Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
Angrymum22 · 07/02/2022 07:52

@Chichimcgee

Such a first world problem.

Starving and freezing to death, such first world problems.

I was referring to the op’s original question which was either or not both. Far more die of heat and starvation in third world countries. The elderly die in both extremes of heat but there is no outcry in the summer months for air conditioning. The elderly suffer the most in the cold due. Perhaps the solution lies in “bunking up” if you have a spare room offer it out to an elderly relative who lives alone. As a nation we are pretty crap at caring for our elderly. Multi generational living has its benefits. We had an elderly aunt who used to stay with us during the winter. She used to close up her house and live with us. My parents benefitted from the childcare, she survived the cold winters.
Tumbleweed101 · 07/02/2022 07:43

Haven't read the whole thread. Would cancel subscriptions and non essentials first then go by weather. Some weeks you need heating more than others, even in winter. To start with would turn it down. Cheaper food choices. Hopefully wouldn't get to the point of really needing to choose between the two as have children who need both.

It's very different today to the past as we have lost our chimneys and other ways to heat the house. If you have a wood burner you might manage more easily but it not you have no way of making use of wood or coal like households would have in the past.

Woahthehorsey · 07/02/2022 07:41

@5128gap

For the majority of people this choice will thankfully be theoretical, as the average price increase will be around £13 per week. In the context of a family living an average type of lifestyle, with all the costs of that, including leisure activities, there is a fair amount of scope to cut back, without having to sit in the cold with hot water bottles and scraping ice off windows. So unless your income is so low that you can already only ever afford to buy from charity shops, never spend on personal care, make up etc, never go to the cinema, have a takeaway, never use Tesco rather than Aldi, never have a day out, or buy a book, or get your highlights done, pay for Netflix, pay for DC activities, then you're not going to starve or freeze, and putting your families through the discomfort of cold homes will not be necessary and may come across as a little dramatic. However this is a vastly different picture from those people who already live a life where only essentials are affordable, and have literally no slack to cut. They already know all the money saving tips and use them already to get by. People in these circumstances are facing circumstances that have no place in a modern society and are rightfully concerned.
I don't care what the price index says, my gas and electric bill has already doubled. Not my direct debit, my actual bill. An extra £13 a week from April will just be the cherry on top frankly.
5128gap · 07/02/2022 07:33

For the majority of people this choice will thankfully be theoretical, as the average price increase will be around £13 per week. In the context of a family living an average type of lifestyle, with all the costs of that, including leisure activities, there is a fair amount of scope to cut back, without having to sit in the cold with hot water bottles and scraping ice off windows. So unless your income is so low that you can already only ever afford to buy from charity shops, never spend on personal care, make up etc, never go to the cinema, have a takeaway, never use Tesco rather than Aldi, never have a day out, or buy a book, or get your highlights done, pay for Netflix, pay for DC activities, then you're not going to starve or freeze, and putting your families through the discomfort of cold homes will not be necessary and may come across as a little dramatic.
However this is a vastly different picture from those people who already live a life where only essentials are affordable, and have literally no slack to cut. They already know all the money saving tips and use them already to get by. People in these circumstances are facing circumstances that have no place in a modern society and are rightfully concerned.

MissAngorian · 07/02/2022 07:07

I've got E7 storage heaters in my rented home & as of next month I'm turning everything off until at least October. I'll continue to pay monthly at my usual rate and hope that builds up a sufficient enough buffer for when winter arrives.

Eating has to be the priority. I'm a bit of a prepper so have enough to get by if we were really struggling. I would scale down my own portions and prioritise DD.

I've got two jobs at the moment but could stretch to a third at a pinch. Single parent so no income into the house other than what I bring in.

Echoing PPs - I was brought up in a council house in the South Wales Valleys and we were often cold, and often hungry. It's not a life I envisaged for my DD but we're certainly headed that way. There are one or two things that we could still cut back on but they're worth pence over the course of an average month.

GrannyBattleaxe · 07/02/2022 05:59

We have only one radiator on as low as possible (storage heater 😢), kids wear thermals/dressing gowns/so many damn layers all the time and it’s so cold we live in just one room scuttling upstairs only for bed, and eat things like 5 bean chilli, pasta & tinned tomatoes, lentil soup, etc…we have already reduced all outgoings…the only thing I have left is eating less myself. Eating less isn’t just having a smaller portion - it’s turning the meals away so they can be put in the fridge for the others’ lunches whilst you laugh merrily and say you fancy some toast with a scraping of marmite. Cheapest bread. Evening after evening. Or laughing, again merrily, and saying you ate earlier, and having a mug of bovril. My portion will feed my children well, and that is all that matters.
OP, your DH has no idea.

Piggyk2 · 07/02/2022 05:48

@purpleme12

After you've factored in the costs of getting a taxi to Aldi it's not really worth going there for food. As opposed to delivery from Asda
Unless your Aldi is very far or Lidl more than £10 back home. Aldi is cheaper than Asda by far everything is branded. Cereals are a lot cheaper than Tesco and so on.
SantaClawsServiette · 07/02/2022 02:59

For people worried about clothes drying, if it's cold enough outside to freeze them and you have a line, letting them freeze on the line works better than you might think. They will be stiff when they come in but the moisture will sublimate away, especially if it's windy, better than it will inside.

We used to do this at my dad's place when I was a kid.

Sn0tnose · 07/02/2022 02:32

Due to some massive bits of luck and some paranoia about having to choose between them (childhood poverty), I think we’ll be mostly fine. We’re on a pre payment meter so I know how much it costs to get warm, and how much I can eke it out to get through to the end of the month. I’ve also been able to build up a bit of credit when we’ve had extra cash so I’ve got a starting buffer. My mum is 5 minutes away and also has a pre payment meter so if/when it gets to the stage where we can’t be warm every day, we’ll take turns and warm up/cook in the other’s house.

I’ve got an old duvet between my sheets and the mattress (makes a big difference) and loads of brushed cotton Christmas bedding which is very warm. I bought my mum thermals and throws. I was worried about power cuts a while back so I bought some extra hot water bottles, a couple of flasks, camping lamps and a camping stove while I had some spare money. I’ve got a slow cooker and I’m a bit of a food prepper so I have a stash I can fall back on to feed us all.

It’s 3miles each way to our nearest supermarket so I’ll either borrow my mum’s shopping trolley, take a rucksack and walk, or she’ll use her pensioner’s free bus pass to go to Iceland where they do free delivery for a £25 spend and we’ll split it. I’ve also got a few areas where we can cut back if we need to.

AutomaticMoon · 07/02/2022 01:09

@UndertheCedartree I don’t have central heating and use a little electric heater, they are most certainly not cheap to run.

Macademiamum · 07/02/2022 01:03

Eating in summer, heating in winter. There are only a few weeks of the year I couldn't do without heating. But my kids need both all year round, so I guess I'll be skipping meals if it comes to that and having heating on low as needed and keeping them fed.

notangelinajolie · 07/02/2022 00:59

I know this thread has moved on but in answer to the OPs question. I would choose heating over eating. A hot water bottle under the duvet is all I need. Less food wouldn't be a bad thing for me. Obviously no food at all would not be great either so I wouldn't take it to that extreme.

Spitspotsput · 07/02/2022 00:57

Having lived in a properly freezing house I choose eating. Its no fun watching your breath condense and it being warmer outside than in. But anything is better than having a constantly sore rumbling tummy.

purpleme12 · 07/02/2022 00:46

After you've factored in the costs of getting a taxi to Aldi it's not really worth going there for food.
As opposed to delivery from Asda

Kennykenkencat · 07/02/2022 00:45

HelloFrostyMorning
I don't understand this choose between eating and heating thing. You can do both. Just cut down on both. Buy cheaper food - Aldi/Iceland/Lidl etc, and wrap up in fleeces and blankets instead of firing up the heating every 5 minutes, and just have it on when it's VERY cold, or one or two hours a day to take the chill off the house, when it drops below 3 or 4 C outside

I already use Lidl and myself, Dd and Ds are Vegan/Vegetarian. Dd and I are both on ADHD medication which has a side effect that it puts you off eating so I don’t think we can cut back anymore on food.
We don’t have central heating. Just electric radiators in each room so 9 radiators.
Having the house heated for 2 hours per day would cost us
9 radiators x 58p/hour x 2 hours per day x 30 days for a month = £ 313.20 per month just on having the heating on for 2 hours per day.

The woman opposite me has her thermostat 22-23 C most of the Autumn and Winter then complains she can barely afford the gas bill. NO-ONE needs it that high FGS. We have ours no higher than 17-18 C - most of the time. As high as 20, maybe 15 days of the year

Your neighbour probably has lower bills than us

And I know what I'm talking about (regarding heating and eating and not having to sacrifice one or the other,) because me and DH have been on the bones of our arse in the past, and have not had a pot to piss in barely, and we have never gone without food, or sat frozen in our house. We just cut down on everything

What do you cut when there isn’t anything to cut.

GreenLunchBox · 07/02/2022 00:43

Trevor Philips made me and my kids laugh today by pronouncing Aldi as 'urldi' ....he's clearly never had to say the word in his life. Sounded like he'd never heard of the place. Admittedly it was him saying he'd talked about Waitrose but most poor people use 'urldi' 🙈 so he should have used that

GreenLunchBox · 07/02/2022 00:37

I would choose to eat. I would bundle myself and my babies in clothes. If we were frozen I would go to a library. If there were no libraries I would go somewhere else with heat

It's interesting that this question is being asked in a so called first world country.

purpleme12 · 07/02/2022 00:34

I think we just surely have the heating on a lot less than many people
I only put it on as and when we feel like we need it warming up a bit
Some days it's not on.
I don't tend to warm the house warmer than 14 degrees normally I'd say. (When I have it on)
When it is on it's not normally on for more than an hour or an hour and a half a day I don't think?

I do have a lot of baths to warm up. And it's hard for me in the cold as I have reynauds and a lot of the time a bath is the only thing that will work when I've got that cold.

So I would find it extremely difficult to have the heating on less than I already do.

I'm very worried

ihaveonecat · 07/02/2022 00:22

Meant to add I'm not saying I'm in the same situation as people who are really desperate but as a fairly "normal" earner, it's right
Especially if my wage drops to £1300 which is can do. I can't take on a second job as I already work 40hrs a week, am WFH and have a load of health conditions which mean I'm always tired

ihaveonecat · 07/02/2022 00:18

[quote Aaaabbbcccc]**@daisypond* @Akire* thanks for your responses. This is awful. A lot of people don’t understand the true reality. Sorry to those dealing with this unacceptable situation, and your poor kids. We all need to act to stop this.[/quote]
I'm ok - ish. But not a high earner. My take home varies but on average is £1600pm
Which sounds ok but then you start looking at
Mortgage, council tax, ground rent, service charges, contents insurance, tv license, water, gas, electric, food, car insurance, car tax, petrol.. I'm single income so £1600 is everything (luckily I don't have DC as I couldn't afford children)
I don't drink, smoke or really do any social activities and it can still be tight

Thankfully I fixed my gas and electric so I'm fine until October. Thinking of either prepping food wise when I see stuff on offer or putting something to one side each month towards gas and electric now.

Zeb81 · 07/02/2022 00:08

Eat. Disgusted that people have to think about this

TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil · 07/02/2022 00:07

oldtinhat its people in your situation I think should have all the help diverted towards them, those who are already on the bones on their arse need it most.

The council tax rebate shouldn't have been for everyone, hell a guy I know who will benefit is a single man on 70k a year with no mortgage. It should have been income based and the money paid in over those two months should have been diverted to further help those who really need it.

I know so many people who have family members basically on 24 hour life support at home with machines constantly going and their homes need to be kept at a constant temperature. I'm seriously worried about we what they're going to do.

GrolliffetheDragon · 06/02/2022 23:44

So thermostat down a couple of degrees and on for less time each day, extra layers and blankets. (and also reduce other energy usage - wash clothes/bedding less often, air dry don't tumble, use recipes that don't need long oven cooking, reduce use of phones/computers/tvs etc.)

Thermostat is set to 18 and heating comes on for 1 hour a day atm. Can't use computer less as I'm working from home. Don't have a tumble dryer, try not to wash clothes too often as I can't get them dry at this time of year. Mostly use the cold eco setting. It's getting harder to see what to cut down on.

etulosba · 06/02/2022 23:42

Yes i agree these things are global but why isn't most of europe facing 54% energy increases?

It is…

www.reuters.com/business/energy/euro-zone-consumers-shock-power-bills-soar-2022-01-18/

Lolamento · 06/02/2022 23:30

@Alexandra2001

I was waiting for someone to blame brexit on a worldwide energy crisis. I guess covid couldn't really be blamed hmm

Yes i agree these things are global but why isn't most of europe facing 54% energy increases?
France is an extra 4% electricity and 12% gas, Spain's has actually been falling.....

Could it be that a Govt of brexitiers (who by definition only care about themselves), embroiled in self preservation aren't bothered about the general population?

Spain has been falling? You mean the electricity prices,p. You are making this up.