Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Carr’s Racist Joke

189 replies

Knutface · 06/02/2022 13:28

www.theguardian.com/culture/2022/feb/04/jimmy-carr-condemned-for-joke-about-gypsies-in-netflix-special

Not something that I find funny but it has highlighted something. Racism against Roma/Sinti people is widely acceptable and not treated in the same away as racism against other minorities. Years ago I worked for a local authority in an area with a fair few traveller sites and noticed that staff that would never dream of using slurs against black or Asian people openly did so against travellers. AIBU to think that this is the ‘joke’? Anti Roma sentiment is unfortunately widespread.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 06/02/2022 17:18

@Agrudge

I think people need to lighten up.

Maybe the laughter wasnt at what he said,just the fact he had the nerve to say .

Nerve to say a minority group should be killed in the holocaust? Would you say that about Jewish people? Confused
Mydogmylife · 06/02/2022 17:17

@Timeyime

David "pineapple" Baddiel is useful in showing that people are naturally inconsistent, I guess.
Yeh, David ' let's dress up in blackface' baddiel truly gets racism I guess
Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/02/2022 17:17

@Joinedforthis22 Ah Thank you!

Joinedforthis22 · 06/02/2022 17:16

@Ihopeyourcakeisshit it's on page 3, someone posted a screenshot and link

JuicySatsuma85 · 06/02/2022 17:16

I am ethnically Roma. My grandparents fled Italy for Scotland during WW2 due to Roma people being rounded up and gassed along with Jews and other groups. I’m not a traveller but I still follow many Roma traditions.

I honestly don’t have a problem with Carrs joke. I don’t like his style of comedy but I accept that it’s a Netflix comedy show & he’s known for that kind of humour. What I find much more offensive is the widely accepted cultural appropriation. There are so many clothing brands named things like “Gypsy Dreams” or some bullshit. Take a look on Instagram at the number of white women who are fond of a maxi skirt and a bangle, who went to Thailand that one time with usernames like BohoGypsyPrincess87. That’s much more offended to me than Carrs joke. His joke actually shed light on something a lot of people probably don’t even know happened!

Irish travellers & Roma people are not the same in any way btw. Culturally, ethnically, historically. We both often live in unfixed abodes, that’s the only similarly.

To the person who said “it’s like racist jokes towards white people have always been acceptable”. Firstly, you can’t be racist to white people. You can make jokes based on stereotypes but that isn’t the same a racism. Secondly “good” comedy usually punches up which is what happens when white people are the but of the joke. There is no joke about another race rounding up white people in their millions and gassing them because it’s never happened.

Valeriekat · 06/02/2022 17:09

@ExtraOnion

Conservatives don't like smutty humour so no I don't think he is supported by the "Right Wing" .

He is just plain nasty.

DGRossetti · 06/02/2022 17:08

Is she comparing him to Hitler, or is she pointing out that someone defending objectionable people because she knows them better doesn’t make said people less objectionable?

The deeper question is whether people are mere sums of their works ?

The flip side of "person does awful thing, so therefore person is awful" is "person does beautiful thing, so therefore person is beautiful". Which I am willing to bet could be disproved with a couple of carefully honed examples from the world of art, or music.

Really entertainment is a quantum state that can only be collapsed by opening the box. Which is fair enough if the boxes weren't labelled.

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/02/2022 17:07

Baddiel what's the deal?

Joinedforthis22 · 06/02/2022 17:06

@MeSanniesareBrannies thank you, yes this is what I was trying to do, and you put it much more eloquently than I did!

DeeCeeCherry · 06/02/2022 17:03

VladmirsPoutine
@DeeCeeCherry If Mo the Comedian or Munya had made that 'joke' I am willing to bet my house and life savings that they would have never worked again, not only in comedy but even the local steak house. They might have even ended up in jail for 'incitement

Exactly. They'd be gone .

People can huff and puff on here as much as they like but the fact remains Jimmy Carr = White Male Privilege. This type of thing doesnt happen in a bubble - its afforded to people like him hence I roll my eyes at 'If he/they said it about Black people'.

As if offensively joking about Black people even to the extent of negatively affecting them profoundly both personally and career-wise (see bandwagon-Baddiel) would ever get a White man cancelled.

Those who support and condone that type of abhorrent privilege, usually whilst hiding behind 'No to cancel culture!' couldn't care less about Black people or Travellers hence the deflection and unbalanced comparison.

DGRossetti · 06/02/2022 17:02

@Joinedforthis22

*I'm so disappointed in Victoria Coren Mitchell defending him as "a man full of goodness and kindness"

Maybe she knows him better than you ?*

Yep, I'm sure she does. Diana Mosley said similar things about Hitler, she also knew him better than me.

I take it we've reached Godwins law ?
MeSanniesareBrannies · 06/02/2022 17:01

@Againstmachine

Yep, I'm sure she does. Diana Mosley said similar things about Hitler, she also knew him better than me.

Man tells joke , gets compared to Hitler Hmm

Is she comparing him to Hitler, or is she pointing out that someone defending objectionable people because she knows them better doesn’t make said people less objectionable?
Joinedforthis22 · 06/02/2022 17:01

And I've now spoken in a double negative, but no I was not comparing Jimmy Carr to Hitler

Joinedforthis22 · 06/02/2022 17:00

@Againstmachine no, I was making the point that you can't say that just cause his friend's say he's a good person doesn't mean he is.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 16:58

Yep, I'm sure she does. Diana Mosley said similar things about Hitler, she also knew him better than me.

Man tells joke , gets compared to Hitler Hmm

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2022 16:58

There is no other minority group that so many people will openly generalise and negatively stereotype.

Really? This is just not true.

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/02/2022 16:57

What's the Baddiel controversy? I'm only vaguely familiar with him.

Joinedforthis22 · 06/02/2022 16:56

*I'm so disappointed in Victoria Coren Mitchell defending him as "a man full of goodness and kindness"

Maybe she knows him better than you ?*

Yep, I'm sure she does. Diana Mosley said similar things about Hitler, she also knew him better than me.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 16:55

Whilst the joke isn't good I disagree with trying to censor or cancel comedians, we do need free speech on this country.

People still think the Germans episode of Fawlty towers Is offensive to the Germans it isn't, it's the English attitude to the war that is being satired.

DGRossetti · 06/02/2022 16:49

David Baddiel once appeared on a show with Michael Gove (when he was "Mikey" Gove the edgy Tory politician who "told it like it was").

I think we can leave it there, really.

You know that comedy has-been that became a rentaquote ?

I may have been made aware of his works

That's you, that is ....

If we need to remember the 90s.

SkiingIsHeaven · 06/02/2022 16:49

I know David Baddiel is no angel but I was specifically agreeing with what he said this time. I didn't want to pass it off as my own ideas/opinion.

DGRossetti · 06/02/2022 16:46

it is strange that it was released on Xmas Day but has taken a few weeks for the backlash to arrive.

It's almost as if the media wanted to crowd out some other big story and knew what dog-whistle to blow to achieve that.

Didn't Kate and Wills say that Jimmy Carr was one of their favourite comedians ?

OhWhyNot · 06/02/2022 16:40

Jimmy Carr is an unbelievable idiot if he thinks this is acceptable. He’s always looked like a relative of Hitler anyway

Staffy1 that is funny. But many would say that is offensive or is it offensive to see humour in your observation….

OhWhyNot · 06/02/2022 16:37

The joke is that the majority of people still view travellers/gypsies with suspicion and are prejudice towards them why deny that

It’s not acceptable to be racist towards black people or Asian etc and as a society that upholds (of course we know too many people are racist)

Gypsies/travellers well they are often treated as if they are not worthy of thought

David Baddiel spent years defending offensive comedy I think he is jumping on a bandwagon with this one.

BadHairDayExpert · 06/02/2022 16:30

www.theguardian.com/stage/2006/jan/06/comedy.bbc
He was being called out for making such jokes 16 years ago.
He has already predicted his own cancellation from ''untellable'' material he chose to do anyway - it is strange that it was released on Xmas Day but has taken a few weeks for the backlash to arrive.
Either Netflix will be happy that the publicity drives people to watch it or they will help with the cancellation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread