Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
Lovemusic33 · 06/02/2022 19:56

[quote AutomaticMoon]@lightand
‘I never get the heating or eating argument.
There are many many things I would cut out before any of those.
Less clothes, less grooming, cheaper tv package. The list goes on.’

The list doesn’t go on for a lot of people, are you unaware of this? Blissfully ignorant, I’d say Hmm[/quote]
Many people have already cut those things out. Some of us buy 2nd hand clothes and lots of people don’t have sky tv (I don’t), I rarely get my hair cut and have never had my eyebrows or nails done.

I hate how people assume people on benefits are living the high life with big tv’s the latest mobile phones and spend £££ on cigarettes and booze 😬.

EveningOverRooftops · 06/02/2022 19:56

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
Benefits only stretch so far. Many on benefits already have debts with electricity companies so are already paying more than just their usage.

Debts can build up because Universal credit takes 6 weeks to kick in. Or because they’ve been sanctioned in the past. Or there was a cock up with UC top ups when in work. Or they’re dealing with UC not accepting their income has lowered. Or they’re on zero hour contracts and got no or very low hours that week.

There are grants but they are low, barely dent the bill and apply once per year.

TheHateIsNotGood · 06/02/2022 19:55

Unfortunately Heating or Eating has become a slogan spouted out by many who really don't make such decisions in their on lives.

It's become a T-shirt or a Twitter hashtag, overused to critique 'ideologies' they don't agree with and so has lost its meaning.

I variate my priorities daily between heating and eating so I don't prioritize one over the other, they are equally important, especially in February. I'm quite poor, with few prospects of improving my economic situation, which I take on the chin, such is life.

But don't 'trope out' Heating or Eating when all it means is some minor adjustments to your thermostat or food bill.

Tillymintpolo · 06/02/2022 19:55

@Aaaabbbcccc you are kidding right ????

SilverDoe · 06/02/2022 19:54

@BobbleAlong

I've just popped on to MN to see what if anyone was discussing this. I have tried to ignore what is happening because I am in disbelief. We are set to experience the largest fall in living standards since comparable records began. I work FT as a single Mum after 5 years of HE and there is no way I can afford this.

So in answer to your question...I won't eat, my children will and the heating will be on low. I'd rather go without food.

Yup, this is our stance :( Feed the kids. Keep their house warm. Eat pasta or whatever for ourselves.

We're not there yet thank goodness but who knows what will happen. Due to previous financial difficulty we're also on a prepay meter so will be one of the worst hit as I understand it.

daisypond · 06/02/2022 19:53

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
No, you can’t. Benefits and allowances won’t cover this huge increase. Many people aren’t entitled to benefits as well, and they too will struggle.
Chichimcgee · 06/02/2022 19:53

@bitemyarsenic I had no heating due to issues with the meters for a few months back in 2010 when it was utterly freezing. I will never forget the cold.
I wore every single item of clothing, dressing gown, every blanket, sheet, quilt. My son and I stayed in one room with rolled up towels under the doors, curtains closed.

It was only a couple of months thank goodness but when the cold gets in your bones there’s no shifting it. As soon as we had heating we had hot bath, climbed into hot pyjamas, and literally cuddled the radiator. Maybe we would have eventually got used to the cold but I’m so, so glad I didn’t have to.

Akire · 06/02/2022 19:53

Job seekers is £73 a week out that depending on how much your rent is you may have top it up. In my area you still have pay 10% council tax so that’s another £2.50 a week gone. Then fed yourself , gas , electric , water, wifi or phone data essential for benefits and job seeking, travel clothes and everything and anything else. Of course your meter is what 50% more expensive than someone who can afford it and trip to a cheap supermarket is £5 on the bus return.

Lovemusic33 · 06/02/2022 19:51

I would always choose food. Grew up in a house with no heating (other than a small log fire), we wore extra clothes in the winter.

My heating will be off during the day, if home I wear extra clothes, bed socks and I have blankets, heating goes on for a hour or so in the evening (5-7pm) and a hour in the morning when kids are getting ready for school. We could probably manage with out it being on at all tbh, food is more important.

Aaaabbbcccc · 06/02/2022 19:50

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.

KurtWilde · 06/02/2022 19:50

Honestly there's some fucking glib comments on this thread 😡

bitemyarsenic · 06/02/2022 19:49

Where has anyone been gleeful?
No one is suggesting a return to the middle ages.
There was heating but we dressed warmly and blocked draughts/ reduced waste.
Your Dad was in charge of coal and no one would consider lighting the fire until it was really needed.
As a nation we are extremely wasteful
Fuel, energy, food, clothing.
You name it we chuck it away!

Thats what I was referring to.
The idea if people cant afford heating they will just freeze.
Jesus hopefully common sense and dressing warmly might make a come back !

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:48

@KurtWilde I feel like people here are not familiar with the copious amounts of excess winter deaths in the UK due to cold damp housing. Check the charts, in 2018 almost 20000 people died like this in the UK.

KurtWilde · 06/02/2022 19:46

Yeah yeah it used to be really cold with no central heating and ice on the inside of the windows. It's bloody unpleasant and children should not be having to deal with that in 2022

Absolutely agree. I grew up like that and it was horrible. It's not something I want for my kids, and it's not something any family should have to be considering in the 21st century.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:46

@oakleaffy Just remembered living in a warehouse and we made a hole in the ground with fire and potatoes in foil, mince patties in foil, into the smouldering hole for a while. It kept us going! But we had a sweet little community then, don’t really have that now anymore.

KurtWilde · 06/02/2022 19:45

@HeyBlaby

Death or feeling cold, difficult one.
Well for an elderly vulnerable person that's one and the same.
WombatChocolate · 06/02/2022 19:44

People will get more creative with their other soending too, so that they can eat and also have limited amounts of heating.

Hardship forces people to be creative. They will cut all their lesiure spending (some don't have much or any of this anyway) and anything like TV subscriptions. Anything like an occasional coffee out with be cut. Soending on food will be reduced to the bare minimum of basic items. People will cut down on cleaning products and toiletries.....not so they have zero, but far less. There won't be much if any spending on gifts.

It shouldn't have to be the case that people cut out pretty much everything else in their lives, but even those on very low incomes will usually have something else they can cut before heat or food. The things they will have to cut might be considered normal expenditure not luxuries these days...but those will have to go before food and heat. You'd cut out hair cuts before heat or food surely? Or you'd cut out Netflix.

Those most likely to be hit by this might struggle and take longer to see where little cost savings just might be made.

And of course, lots of people will reduce rather than cut out and go into debt over this. That is the other option, as it often is when peoole are faced with more outgoings than income.

tillytoodles1 · 06/02/2022 19:44

My heating has been broken for three days and I have no hot water. It will be fixed tomorrow, hopefully, but it's had an awful effect on my mood. Luckily I live by myself, I'm a widow and my children are adults, but long term I couldn't live without heat. I could eat soup and toast to save money, but at least I wouldn't be cold.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 06/02/2022 19:43

My electric costs a fortune. I'm on benefits and get carers allowance for my youngest dc. No way can 8 just go out and buy electric blankets and plug in electric heaters, I'm already trying to cut electric down

Yeah yeah it used to be really cold with no central heating and ice on the inside of the windows. It's bloody unpleasant and children should not be having to deal with that in 2022

Kennykenkencat · 06/02/2022 19:43

@user1493494961

I was the typical 50s/60s kid who grew up in a large family with no heating except one coal fire and ice on the inside of the windows. I still don't feel the cold. I would choose eating any day.
Same era but my family would rather eat than heat. I always said the other way round.

My last house had gas central heating and the bills were, even at their highest half what we are paying now and I was never cold.
If it felt even the slightest chill the heating would go on, even if it was July.

B0J0ker · 06/02/2022 19:42

@lightand

I never get the heating or eating argument. There are many many things I would cut out before any of those. Less clothes, less grooming, cheaper tv package. The list goes on.
Please see my post about pre-payment meters - to summarise:

If you're on a pre-payment meter you are legally bound to top-up EVERY WEEK by the amount dictated by the energy company.

Mine is £40 per week. £20 is immediately deducted to pay towards my debt. Therefore each week I have £20 split between the gas and electric at £12 gas, £8 electric.

Central heating and hob are gas, oven, appliances, lighting is electric.

£12 gas does not last all week if I have the heating on. If I run out and cannot afford to top up I will be disconnected and charged a fortune for reconnection.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 19:42

@FourTeaFallOut

It seems beyond some of the posters here, to consider the stark reality for many of their fellow humans

I think ignorance is one thing, and to be expected. But trying to whip it into a narrative of stoic grit and mind over matter positivity, is calculated fuckwittery.

Ah thank you, it’s not my paranoia, is it 😕 I even thought there’s energy shareholders posting here 😭 Now I am paranoid
HTH1 · 06/02/2022 19:42

@oakleaffy

Baked potatoes cost ££ to heat!
Microwave for 10-12 mins or bbq
HeyBlaby · 06/02/2022 19:40

Death or feeling cold, difficult one.

EveningOverRooftops · 06/02/2022 19:40

[quote AutomaticMoon]@EveningOverRooftops Oh you’re reminding me of this solar ‘oven’ for homeless or camping, it’s brilliant. There’s a website 123homefree.org IIRC and Aaron is a shepherd and homeless and has lots of tips. This oven is bloody brilliant, but you need a bit of sun, dunno if it’s gonna work with winter sun 😞 Maybe I should just go and be homeless in a warm country, like Portugal.[/quote]
Oh I know about those solar ovens. They’re pretty amazing and honestly technology like that should be the norm where possible. I pondered a DIY one for dehydrating food in the summer so we’d have fruit leathers etc. I’ve a very handy skip diving friend who LOVESs projects like this.

For the U.K. you might want to look up a wonderbag. They’re fantastic, like a hay box slow cooker without the hay but can also double up as a cooler too as it’s very well insulated. They can cut down around 70% if your cooking fuel costs apparently. They’re probably a much better investment for the British winter