Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

If it comes to it would you choose heating or eating?

713 replies

Tuliprain · 06/02/2022 16:07

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.

OP posts:
AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 20:37

@BlueMongoose Exactly, and people in damp slum flats like me (listed building btw, with 0 maintenance) can’t dry clothes anywhere indoors, no outside space... I noticed that in Scotland even flats have outdoor space for drying clothes and sometimes even a storage shed. Don’t see this in England.

Twillow · 06/02/2022 20:36

@Hearwego I get a discount in Tesco, but I still shop in Aldi and Lidl because although some items in Tesco are price-matched, a lot isn't. There is less variety, brand names and special offers to tempt you into spending more, that's the crux point. If you know you get tempted by those things, you will definitely benefit from shopping in ALdi/Lidl.
Also NEVER shop without a list, or when you are hungry!

Piggyk2 · 06/02/2022 20:34

Sorry to be thick here. I understand you saying you don't need all radiators oñ but your boiler is on so are you not being charged the same amount regardless Confused

shinynewapple22 · 06/02/2022 20:34

@Nohypocrate

Eating but not wasting money on crap food. I was in Aldi earlier and a couple had a trolley laden with crisps, sweets, cake and chocolate. The total bill was £80ish but I'd say £30 was crap. If they stopped that it's an extra £120 a month. People have got to change their ways I guess.

And were this couple complaining about lack of money for food or were you just judging their trolley ?

KurtWilde · 06/02/2022 20:33

I think the problem is that some people are way past this advice having an impact - not a case of turning the thermostat down as switching it on to start with . And already on the cheapest food.

Exactly.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 20:31

@Aaaabbbcccc People (single) are expected to live on £70 a week on benefits, someone please correct me? That’s for everything, including Council Tax, yes you still have to pay it. So I don’t understand what fantasy world in you get more benefits when you need them. People are also sanctioned for spurious reasons and expected to live on nothing. There are disabled people who cannot get approved for disability benefits. Someone dear to me has visibly very deformed ankles which kill him with pain yet he gets absolutely nothing, and no help from nhs, even though he’s young, he’s just supposed to get on with it, a job on his feet all day while his ankles crumble.

shinynewapple22 · 06/02/2022 20:31

@mrsm43s

Surely it's not either or? And no one would choose NO heating and plenty of food or NO food and heating normally. Surely absolutely everyone would try to cut costs across BOTH heating and eating so that you neither froze nor starved?

So thermostat down a couple of degrees and on for less time each day, extra layers and blankets. (and also reduce other energy usage - wash clothes/bedding less often, air dry don't tumble, use recipes that don't need long oven cooking, reduce use of phones/computers/tvs etc.)
Food shopping pared back to cheapest options, whatever's in the reduced aisle etc (even if they're not your preference) in order to ensure that the was sufficient heat and food to get by.

I think the problem is that some people are way past this advice having an impact - not a case of turning the thermostat down as switching it on to start with . And already on the cheapest food.

mydogisthebest · 06/02/2022 20:30

@Hearwego

Sorry to derail this slightly, but where is cheapest for shopping bills? I seriously need to reduce my food bills. I shop at Tesco buy they apparently price match Aldi for lots of items.
You can usually get cheapish fruit and veg from markets and often they sell some off very cheap when they are packing up.

We are vegetarian and buy things like lentils, chickpeas, different beans from Asian supermarkets. They also usually do big nets of onions very cheap. Also spices, herbs etc are cheap and come in bigger amounts that the silly little jars that supermarkets sell.

Eating more veggie meals has to be the way to go as it is so much cheaper than eating meat or fish. A biggish pack of lentils or chickpeas is cheap and can make so many meals just adding some veg, spice etc

Ofalltheginjoints · 06/02/2022 20:26

If it came to it heating.

Like others on this thread I have a disability and if I get too cold I can't function, my pain increases a huge amount and my quality of life really deteriorates.

I'm very lucky that I have a bit of a buffer in credit with my energy company and I a freezer full of food which includes a lot of home made batch cooking which can go in the microwave.

I live alone so no one to share bills with and I've already made changes to reduce the time I have my heating on for across the day and trying to bulk out more meals with added vegetables, I have several electric blankets and do have thermals but on some days my limb cannot tolerate anything on it so that doesn't help the situation, having a cold house isn't worth the cost to me

Coulddowithanap · 06/02/2022 20:26

I grew up in a house without central heating, think that was the norm when I was young. Used to scrape the ice off the windows in the morning where the condensation froze.

We would eat before heating the house if it came down to it. We use blankets, jumpers and hot water bottles anyway. Luckily it's been mild and barely need the heating on.

BlueMongoose · 06/02/2022 20:25

@Idontliketuesdays

All I remember is that even though I'd experienced physically far lower temperatures, I had never felt cold in my life like a Scottish February.

Agree with this. I’m brought up in a country with very long winters and easily down to -30. Never been cold indoors in my life (nor am I now). Moved to UK when I was 19 and have never been as cold in my life. This is when I learnt to drink tea. 😂 I can never forget how cold I was all the time, and the lack of long hot showers. And lack of being able to dry clothes properly. (Still loved it though!)

The UK has an unfortunate combination of cold and damp. And poorly built and maintained housing. Damp makes it feel cold. When we moved here, this house was damp. I didn't think it was very damp at first, just a few bits of wallpaper on lower walls a bit damp, but gradually realised how bad it was. We first started to sleep here in August, and I found I needed a quilt + 2 woollen blankets and a nightshirt and bedsocks so as not to be staying awake because I was cold. In August. And generally I don't feel the cold, and need to be cool at night to sleep. We had a (real) damp specialist in. He recommended a lot of ventilation- direct and indirect, as well as insulation. (Note- this costs money poor people do not have to spend.) It took about 2 years for the house to really dry out. Thing is- we keep the heating on low on a thermostat, and had temp/moisture meters monitoring various rooms. The actual temperature is set at exactly the same as the first winter- 17 degrees. But it feels absolutely masses warmer, because it isn't damp. (*The insulation makes it cheaper to heat, but doesn't affect the temperature as the thermostat is set at the same temp.)

UK housing stock is often badly insulated, and badly ventilated. Combine that with a damp climate and fuel poverty and this is what you get- cold, moldy houses- horribly unhealthy for the occupants, especially children.

People living in (often rented) poorly insulated and ventilated housing are paying a fortune for heating and are still cold, and still have moldy walls.

DancyNancy · 06/02/2022 20:25

@JuergenSchwarzwald

Eating, obviously. You can't survive without food. You can just warm one room, or have the heating on every other day for an hour to stop damp etc.
This I think is the best option
AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 20:23

@oakleaffy How right you are! I only caught the last years of squatting before the law changed for residential buildings but I then lived in commercial ones for a while. It really was the best times of my life. I only lived in Whitechapel and Leytonstone so not the ‘glamourous’ 😂 squats but I met so many different people and learned so much, started playing in bands and getting some self worth after an abusive childhood and foster care, etc. Oh I did stay in City Rd squat too for a while and that was surrounded by high rise offices and luxury flats. Meanwhile people made walls out of straw bales in our (office) building 😂

Skipping food from skips (supermarket bins) was a regular affair and many nice things we found for free. A whole case of honey because one jar was broken. In London there was the free vegetarian food you could get from the Sikh temple.

Now the supermarkets spray blue paint on the stuff so people don’t use it. Or I don’t know now, but that was the case towards the end, in 2010. Thankfully I’ve been able to buy food since then but just about, carers get paid less then cleaners for some reason, just minimum wage. I don’t have formal education due to having to care for my mother when I should’ve been going to school as she had paranoid schizophrenia and we were in Africa, in a foreign place.

Zilla1 · 06/02/2022 20:22

@AuntyBumBum yes in the long term though it would depend on the weather in the short term - cold weather does increase mortality beyond falls - I vaguely recall an 11% increase in cardiovascular events leading to mortality following colder weather in preceding days for example. I wasn't suggesting the starvation approach, just a flaw for some people suggesting the 'in the old days, another jumper' approach.

Hawkins001 · 06/02/2022 20:20

@Tuliprain

We were having this discussion the other night. I would choose eating and husband would choose heating - so we are already stuck. Im thinking we could warm up with blankets and hot water bottles etc but nothing you can do about hunger. He says the house will go mouldy and he’s rather be hungry than cold. Such a depressing subject to be considering.
For me it's easy, basic heating to take the chill off the air. Then food. I wear when chilly, thermal trousers and thermal jumper, then a dressing gown on top, with thermal lined slippers.
SantaClawsServiette · 06/02/2022 20:14

It's not in reality a straight choice. No one can not eat at all so anyone saying "eating" is fudging.

Most people will strike a balance as best they can between very cheap food and measures to remain warm like extra blankets, curtains, keeping active, and heating only one part of the house. I live in a cold place, it's -9 now which is the warmest it's been all week, if we didn't heat at all there would also be no water. But in a pinch we could just heat the kitchen with the fire and spend most of our time there - the house was built for that. It's a lot harder in modern homes which, even with better insulation, just aren't designed with that kind of problem in mind.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 06/02/2022 20:13

@TheRemotePart

I don’t understand why were are not out demonstrating? We March for everything else? Why not this? I’ve got my slow cooker looked out, my dryer is taking a holiday and I’ll be put it iv socks over my baby’s hands at night. Good times , in this 2022 modern U.K. life……..Sad
They demonstrated in France when their bills went up 45% and their Government listened and changed it so that the bills could only go up 4%. Boris and his ilk would sooner see people die than upset their corporate buddies.
AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 20:12

@bitemyarsenic www.e3g.org/news/17000-people-in-the-uk-died-last-winter-due-to-cold-housing/

15 Feb 2019
On Fuel Poverty Awareness Day, E3G [1] and National Energy Action (NEA) [2] reveal there were over 17,000 deaths due to cold housing conditions last winter and almost twice as many people died compared to the previous winter [3]. E3G and NEA also confirm last winter’s excess winter mortality in the UK was the highest since 1976. The new findings are released on national Fuel Poverty Awareness Day [4], the national day highlighting the problems faced by those struggling to keep warm in their homes.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 06/02/2022 20:12

Death! DlA

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 06/02/2022 20:11

My sons death has dropped down to medium rate so I've lost tax credits. I've also just been moved onto universal credits because of it and it looks like I'll be getting even less

Then there's the fact that I now need to pay bedroom tax as older ds has finished full time education and moved out.

I'm lucky that the dla I get covers that sort of thing but it's getting really tight

Twillow · 06/02/2022 20:11

If you're hungry, you feel the heat more. Eat.
Plus cooking will at least warm the kitchen a little.

But - we have got used to having our homes at a semi-tropical level. Most people over 60 grew up with very little heating and certainly no central heating. It is not the end of the world for healthy active adults and children to move around more and put a jumper on.

But what is really sad and worrying is that the government have made no special allowance for fuel costs for elderly and disabled people.

oakleaffy · 06/02/2022 20:11

[quote AutomaticMoon]@oakleaffy Just remembered living in a warehouse and we made a hole in the ground with fire and potatoes in foil, mince patties in foil, into the smouldering hole for a while. It kept us going! But we had a sweet little community then, don’t really have that now anymore.[/quote]
Sadly you are right.
A street of squats ( Swaton Road, E3) was a nice community,
As were some in Notting Hill and even Richmond- but laws have changed.
I look back on Rightmove at my old Squat with almost nostalgia now
The wooden shutters are still there that I painted with skip found paint,
But now so many of these areas are gentrified.

I saw a postcard the other day
“
Make Bristol Shit Again” and laughed.
With sadness.
There was much more community.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 06/02/2022 20:10

I’m shocked and disgusted at the Government’s inaction over this. They seem more concerned about gutter politics and slinging mud at each other than acting like grownups and working together to find a solution to this. Of course non of them will be affected which might explain the lack of action. £200 loans doesn’t cut it. Sorry.

BooksAndHooks · 06/02/2022 20:08

We’ve already turned our heating off.

AutomaticMoon · 06/02/2022 20:08

@bitemyarsenic

Where has anyone been gleeful? No one is suggesting a return to the middle ages. There was heating but we dressed warmly and blocked draughts/ reduced waste. Your Dad was in charge of coal and no one would consider lighting the fire until it was really needed. As a nation we are extremely wasteful Fuel, energy, food, clothing. You name it we chuck it away!

Thats what I was referring to.
The idea if people cant afford heating they will just freeze.
Jesus hopefully common sense and dressing warmly might make a come back !

But people DO just freeze to death.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1173232/#__ffn_sectitle

‘The UK government has launched a 10 year strategy to prevent deaths among old and vulnerable people as a result of fuel poverty. Some studies have suggested that as many as 50 000 people die annually because they cannot afford to heat their homes properly.’

This is from 2001. In 2018 almost 20.000 people died from cold homes, and that’s the official number which I believe is lower than the reality.