Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 18:26

@FourTeaFallOut

I don't think people SHOULD have to live like this, but living here has taught me that it's perfectly possible to healthily live without heating

What is simply uncomfortable for a healthy adult comes with adverse health outcomes for those who are vulnerable. Could we stop peddling this myth that it's just fine for people to freeze in their homes, by just about every metric it's false.

THIS 😞

People are very ignorant of the science showing the awful health outcomes from cold (and damp) homes, it seems.

saleorbouy · 06/02/2022 18:26

Buy some good thermals and base layers and turn off the heating.
You can always fill a hot water bottle with your veg or pasta cooking water to snuggle into, why pour hot water down the sink.
I think people could save a lot with some creative thinking and common sense. My grandparents lived without central heating and eating cheap wholesome food, maybe it's back to basics for a while to take stock of things. The world has become very materialistic and wasteful in a lot of ways.

Scianel · 06/02/2022 18:26

This must be such a worry for the very elderly or those with chronic illnesses though, the very people least likely to weather price increases. My late next door neighbour was 96 and her house was absolutely sweltering as the poor thing would have been too cold at a temperature any lower. I wonder if they're going to increase the fuel allowance then?

Oblomov22 · 06/02/2022 18:26

For most people it won't come to that. We'll just have to cut back in certain areas. It's doable. Or rather we'll all have to, won't we?

CotswoldWoolly · 06/02/2022 18:24

What worries me is what happens to families for whom this is already a stark choice? Food prices are on the rise too. What happens when you can’t afford even to make a choice between food or heating because you can’t afford either?

HelloFrostyMorning · 06/02/2022 18:24

*THE drama llamas!

PrivateHall · 06/02/2022 18:24

I would cut spending on both, but wouldn't cut either out.

HelloFrostyMorning · 06/02/2022 18:23

@TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil

In all honesty im not getting the constant dramatics, it's something we rarely use.

Ive always layered up and used blankets on the sofa, this year Ive upgraded to a heated throw. It wouldnt even occur to me to use the heating when it was just me in the house. Or at night for that matter.

I get people with disabilities will struggle as will the elderly. I actually think those groups of people should have the maximum support directed towards them..... But the majority could do with cutting with the dramatics. 😬

This.

@bitemyarsenic

No doubt will be flamed but seriously do people think that central heating has always existed?

Ridiculous notion.

You eat or you starve!? Put a jumper and socks on, exclude drafts etc. Stop washing towels after every use.

And this ^

This exactly. There's some ridiculous posts on here. Empty vessels and all that. Wink

As I (and a few others have said,) there is no need to have to choose between eating and heating. Most sensible, logical people will just cut down on both to enable them to spread the cost between the two.

And as has been said, how on EARTH do he drama llamas on here think people coped before central heating? Fuxake. Hmm

HelloFrostyMorning · 06/02/2022 18:23

@5128gap

I'm assuming that you and your DH have never found yourselves completely penniless, perhaps due to an insolvent employer not paying wages due to you, or a delay in your benefits being paid, of having to flee your home with only what you stand up in, or having your only money stolen from you, and then found yourself with empty cupboards and a prepayment meter that's run out.

Don't ASSume anything You know fuck all about me or my life.

Rosieposie101 · 06/02/2022 18:22

@FourTeaFallOut

I don't think people SHOULD have to live like this, but living here has taught me that it's perfectly possible to healthily live without heating

What is simply uncomfortable for a healthy adult comes with adverse health outcomes for those who are vulnerable. Could we stop peddling this myth that it's just fine for people to freeze in their homes, by just about every metric it's false.

Well there are other ways to keep warm. Heated blankets, hot water bottles, electric heaters exist for those who need them. It's not 'have the heating on or freeze' is it
OlympicProcrastinator · 06/02/2022 18:18

Heating. I can’t abide the cold. I’ll do intermittent fasting and only eat every other day. It’s actually quite good for you. I’ll stop and turn the heating off if my BMI goes below 18.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 18:18

@Rosieposie101

I live abroad in a country that reaches the same temperature as England in winter but has much hotter summers. Housea don't have central heating. People wear many clothes at home - the same as outside. People still spend a lot of time outside in winter but just dress in many layers and keep these layers on at home. I was so surprised and slightly horrified when I first moved here, but now I don't mind at all. I use a heated blanket, and if anything I'm too hot at night! Getting up in the morning is horrible, so I shower the night before, and keep my clothes beside the bed to get dressed quickly! I'm currently wearing thick, fluffy, ugly but remarkably cosy pyjamas and slippers and sitting on the sofa perfectly warm. I don't think people SHOULD have to live like this, but living here has taught me that it's perfectly possible to healthily live without heating.
Not everyone is healthy and some people need a warm environment due to illness or disability.
1forAll74 · 06/02/2022 18:18

Defintely eating without any proper heating, I was born in 1942, and we just had one small open fireplace, a coal burning one, but sometime we were short of coal in the war, The fireplace had a small oven attached to it, so food could be cooked in it, mainly stews of some sort, and could bake bread in it.

There was no heat at all in all the three bedrooms,, the windows got all iced up on the windows in a bad winter, especially one of the worst winters in 1947, when the whole of the country got frozen solid for weeks on end.

I started school in 1947, aged 5, and had to walk about a half mile to school, in not many suitable items of clothing, no padded coats then, fortunately, my late Mum, was a great knitter, and she knitted lots of jumpers and cardigans for the whole family, and some neighbours kids too,, She knitted lots of mittens and scarves too.

Any unwanted or a bit worn knitted items, she would collect from neighbours, and unwind the wool, and make another jumper or whatever, out of the old one.. Everyone would pile old blankets, and even old coats on the bed when it was icy cold in the bedrooms..

But whatever little food we could get, was the most important thing to have. My grandparents lived with me and Mum, plus one of her brothers., my Father was not yet home from being in the RAF abroad.
My beloved Grandad, grew lots of veg, and soft fruit in the garden,, so this was a lifesaver for us all getting something to eat., so eat and be cold, was the order of the days then.

Idontliketuesdays · 06/02/2022 18:18

All I remember is that even though I'd experienced physically far lower temperatures, I had never felt cold in my life like a Scottish February.

Agree with this. I’m brought up in a country with very long winters and easily down to -30. Never been cold indoors in my life (nor am I now). Moved to UK when I was 19 and have never been as cold in my life. This is when I learnt to drink tea. 😂 I can never forget how cold I was all the time, and the lack of long hot showers. And lack of being able to dry clothes properly. (Still loved it though!)

Svara · 06/02/2022 18:17

I lived in a warmer climate where winter (July) average temperature is 16/8, and my house was unheated and uninsulated, so I know I could go colder than that without heating here as my house holds the heat well.

With food, a sweet potato, red lentil and coconut milk curry with rice is cheap and fills you up for ages. Porridge for breakfast, skip lunch as it's easy to go hungry in the day, better to save food for dinner so you can sleep.

WutheringHeights66 · 06/02/2022 18:14

Eating, I haven’t had central heating for 27 of my 55 years and grew up with frozen condensation on the inside of the windows and being able to see my breath when laid in bed.

It wasn’t pleasant I’m sure but I don’t recall the cold, only the novelty.

I am going to start heating one room though which makes absolute sense, and putting a hot water bottle in my bed.

ConsuelaHammock · 06/02/2022 18:13

If I’m fit and healthy and able to work, I’d get another job or up my hours if possible if it came to a choice between the two.
I grew up without central heating and it’s horrible but survivable. No one can survive without food!

pradavilla · 06/02/2022 18:13

It would have to be food. If I cldnt afford even basic food and heating then I'd have to eat and just layer up and get big blackness and duvets.

If it was a choice between basic food to enable some heat I would go with that. I hate being cold so if I cld only afford to heat one room then I'd do that too and get cheap basic food.

Choosing however is awful and it's going to be the reality for so many people now which is so sad 😞

HerRoyalHappiness · 06/02/2022 18:13

Eat. Definitely.

Scianel · 06/02/2022 18:12

What was the difference between where you grew up and the flat where you lived when you moved to the UK?

A few things, I think. It was a very dry cold where I lived (some downsides, your skin cracked to the point your lips bled!). I find with dry cold it's just a case of the right clothing, you can get by with a fire or heater in the main living area etc. Damp cold just feels intolerable to me, like it gets right inside me somehow.

It also heated up substantially during the day and winter was short so that made it easier as well.
All I remember is that even though I'd experienced physically far lower temperatures, I had never felt cold in my life like a Scottish February. And yes the crap accommodation didn't help, I was naive and didn't know about central heating and double glazing.

cuparfull · 06/02/2022 18:09

Heating for sure. My bones set solid when I'm cold due to arthritis.
But happy to live on basic cheap pasta tarted up with anything handy. Keep stocked with smoked cooking bacon, tuna, cheap Aldi pasta sauces and squeezy garlic paste. It can be fun and inventive for kids too. The instant noodle blocks just need boiled water poured over and an egg stirred in.
Iceland frozen veg packs are invaluable, cheap and nutritious and keep forever.

San141 · 06/02/2022 18:09

Eat. As a child we didn't have heating, just one coal fire for a 3 storey terrace house, we didn't have any double glazing and we coped! I need to fuel my body to be able to cope with kids/work. Extra layers, blankets and shutting curtains at dusk will help with the cold, especially as a lot of homes now have double glazing and better insulation

trevthecat · 06/02/2022 18:08

Anyone really struggling please find out what local food banks are available and how you can access them, some need a referral.

Second, your council may have a discretionary fund which may help, when the warmer home grants open, please apply.

If you are on a low income check if you are receiving all benefits and look at the healthy start vouchers.

So many people are not receiving what they are entitled too and tight now, every penny will help.

Also some schools will help with a grant, free school meals (even if you are not formally entitled) or support.

I do know some people will be doing all this and still struggling. But this may help someone

duffeldaisy · 06/02/2022 18:08

I'm genuinely disgusted that this is even a question in a first world country. it really is wrong.

Having both been cold and hungry in the past, I'd say a combination is best in the winter. Yes, you can do exercise to warm up and wear layers when it's cold, but when it's been cold for a long time, the place feels damp, you try to sleep and quite literally ache from the cold, it is properly debilitating.

If you're in this situation, seek help, visit your food bank, write to your MP over and over and over again. Do not let up. Do not allow this government to make this a question for people, especially for the most vulnerable ones. It is not necessary that people face this. We have the money to help everyone. It's just being siphoned out through rich companies and individuals taking advantage.

tillytown · 06/02/2022 18:08

I grew up in a council flat, the block didn't have central heating or hot water until I was 15. You get used to washing in the cold and wearing a hoodie and tracksuit bottoms to bed, but the times when there was no food were the worse. I'm so thankful there are food banks now so no other child has to deal with being properly hungry.

Swipe left for the next trending thread