Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/02/2022 23:06

@OldTinHat

I've already had to choose. I've not had the heating on at all this winter and layer up with masses of clothes. I can't afford the eating part either so rely on the food bank and local church.

It's worse because I'm disabled and stuck at home, can't move about much to keep warm and my asthma is now awful because the house is damp.

I'm so sorry to hear of your struggles.
Piggyk2 · 06/02/2022 23:05

@OldTinHat can you apply for PIP?

MaryLennoxsScowl · 06/02/2022 23:05

My plan is to install a wood burning stove by next winter. I grew up in a series of houses with no heating and a mix of open fires and stoves, and despite mumsnet’s conviction that half an hour next to a woodburner will kill you, they’ve never done us any harm, and I can gather wood for free and dry it in the garden.

OldTinHat · 06/02/2022 23:00

I've already had to choose. I've not had the heating on at all this winter and layer up with masses of clothes. I can't afford the eating part either so rely on the food bank and local church.

It's worse because I'm disabled and stuck at home, can't move about much to keep warm and my asthma is now awful because the house is damp.

BlackeyedSusan · 06/02/2022 22:58

@mrsm43s

Surely it's not either or? And no one would choose NO heating and plenty of food or NO food and heating normally. Surely absolutely everyone would try to cut costs across BOTH heating and eating so that you neither froze nor starved?

So thermostat down a couple of degrees and on for less time each day, extra layers and blankets. (and also reduce other energy usage - wash clothes/bedding less often, air dry don't tumble, use recipes that don't need long oven cooking, reduce use of phones/computers/tvs etc.)
Food shopping pared back to cheapest options, whatever's in the reduced aisle etc (even if they're not your preference) in order to ensure that the was sufficient heat and food to get by.

I think people will have to return to seventies habits. Not bathing/showering daily but having a wash instead. Washing bedding and towels less often. Wearing clothes more than once. Mumsnet magic chicken... Learn to make cheap nutritious meals eating more in season. Using the car less frequently. Make do and mend. Not replace stuff as often. The average person lives a very luxurious life now compared to how we lived growing up. Yes you need some things you didn't used to...tech being one for school and benefit applications etc.

I worry about those who are already doing this and have got nothing left to cut back.

etulosba · 06/02/2022 22:56

Eating. There no point in starving yourself to death in a warm house.

Plus I’m old and was brought up in a house where the only heated room was the sitting room. Obviously not ideal, but not the end of the world.

UndertheCedartree · 06/02/2022 22:49

@HelloFrostyMorning

I don't understand this choose between eating and heating thing. You can do both. Just cut down on both. Buy cheaper food - Aldi/Iceland/Lidl etc, and wrap up in fleeces and blankets instead of firing up the heating every 5 minutes, and just have it on when it's VERY cold, or one or two hours a day to take the chill off the house, when it drops below 3 or 4 C outside.

The woman opposite me has her thermostat 22-23 C most of the Autumn and Winter then complains she can barely afford the gas bill. NO-ONE needs it that high FGS. We have ours no higher than 17-18 C - most of the time. As high as 20, maybe 15 days of the year.

And I know what I'm talking about (regarding heating and eating and not having to sacrifice one or the other,) because me and DH have been on the bones of our arse in the past, and have not had a pot to piss in barely, and we have never gone without food, or sat frozen in our house. We just cut down on everything.

If you're already using Lidl/Aldi and the food bank for food you probably can't cut back anymore. So heating has to go.
BlackeyedSusan · 06/02/2022 22:46

Also remember frost on the inside of the windows. You could make it snow indoors by gently pulling the net curtain off the frost. Whoa betide you though if you tugged too hard and ripped the nets as they were too frozen to the window.

Just had a coal fire downstairs. No central heating at all.

BlackeyedSusan · 06/02/2022 22:40

Eat. We hardly have the heating on as it is. Just when we have a bath. Live in a flat that is reasonably well insulated west facing so warm when sunny. Coldest when windy. Ds keeps complaining of being cold. Yeah well that's what happens when you wear shorts and a t shirt in the middle of bloody winter child. (Teen )

I wear loads of layers. Thermal base layers (1 Merino from Aldi, one synthetic) and a couple of woolly jumpers/cardis from the charity shop and three pairs of woolly socks. I ask for woolly socks and thermals for Christmas. I have woolly blankets from the charity shop too. And a duvet on the sofa.

Kennykenkencat · 06/02/2022 22:31

[quote Chichimcgee]@Kennykenkencat

My granny used to say don’t let the cold get into your bones because it never leaves. Some people have never felt that and can’t understand what it means but it’s physically painful and impossible to warm up when you’re that cold.[/quote]
Funnily enough I can only remember one time that I can honestly say that by bones felt warm for the first time ever.

It was 112 degrees in the shade.

Even when it is hot my inner core doesn’t get the same warmth.

I am slowly seizing up. The only thing that got me through the winter was a holiday every other year in a hot country and another holiday to dry me out during the year.

Really thinking about jacking it all in and going to live in a hot country. One where I can walk without pain.

UndertheCedartree · 06/02/2022 22:25

@Changethetoner

Unfortunately some of us are already living like this. Not putting heating on all day until 4pm for when DC get home from school. Using blankets to wrap selves in all year round in the living room. Wearing socks, slippers, thermals, several jumpers, and sometimes a woolly hat (indoors). Going to bed early to keep warm in evening. Even rationing the hot water bottles, due to the electricity costs of boiling kettles.

So what are families like ours supposed to do? We are already doing as much as we can. At least it's normal for us, my DC are used to it.

I would suggest a little electric heater or heated throw that are cheap to run so you don't need to put the heating on atall.
UndertheCedartree · 06/02/2022 22:23

@Nohypocrate

Eating but not wasting money on crap food. I was in Aldi earlier and a couple had a trolley laden with crisps, sweets, cake and chocolate. The total bill was £80ish but I'd say £30 was crap. If they stopped that it's an extra £120 a month. People have got to change their ways I guess.
I sometimes get maybe £30 of crap/treats for DC. But I don't get it every week. That would be to last a couple of months.
leavingtime · 06/02/2022 22:18

My income is very low. I don't have central heating but do have a multifuel stove [only burn kiln dried wood].

In the winter I layer up with wool jumpers, put a wool blanket on top of a winter duvet. I never have and don't need heating in the bedroom. I rarely have any heating on in the daytime. If it's really cold/rainy and damp I'll put on an oil-free radiator in the room I'm in. I only light the stove at 6pm [til 10.30pm]. I've a heated throw for sitting on the sofa/watching tv or I'll hug a hot water bottle.

I'm fine with it, I'm so used to it which helps. My place is well insulated though and when the sky is clear after a frosty night the sunshine comes into the back of the house all day and warms it a lot.

Food has to be priority though for everyone. Soups [I add all sorts of chopped up veg to mine] and one pot casseroles, baked potatoes with fillings, cottage pie bulked up with veg, curries adding lentils, anything on toast, pasta dishes...all economical.

purpletrees16 · 06/02/2022 22:09

My parents made similar choices (due to slightly different push factors - unemployment, inflation, mortgage rates) when I was little in late 80s early 90s - with a coal fire and no heating. And I have fond memories :)

Still lentils. Not the worlds biggest fan… but they were a large part of the solution. 20% protein. Used to get them by the sack from a local shop. So many lentil based meals. Though meat used to be way more expensive relatively.

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?
Chichimcgee · 06/02/2022 22:09

@Kennykenkencat

My granny used to say don’t let the cold get into your bones because it never leaves. Some people have never felt that and can’t understand what it means but it’s physically painful and impossible to warm up when you’re that cold.

EveningOverRooftops · 06/02/2022 22:08

@daisypond most supermarkets price check against Aldi or lidl and their own brands are comparable in price so if it was a choice between a saver slot at sainsburys for £1 when my shopping basket this evening for 2 weeks of staples is £49.30 or go to lidl tomorrow, spend 30 minutes walking there, 30 around the shop, then book a taxi for £6 to bring the lot home with the taxi jacking it up to being more expensive only by £1 I’d choose the home delivery and make use of the extra hour of time.

Being poor it’s not just about money. Being poor takes a lot of time too.

I’m a step or two away from being as poor as I was but I can remember spending hours every day walking to and from school to drop DC off, walking an hour and a half to get the food shopping done. Another 45 minute round trip walk to go to our local pound style shop for the stuff that was cheaper there than the supermarket (bar soap for example) the time spend repairing and making do because you couldn’t afford to replace when it really should’ve been replaced.

Money and time. The poorest never have enough of either.

Kennykenkencat · 06/02/2022 22:07

@bitemyarsenic

Where has anyone been gleeful? No one is suggesting a return to the middle ages. There was heating but we dressed warmly and blocked draughts/ reduced waste. Your Dad was in charge of coal and no one would consider lighting the fire until it was really needed. As a nation we are extremely wasteful Fuel, energy, food, clothing. You name it we chuck it away!

Thats what I was referring to.
The idea if people cant afford heating they will just freeze.
Jesus hopefully common sense and dressing warmly might make a come back !

I am presuming you weren’t in a slum single skinned council house which the pointing kept falling out from between the bricks and you could see outside so you stuffed it with torn up newspaper and flour and water paste We had one fire but sometimes no coal. We would burn broken furniture we found or anything that was to hand. Outside toilet and a tin bath hung on the wall it was really grim

My childhood memories are of being cold.
This house reminds me of that house. Including ice on the inside of the windows.
No amount of layers of clothing is going to prevent ice forming on the windows or keeping your face warm.

The only way I work now is to go out in my van till the heating comes through and then sit and do paperwork parked up outside the house
My house just doesn’t get warm.

Chichimcgee · 06/02/2022 22:05

@daisypond

Either I spent £50 on bus fair to get 8 bags of shopping from Lidl a week. I also spend 8 hours of my week travelling.

OR

I spend £1 on delivery and get as much food as I can, let’s say 8 bags from Asda.

I save £49 on travel. Asda price match Aldi and can be super cheap so say at a top estimate my Asda shop is £20 more than if I’d gone Lidl.

I’m still saving £29 plus 8 hours of my time.

Do you get it?

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 06/02/2022 22:05

Eating. And I hope that one day such decisions are not a reality for so many people....

Blondeshavemorefun · 06/02/2022 22:04

I can totally get why someone would use delivery if couldn’t drive and hard to get to shop whether by bus, and bus fare cost may be more the delivery

Plus even if did get a bus unlikely to take you right past the shop you want

Chichimcgee · 06/02/2022 22:01

Such a first world problem.

Starving and freezing to death, such first world problems.

UndertheCedartree · 06/02/2022 22:01

I have chosen eating over heating. I generally never put the heating on but do sometimes to get the washing dry. I am very lucky to have a heated throw that I use at night as I have an underactive thyroid and get very cold. Also lucky to have an electric heater that we use downstairs if needed. We all have a blanket we can use when sitting on the sofa. The DC have hot water bottles and heated cuddlies for bed.

I think it is better to provide them with adequate food especially as my eldest is a teen and forever hungry. I have started to use the food bank sometimes but aside from that shop mainly at Lidl with a Sainsbury's shop now and again to get things I can't get at Lidl. I always make sure my DC have a good breakfast and dinner. I sometimes just make dinner for them and eat my DD's leftovers. She is really fussy so if I've made something veg heavy I'll eat all the vegetables she's left!

JustSinginIntheRain · 06/02/2022 22:00

AutomaticMoon. The prices will stabilise but I doubt anyone will get refunds.

Inspectorslack · 06/02/2022 21:59

What can’t you understand? I was shit poor and I ordered food off the internet because it was cheaper than to go and get it.

I was living in a small house.

And I picked Asda because it was the cheapest of the delivery supermarkets.

Not everyone has access to aldi or Lidl within walking distance.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 21:58

@Angrymum22

Such a first world problem. As a child growing up in the 60s and 70s central heating was a luxury. And with no double glazing we often woke up to frosted bedroom windows. We just wore more clothing. Walked everywhere and were a lot thinner as children as a result. You never went anywhere without a vest and gloves were attached to your coat by a length of elastic. The hot water was only on for a short time and just a gas fire in the living room. We only have the heating on downstairs in our house by choice and often sleep with it off totally. We do have a modern house which is well insulated but if anything be is cold they are advised to wear more clothes.
Tens of thousands of people die every year due to cold homes. How is this a first world problem? Hmm
Swipe left for the next trending thread