Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 06/02/2022 20:08

It's not often that people post on such a thread whilst claiming to be blissfully ignorant and in need of eduction about 'benefits'.

aaahbbb - Job Seekers is a very old benefit that new claimants can't apply for now - it's all Universal Credit now, which can be super-harsh to people with isabilities and their Carers.

Start your 'education' there.

reesewithoutaspoon · 06/02/2022 20:07

[quote Scianel]@Piggyk2 I've always wondered that as well. Surely if the boiler is running its running, I don't understand what you'd save by turning some of the radiators off.[/quote]
You save because you dont lose heat through that radiator so your boiler warms up the rest of the house quicker (less radiators to heat less work) so it gets to temp faster and can be turned off sooner. Just remember to close the doors to any rooms with radiators off and use a draught excluder

5128gap · 06/02/2022 20:06

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
Benefits are calculated only to cover the absolute essentials, based on the minimum the government thinks people can live on, leaving little if any margin for other expenses that most people would take for granted; repair bills, replacing white goods and so on. Its difficult to put money aside for these things when your income has been deliberately set at a subsistence level, so people end up using money they would otherwise have spent on bills. Many people move suddenly and unexpectedly onto benefits as a result of life events, job loss, illness, relationship breakdown etc, and have pre existing financial commitments, loans, credit card repayments that were affordable when they were waged but are suddenly not. Many don't realise they can be renegotiated and try to repay them from their low income, which is not sustainable and often results in an inability to affird essential expenditure. The benefit system is often poorly administrated with long delays before people receive their entitlements, or are they refused their entitlements due to error or incorrect decision making. Entitlements are not well publicised. People who have never claimed before are often unaware there is help available and so fail to apply. There are other reasons connected to universal credit, zero hours contracts and fluctuating income that can leave people without sufficient money, which are too much to describe here. There is a lot of information from the child poverty action group that explains though if you're interested.
Svara · 06/02/2022 20:06

[quote Scianel]@Piggyk2 I've always wondered that as well. Surely if the boiler is running its running, I don't understand what you'd save by turning some of the radiators off.[/quote]
My thermostat is downstairs, I don't need upstairs heated as it's mostly bedrooms and also the heat rises anyway. I have the radiators on where I want the heat, in the sitting room and bathroom. The thermostat reaches temperature then the boiler turns off.

speakout · 06/02/2022 20:06

Silly question- has to be food.
I grew up in a house with no central heating. Only a coal fire which would be lit late afternon.
In winter times we could scrape ice off the inside of the bedroom and bathroom windows.
I had zero heating in my bedroom as a child- and lived in Scotland.

TheRemotePart · 06/02/2022 20:06

I don’t understand why were are not out demonstrating?
We March for everything else?
Why not this?
I’ve got my slow cooker looked out, my dryer is taking a holiday and I’ll be put it iv socks over my baby’s hands at night.
Good times , in this 2022 modern U.K. life……..Sad

AuntyBumBum · 06/02/2022 20:06

@Zilla1

Regrettably some patients can't cope with cold houses even with layering clothing and blankets. Some medical conditions make cold houses practically intolerable.
Starving is more likely to kill you.
EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 06/02/2022 20:06

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
There are some individuals who don't because they can sometimes literally be £1-2 pounds over some threshold.

Depending on where you live in the UK, and the type of housing, you might have substantially different fuel bills while having roughly the same income. The welfare system doesn't take account of this.

Despite the publicity about wealthy pensioners, a substantial number of women who took time out from their careers to care for children or went part-time to care for parents or other family members, don't have much of a pension and inadequate resources to buffer them against financial shocks like this.

Tenants in private housing have their housing costs pegged to the Local Housing Allowance and it can be significantly out of step with their actual rent.

Universal Credit is capped for a large number of people. People with disabilities on legacy benefits didn't qualify for the UC uplift when it was available.

The Resolution Foundation, the Joseph Rowntree Trust and many others, including the Royal Society, have lots of relevant reports.

Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 20:04

Regrettably some patients can't cope with cold houses even with layering clothing and blankets. Some medical conditions make cold houses practically intolerable.

BlueMongoose · 06/02/2022 20:04

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
See Akire's post just below your own.
Akire · 06/02/2022 20:03

Plus max rent you can claim
Is 30% of the average mean rent in your area. Which is usually enough cover social or council housing rents. Say home is £100 week on council and private is £250 the max council will pay is £170 say. That leaves you massive gap which has come out of any benefits you may have. You may be able downsize later on if you can find someone who take you on benefits but that doesn’t help If you lost job or off sick and have 6m left on your lease.

KurtWilde · 06/02/2022 20:03

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
Well upthread I mentioned that my DD and her partner work and also get Universal credit but because of a mess up with their employer have been told they'll get nothing this month and it'll take weeks to sort out. So not only cant they afford their normal bills/food/rent, they certainly couldn't afford higher bills than they have now.

And people on zero hour contracts have no guarantee how much work they'll have each week so their income fluctuates because of that. Meaning a hike in prices might be affordable one month but not the next.

It's never as cut and dry as 'just get some benefits to top it up' as universal credit really isn't fit for purpose.

SantaClawsServiette · 06/02/2022 20:03

Eating. People lived with minimal heating in houses for centuries. But you need to eat to stay warm as well as to do everything else.

BlueMongoose · 06/02/2022 20:02

@Gingerkittykat

Where do the people live who say they rarely or never heat their house?

I'm in central Scotland and right now it is 1degree but feels like minus 4 according to Google.

I've got a crappy old heating system which will thankfully be replaced soon but I'm still cold with the heating on right now. There is no thermostat so no way to have it switched onto a lower temperature.

I'll definitely be looking at ways to save energy (I'm going to be buying a multicooker to cut down using the oven) and also have to cut back my food spend.

Quite. Even down here in the NW of England it's pretty Baltic today.

It is a hideous irony that people who struggle to afford their food and fuel needs are the very same people who can't afford the high capital costs of insulation. We're very fortunate, can afford both, are fit enough to put up with a chilly house, and are doing our best to make this old house better insulated, but it doesn't blind me to the terrible situation other people are in. I cannot understand why some people here, who have clearly nothing to worry about when it comes to food or fuel costs, have so little sympathy for those in such dire situations as so many currently are. I'm finding it horrifying.

DomesticatedZombie · 06/02/2022 20:01

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.

Not necessarily. There are (great huge) gaps in the system. Benefit sanctions, age, refugee status, students, debt, people in financially abusive situations, disabled but not considered 'disabled enough', etc. Benefits are not given according to need, but according to set levels. So some may find their expenses outweigh any entitlements. These are worse for longer term poor - if you've struggled to pay bills before you may be put on a prepay meter, for example, which costs more.

I was completely without food (or heat) for a week when I was younger - there were no foodbanks in those days. I spent a week in bed. There is begging, of course, but it's hard. Some would rather starve.

Crummles · 06/02/2022 20:01

People need fuel, aka food, in order to survive which in turn helps to deal with living in cold homes

Body fuel first, home fuel second

Hmm at some people suggesting buying thermals or heated throws

Chichimcgee · 06/02/2022 20:01

@Aaaabbbcccc

I’m in a different situation now as my son gets dla.
However before we would get after paying rent £300 a month.

That’s for, gas, electric, water, council tax, food, toiletries, nappies, anything baby might have needed like clothes, cream. Everything had to come out of that £300. Including saving whatever the hell you can incase the washing machine breaks because you can’t afford house insurance.
Gas and electric on a meter so a hell of a lot more expensive than direct debit.

It literally covers the absolute basics. There’s nothing to cut down on except food and energy bills.

Fuckedoffisanunderstatement · 06/02/2022 20:01

Is it going to come to this?

Rosebel · 06/02/2022 20:00

Eat because even a basic hot meal like beans on toast or soup will warm you up a bit. Like it's been said hot drinks, hot water bottles, extra clothes or blankets will all keep you warm. Not sure how I'll be drying my washing mind you.

Kennykenkencat · 06/02/2022 20:00

B0J0ker my bills are in excess of £300 per month and were cheaper when we were on the PAYG metre.
We changed to monthly DD but firstly the company won’t allow me to set up an online account to monitor my account and secondly instead of emailing me what I owe each month someone sent me a copy of my latest bill and the metre readings to begin with don’t correspond with the metre reading on our metre.
I can’t do anything until I get an online account and go through their figures from day 1 but we are in month 5 of a 12 month rental and I am no further on with finding out what the problem is.

Also we are all electric which is a huge issue as it costs so much

I will never get a house either buying or renting with electric heating again.

oakleaffy · 06/02/2022 20:00

@KurtWilde

Honestly there's some fucking glib comments on this thread 😡
Absolutely! It’s easy to be smug for some people.
Aaaabbbcccc · 06/02/2022 19:59

[quote Tillymintpolo]@Aaaabbbcccc you are kidding right ????[/quote]
My question was genuine - I do not know what job seekers is per week and PP have now educated me.

SilverDoe · 06/02/2022 19:57

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question

It depends on people's circumstances and also, if benefits have been designed to cover a certain standard of living based on previous standard costs, it's natural that they will not stretch to meet a sudden large rise in living costs.

The same as anyone else's budget, benefits or not really. If you have £400 to spend on food shopping which was getting you by but then suddenly food shopping costs skyrocket and your bill is suddenly £200 for the same goods, even cutting back is still likely to put you dramatically over your original budget.

Aaaabbbcccc · 06/02/2022 19:57

@daisypond @Akire thanks for your responses. This is awful. A lot of people don’t understand the true reality. Sorry to those dealing with this unacceptable situation, and your poor kids. We all need to act to stop this.

RedCandyApple · 06/02/2022 19:57

@Aaaabbbcccc

Someone educate me - if your income is so low that this is a real dilemma surely you get benefits/allowances so you can have both. This is a genuine question.
Can only speak for me but when I was on benefits I would get sanctioned so they would stop my money.