Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be a bit annoyed with my brother?

62 replies

SkiBumOne · 06/02/2022 17:51

My dad and my daughter have birthdays within 2 days of one another and we always meet for lunch as a family. It’s the first time we all get together after Christmas (we live a long way apart from one another). I hadn’t spoken to my parents but assumed we’d be meeting either weekend of the birthdays or the following one so kept both free.

My daughter will do something with her friends but she’s 17 and she won’t care if it’s the weekend of her birthday or the one after. Because of ill health, my parents can’t travel far which means we will go to them which is a 5-6 hour round trip. We can do it in a day but it’s not much fun spending hours on the M25 and so I’d like to keep the family lunch and the thing with DD’s mates on separate weekends.

My mum has just been in touch to suggest we meet 2 weeks after their birthday weekend but I can’t make that as I have plans. So then it’s the week after that which will be 3 weeks after their birthday and into the Easter holidays.

It turns out we meet on the weekends closest to the birthdays because my little brother has decided to go skiing that week.

AIBU to suggest we should just meet the weekend after their birthdays like we have done for the last 17 years without him? It’s not like my dad’s birthday is a moving feast. Hmm

In case you hadn’t guessed, my brother is the golden child.

OP posts:
Sedai · 06/02/2022 19:34

I don't get why its OK for you not to do a weekend because you have plans, but its not OK for your brother to go skiing? It sounds like your parents want all the family together and that sounds lovely. I get your daughter is maybe a bit miffed its her birthday, but you did say in your OP she's not fussed if she does something before or after it did you not?

AlDanvers · 06/02/2022 19:30

Isn't it normal to celebrate a birthday on or near the actual day?

Of course it is. Its also normal to move a bit further away, to accommodate other people too.

GiltEdges · 06/02/2022 19:28

Sounds like a bit of a rigid schedule to me, year in year out. Evidently too rigid for your brother, who (probably deliberately) opted himself out by booking his holiday at the same time this year.

Why not plan to do something special for your DD at home this year and see your parents separately on the date that they’ve proposed? Just because their birthdays are a day apart doesn’t mean your DD and your Ddad need to share a birthday celebration every year.

saraclara · 06/02/2022 19:26

You do something else for your DD's birthday. Surely meeting up with her GPs isn't the only kind of celebration she will accept? You've already said that she doesn't care if her uncle's there, so surely the family thing isn't a big deal for her?

Kite22 · 06/02/2022 19:16

Isn't it normal to celebrate a birthday on or near the actual day?

Well, not for everyone, no.
In my family we have people who have birthdys at times when it is difficult to get people together, so we sort out a weekend when we can see each other.

As that is the point of this meal.
Your dd is celebrating her birthday at the time - you said she is doing so with friends, as is normal at that sort of age. This is traveling 2.5 hours each way to meet up with Grandparents, and Uncle, so it seems to make sense to do it when all the people can get there..

W ed o it on the weekend of their birthday or the weekend after every single year.

But you are still expecting everyone to keep 4 days 'free' rather than just settling on one day.

AlexaShutUp · 06/02/2022 19:11

In the nicest possible way, you need to tell your dd to get over herself a bit. She is 17 and old enough to understand now that not everything revolves around her.

A birthday is just a date. It doesn't matter when you celebrate it, surely the important part is getting everyone together. And as you can't do that on the weekends that you had originally had in mind (but not communicated to anyone else about), then just do it a couple of weekends later.

What's the big deal?

billy1966 · 06/02/2022 19:09

Tell your mother the dates that suit you, as per normal and if she insists its one that doesn't suit you just leave it go for this year.

Your brother isn't pushed to be there so stick to the usual plan or don't bother at all.

mrsm43s · 06/02/2022 19:06

Nope, my daughter is not happy with the rearranged date. And it's her birthday

Well plan something else (in addition to the other party she has planned with her friends) for her on that weekend then, if she must celebrate on that day.

If she really values a specific day (despite you saying in your OP that she didn't mind what day) over having her uncle there, and making her grandparents happy, then something has gone with her upbringing. Let's be honest, with a 17 year old the family get together is hardly the "main event" for her birthday is it!

GiantSpider · 06/02/2022 19:06

YANBU to suggest meeting on the original date without him.

But I think YABU to expect him to have kept the weekends free if a date hadn't been fixed. If I was your brother and I looked in my diary and it was clear I'd happily arrange to go skiing and assume that a family birthday celebration would already have been mentioned.

Marmm · 06/02/2022 19:06

It's my mum who is insisting we wait until we get back. I don't think we should. I think we should celebrate their birthdays on their birthdays and my brother can go and see them another time (my DD couldn't give a toss if her uncle were there or not). I absolutely agree with you. Or celebrate DDs then and dad can celebrate another time if he really must.

DollyPartBaked · 06/02/2022 19:03

YABU - bizarre that you expect other adult family members to keep weekends 'free' for their niece's/parents birthday.

Nobody has an issue with but you.

DockOTheBay · 06/02/2022 19:03

Do both? Celebrate with them on their actual birthdays without your brother, and then have another joint celebration a few weeks later with him there.

SkiBumOne · 06/02/2022 19:01

@Kite22

It does sound as if the birthdays are the hook to hang a "whole family get together" on, which, as dc grow up does start to get more difficult.

If you were 'keeping 2 weekends free' , then it probably would have been wise, in hindsight to have had that conversation in the family whatsapp - "DF and dd's birthdays being mid week, which day are we doing the lunch this year?" would have put it on everyone's calendar and then up to DB if the particular holiday he was looking at was worth moving to another date, or if he felt you could all cope without him this year.

We do it on the weekend of their birthday or the weekend after every single year. And have done for years. Probably even before my daughter was born.

Isn't it normal to celebrate a birthday on or near the actual day? Confused

OP posts:
SkiBumOne · 06/02/2022 19:00

@mrsm43s

YABU.

Your brother is entitled to go on holiday whenever he likes.

Your dad is entitled to want to have a celebration with both of his children there.

You are not entitled to dictate what everyone can do and when. Everyone is happy with the rearranged date apart from you. Why do your wishes trump everyone else's? It's not your birthday!

You've basically got the hump because you're not getting your own way! Cancel your plans on the 2nd week after birthdays if the currently suggested one isn't acceptable to you.

Nope, my daughter is not happy with the rearranged date. And it's her birthday
OP posts:
Kite22 · 06/02/2022 18:59

It does sound as if the birthdays are the hook to hang a "whole family get together" on, which, as dc grow up does start to get more difficult.

If you were 'keeping 2 weekends free' , then it probably would have been wise, in hindsight to have had that conversation in the family whatsapp - "DF and dd's birthdays being mid week, which day are we doing the lunch this year?" would have put it on everyone's calendar and then up to DB if the particular holiday he was looking at was worth moving to another date, or if he felt you could all cope without him this year.

mrsm43s · 06/02/2022 18:58

YABU.

Your brother is entitled to go on holiday whenever he likes.

Your dad is entitled to want to have a celebration with both of his children there.

You are not entitled to dictate what everyone can do and when. Everyone is happy with the rearranged date apart from you. Why do your wishes trump everyone else's? It's not your birthday!

You've basically got the hump because you're not getting your own way! Cancel your plans on the 2nd week after birthdays if the currently suggested one isn't acceptable to you.

SkiBumOne · 06/02/2022 18:57

Seems very weird to celebrate a birthday when it's nowhere near the birthday date. And no my daughter won't mind if it's on the day and is bemused and a bit hurt that her family birthday celebrations are being organised around her uncle's holiday.

But there we are. I expect nothing less from AIBU than a good kicking Grin

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 06/02/2022 18:51

There are 2 birthday people - your dad and your daughter.

Your daughter doesn’t care when you celebrate her birthday with family, or who is there.

Your dad doesn’t care when you celebrate his birthday, but wants your brother there.

Therefore you do it in the Easter holidays.

When you want to do it is irrelevant, surely? As you’re not the birthday person.

Chilesstanton · 06/02/2022 18:35

Why is it okay for you to have plans but not him

Macaroni46 · 06/02/2022 18:28

I think YABU. It obviously matters to your DP to get the family all together and whereas in previous years, your DD and dad's birthdays have provided the excuse for this, this year the dates don't work. So just have the get together when your DM suggests. Sounds like a lot of fuss about nothing!

WonderfulYou · 06/02/2022 18:24

YABU it’s your dads birthday and I assume he wants his son there just as much as his daughter.

As the birthday meal is flexible then your brother probably didn’t think it would be a big deal booking a holiday near then especially if he found a good deal.

AlDanvers · 06/02/2022 18:20

He hasn't chosen anything over anyone's birthdays.

You are making this way bigger than it needs to be. That weekend is out because your mum and dad, want it to be when he is there. So arrange it another.

SkiBumOne · 06/02/2022 18:09

@namechangerqwerty

I can't see why your brother shouldn't be able to plan a holiday for when it suits him. Are they milestone birthdays? If not then it seems a bit much to expect everyone to hold all plans (without a prior request to keep the date free). Just go ahead without him this year if that's what works for the majority.
I absolutely think we should! He's chosen to go away over his family's birthdays which is fine with me - it's entirely his prerogative.

It's my mum who is insisting we wait until we get back. I don't think we should. I think we should celebrate their birthdays on their birthdays and my brother can go and see them another time (my DD couldn't give a toss if her uncle were there or not).

OP posts:
Awrite · 06/02/2022 18:08

I don't think someone should refrain from booking a holiday for a birthday lunch.

Did your brother choose to be the golden child?

Marmm · 06/02/2022 18:07

Maybe your brother is fed up with it and deliberately booked that weekend hoping to get out of it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread