Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To opt out of NHS pension to make childcare more affordable?

239 replies

pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 16:22

Am I going to regret this?? I've temporarily opted out of my NHS pension contributions to make our childcare expenses more affordable. It will probably be for around 18 months or so I think, hopefully less. Has anyone done this? Is it a bad financial decision? Confused

OP posts:
pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 21:10

To be honest I've got a bit lost now 🙈
Defined benefit etc... it means nothing to me. I really don't know anything about pensions! Perhaps I should learn. I feel a bit naive and stupid now.

OP posts:
Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:07

@Polkadotties
What point are you trying to make to the Op? It sounds like you are minimising the impact of opting out - which wouldn’t make any sense. If that isn’t what you are trying to say - what are you trying to say?

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:06

But it doesn’t matter if it’s a defined benefit pension or not. What matters is that the op will lose out significantly if she opts out even for a year or two.

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 21:05

[quote Abigail12345654321]@Polkadotties

The accrual rate depends on the years paid in. If you opt out for a few years, you get reduced benefits. Obviously.[/quote]
Everyone has the same accrual rate.

pleasehoover · 06/02/2022 21:04

@PigletJohn

No, you have to make the contributions to earn the year of service. So if you contribute for 15 years you get 15 years worth of benefits, even if you worked there for 20 years.

What @Polkadotties is saying is that the benefit you receive does not depend on how much was actually contributed, it is based on the formula for years of service and salary.

Unlike a defined contribution scheme where the contributions are invested for you and the amount you get at retirement depends on how much the investment has grown to.

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 21:04

[quote PigletJohn]@Polkadotties

I find it hard to believe what you say.

Surely you are not suggesting that

Person A works for 20 years and contributes for 15

Gets the same pension as

Person B works for 20 years and contributes for 20[/quote]
No because person A hasn’t been an active member of the scheme for the same amount of time so they would get a smaller pension.
If we assume they both earn the same salary.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 21:03

CAB has decent guide re unmarried v married differences.
If only you opt of pension and you later split there’s no pension sharing like you get in a divorce if you are unmarried.

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:02

@Polkadotties

The accrual rate depends on the years paid in. If you opt out for a few years, you get reduced benefits. Obviously.

pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 21:02

@AnneElliott

I agree with everyone else op - don't do this unless there is literally no other option. I agree a loan for the childcare would be a better option.

What scheme is your DP in? And being unmarried you are taking a risk.

He's in the civil service pension scheme.

OP posts:
pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 20:58

@millytint44

I put my mortgage on payment holiday rather than cease pension contributions when I had nursery fees after maternity leave. Is this an option for you?

No because we are renting, no mortgage.

OP posts:
PigletJohn · 06/02/2022 20:56

@Polkadotties

I find it hard to believe what you say.

Surely you are not suggesting that

Person A works for 20 years and contributes for 15

Gets the same pension as

Person B works for 20 years and contributes for 20

FFSFFSFFS · 06/02/2022 20:54

MASSIVE MISTAKE

millytint44 · 06/02/2022 20:53

I put my mortgage on payment holiday rather than cease pension contributions when I had nursery fees after maternity leave. Is this an option for you?

DerAlteMann · 06/02/2022 20:52

Get back into it ASAP. The NHS pension is probably the best available. When your finances are better give very serious thought to paying additional voluntary contributions to "buy-back" the period of pensionable service you opted-out of. I say this as someone who ran occupational pension schemes.

AnneElliott · 06/02/2022 20:52

I agree with everyone else op - don't do this unless there is literally no other option. I agree a loan for the childcare would be a better option.

What scheme is your DP in? And being unmarried you are taking a risk.

Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 20:48

HNRTT but in line with the above post, what other benefits will you potentially risk, OP, beyond the years lost which might not be the most material depending on your ultimate length of service. Ill-health, death in service and so on?

Crimesean · 06/02/2022 20:43

Please, please don't do this. It would be utterly foolhardy. If, as you say, you're likely to get promoted withim a few years you should hang in there and wait it out.

You are very unlikely to get anywhere close to an average salary pension elsewhere. Don't squander it now, you will get used to the extra income and never feel like you can afford to opt back in. And your DP will be grand, as since you're not married you'll have no claim on his pension and no more than 50% of the house, even if you pay lots more in.

Hillarious · 06/02/2022 20:42

Don't even think about pension contributions as being accessible funds. Look elsewhere to make savings for 18 months, rather than stopping the pension contributions.

Dishwashersaurous · 06/02/2022 20:41

Honestly with a DB pension the employer contributions are so high its always worth it.

It's just better to think of the pension contributions as not yours, but rather like tax etc. Your income is yours after pension contributions.

loislovesstewie · 06/02/2022 20:38

But you have to actually pay into the scheme to get the pension, don't you? So if you opt out for a few years then, logically, you will have fewer years of service. So, if it's like local government schemes, instead of being 40 years you might have 32 which makes quite a difference.

LoudSnoringDog · 06/02/2022 20:35

I asked a financial advisor about coming out of the nhs pension when I was pregnant with Dd. I intended to explore just coming out for 3 years.

He asked me if I was insane and advised me to try and cut my cloth elsewhere but not my pension. Just three years out would be a huge impact on my pension allowance. Glad I listened to him. Will never forget the incredulous look on his face.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 20:35

Defined benefit is based on service and final pensionable pay. Not contributions paid.

Yes, I know what defined benefit means.

The point is that in order to get that benefit, both the employee and the employer pay into the scheme.

The employer contributions are part of your overall salary and benefits package. But if you don't pay the employee contributions, you don't get them. You can't take those contributions as extra salary instead. It's use it or lose it.

So by not contributing to the pension scheme, the OP loses the employer contributions which are part of her salary and benefits package.

kitcat15 · 06/02/2022 20:32

@wonderwomen1

I'm going to go against what everyone else says and say do what ever you can to make living more comfortable now.

I'm nhs and I remember the childcare costs so I opted out of pension and started again once they started school. I'll still have over 30 years paying in when I retire.

Might sound depressing but you never know what's around the corner, why struggle now

She will struggle big time if she has a serious illness and needs to take ill health pension....but I guess some people are just risk takers
Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 20:32
  • pressed post to soon

The only schemes which are contribution dependent are defined contribution schemes and schemes like SIPPS

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 20:30

@babyjellyfish

The NHS pension scheme is not a defined contrition scheme. The benefits are accrued based on the member’s pensionable pay and the accrual rate. The contributions paid in are irrelevant.

I used to be in the civil service so I was a member of a defined benefit scheme. There were definitely both employee and employer contributions, and I'd have lost the employer contributions if I'd stopped my own.

Defined benefit is based on service and final pensionable pay. Not contributions paid.
Swipe left for the next trending thread