Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Carr’s Racist Joke

189 replies

Knutface · 06/02/2022 13:28

www.theguardian.com/culture/2022/feb/04/jimmy-carr-condemned-for-joke-about-gypsies-in-netflix-special

Not something that I find funny but it has highlighted something. Racism against Roma/Sinti people is widely acceptable and not treated in the same away as racism against other minorities. Years ago I worked for a local authority in an area with a fair few traveller sites and noticed that staff that would never dream of using slurs against black or Asian people openly did so against travellers. AIBU to think that this is the ‘joke’? Anti Roma sentiment is unfortunately widespread.

OP posts:
lonelyapple · 06/02/2022 14:58

@Knutface

www.theguardian.com/culture/2022/feb/04/jimmy-carr-condemned-for-joke-about-gypsies-in-netflix-special

Not something that I find funny but it has highlighted something. Racism against Roma/Sinti people is widely acceptable and not treated in the same away as racism against other minorities. Years ago I worked for a local authority in an area with a fair few traveller sites and noticed that staff that would never dream of using slurs against black or Asian people openly did so against travellers. AIBU to think that this is the ‘joke’? Anti Roma sentiment is unfortunately widespread.

I thought most travellers were Irish? Are the Irish travellers of Roma/Sinti origin or do some people just use the word "gypsy" to refer to Irish travellers too? I always thought Irish travellers were ethnically white Irish?
StScholastica · 06/02/2022 14:58

I can't abide Jimmy Carr, but the irony of David Baddiel commenting is sickening. Has he forgotten his own past now?

IncompleteSenten · 06/02/2022 14:57

@SkiingIsHeaven

Totally out of order.

David Baddiel made a good point. Would a joke about the KKK killing black people be funny or acceptable?

We had the misfortune of being given tickets to see Jimmy Carr. He was just rude and tried to be really shocking and controversial. Not clever, witty or funny.

If anyone needs "cancelling" it is this idiot.

To racists, yes.
ElenaCouch · 06/02/2022 14:54

Hmmm I'm on the fence.

I don't think any joke about the Holocaust or genocide is good, no matter how "clever", it's just a no - go for me.

But, from what I'm seeing, travellers come from many different ethnic backgrounds. So if a comedian takes a pop at a travellor for their behaviour, I'm not sure I'd think that was racist, as they could be Irish, Scottish, northern India etc etc. It's not about their actual race, so I guess it would be more like a hate crime? But I'm not sure, I think being a travellor still seems fair game for a joke, if written well, if it was about behaviour.

But they are a recognised race according to law so it's a moot point I guess.

phishy · 06/02/2022 14:50

@Agrudge

Agreed, like racist jokes against white people have always been acceptable
It’s white people making the jokes though.

That joke is abhorrent but you seem to be implying it’s minorities.

Stevenage689 · 06/02/2022 14:48

I've now reported four posts on here for racist views. They are openly implying that all travellers (or, in one case, specifically all Irish travellers) are criminals and delinquents. These are harmful views.

As Jimmy Carr specifically stated, he made a joke about a bad thing. He did not condone the bad thing. Whether or not you find it funny, I find it hard to see how it stokes negative views and potential demonisation in the way that PPs have with their posts.

Many travellers are good people. Some aren't.
Many people are good people. Some aren't.
Don't lump huge groups of people together and generalise about their behaviours.

Iwonderifiwonderwhy · 06/02/2022 14:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Timeyime · 06/02/2022 14:46

I think some of the responses on here are neatly proving Carr's point lol.

sadpapercourtesan · 06/02/2022 14:46

@Booboobibles

I’m not getting into any discussions btw because I’ve stated facts and said that it’s just some of them.
That's OK then - you just post as much disgusting racist crap as you like, and nobody will challenge you because you've said you're not up for it Hmm
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/02/2022 14:44

Jimmy Carr is Benard Manning for people who sneer at Bernard Manning. He is a tax-dodging cunt. Why is anyone surprised at this?

Booboobibles · 06/02/2022 14:42

I’m not getting into any discussions btw because I’ve stated facts and said that it’s just some of them.

CorrBlimeyGG · 06/02/2022 14:41

@ElenaCouch This is an interesting overview of GRT history.

travellermovement.org.uk/gypsy-roma-and-traveller-history-and-culture

Booboobibles · 06/02/2022 14:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Agrudge · 06/02/2022 14:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. We've removed this because it quotes a previously deleted post.

ElenaCouch · 06/02/2022 14:38

I'll stick my neck out....

I didn't know that Travellers were a race of people. Never heard the term/name Roma etc.

So when people make jokes about travellers, I would of thought it was a joke about people who choose to live a certain way (and have a reputation for being a nuisance) and wouldn't of known that it was racist.

Could some of the clapping and laughing been because some people were also ignorant like me?

Interested in finding out more about their heritage etc to fill in the blanks for myself.

P.s Don't think that genocide is funny.

lesleylol · 06/02/2022 14:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Agrudge · 06/02/2022 14:27

[quote CorrBlimeyGG]@namechangehistory Are there any other groups you so readily stereotype like that? "They" do this, and "they" do that, like "they" are one homogeneous group all guilty of terrorising your children.[/quote]
Sound like she was specifically talking about the ones who camp it her local parks

CorrBlimeyGG · 06/02/2022 14:22

@namechangehistory Are there any other groups you so readily stereotype like that? "They" do this, and "they" do that, like "they" are one homogeneous group all guilty of terrorising your children.

WhyMeLord · 06/02/2022 14:18

I am forever astonished at how Baddiel managed to rebrand himself as an advocate of anti-racism. Truly astonished

Exactly, Jason Lee must wake up some mornings and wonder if he imagined the 90s.

Agrudge · 06/02/2022 14:13

I think people need to lighten up.

Maybe the laughter wasnt at what he said,just the fact he had the nerve to say .

Joinedforthis22 · 06/02/2022 14:08

But then plenty of people fly tip and litter and drive motorbikes for fun in the parks anyway so 🤷
So I don't care about travellers and think that they shouldn't be discriminated against but in reality some are arse holes and make a mess, breaking down fences etc. So again I don't know. It's a tough one.

What is your point?! That it's a tough to know whether the Nazis were right?? that was the joke!

namechangehistory · 06/02/2022 14:05

Oh but the joke was disgusting but he has a pretty disgusting kind of humour and most of his jokes are vile anyway. This one was taking it way too far though and it is racist. or discriminatory.

Agrudge · 06/02/2022 14:04

Agreed, like racist jokes against white people have always been acceptable

TidyDancer · 06/02/2022 14:03

I don't particularly find Jimmy Carr funny but my take on it was more that he was highlighting how certain groups seem to be easily targeted. I don't necessarily think it should be taken at face value.

namechangehistory · 06/02/2022 14:03

I come from travellers my grandparents were travellers when children but settled into permanenthousing, and so I care a little bit more about it, but when they show up at local park and nearly hit my kids with their cars on the grass and their mopeds or motor bike things then I think "fuck you!". And then I feel bad because there is literally nowhere you can live in this planet for free and I think they are standing up to that and that's good. But then they leave their rubbish and shit on tissues where my kids play and think "fuck you" again. So it's half and half.

But then plenty of people fly tip and litter and drive motorbikes for fun in the parks anyway so 🤷
So I don't care about travellers and think that they shouldn't be discriminated against but in reality some are arse holes and make a mess, breaking down fences etc. So again I don't know. It's a tough one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread