Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exs mum cut my daughter's hair!!

169 replies

Singlemum90 · 06/02/2022 20:50

I have 2 DC's with ex. He lives with his parents and has children 1 night a week-so they stay in his parents house with him. He has lived there since we split years ago. The rest of the time children are with me and DH and our youngest child.

So ex had the kids his night this weekend and daughter returns with her hair cut! I'd say 6 inches of her beautiful long blonde hair all gone. I was obviously shocked and asked had he taken her to the hairdresser. Nope, his mum had decided she needed a hair cut, booked an appointment for DD, and told the hairdresser she wanted it all chopped off. Previously long hair is now shoulder length. DD isn't upset but doesn't like it as it was shorter than she wanted but granny had the final say. Her hair had not been cut in a year but I had literally just booked her brother in for a haircut the day before and had planned me & my DD would get booked in this week as we could both use a trim. She had lovely thick long blonde hair so was in no way bad looking or stragily-i assume his mum just didn't like the length.

He can't understand why I am absolutely fuming!! Neither can his mum by the sounds of it. AIBU to think that his mum had no right to take my daughter without my permission to get her hair cut !?! I asked DD had she asked to have her hair cut and she said no but his mum said she needed it done. Why would she think thats her decision!? It's so much shorter! I really don't like it, she looks so different. Ex wasn't there as had taken other DC out for the day so it was all his mum. Apparently she had booked the appointment a few weeks ago so had plenty of opportunity to ask if I was ok with it or what way she should have it done or if I wanted to take her myself but nope, she just completely bypassed me!!

OP posts:
Veryworried22 · 07/02/2022 16:42

The hair itself wouldn't bother me. I'd be more upset that the child didn't actually want it done but their autonomy wasn't respected. That's disgraceful.

whysoserious123 · 07/02/2022 16:40

Dad said yes then there is no issue

Dad has rights too

phoenixrosehere · 07/02/2022 16:33

Yes, if they had my child’s consent. The issue here is that the child didn’t want it.

I agree.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 07/02/2022 16:20

Would you really accept someone doing something to your child without either you or their father’s permission that alters their appearance?

Yes, if they had my child’s consent. The issue here is that the child didn’t want it.

Which brings me back to why hairdressers cut hair according to the (female) with the child, and don’t ask the child.

I had a whole childhood of haircuts I hated, because my mum booked and insisted I had it how she wanted. I actually hated the hairdresser more than the dentist, and quite often found it more painful.

phoenixrosehere · 07/02/2022 15:20

Why though? I wouldn’t, because it’s only hair. Why are mothers so invested in their daughters hair?

It’s more than just the hair. Did you read the OP’s posts?

MIL planned this weeks ago without either parent or the child knowing. The child didn’t ask for this and was told by MIL she was getting her hair cut because it was necessary and MIL decided on how SHE felt ger granddaughter should look.

Would you really accept someone doing something to your child without either you or their father’s permission that alters their appearance?

I would not and I have sons with curly, long hair.

onedayoranother · 07/02/2022 15:16

Fir those who say you are overreacting /he's an equal parent etc - but he didn't do it did he? Would he have thought to take them? Probably not, and if he did he should have passed it by you.
His mother, who apparently decided and took her there, made the decision and she had no right to. And I don't care about this equal parenting bit - you should have been asked.

WomanStanleyWoman · 07/02/2022 14:39

I would be pleased it had saved me a job.

But it didn’t save the OP a job, did it? To have saved her a job, the MIL would have to have done something the OP was planning to do herself. If she’d been planning to cut six inches off her daughter’s hair, we wouldn’t be having this discussion.

If you’d been thinking about painting the walls green and you came home to find your ex-MIL had painted them yellow, would you think ‘Ooh, saved me a job!’? Would you buggery!

billy1966 · 07/02/2022 13:52

This is NOT about long hair.

This is about doing something a child didn't want and the parents didn't know about, and didn't agree to.

billy1966 · 07/02/2022 13:50

So both parents didn't know or agree to this?

And your 8 year old child didn't want it?

To say I would be apoplectic, is putting it mildly.

You want to do something that drives the point home to her?

Report her to 101 and ask their advice.

Your 8 year old didn't want this done but she insisted.

What an awful woman.

I wouldn't dream of cutting a 5 year olds hair if they didn't want it cut.

I think she was very wrong to do this.

No respect for her granddaughter and no respect for her parents.

She is an absolute disgrace.

Blueberryflavour · 07/02/2022 13:40

As a grandma I wouldn’t dream of doing something like this, it would be totally over stepping. I am wondering though how much of the parenting of your DD is her dad leaving his mother to do during their contact time with their dad. If he’s expecting her to look after them, feed them, wash their clothes etc just to make his life easier, maybe the boundaries have become a little blurred esp as he didn’t really care about the hair cut til you raised the issue. She still shouldn’t have done it though.

Monopolyiscrap · 07/02/2022 13:18

@Eleganz

Given the continuing debate does OP clear up whether her ex was happy for his mother to do this? Given he is not bother sounds like he was.

There has been a lot of hyperbole on this thread into what amounts to an slightly over enthusiastic trim that the parent who was looking after the child appeared to be okay with. It is annoying and probably suggests that communication between the parents needs to improve, but it is not abusive, it is not some kind of breach of anyone's rights and it is not some irreversible change.

I think a lot of people on her assume that primary carer means you have some ability to demand consultation and trump the other parent's decisions about their child while they are with them. Yes, there are certain circumstances where clear agreement between both parents is advised or required but a haircut isn't one of them. Beyond that it is a matter of agreement and compromise or you are going to spend a lot of your life pissed off.

I agree with this. I would be pleased it had saved me a job.
Nomoreusernames1244 · 07/02/2022 12:58

I'm always taken aback on threads like this when posters think an OP is being unreasonable - most mothers would be upset at their child coming back with 6 inches off their hair!

Why though? I wouldn’t, because it’s only hair. Why are mothers so invested in their daughters hair?

Eleganz · 07/02/2022 12:51

Given the continuing debate does OP clear up whether her ex was happy for his mother to do this? Given he is not bother sounds like he was.

There has been a lot of hyperbole on this thread into what amounts to an slightly over enthusiastic trim that the parent who was looking after the child appeared to be okay with. It is annoying and probably suggests that communication between the parents needs to improve, but it is not abusive, it is not some kind of breach of anyone's rights and it is not some irreversible change.

I think a lot of people on her assume that primary carer means you have some ability to demand consultation and trump the other parent's decisions about their child while they are with them. Yes, there are certain circumstances where clear agreement between both parents is advised or required but a haircut isn't one of them. Beyond that it is a matter of agreement and compromise or you are going to spend a lot of your life pissed off.

Frazzled2207 · 07/02/2022 12:23

I’d be fuming too and agree she’s overstepped but as pp have said any decisions while she’s in the care of her df are his responsibility

I would say as diplomatically as possible to her dp “seeing as I am her primary carer please do let me know if you are planning on getting your mum to cut her hair again so that we can discuss it first”.
I would also expect an apology from the MiL.

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2022 12:15

@SartresSoul

YANBU, this sounds like abusive behaviour. If it were just a small trim then fair enough but she’s totally changed the style against your DD’s wishes. Very wrong, I’d be fuming too.
Only on MN could a haircut be classified as abuse. So tone deaf and disrespectful to people experiencing actual abuse.
phoenixrosehere · 07/02/2022 10:06

It also really frustrates me when some MNers completely fail to read even the most basic information. The OP made it perfectly clear on several occasions that her ex didn’t instigate the haircut; his mother did. Yet still people trot out ‘Why shouldn’t her dad have a say in his daughter’s hair?!’ Is it really too difficult to just read?

For far too many it is despite the option to read all of OP posts. They might as well take it away considering the number of people who can’t be bothered to use it.

AliceS1994 · 07/02/2022 10:02

Your ex is an equal parent and so it wouldn't think it's necessarily critical that he has your permission to have her hair cut- you wouldn't expect to have to ask him first, right?

That being said, it is really rude and as a courtesy I would expect this to be run by your first!

Westfacing · 07/02/2022 09:38

Just because the ex as the father has the right to get the child's hair cut, it's surely not the right of his mother to take it upon herself - the father is unlikely to have instigated the cut.

I'm always taken aback on threads like this when posters think an OP is being unreasonable - most mothers would be upset at their child coming back with 6 inches off their hair!

There was a recent thread where the ex was still in bed at noon and the 8 year old was having to amuse herself while the lazy arse snoozed. Not a problem according to some posters!

cheninblanc · 07/02/2022 09:27

If it hadn't been cut in a year it most likely needed cutting and this is why she did it probably. I always have my sd hair cut, her mum would leave it but it's messy and dead at the ends so I book and pay for it. Mum objected once but didn't really have a argument given her hair hadn't been cut in six months and was a mess. It's hair, it needed cutting and now it's been done, maybe not to your taste but it'll grow. If your ex had agreed he's as much an equal right to say as you

SartresSoul · 07/02/2022 09:18

YANBU, this sounds like abusive behaviour. If it were just a small trim then fair enough but she’s totally changed the style against your DD’s wishes. Very wrong, I’d be fuming too.

WomanStanleyWoman · 07/02/2022 09:14

Whenever these threads come up (worryingly often) there’s a chorus of people saying, ‘It’s hair; hair grows’. Do any of you saying this really think the rest of us don’t understand how hair works? I’m sure the OP knows her daughter is a human child and not a Girl’s World doll.

The fact that hair grows back ISN’T RELEVANT. The issue is, this should have been a decision the child made, or at least discussed with her parents. She’s 8 - it’s not like she’s too little to have some idea of what she’d like her hair to look like.

It also really frustrates me when some MNers completely fail to read even the most basic information. The OP made it perfectly clear on several occasions that her ex didn’t instigate the haircut; his mother did. Yet still people trot out ‘Why shouldn’t her dad have a say in his daughter’s hair?!’ Is it really too difficult to just read?

Her ex mil is the chid's grandma?! Hardly a bloody stranger.

I don’t think anyone has suggested she was a random stranger who just came at the child brandishing scissors in the middle of Sainsbury’s. The point is, it still wasn’t her place.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 07/02/2022 08:08

It’s hair. All this “crowning glory” bullshit is weird IMO.

My kids have been taught to ask for what they want at a hairdresser. It doesn’t matter who takes them, we discuss what they want, and If they get too shy I insist at least they say yes verbally to the hairdresser.

What I find weird is that hair is such a big deal to parents, especially mums, that hairdressers will often override a childs wishes in favour of mum.

My dc wanted short hair at one point and we had a tough time persuading a hairdresser to cut it. If dh takes her they’re even more hesitant, because they worry about what I want.

It’s hair. If a child is sat in the hairdressers seat they should be checking with the child what they want.

phoenixrosehere · 07/02/2022 02:08

I think most kids at some point have an accidental chop - self inflicted, peer inflicted, super glue inflicted, interfering gran inflicted is new but you and daughter will be used to it in a few days and she'll know to say no thanks next time.

And? MIL planned this in advance without consulting either parent because she thought she knew better than the parents of a child that was not hers, that she knew better than her son and the mother of her granddaughter who is the one that does her hair. Also, who is to say this grandmother would have listened to her granddaughter if she had said no.

It’s more than about hair, it is the lack of respect, consent, and crossing of boundaries. MIL had her children and had her say there. That does not mean it continues on to her grandchildren.

Nanny0gg · 07/02/2022 02:02

@Singlemum90

Also ex was not asked by his mum either, told after the fact that it was arranged & didn't disagree, just didn't care either way
I bet she does your daughter s hair and couldn't be arsed with it being long.

How old is your DD? Can she say No in future?

contrary13 · 07/02/2022 01:45

"Could it be that exH gets MIL to brush dd hair and she complains about knots? I can imagine that might be a reason why she decided to go for it. I used to keep suggesting a hair cut to one of mine for years because of the hassle of brushing it."

My grandfather had my waist-length/never been cut hair shorn by his barber to a shaggy ear length effort at a girl's hair cut, when I was 6 and staying with my grandparents for the summer holidays from school (yep; all 6 weeks of them!) without my parents permission almost 40 years ago. When they turned up to collect me at the start of September, he presented my mother (his daughter) with a plastic bag that held the two bunches which had literally been cut off just above their bobbles.

And my mother went ballistic.

Years later, I asked him why he'd done it and he said that he literally couldn't stand idly by and watch me melt-down in absolute terror every time my grandmother or oldest brother (big age gap, he was 20-ish at the time and was raised by my grandparents from birth, pretty much) attempted to brush my hair - so he did something about it. What I never told any of them, but often wonder whether my grandfather knew anyway, was that my terror was because my mother took to beating me with the 1970s wooden hairbrush she used every time I squirmed or cried out when she encountered a pug (and she would yank the brush through regardless - it's a wonder I wasn't bloody bald because of her!), when I was little more than a baby (my hair has a natural wave to it and is very fine, so... pug/knot central!).

Okay, yes; it was a bad haircut, and I definitely looked like a boy - but to this day, I have never had hair past my shoulders since my grandfather stepped in and said "enough!" (My mother still used him for the free child care, though...)

Having said that, however, my ex-MIL had my then-toddler son's baby curls (first haircut) shorn into the "neater" short-back-and-sides which she preferred when he was under-3. His hair was never knotted, he never cried when it was brushed, and he left my house one day looking like a toddler - and returned looking like a miniature adult. I've never forgiven her for that, and he's 17 now - and insists on a Peaky Blinders style cut (his hair = his choice, I just pay for it). That really was a power-play on her part, and even her son admitted it was when I cried over it. Yes, it's "just hair" but she stole his first hair-cut from me and from her own son, too (we were together at the time). There've been other efforts at undermining me over the years, but she's reaping the consequences now, because my son refuses to see her unless he's forced into it by his Dad - and then he'll turn into a grumpy teen, so she doesn't get the benefit of his actual personality at all. Which is a shame, but... it's down to her. Not me.

So, I can see it from two out of the three sides. I just hope I will never be that MIL or grandmother who dares to think that they have the control over the child's hair, rather than the woman who actually carried, gave birth to and is raising them.

So yeah; power-play on the ex-MIL's part, OP, and I'm sorry but it'll ramp up the older your daughter gets (taking her to have her ears pierced, without checking with you - who'll have to do the aftercare - for example; my mother did that with my then 9-year-old daughter and it wasn't fun, because my daughter hadn't banked on it hurting and they could only do one correctly, with the other at a definite angle!). Unless you lay out some ground rules about both parents having to be consulted regarding changes to the children's appearances, of course, and you make it clear that she had her time to be a mother; now that's your job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread