Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
Gilld69 · 07/02/2022 18:52

definitely eating we can go back to the old days and all snuggle under blankets for a warm

skippink · 07/02/2022 18:51

I think it’s hard to say exactly until your in that situation of having to choose, but if I did have to I would choose to eat as food is essential. I would put extra layers on in the house. We’re fortunate that we can cover our gas and electricity costs at the moment but we’re very careful even now on how often we put the heating on and it gets turned off completely on a night before bed. I really feel for people who have to choose between 2 basic needs!

Mirrorball2022 · 07/02/2022 18:43

@KurtWilde

They sent kids down the mines too, shall we bring that back?

Seriously.. this thread is turning into a 'we only had one lump of coal to last a month but we were happy so stop complaining and stick a cardi on..' Hmm

It's 2022 folks, this shouldn't even need to be a discussion in what's supposed to be a wealthy country.

I was thinking exactly the same!! Why are people suggesting that that level of living is acceptable just because it happened 40+ years ago? I grew up pretty poor in the 80s we have single glass windows and wall heaters. Our house was freezing. I remember having to run downstairs from the bath to the fire in the living room. It was shit when the window had ice on it. Yeah we survived, but it wasn’t great and I constantly was ill as a kid.

Our quality of living has been much better in the last few decades, people now live longer thanks to that better way of life and healthcare, but we now have bigger bills and mortgages, the lovely council tax, different ways of working: often less physical work, work further away from home so need the ca. The internet is now almost a necessity of life from school homework to work and even food shopping. We have better expectations/understandings of our diets with foods from around the world.

Comparisons to a completely different time don’t take away from or justify the ways some people on this thread and many throughout the country are going to have to do to just survive. We shouldn’t just accept it and say oh we’ll generations did it before.

This is one thread the daily mail should actually pick up because no one should be living in such poverty while the rich and corporations carry on getting mega rich it’s disgusting.

Moody123 · 07/02/2022 18:38

Choose basic food from Aldi and low/no heating, jumpers/quilts ect

Mirw · 07/02/2022 18:36

Come to my house in the winter, you get a cosy bundle to wear. Why? I live on the west of Scotland and have no cereal heating, only a gas fore in the living room. It can be 5 degrees in the rest of the house including the bathroom so visitors need the cosy bundle. If they don't like it, don't come and visit... We have never had central heating so don't miss it. May more of hge UK population should try it!

HarrietsweetHarriet · 07/02/2022 18:36

I find hot water bottles a Godsend! As someone else mentioned, door curtains help keep the heat in and also draught excluders (not that hard to make or look in charity shops).
If you don't mind drinking 'old' tea / coffee then using a thermos flask means needing to boil the kettle less often.
We'll be living mostly on veggie soups as I really can't bear to be freezing cold all the time.

AuntyBumBum · 07/02/2022 18:32

@SJFarter

Are electric blankets safer than they were years ago?
Yes
SJFarter · 07/02/2022 18:31

Are electric blankets safer than they were years ago?

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 18:21

@BooneyBeautiful - that is the only reason I put the heating on occasionally (and it helps with drying washing) is because I don't want the pipes to freeze! I've got chillblains - hoping my DC don't get them but I'm sure many more people will get them now many of us can't afford to put the CH on Sad

BooneyBeautiful · 07/02/2022 18:08

@FormerlySpeckledyHen

Eating definitely. I’m old enough to remember living without central heating. Only a coal fire in the sitting room and frost on the inside of bedroom windows in the morning. I’m still alive. I rarely have the heating on in the daytime regardless of the temperature.
Me too. I remember writing my name in the frost on the inside of my bedroom window. We had a coal fire in the kitchen with a back boiler to heat the water (immersion heater in the summer months) and a gas fire in the living room. Paraffin heater in the bathroom for a bath once a week. The toilet had been added onto the back of kitchen long after it was built in the Victorian era and we had to put a tiny paraffin heater in there during the bitterly cold weather because all the pipes had frozen. I had chilblains every year.

I had a wonderful childhood, but the only thing I really didn't like was the cold. My house is very warm anyway, so if necessary I would just reduce the time the heating is on and layer-up if I needed to.

ladyyl34 · 07/02/2022 18:05

I have storage heaters which are rubbish and expensive. When its really cold, i bring my mattress in living room and me and 2 kids sleep on that.
By the time iv finished work and got kids home, heating is cold. So its blankets, dressing gowns and water bottles for us This is every winter. So its defo food for us.

SuperBlondie28 · 07/02/2022 18:02

Food for sure... My migraines flare up if I'm hungry. Doesn't have to be a lot of food or expensive food. Or even healthy!! Microwave jacket pot, baked beans and cheese will do

Cromple · 07/02/2022 17:56

Years ago I had to make this decision and I think I'd make the same now. I kept the heater on in my bedroom and would skip meals and eat very very cheap yellow sticker meals when I did. My extremities get so cold and I find it so hard to concentrate/function when cold.

Retired65 · 07/02/2022 17:45

Food over heating. I was bought up in the 50's so no central heating then. We had one coal fire in the living room and that was that. We had hot water bottles and as a young child paraffin heaters in the bedrooms, how dangerous was that? The windows were iced up when it was very cold, no double glazing in those days.

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 17:40

[quote AutomaticMoon]@UndertheCedartree Yes, will get a heated blanket, thank you! I’m moving to Shetland and it gets so cold there, apparently. The electric heater is expensive to run here cause I’m in a old listed building with sash windows and rotted sills, landlord does 0 maintenance and there’s penetrating damp in the walls too and I’m disabled so need it on a lot, otherwise I lose the will to live. I grew up in communism with power cuts but my grandparents had hungarian stoves, they are huge and tiled and use wood, but in the cities, in flats, it came on for set periods and hot water was 2 nights a week only.[/quote]
Oh, you'll definitely need the heated blanket, I should think! And yes, you definitely need to keep warm. Interesting to hear your experiences from childhood. I have a Russian friend - she said the heating was on all the time but they couldn't change the temperature.

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 17:36

[quote KurtWilde]@oopsIdiditagaintoo I think it started out as their rationale was that internet was a luxury, it was for entertainment like a Sky package for instance. The policy is so outdated now. So you'd think they'd catch up and realise that without internet, people can neither fill in their UC journal, look for work, or indeed work if they use internet for their job. And yet they expect people to have an email address for correspondence. So at this point I can only think it's a deliberate way of keeping people 'in their lane', and a handy way to dish out sanctions - thus saving money and creating perpetual poverty through the knock on effect of these sanctions. [/quote]
I found that it was a way to prevent people applying. I had a mental breakdown and was on a psych ward with no access to the internet. I was unable to claim UC. I phoned then up and the told me my 'guardian' would have to apply for it for me. I had no idea what that meant so just couldn't apply. Eventually it was sorted that someone came in to help me apply for it but then they said I had to go to the JC for a face to face appointment but I was sectioned with no leave. It was a nightmare (and continues to be 4 years later - I still get no help with my housing costs).

UndertheCedartree · 07/02/2022 17:31

@Chichimcgee

If that's the case then it's either fucking stupid or quite deliberate.

Yep, all messages are online, job applications online, changes have to be declared online. It’s ridiculous to not see it as essential

The other side to it (for me anyway) is all changes will also require a phone call and all online messages will be ignored! While on hold there is a message telling you, you can do everything online. If that was so I wouldn't be phoning!!
oopsIdiditagaintoo · 07/02/2022 17:22

[quote AutomaticMoon]@KurtWilde What the hell, I found this from 2015.

The UK Parliament says internet service should now be classed as a utility, ranking it alongside essential services like gas and electricity. ... “All of this will require universal access to the internet to engage with vital public and personal services.”19 Feb 2015
www.trustedreviews.com › u...
Internet should be classed as utility, says UK Parliament | Trusted Reviews[/quote]
Sounds like one arm of government doesn't know what the other is doing.

I've already written to my MP twice this week but I might write again about this because it's just stupid.

AutomaticMoon · 07/02/2022 16:50

@KurtWilde What the hell, I found this from 2015.

The UK Parliament says internet service should now be classed as a utility, ranking it alongside essential services like gas and electricity. ... “All of this will require universal access to the internet to engage with vital public and personal services.”19 Feb 2015
www.trustedreviews.com › u...
Internet should be classed as utility, says UK Parliament | Trusted Reviews

AutomaticMoon · 07/02/2022 16:49

[quote KurtWilde]@oopsIdiditagaintoo I think it started out as their rationale was that internet was a luxury, it was for entertainment like a Sky package for instance. The policy is so outdated now. So you'd think they'd catch up and realise that without internet, people can neither fill in their UC journal, look for work, or indeed work if they use internet for their job. And yet they expect people to have an email address for correspondence. So at this point I can only think it's a deliberate way of keeping people 'in their lane', and a handy way to dish out sanctions - thus saving money and creating perpetual poverty through the knock on effect of these sanctions. [/quote]
This. I thought this was supposed to change and internet be considered a necessary utility?! Or did I dream that?

AutomaticMoon · 07/02/2022 16:46

@UndertheCedartree Yes, will get a heated blanket, thank you! I’m moving to Shetland and it gets so cold there, apparently. The electric heater is expensive to run here cause I’m in a old listed building with sash windows and rotted sills, landlord does 0 maintenance and there’s penetrating damp in the walls too and I’m disabled so need it on a lot, otherwise I lose the will to live. I grew up in communism with power cuts but my grandparents had hungarian stoves, they are huge and tiled and use wood, but in the cities, in flats, it came on for set periods and hot water was 2 nights a week only.

2bazookas · 07/02/2022 15:10

50 shades *

we have been living in a house with only one coal fire for the last two years and its been awful.

I spent my entire childhood in a north- England house with only one coal fire and no CH;' so did everyone we knew. It's do-able. Wear more clothes, keep doors shut, use hot waterbottles in bed.

theruffles · 07/02/2022 15:10

I'd choose eating though being without/less heating with two young DC worries me. I don't want them to be cold. It's easy enough to layer up with thermals/jumpers/fleeces/blankets and hot water bottles, but what a choice...

KurtWilde · 07/02/2022 15:01

@oopsIdiditagaintoo I think it started out as their rationale was that internet was a luxury, it was for entertainment like a Sky package for instance. The policy is so outdated now. So you'd think they'd catch up and realise that without internet, people can neither fill in their UC journal, look for work, or indeed work if they use internet for their job. And yet they expect people to have an email address for correspondence. So at this point I can only think it's a deliberate way of keeping people 'in their lane', and a handy way to dish out sanctions - thus saving money and creating perpetual poverty through the knock on effect of these sanctions.

oopsIdiditagaintoo · 07/02/2022 14:59

@Chichimcgee

If that's the case then it's either fucking stupid or quite deliberate.

Yep, all messages are online, job applications online, changes have to be declared online. It’s ridiculous to not see it as essential

I hope it's fucking stupid and they'll fix it.

Worries me more that it might be a quite deliberate trap, so that people miss messages / don't reply in time and get their benefits stopped.