 13:37

@Fuuyf5677 might I ask what you studied? Econ as well?

DS likes the fact that with LSE being in London there's lots of 'political' stuff going on. Some people he has spoken to have called Oxbridge a bubble.

OP posts:
Fuuyf5677 · 22/02/2022 07:38

I did LSE and then Oxford. Personally LSE broadened my horizons, everyone was very International and I loved it. But you end up with a very mature social life, I hardly went to any student bars because frankly they weren't so nice. I appreciate this has changed recently. I found Oxford a bit small and stuff but undoubtedly its Oxford that people care about. However, most undergrads from both places end up doing MAs so this isn't such a big deal what he ends up doing for his first degree

Universe1969 · 22/02/2022 07:23

I studied at LSE. Not econ. You hit the ground running. Both lse and Cambridge are excellent. The student experiences are very different. Talk to people doing both and visit both a few times if you can

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 13/02/2022 13:27

Believe I should give an update. DS firmed Cambridge and actually insured LSE.

He was originally put off by LSE but I encouraged him to research LSE as much as possible before making his final choice. He has looked at the virtual open day recordings (those from the uni and from the Econ dept) and saw that the uni has invested a lot of time and money trying to improve the student experience and create a better community feel. DS is still intrigued by the economics curriculum reform.
He has looked at a student Youtuber at LSE and she seems to be having a lot of fun in her vlogs.

The negative stereotype of LSE social life seems exaggerated to an extent. DS tells me people he has spoken to say 'it is what you make it'.

OP posts:
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 08/02/2022 15:49

DS has many years before he needs to decide about his postgrad life. Thankfully now he's a bit more sure about where he wants to study his undergrad.

Thanks all for your honest advice.

OP posts:
irregularegular · 08/02/2022 15:22

@irregularegular from what I've seen in the US the postgrad degrees are straight to phd. cant find a masters in economics degree taught at Harvard

True, in the US you essentially do the masters and phd in one go. Though I think most give the (non-advertised) option to leave with a Masters if you don't complete the phd. Oxford is moving the same way - encouraging students who expect to do the Dphil to apply for the combination from the start.

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 08/02/2022 15:17

@irregularegular from what I've seen in the US the postgrad degrees are straight to phd. cant find a masters in economics degree taught at Harvard

OP posts: