Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Carr’s Racist Joke

189 replies

Knutface · 06/02/2022 13:28

www.theguardian.com/culture/2022/feb/04/jimmy-carr-condemned-for-joke-about-gypsies-in-netflix-special

Not something that I find funny but it has highlighted something. Racism against Roma/Sinti people is widely acceptable and not treated in the same away as racism against other minorities. Years ago I worked for a local authority in an area with a fair few traveller sites and noticed that staff that would never dream of using slurs against black or Asian people openly did so against travellers. AIBU to think that this is the ‘joke’? Anti Roma sentiment is unfortunately widespread.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2022 18:10

@Againstmachine

Who is Mo the comedian or do you mean Mo Gillingham, it's strange we keep refering to him this way as we aren't on on insta.
I have no idea who Mo Gillingham is but if you mean a man called Mo Gilligan who uses the alias Mo The Comedian across different media platforms including radio and TV yes that's him Smile
JuicySatsuma85 · 06/02/2022 18:10

In its most simplistic definition, racism is prejudice or discrimination directed at someone of a different race – based on the belief that your own race is superior.

Taking this definition at its word, then, would suggest that it is possible for a person of any race to experience racism if someone treats them badly for this reason – even white people.

But this definition of racism leaves out one crucial element: The power structures that uphold and perpetuate racism.

Racism doesn’t exist in a vacuum. It exists within a hierarchical structure with power at its core. Racism only works because one group has power and other groups do not.

Stereotypes and negative beliefs about white people are examples of racial prejudice – but not racism.

Which, to be clear, is still wrong. Prejudice directed at any group based on a set of pre-conceived assumptions is never a good thing, and almost always leads to behaviour that is hurtful and causes harm.

The difference between racial prejudice and racism is the lack of any power structure weighted in favour of a particular race.

Literally read any book about racism written by people who have properly experienced it and not just had a black comedian say “white people don’t know how to season food”.

BOOTS52 · 06/02/2022 18:08

I am shocked after seeing what David Baddiel did to that footballer and Frank Skinner on their show. Hearing how that footballer felt and his family due to Baddiel and Skinner's show is just horrible.They kept doing it on and on and the footballer had to endure horrible abusive songs at football games because of Baddiel putting a pinapple on his head and making fun of this footballer. I had no idea Baddiel had done this. That is racist but it is also extreme bullying and like the thing that that horrible man from Bo Selecta did to Craig David all the time. Non-stop bullying and put downs and that is an extreme form of bullying. Jimmy Carr is not funny and uses one liners with just sarcasm and put downs to get a laugh.

JuicySatsuma85 · 06/02/2022 18:03

[quote trunktoes]@JuicySatsuma85 eh? What colour are Jews then? What the fuck?[/quote]
What the hell are you on about?

Jewish people and white people aren’t ethnically the same. My skin colour is “white” but I’m Roma. You can be Hispanic and light skinned. Surely you know the difference between ethnically white people and light skinned people races? You know there are ethnic differences between Jewish people, Roma people and white people surely??

Roma people originate from India but are mostly light skinned nowadays. Jewish people originate from the Middle East.

Georgyporky · 06/02/2022 17:59

There's a difference between Roma & "travellers".
The first dislike the second as much as settled people.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 17:58

Who is Mo the comedian or do you mean Mo Gillingham, it's strange we keep refering to him this way as we aren't on on insta.

JuicySatsuma85 · 06/02/2022 17:56

@lesleylol

So white women wearing long skirts and bangles is cultural appropriation? What utter tripe,
So you just chose to ignore the rest of that sentence then did you? I said white women dressing that way AND THEN referring to themselves as “gypsies” is wrong because wearing a maxi skirt and bangles doesn’t make you “a gypsy”.
Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 17:55

So white women wearing long skirts and bangles is cultural appropriation? What utter tripe

Yep it's sorta cultural appropriation to appropriate them even though long skirts and braclets existed before that.

OhWhyNot · 06/02/2022 17:55

Isn’t the point being made Jimmy Carr will get away with it it will harm his career for a bit but there will be comedians who will come out and support him. He will make a statement and lay low for a bit

Would Mo the Comedian get away with it I doubt it. Would it be aired by Netflix no I don’t think so

lesleylol · 06/02/2022 17:52

So white women wearing long skirts and bangles is cultural appropriation? What utter tripe,

Agrudge · 06/02/2022 17:43

@DeeCeeCherry

It's not a conversation about "white male privilege"

It a conversation about a joke made that some people dont like

roarfeckingroarr · 06/02/2022 17:39

It's funny though. Humour doesn't have to be right on. He's also correct to say it's raising awareness that not just Jews died in the holocaust.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 17:39

So rather than a conversation about White Male Privilege its yes you can/no you can't be racist to White people.

Oh do give over it's not about that at all.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 17:38

I do not think he should be allowed to get away with this as if this was said about anybody else people would be outraged.

Why what do you think should happen then. If he shouldn't getaway what's the punishment.

There is a good sketch by Steve Hughes about being offended. Do you know what happend when you are offended nothing happens all it is is you are offended

DeeCeeCherry · 06/02/2022 17:34

So rather than a conversation about White Male Privilege its yes you can/no you can't be racist to White people.

Just more proof of how far around the houses people will go so as to not disturb the status quo, and keep that WMP right on going.

All negative 'isms' are impacted by that Privilege which isnt ever going to be properly challenged. & is why be it racism or sexism, nothing gets done.

Jimmy Carr will be fine.

BOOTS52 · 06/02/2022 17:33

I do not think he should be allowed to get away with this as if this was said about anybody else people would be outraged. He is not funny and think he is past his sell by date. He just uses sarcastic one liners and puts down others. As Oscar Wilde once said 'Sarcasm is the lowest form of wit'. I love dark comedy and have a weird sense of humour but I do not like humour at the expense of any minorities as find it disgusting.

Stevenage689 · 06/02/2022 17:32

@UtterlyUnimaginativeUsername Yes his line said "there was a good thing" but it was a joke. In satire you often say something controversial in order to highlight it. It didn't celebrate the murder of the Gypsies in the holocaust. It mocked the dickheads that genuinely think gypsy lives are worthless.

Anyway, I'm reasonably certain that the appearance of this in the press two months after it came out is a publicity stunt.

I watched the special. It's not my favourite type of comedy but parts were funny. Like many, he tells outrageous jokes. They make me uncomfortable more than they make me laugh. But I don't feel they are dangerous in any way, so I can't get worked up about them.

MeSanniesareBrannies · 06/02/2022 17:30

@DGRossetti

Is she comparing him to Hitler, or is she pointing out that someone defending objectionable people because she knows them better doesn’t make said people less objectionable?

The deeper question is whether people are mere sums of their works ?

The flip side of "person does awful thing, so therefore person is awful" is "person does beautiful thing, so therefore person is beautiful". Which I am willing to bet could be disproved with a couple of carefully honed examples from the world of art, or music.

Really entertainment is a quantum state that can only be collapsed by opening the box. Which is fair enough if the boxes weren't labelled.

I really don’t give a shit if someone whose work I find offensive or problematic is lovely in real life. I don’t care who they are ‘as a person’. Its unlikely I’m ever going to meet them. If you’re punching down on minority groups, you are trash to me - I’m not interested in your charity work or the fact that you’re nice to your grandma.

Your question isn’t ‘deeper’, I consider it wholly irrelevant to the matter at hand.

Really entertainment is a quantum state that can only be collapsed by opening the box. Which is fair enough if the boxes weren't labelled

I’m sure you thought that was rather clever, but it’s utter nonsense.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 17:28

People are basing the you can't be racist against white people to loving in predominantly white country's, in non white country's they is racism towards whites.

Flammkuchen · 06/02/2022 17:27

You absolutely can be racist to white people! If you refuse to hire someone because of their race, that is race discrimination. And that includes racism against Roma, Irish travellers etc

This nonsense is why Whoopi Goldberg got into trouble for saying the Nazis weren't racist for trying to exterminate the Jews and Roma to create a 'master race'.

Againstmachine · 06/02/2022 17:26

To the person who said “it’s like racist jokes towards white people have always been acceptable”. Firstly, you can’t be racist to white people. You can make jokes based on stereotypes but that isn’t the same a racism.

Of course you can be racist against any race, the all you can be racist against any race is stupid.

Agrudge · 06/02/2022 17:26

@JuicySatsuma85

Of you can be racist to white people

That myth needs to stop

Racism is the belief that groups of humans possess different behavioral traits corresponding to inherited attributes and can be divided based on the superiority of one race over another

trunktoes · 06/02/2022 17:26

@JuicySatsuma85 eh? What colour are Jews then? What the fuck?

Mydogmylife · 06/02/2022 17:25

@NutellaEllaElla

To be fair Baddiel has apologised a lot for that, is that not enough? It seems a little unreasonable to say he should never speak publically again.
Never apologised to Jason lee though
trunktoes · 06/02/2022 17:25

I fucking hate wokery with a passion. But this is disgusting. People died - it was mass murder. You don't joke about the holocaust because nothing about it is remotely funny

Swipe left for the next trending thread