Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 06/02/2022 19:39

You can put on as many layers, thermal hats and gloves and ski socks as you like. But it doesn’t warm your face.
I never take my coat off in the house. My feet are like 2 blocks of ice and I haven’t felt my fingertips since November. I am freezing and we only have 1 heater on but as it is 58p per hour and barely wafts warmish air out and we can’t afford to put any more on it is a case of freezing. There is no choice.
I have gone nights without sleep as I am so cold

I can do without food. I am struggling without heat.

user1493494961 · 06/02/2022 19:38

I was the typical 50s/60s kid who grew up in a large family with no heating except one coal fire and ice on the inside of the windows. I still don't feel the cold. I would choose eating any day.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:37

@lightand
‘I never get the heating or eating argument.
There are many many things I would cut out before any of those.
Less clothes, less grooming, cheaper tv package. The list goes on.’

The list doesn’t go on for a lot of people, are you unaware of this? Blissfully ignorant, I’d say Hmm

Scianel · 06/02/2022 19:37

@Piggyk2 I've always wondered that as well. Surely if the boiler is running its running, I don't understand what you'd save by turning some of the radiators off.

Parsley1234 · 06/02/2022 19:35

@AutomaticMoon I have read about the social credit score the great reset CCP and WEF but I can’t see it I can’t see how governments will babd together to work together and for what purpose

oakleaffy · 06/02/2022 19:34

@Chichimcgee

God Bless Hostels! Mine was lovely- own room good staff.

Same here, I still give money to the Salvation Army when I can, pretty sure I’d have died without them!

A great Service! And with the baked potatoes in bonfires- yrs we did that, too.

Skip wood
I can get good wood off cuts from skips now,
And that 19 th C softwood burns well.
Zero carbon can get stuffed.

Piggyk2 · 06/02/2022 19:34

@Rosieposie101

I live abroad in a country that reaches the same temperature as England in winter but has much hotter summers. Housea don't have central heating. People wear many clothes at home - the same as outside. People still spend a lot of time outside in winter but just dress in many layers and keep these layers on at home. I was so surprised and slightly horrified when I first moved here, but now I don't mind at all. I use a heated blanket, and if anything I'm too hot at night! Getting up in the morning is horrible, so I shower the night before, and keep my clothes beside the bed to get dressed quickly! I'm currently wearing thick, fluffy, ugly but remarkably cosy pyjamas and slippers and sitting on the sofa perfectly warm. I don't think people SHOULD have to live like this, but living here has taught me that it's perfectly possible to healthily live without heating.
You have made me think that I should invest in some PJS that sound as warm as yours. I think your right a lot of the pj's here in UK are not that warm without having your heating turned on!
Akire · 06/02/2022 19:34

Food every time it helps keep you warm and with hot food and drink and layers and blanket/HWB you can keep warm inside. You can skip say one meal a day but then you feel miserable your body will feel colder and it’s just miserable. Your body is designed to look for food if your hungry in way being at 20c isn’t.

FourTeaFallOut · 06/02/2022 19:34

It seems beyond some of the posters here, to consider the stark reality for many of their fellow humans

I think ignorance is one thing, and to be expected. But trying to whip it into a narrative of stoic grit and mind over matter positivity, is calculated fuckwittery.

sairiegamp · 06/02/2022 19:33

[quote KurtWilde]@AutomaticMoon because this is MN and some of these posters have no idea what it's like for people living in poverty.

Almost half of the people claiming universal credit are in paid work.

Nearly a quarter of the population of the U.K. are living in poverty - 8 million adults, 4 million children, and nearly 2 million elderly people.

But no, let's pretend everyone's a middle class 2 income family eh. [/quote]
And they as a group voted for Brexit, and repeatedly for the Tories, so I'm afraid it's a case of repent at your leisure. What the fuck did people think was going to happen with the Tories in power for decades?

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:33

[quote ElectraBlue]@bitemyarsenic

For goodness sake, do you want to go back to the Middle-ages?

While fat cat energy bosses pay themselves and their shareholders millions in bonuses?[/quote]
That’s what I don’t understand. Just because there was no heating (there really was!) way back when, people seem gleeful for a return to this? It makes no sense, no sense at all.

PickAChew · 06/02/2022 19:32

@lightand

I never get the heating or eating argument. There are many many things I would cut out before any of those. Less clothes, less grooming, cheaper tv package. The list goes on.
Then you lead a privileged life compared to people who have gone through the list and are now facing the dilemma in this thread. You also lack empathy.
BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 06/02/2022 19:32

We had no heating in this house when we bought it (unless we lit the coal fire) and we lived like that (very rarely lit the fire) for about 6 years.

One of my neighbours still doesn’t have heating - she’s in her seventies and just puts on more clothes!

I can live without heating but not without eating!

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:31

@KurtWilde

Gas and electric companies will not cut you off unless they really have to. Especially if you have kids or are elderly

Well for starters they'll cut you off if your child is over 2. Elderly have to fit a certain criteria to not be cut off.

And if you're on a pre-payment meter like me and many others, if you don't top it up you don't get gas or electric. If you can't afford to top it up, you don't get any gas and electric.

It seems beyond some of the posters here, to consider the stark reality for many of their fellow humans.
MyGPsurgeryisUseless · 06/02/2022 19:31

Food, always food.

Can wear layers, move about etc won’t be long before it’s cheaper to take the car out for a drive to warm up

If it came to it and it has done before I would not eat so the dc could!

I’m looking at ways to reduce our electricity, and a few things I’ve done so far are not ever going to cancel out the amount it’s gone up by…

HTH1 · 06/02/2022 19:31

@Ponoka7

"People lived for centuries with no central heating"

And suffered Ill health, particularly lung complaints. Infant mortality was higher and life expectancy lower. Senior consultants are already saying that without proper funding for the most vulnerable, we will pick up the cost in healthcare. Poorer health = poorer educational and life outcomes. We will pick up the bill across health, social care, early years, the justice system. It's cheaper to guarantee a reasonable standard of living for everyone.

Yes but not eating will directly lead to death!
ElectraBlue · 06/02/2022 19:30

@bitemyarsenic

For goodness sake, do you want to go back to the Middle-ages?

While fat cat energy bosses pay themselves and their shareholders millions in bonuses?

HTH1 · 06/02/2022 19:30

Definitely eating. Also I just bought little electric heaters from Amazon (£16 each) and one of them very quickly heats up a whole room so can be done with just a little electricity (combined with warm clothing and blankets, we wouldn’t go cold or the house mouldy).

Piggyk2 · 06/02/2022 19:30

@Timeturnerplease

We’d feed the children and miss meals ourselves (probably be good for us). Heat their bedrooms only and wear lots of layers ourselves.

Our house is already cold, so we already dress warmly and sit under blankets on the sofa of an evening. DC wear vests and layers, but we do heat their rooms well at night. DD1 has a hot water bottle, but DD2 is too young yet.

If you turn your boiler on and only have 2 radiators turned on out of 5 for example does it not just cost the sample as having all radiators turned on?

My nan used to do that and I never understood

Ponoka7 · 06/02/2022 19:29

"People lived for centuries with no central heating"

And suffered Ill health, particularly lung complaints. Infant mortality was higher and life expectancy lower. Senior consultants are already saying that without proper funding for the most vulnerable, we will pick up the cost in healthcare. Poorer health = poorer educational and life outcomes. We will pick up the bill across health, social care, early years, the justice system. It's cheaper to guarantee a reasonable standard of living for everyone.

venusmay · 06/02/2022 19:29

We shouldn't have to choose but currently our heating is on low due to the hike in energy costs. We have really scaled down our weekly shop and no longer have as much, it's all a bit grim.

Dcs have complained its a bit cold but unfortunately we need to think about how much we are spending.

BungleandGeorge · 06/02/2022 19:29

I’m shocked that people are so accepting of this. In the days of no central heating the life expectancy was also lower and there is lots of evidence that living in sustained cold conditions has negative impacts on health, especially for those with breathing problems etc. Which doesn’t mean we all need houses at 22 degrees but there’s a limit to what jumpers and thermals can do. Why aren’t people angry that the government aren’t doing more? It’s certainly not only those on benefits that will be affected. People also need to accept that they might have to look out onto a wind/ solar farm or live near a nuclear power station.

B0J0ker · 06/02/2022 19:28

The people who are possibly going to be hardest hit are those like me who are on a pre-payment meter for their utilities.

Granted it is my fault for getting in to debt, although there were reasons for that.

Each week I HAVE to pay AT LEAST £16 on the electric meter and AT LEAST £24 on the gas meter.

Of that £8 is automatically deducted from the electric, and £12 from the gas, to pay towards the debt.

If I don't top-up weekly it breaks the 'agreement' and I will be cut-off.

Each meter does allow £5 emergency credit and they don't cut you off over a weekend.

There have been times recently where I have had to go without hearing AND eating.

I am very lucky not to still have children at home but their will be families - many, many families in this situation.

It is already one of the most depressing times of my life, the absolute shame of having got in to debt is mortifying, and knowing that the essential £40/week spend will only actually give £20 of 'fuel' means "heating or eating" is barely a choice. The poverty trap is a very real thing.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:27

Is everyone familiar with social credit score? Cause that’s what Klaus Schwab really admires about the CCP. I hope everyone here is familiar with the WEF. Sorry to derail but as far as I can see, this is by design.