Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
ihateliningup · 07/02/2022 10:43

Years ago when I had no money my electricity was often cut off. I lived on potatoes and pasta so there was nothing to cut back on. I had no fridge, no washing machine, barely owned anything that even used electricity. Lights were mostly the problem, it's horrible living in the dark.

Angrymum22 · 07/02/2022 10:34

@oopsIdiditagaintoo

Add to that job losses as employers also feel the effect of increased running costs.

Add to that job losses in non essential services and non essential retail. As that's where the squeezed middle will cut back.

I was going to elaborate on this. So true. After the last two years this may be the end of many small businesses. Heating is often a very small part of running costs for many of the entertainment/leisure businesses, but energy use is high.
AgentJohnson · 07/02/2022 10:27

Fortunately, we now live in a very well insulated apartment with underfloor heating and solar panels, making our energy costs relatively low (under 50 euros pm in the winter). Three years ago it was a very different story and DD and me slept in the living room because it was so cold in the rest of the flat (God those were dark times). Hopefully this awful situation will stimulate the government and property developers to pull their fingers out to better insulate homes.

mamaoffourdc · 07/02/2022 10:24

@AnotherMansCause

Half and half. We put off turning on the heating for as long as possible (I think we left it until early December) & now we only have it on for a couple of hours in the morning & again in the early evening, at about 18°c. It doesn't usually get up to 18°c though, unless the sun is shining in. We have blankets on the beds & downstairs, & draught excluders at the doors. And re food - we just reduce expenditure as much as possible. Tricky as DD & DH are fussy, & I'm intolerant to a lot of foods but we do our best. DH only eats once a day, I usually eat twice a day but only once daily at the weekend, & DD eats twice a day at weekends (but often forgets to eat breakfast anyway). You do get used to being hungry, or altered / stretched out mealtimes. Your body just adjusts to it over time.

I'm going to make a curtain for the front door this year. Our house is in a very exposed position & the front door opens directly into the living room.

This is so sad - how will you cope next year? 😢
5128gap · 07/02/2022 10:23

I also think that as is so often the case, support that is forthcoming is badly targeted. I am fortunate enough now that I won't need to make a choice between food and heat, yet I am apparantly going to get a discount on my council tax to help me with the extra costs of my utilities (yes, I know, I can donate this, but what a waste of time and money to give me help I don't need for me to pass on rather than it going direct.) Similarly, the winter fuel payment of £200 given to everyone of a certain age whether its needed or not. Clearly there is a government budget that would help people avoid the choice in this thread, but it seems it will continue to be spent in ways that are driven by politics rather than need.

oopsIdiditagaintoo · 07/02/2022 10:14

I know so many people who have family members basically on 24 hour life support at home with machines constantly going and their homes need to be kept at a constant temperature. I'm seriously worried about we what they're going to do.

I don't want this £200 loan / tax / rebate on my electricity bill. I'd rather the money went to help people like this. I genuinely think that the money should be going to help the sick / disabled / elderly. I have written to my local MP and I hope others do too.

5128gap · 07/02/2022 10:03

@Twillow

So unless your income is so low that you can already only ever afford to buy from charity shops, never spend on personal care, make up etc, never go to the cinema, have a takeaway, never use Tesco rather than Aldi, never have a day out, or buy a book, or get your highlights done, pay for Netflix, pay for DC activities, then you're not going to starve or freeze, and putting your families through the discomfort of cold homes will not be necessary and may come across as a little dramatic.

I'm a working single parent. The above is already my life.
Get my highlights done?? One of my teenage children cuts my hair!
I think this poster misunderstands the living conditions of a great many people.
Just when you think you've nailed getting by on the skin of your teeth, another boot in.

If you'd included the second half of my post it would be apparant that I fully understand the living conditions of a great many people, I've posted on this thread at length about the difficulties of living on a low income. You have chosen only to focus on the first paragraph, which clearly doesn't apply to you. However it does apply to many of the demographic who use MN and for whom the choice of heat or eat will remain theoretical. I think my point is, like anything, this issue will not be one that affects us all equally. For many there is no real cause for alarm while for others it will be catastrophic if no support is forthcoming.
oopsIdiditagaintoo · 07/02/2022 09:59

Add to that job losses as employers also feel the effect of increased running costs.

Add to that job losses in non essential services and non essential retail. As that's where the squeezed middle will cut back.

Almostwelsh · 07/02/2022 09:55

"It wasn’t cheap to run which is why often only one room was heated. The point being made is that drastic economies can be made if only one room is heated and that living in a house with heating on one room is a perfectly viable way of living. As many baby boomers will confirm through first hand experience."

I know what it's like and I'm younger than a boomer. But a coal fire did heat a lot more than one room. The chimney went up through the house, so other rooms got some residual heat from the fire. Not fully warm, like central heating, but it took the edge off and prevented damp to an extent. If you have a house with absolutely no heating on except maybe an electric heater in one room, the rest of the house gets freezing cold very quickly and stays that way for weeks. Even putting the central heating on takes days before the house feels warm again.

I've lived in a house with just a coal fire, where you dress in front of it to try and stay warm. It's still a pretty miserable way to live in winter, but isn't comparable with no heating, or sparse heating from a small electric appliance/ hot water bottles where the whole house just behaves like an ice box.

In any case, boiling kettles for hot water bottles and running electric heaters isn't free either.

KurtWilde · 07/02/2022 09:35

@Twillow single parent here too. I hear you. Some posters just don't get it. They've never lived it.

Twillow · 07/02/2022 09:28

So unless your income is so low that you can already only ever afford to buy from charity shops, never spend on personal care, make up etc, never go to the cinema, have a takeaway, never use Tesco rather than Aldi, never have a day out, or buy a book, or get your highlights done, pay for Netflix, pay for DC activities, then you're not going to starve or freeze, and putting your families through the discomfort of cold homes will not be necessary and may come across as a little dramatic.

I'm a working single parent. The above is already my life.
Get my highlights done?? One of my teenage children cuts my hair!
I think this poster misunderstands the living conditions of a great many people.
Just when you think you've nailed getting by on the skin of your teeth, another boot in.

KurtWilde · 07/02/2022 09:24

They sent kids down the mines too, shall we bring that back?

Seriously.. this thread is turning into a 'we only had one lump of coal to last a month but we were happy so stop complaining and stick a cardi on..' Hmm

It's 2022 folks, this shouldn't even need to be a discussion in what's supposed to be a wealthy country.

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 07/02/2022 09:23

Eating obviously. White vinegar kills mould and is much cheaper than heating (or specific mould products)

etulosba · 07/02/2022 09:06

A coal fire is heating. And that never used to be cheap to run either. If you have a coal fire, you're not living without heating.

It wasn’t cheap to run which is why often only one room was heated. The point being made is that drastic economies can be made if only one room is heated and that living in a house with heating on one room is a perfectly viable way of living. As many baby boomers will confirm through first hand experience.

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 09:03

@Almostwelsh

There's a lot of posters telling us about how they survived as children with "no central heating only a coal fire".

A coal fire is heating. And that never used to be cheap to run either. If you have a coal fire, you're not living without heating. But lots of houses now no longer have a fire, or even a chimney. If you don't put the central heating on, you have nothing.

You don't necessarily have nothing if you have blankets, hot water bottles, and have/could invest in a little fan heater or heated throw.
UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 09:01

@Angrymum22

I’ve also noticed that no one seems to mention the other necessity, the internet. I roughly added up our phone ,internet and tv costs each month and as a family of 3 we spend double on media, on average each month than fuel. Probably more if you were to include the cost of running and charging devices. Perhaps we should revert back to one phone ( landline) and one tv per household with just 4 channels. Priorities are so different now.
Double on media than fuel! Shock Our media costs come in at less than half what I pay for energy.
CrunchyCarrot · 07/02/2022 08:58

Having experienced no heating for 6 days last winter with a broken boiler (and it was freezing out) I was quite shocked how cold the house became, down to 10'C in the downstairs rooms. We did have an oil-filled radiator we used to keep the bedroom warm, which is where I spent all my time during that period. It was miserable because I am hypothyroid and the intense cold in the other rooms was like walking into cold water. I began to feel really ill after a few days of that, even though most of the time I was not in those rooms, I just went down to make food. If we'd had no heat whatsoever then I just don't think I could cope! But without food, you have no energy going in, so I think I would have to compromise and keep one room warm and still eat, but look into economical foods that could be had without a lot of cooking.

It really is a miserable subject that no-one should have to be considering. Sad

FindmeuptheFarawaytree · 07/02/2022 08:55

As someone from a medium income household this is going to be scary for us, our mortgage is a significant chink of our income (not a crazy stretch but still a lot) and increases in everything - council tax, electricity, car fuel, food, Internet, insurances etc. add up fast and will make things tight. We've already cut back where we can and hopefully it will be enough to get us through, but I feel massively for those with less than us who will really suffer. We will try to continue to give to food banks where we can, but I imagine they too will struggle if they can't get the donations they need. I'm hoping a warm spring will come early this year so that people don't have to make such awful decisions. I can't believe the position this savage government is willing to put people in.

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 08:46

[quote AutomaticMoon]@UndertheCedartree I don’t have central heating and use a little electric heater, they are most certainly not cheap to run.[/quote]
Oh, that's a shame my one is. We only use it now and again, though. How about a heated throw? They are definitely cheap to run.

KurtWilde · 07/02/2022 08:36

Just reiterating what's been said throughout the thread, about 'just cut back' .. What do you cut when there's nothing left to cut?

I don't think some posters realise that many people are already AT this point.

Angrymum22 · 07/02/2022 08:31

@Almostwelsh

There's a lot of posters telling us about how they survived as children with "no central heating only a coal fire".

A coal fire is heating. And that never used to be cheap to run either. If you have a coal fire, you're not living without heating. But lots of houses now no longer have a fire, or even a chimney. If you don't put the central heating on, you have nothing.

It heated one room not the whole house. It was lit, if you were lucky in the morning and then again in the evening. The rest of the house was cold. We lived in a large house and as children, despite having enough bedrooms for one each we shared a bedroom because more bodies meant more warmth. In fact we often used to share a bed to keep warm. When central heating was installed it was a whole new style of living. We adapt to environment and we have become used to well heated homes so have nothing to compare it with. As a child it was the norm to get dressed in the living room in front of the fire. You had a good wash rather than showered every day. Lights were switched off. People were very careful with energy use not just because of the cost but because of the fuel crisis. I remember the power cuts during the 70s when whole sections of the domestic grid were switched off to divert to industry. Even petrol was rationed for a short while. Maybe we need to gradually reduce the temp in our houses and encourage everyone to layer up.
Angrymum22 · 07/02/2022 08:05

@Spitspotsput

So nice you’ve got a spare room. I’d say the people who are really worried about rising prices can’t afford a spare room. Do you remember bedroom tax?
There are a lot of people who live month to month, who have stretched themselves to the limit with mortgages and rental costs. Doubling of fuel bills and the increasing price of food will have a wider effect than you think. Add to that job losses as employers also feel the effect of increased running costs. Fuel poverty is universal.
Almostwelsh · 07/02/2022 08:01

There's a lot of posters telling us about how they survived as children with "no central heating only a coal fire".

A coal fire is heating. And that never used to be cheap to run either. If you have a coal fire, you're not living without heating. But lots of houses now no longer have a fire, or even a chimney. If you don't put the central heating on, you have nothing.

Angrymum22 · 07/02/2022 08:00

I’ve also noticed that no one seems to mention the other necessity, the internet. I roughly added up our phone ,internet and tv costs each month and as a family of 3 we spend double on media, on average each month than fuel. Probably more if you were to include the cost of running and charging devices. Perhaps we should revert back to one phone ( landline) and one tv per household with just 4 channels.
Priorities are so different now.

Spitspotsput · 07/02/2022 08:00

So nice you’ve got a spare room. I’d say the people who are really worried about rising prices can’t afford a spare room. Do you remember bedroom tax?