Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To opt out of NHS pension to make childcare more affordable?

239 replies

pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 16:22

Am I going to regret this?? I've temporarily opted out of my NHS pension contributions to make our childcare expenses more affordable. It will probably be for around 18 months or so I think, hopefully less. Has anyone done this? Is it a bad financial decision? Confused

OP posts:
pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 21:36

Wow what a can of worms this is! I didn't realise the complexity and significance of opting out to be honest. I'm almost 37, for those wondering my age. I'm expecting to be promoted to band 8c by age 45-47 ish, all being well with the direction and rare that my career is expected to progress.

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 21:35

It looks like MP's pension still has a 1/40th accrual rate unless they choose a 1/50th or 1/60th to reduce their contributions. All in it together.

saleorbouy · 06/02/2022 21:34

It's a very bad decision, the pension is the most tax efficient way of saving and Compound Interest is your friend, the longer its saved/invested the better the return. Make every other financial cut before this.

Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 21:29

@Abigail12345654321 could be wrong but the 40ths is the accrual rate for the 2015 nurses scheme, I think it's 54ths. You are correct in principle though. 40ths was the rather for the Civil Service scheme though don't know what there's is for the newer career-average schemes, post-austerity.

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 21:29

[quote Abigail12345654321]@Polkadotties

But the years you pay in do including an employee and employer element - neither are paid if you opt out. So if you think of it only in terms of what you save each month you don’t pay in that is misleading as it would make you think you are ‘only’ missing out on 18 months of employee contributions. When in fact you are missing out on 1.5/40th’s of your entire pension.[/quote]
Yes I know that. I have never told OP to look at what she pays in contributions.
I work for a public sector pension scheme. I am fully aware of how CARE, final salary, accrual rates, contributions etc work

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:29

You are right Zilla1 she would lose death in service benefit too

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:27

3/80ths would have made more sense there!

Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 21:27

@babyjellyfish I could be wrong but I think it's worse than that, depending on which scheme they are in. The employer doesn't contribute so the OP accrues a part of a year if the OP opts out in some schemes. In effect, if they opt out then they lose that year's accrual - 1/54th in the 2015 career average scheme. Possibly not if the OP is younger but if they opt out for five years then they might lose the final salary-ness of the previous schemes they might have been in, depending on when they joined.

If they opt out then I think they might lose the death in service and ill-health elements too.

Could be wrong though. Haven't looked at the nurses schemes for a while since the PNs asked a similar question.

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:26

And for this discussion Op doesn’t need to worry about the ins and outs of how the pension works. She just needs to know she would have to be insane or quite literally starving to making opting out make sense!

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:25

@Polkadotties

But the years you pay in do including an employee and employer element - neither are paid if you opt out. So if you think of it only in terms of what you save each month you don’t pay in that is misleading as it would make you think you are ‘only’ missing out on 18 months of employee contributions. When in fact you are missing out on 1.5/40th’s of your entire pension.

Worriedatwork1 · 06/02/2022 21:22

I did this OP, not ideal but it was better than getting more in debt to afford £1500 a month childcare. If it’s the way to keep your head above water just go back in ASAP

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 21:22

@babyjellyfish

I have tried to explain that the NHS is defined benefit scheme, what she pays in does not determine what she gets out.

That's not the point I was making though.

She is still losing employer contributions, because to get your £X amount of pension per year of pensionable service, the scheme invests both the employee contributions and the employer contributions. The employer contributions are part of the OP's benefits package. The OP (along with most people in the public sector) gets paid a lower salary than she would get in an equivalent job in the private sector with less generous employer contributions. So by not contributing to her pension and losing the employer contributions, she's effectively losing part of her salary.

There were people on this thread who were saying that by OP opting out she was losing the ‘free pension’ which comes from an employers contribution which is not true. Yes the employers contributions can make up part of the package, for example if you were to transfer to private sector you should look at what your employer would pay in contributions
Ozanj · 06/02/2022 21:21

I wouldn’t opt out of a pension unless I was starving each month. As you’re not keep going

SwedishEdith · 06/02/2022 21:20

@pensionoptout

To be honest I've got a bit lost now 🙈 Defined benefit etc... it means nothing to me. I really don't know anything about pensions! Perhaps I should learn. I feel a bit naive and stupid now.
A defined benefit pension is calculated based of a formula of years in the scheme and final salary/amount accrued per year. You can work it yourself and know what you should get. Pensions are benefits.

A defined contribution pension is you know what you need to contribute/pay in each month. But what you get at the end of it, when you claim your pension, isn't known for sure. You're relying on the investment to make you enough money.

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:19

Honestly Op- see if you can find any alternative to opting out from either of your pensions. Even if it means a painful 18 months or so. Could you extend the term of your existing debts to reduce the burden?

TheKeatingFive · 06/02/2022 21:18

That would be a really, really, really stupid move OP.

babyjellyfish · 06/02/2022 21:18

I have tried to explain that the NHS is defined benefit scheme, what she pays in does not determine what she gets out.

That's not the point I was making though.

She is still losing employer contributions, because to get your £X amount of pension per year of pensionable service, the scheme invests both the employee contributions and the employer contributions. The employer contributions are part of the OP's benefits package. The OP (along with most people in the public sector) gets paid a lower salary than she would get in an equivalent job in the private sector with less generous employer contributions. So by not contributing to her pension and losing the employer contributions, she's effectively losing part of her salary.

Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 21:17

Simplistically, OP, what will you do if you get disabled or die while working and opted out? Do you pay for sufficient additional life assurance and permanent health insurance (I suspect not but am trying to make the point) to enable your DC and DP to survive without your income?

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 21:17

@pensionoptout

To be honest I've got a bit lost now 🙈 Defined benefit etc... it means nothing to me. I really don't know anything about pensions! Perhaps I should learn. I feel a bit naive and stupid now.
Defined benefit means the benefits are defined I.e you can work out what you will get at retirement. Unlike SIPPS which are based on stock markets which can fluctuate and you cannot be certain what you will have in your ‘pot’ at retirement
pensionoptout · 06/02/2022 21:17

@timeisnotaline

We are paying extra into my pension this year, because I have had non paying periods during may leave (different country so different system). Theres actually more in my pension than in dhs and we are married so it’s irrelevant whose gets the extra but it’s the principle of the thing. We agree that having our baby shouldn’t be my financial cost. Your dp can only do that overtime because you’re looking after baby. So if you do stick with this plan I would do the 9 months each if you are allowed to opt in and out with that timing.

I’m concerned you’re trying to drop a day of work to save childcare costs and haven’t worked out if you’ll be better or worse off! Obviously if you are worse off doing that don’t do that, and it will be too late once it’s done to realise!!

So we've just looked over wage slips at the differences in our pension contributions. Mine is 3 x DP's. He doesn't make any higher contributions with overtime, it's the same amount each month. That means we wouldn't be able to claw back as much per month if he opted out instead of me.

I feel a bit lost with it all now tbh. Maybe just need to sleep on it and re read all of the very helpful advice on this thread with a clear head tomorrow.

OP posts:
Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:16

@pensionoptout

To be honest I've got a bit lost now 🙈 Defined benefit etc... it means nothing to me. I really don't know anything about pensions! Perhaps I should learn. I feel a bit naive and stupid now.
It just means that with some pensions if you pay in £100 a month and your employer pays £100 a month, then £200 a month is invested and you get out whatever that investment makes. So what you get depends on the investment market and how much your pension portfolio makes.

However with nhs pension it doesn’t work like that. You pay in and regardless of how investments go, you get a specific amount based on how many years you paid in and your salary band. The scheme before 2008 was different to the current scheme but both are pretty good.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/02/2022 21:15

Op check he’s nominated you as beneficiary under his scheme as you don’t appear to have ever nominated him.
As you are unmarried you won’t get lump sum and £350 a week bereavement support payment (widows allowance) if one of you dies.

Abigail12345654321 · 06/02/2022 21:13

[quote Polkadotties]@Abigail12345654321 I am most definitely not minimising! I was one of the first on this thread to point out the loss of death in service benefits!
I have tried to explain that the NHS is defined benefit scheme, what she pays in does not determine what she gets out.[/quote]
Ah good - was confused about what you were trying to say! Yes appreciate the scheme is about duration and final salary rather than actual £ paid in but for her purposes it’s the same difference - she shouldn’t opt out!

timeisnotaline · 06/02/2022 21:11

We are paying extra into my pension this year, because I have had non paying periods during may leave (different country so different system). Theres actually more in my pension than in dhs and we are married so it’s irrelevant whose gets the extra but it’s the principle of the thing. We agree that having our baby shouldn’t be my financial cost. Your dp can only do that overtime because you’re looking after baby. So if you do stick with this plan I would do the 9 months each if you are allowed to opt in and out with that timing.

I’m concerned you’re trying to drop a day of work to save childcare costs and haven’t worked out if you’ll be better or worse off! Obviously if you are worse off doing that don’t do that, and it will be too late once it’s done to realise!!

Polkadotties · 06/02/2022 21:11

@Abigail12345654321 I am most definitely not minimising! I was one of the first on this thread to point out the loss of death in service benefits!
I have tried to explain that the NHS is defined benefit scheme, what she pays in does not determine what she gets out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread