Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
D0lphine · 08/02/2022 19:58

Shall we all just move abroad?

Seriously. If we have remote only jobs in a cheap country we would live like kings.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/02/2022 19:57

[quote mylifestory]@KurtWilde
mylifestory

Its not just a case of eating or heating, what about all those other things ppl cd give up like expensive tv or phone packages? I know its whats always quoted but there are many other things you can cut back on too, there's so many little things ppl take for granted that they must have, ive learnt to cut back on those a couple of times in my life when its all gone tits up & I never really went back to them so manage to save for a rainy day .....

And what about those who've already given those up? Have you read the thread?

  • i mentioned that there are many more things like this. I was once towards the end of a house renovation at xmas, i dedicated myself to it for 6 months so had no job, no money, no more savings, nada. Xmas in our house was a turkey & 2 bottles of champagne, no gifts or anything. Now that is giving stuff up big time.[/quote]
Buying 2 bottles of champagne is not "giving stuff up big time." Utterly laughable. If you can afford champagne and home renovations you're doing absolutely fine in life, do not compare yourself to someone living in poverty and say you're "giving stuff up."
KurtWilde · 08/02/2022 19:49

@mylifestory why have you tagged me in this??

People who are facing poverty have already given up extras. Me included. I don't have a phone contract, I don't have tv packages, I don't smoke. My outgoings have been cut to the bare essentials.
Rent
Council tax
Food (already shop at the cheapest supermarket)
Gas
Electric
Water
Internet (because I need it for work)

And I'm one of millions for whom there's nothing left to cut back on.

Renovating a house?? Not something I can ever even dream of doing. Maybe you could've bought presents instead of alcohol that Christmas eh. That's what I'd have done. I've gone without food to make sure my kids have eaten well in the past and will likely have to do it again. THAT'S giving stuff up 'big time'

mylifestory · 08/02/2022 19:40

@KurtWilde
mylifestory

Its not just a case of eating or heating, what about all those other things ppl cd give up like expensive tv or phone packages? I know its whats always quoted but there are many other things you can cut back on too, there's so many little things ppl take for granted that they must have, ive learnt to cut back on those a couple of times in my life when its all gone tits up & I never really went back to them so manage to save for a rainy day .....

And what about those who've already given those up? Have you read the thread?

  • i mentioned that there are many more things like this. I was once towards the end of a house renovation at xmas, i dedicated myself to it for 6 months so had no job, no money, no more savings, nada. Xmas in our house was a turkey & 2 bottles of champagne, no gifts or anything. Now that is giving stuff up big time.
Siameasy · 08/02/2022 17:44

We are lucky to be in a new build so the heating doesn’t need to go on much. DD is always rampaging around and currently in just underwear.
Growing up in the 80s though our house was freezing. It was so depressing. We just had a calor gas heater and the odd “blower” heater and one of those wall gas fire things. Don’t know how we managed but we did

daisypond · 08/02/2022 17:33

@UKorNZdilemma
No, I wouldn’t think so. I’m in terraced housing, so relatively protected.

UKorNZdilemma · 08/02/2022 17:13

@daisypond

Eat. We turned off the heating last week completely.
@daisypond where do you live? You really should put it on low, say 5°, so your pipes don't freeze
etulosba · 08/02/2022 13:45

I can go without food, I was probably one of those million who went without food last month probably because I forgot to eat

Your body uses the energy stored in food to heat itself. It can’t if you don’t eat enough.

AryaStarkWolf · 08/02/2022 13:20

Definitely eating, you can at least put on more clothes blankets etc (neither are ideal though of course)

D0lphine · 08/02/2022 13:19

At uni I remember being cold and hungry. Difference was I had energy and health to go out and earn money when needed. Lots of people don't have that luxury.

£10 went a long way in terms of food but it didn't (even then) in terms of heating our damp, mouldy house.

I remember wearing 3 layers on my bottom half, thermals, hat and dressing gowns and Hoodies to bed. I could see my breath in bed.

It was miserable and I refuse to go back there.

UndertheCedartree · 08/02/2022 13:15

@Pinkfluff76

I’d choose heating for sure. I’d rather be hungry than cold 🥶
But you can't live with no food. So ultimately once you have cut back on that as much as you can (cheapest food, food bank, skipping meals so kids have more), heating has to go.
UndertheCedartree · 08/02/2022 13:13

@Mirw

Come to my house in the winter, you get a cosy bundle to wear. Why? I live on the west of Scotland and have no cereal heating, only a gas fore in the living room. It can be 5 degrees in the rest of the house including the bathroom so visitors need the cosy bundle. If they don't like it, don't come and visit... We have never had central heating so don't miss it. May more of hge UK population should try it!
We are trying it! Except we don't have the gas fire!
RainbowZebraWarrior · 08/02/2022 12:14

@KurtWilde Flowers it's a bloody disgrace what the Govt put older people through

Blondeshavemorefun · 08/02/2022 11:39

I was checking my bulb for last year to this year. Pence per thing and daily tarif have gone up by 25%

Knew my bills had gone up but didn’t think was using more then usual and that’s why 😢😢

KurtWilde · 08/02/2022 11:27

@HappyWinter thanks, she does already get those but because she already had some debt on her gas/electric account (from when she was trying to rejig her budget after losing the income my dad brought in), it just gets swallowed up. We've been down every avenue!

She had never been in debt in her entire life before now, she was a bookkeeper by trade and prided herself on how well the home finances were run too. I learned my budgeting and frugality from her.

HappyWinter · 08/02/2022 11:18

@KurtWilde The link above has information about cold winter payments and other benefits, I don't know if it will help.

We shouldn't need to have this conversation in 2022, in a rich country. It's bad enough already, you only have to look at the amount of food banks (and demand for them) to see how people are struggling. I'm horrified to think that it is going to get worse.

KurtWilde · 08/02/2022 11:18

@RainbowZebraWarrior yes we've looked into everything. When my dad died she went from having a decent double income and a car to barely anything overnight. The government even demanded half my dad's last pension payment back because it went in on the Tuesday and he died on the Friday so he wasn't eligible for it. She had to sell the car to get through the first few months without him, which took her freedom away with it.

I did a lot of shouting down the phone at people who didn't give a rats arse. What she gets is everything she's entitled to and despite working for years it's just not enough. When they say 'pensions are rising' the amount is an insult quite frankly when you compare it to the rise in the cost of living.

One of my siblings has moved back in to try and help with the outgoings but it's not sustainable and also meant her council tax went up, which he's trying to absorb but he's not exactly rolling in money either.

And she doesn't go to the hair dressers or have tv packages or a mobile phone contract or any of the other bullshit some posters suggest can be 'cut back on'.

I'm a single mum too, Rainbow, so it's one income to cover it all (no CMS from useless exh), and I've already cut down to basic outgoings. I'm frantically trying to get more clients in (self employed), but everyone is feeling the pinch and it has a knock on effect.

HappyWinter · 08/02/2022 10:45

@GrandmasCat I posted this link on another thread, it's for finding local grants to fund energy saving home improvements.

www.simpleenergyadvice.org.uk/grants

RainbowZebraWarrior · 08/02/2022 10:26

@KurtWilde it might be worth checking if your Mum is entitled to pension credits or any other benefits. My Mum is late 70s and due to her health issues I was able to claim Attendance Allowance for her last year. She now gets an extra £60 a week. Sorry if it's something you've already looked into. I just feel so sad and angry at it all too. I'm a disabled single parent and hopefully I'll manage, but it's such a worry.

Kennykenkencat · 08/02/2022 10:19

I think those that would choose eating over heating I think have never lived for years in a freezing cold house.
I don’t mean a freezing cold house house wheee there was 1 coal fire, I mean a freezing cold house where there is no heating.

I can go without food, I was probably one of those million who went without food last month probably because I forgot to eat

But being cold is unbearable. My brain and body freezes up. Even if I wrapped myself in every thermal clothing known to man my face would still be cold, I would still be able to see my breath.
Having the heating on for one hour per day is £150 per month, 2 hours and it is £300 etc Because we have electric heating instead of gas each radiator we have on costs 58p per hour

If I am cold I can’t sleep, I can’t work, I can’t think. The cold is all I can think about.
I know I have a different body temperature to most other people. Even when every one is complaining of the heat in summer I just find it mildly pleasant. Even in Florida one year I bought a sweat shirt so I wouldn’t be cold when every one else was in t.shirts and shorts.
So imagine what it is like living in a cold house in the U.K. in the middle of winter. For me being cold is torture

KurtWilde · 08/02/2022 10:04

ONE MILLION people went without food for at least one day last month. Working people, people on UC, disabled people. Food insecurity is very real, and it's not new. Figures are up already. This is in the 5th richest country in the world for fucks sake.

Food banks are getting less and less donations (as people who used to donate are now tightening their own belts), yet demand for them is higher than ever. Those who say 'go to a food bank' must think these places get magically restocked by the food fairy every day.

The benefits uplift that helped so many last year should never been ended. The government knew that unemployment was up, they knew energy bills would be going up, food bills, too, and yet they removed went ahead and removed the uplift from the poorest in the country.

When the fuel costs hit, my mum will end up in massive debt. She's 83. She can't 'work more hours' or 'take in ironing (as people on here are fond of saying), her pension is what it is. There's no savings to dip into. There's no magic money tree that will give her an extra £80 a month. She's already behind. She will fall further behind. As will many more elderly people like her. They will turn their heating off. She knows what cold is, she grew up in one of these homes people talk about with the one coal fire in one room and ice on the inside of the window. But she should NOT have to face that again at 83.

This is the U.K. in 2022 with a government that's one of the worst country has ever known.

thenovice · 08/02/2022 10:03

Alternate days

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 08/02/2022 07:35

Drying everything during the winters going to be fun

Married17 · 08/02/2022 07:25

There are things you can do if your on a prepayment meter keep topping up the same amount through summer as you do winter. I live in a cold house I put the foil insulation behind radiators now have a warm house. It's about looking at ways to keep heat so have heating on less

swampygirl · 08/02/2022 02:14

I don't have the heating on much. In the daytime I don't and the evening I have the central heating on low for an hour. My home is well insulated so stays fairly warm plus I don't feel the cold.
One way to eat and keep warm is to make a big pot of stew.
Some years ago our boiler packed up and we were without hot water and heating for three days. I made a big pot of stew and dumplings and for those three days we ate the stew and kept warm. It's surprising how eating a bowl of stew can warm you up.