Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Carr’s Racist Joke

189 replies

Knutface · 06/02/2022 13:28

www.theguardian.com/culture/2022/feb/04/jimmy-carr-condemned-for-joke-about-gypsies-in-netflix-special

Not something that I find funny but it has highlighted something. Racism against Roma/Sinti people is widely acceptable and not treated in the same away as racism against other minorities. Years ago I worked for a local authority in an area with a fair few traveller sites and noticed that staff that would never dream of using slurs against black or Asian people openly did so against travellers. AIBU to think that this is the ‘joke’? Anti Roma sentiment is unfortunately widespread.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VestaTilley · 08/02/2022 20:59

It’s disgraceful what he said - it’s not acceptable and it shouldn’t have been made.

If the joke was meant to expose the double standard then that’s a bloody insulting way of making the point.

SnowFlo · 08/02/2022 20:57

Hey, Jimmy, just so you know in future, a joke is supposed to be funny.

And people laughed, therefore it was funny to them. Humour is subjective. I find Only Fools and Horses funny but plenty don't and will say it's "not funny". Funny isn't a fact, it's an opinion.

Againstmachine · 08/02/2022 20:13

So either not watched it or don't think they are worthwhile mentioning which means that it doesn't matter they also was persecute and killed in the Holocaust

I think it's they haven't watched and getting triggered by the headlines.

WingingItSince1973 · 08/02/2022 18:20

@Snoozysnoozy

170+ messages and nobody had mentioned the fact that he goes on to further insult Jehovah's Witnesses. Meaning that an awful lot of you either haven't watched the show and don't know the context, set up and follow up; or you have seen the test and saw the part about Jehovah's Witnesses and don't give a fuck.
Yep so many threads about this, so many comments on other platforms yet no one mentions the comments about JWs at the end. So either not watched it or don't think they are worthwhile mentioning which means that it doesn't matter they also was persecute and killed in the Holocaust
Balaboostah · 08/02/2022 00:53

@Againstmachine

What happened to "If you don't like it, don't watch"? I've seen the portion being discussed here. I didn't like it and I'm not going to watch any more.

The problem is most complaining haven't watched any of it they are complaining and jumping on a bandwagon

I don't think that's a problem! The way it's described captures very well what Carr did and said. To a certain extent, we need comedians like Carr to shine a mirror at us and see the ugliness which is there, intentionally or not. The fact that there were gales of laughter from the audience. I can totally see Carr making an offensive joke about Jews or Blacks but I can also the audience reacting differently. I don't think it was a funny joke and I'm not sure it's "educational" component justifies the offence. I don't find his other 'edgy' jokes about rape etc funny either. But intent is important and it's not like he's writing jokes for 'der spiegel' or making jokes about tutsis being cockroaches on Radio Libre des Milles Collines. The racism, ignorance and prejudice exist and it's good to talk about it (although shame it took an offensive joke to do so).
CPL593H · 07/02/2022 23:53

OK. I felt it only right after previous comments to watch the section on the Jehovah's Witnesses and to be honest, I think it goes even further from any valid point he could claim as 'education', in terms of mockery in search of a laugh.

Thank you to the people who pointed this out.

Againstmachine · 07/02/2022 21:45

What happened to "If you don't like it, don't watch"? I've seen the portion being discussed here. I didn't like it and I'm not going to watch any more.

The problem is most complaining haven't watched any of it they are complaining and jumping on a bandwagon

CPL593H · 07/02/2022 21:38

@Againstmachine

170+ messages and nobody had mentioned the fact that he goes on to further insult Jehovah's Witnesses. Meaning that an awful lot of you either haven't watched the show and don't know the context, set up and follow up; or you have seen the test and saw the part about Jehovah's Witnesses and don't give a fuck.

Because most people complaining haven't watched a minute of it and are being offended by what they are told.

What happened to "If you don't like it, don't watch"? I've seen the portion being discussed here. I didn't like it and I'm not going to watch any more.
Againstmachine · 07/02/2022 20:48

170+ messages and nobody had mentioned the fact that he goes on to further insult Jehovah's Witnesses. Meaning that an awful lot of you either haven't watched the show and don't know the context, set up and follow up; or you have seen the test and saw the part about Jehovah's Witnesses and don't give a fuck.

Because most people complaining haven't watched a minute of it and are being offended by what they are told.

CPL593H · 07/02/2022 20:35

This is off topic but not really. In one of his books Stuart Maconie talks about filming in Yorkshire and someone (not part of the production) made a 'joke' about the Moors murders. He said the whole crew, consisting of arty, edgy London creative types fell into a horrified silence. Noone laughed.

I think this is what bothers me most. Jimmy Carr's audience laughed and applauded. Maybe some of them realised any ironic tone he meant, maybe some will think about it later and challenge themselves and find out more, but I am very sure that many of the audience and those who've seen it since will laugh because they don't give a damn about the genocide of the Roma and Sinti. There have been comments on this thread (thankfully only a few) that talked about negative experience of travellers/ some traveller behaviour in a way that is utterly grotesque in the context of the mass murder he referenced.

The hate is real and it doesn't need feeding in the name of 'humour'. I am certain, though, that everyone in that audience would have personal a cut off point where he went too far, because everyone has one. I applaud those standing up for the memory of hundreds of thousands of innocent people who have been turned into a cheap "Oooo this will end my career" joke by a dark haired version of Max Headroom. I'm sure he won't be offended by that comparison, nothing off limits, remember?

MeSanniesareBrannies · 07/02/2022 20:32

@Mouthymum82

Humour should not be censored. It’s called freedom of speech. If you don’t like it, you can always watch something else.
We don’t have freedom of speech in this country. We have a qualified right to freedom of expression, which may be subject to formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society.
Agrudge · 07/02/2022 18:45

@Snoozysnoozy

170+ messages and nobody had mentioned the fact that he goes on to further insult Jehovah's Witnesses. Meaning that an awful lot of you either haven't watched the show and don't know the context, set up and follow up; or you have seen the test and saw the part about Jehovah's Witnesses and don't give a fuck.
This is half the problem what's being said is taken out the context of the segment he was doing.

I haven't watched it yet but will do

Snoozysnoozy · 07/02/2022 18:40

170+ messages and nobody had mentioned the fact that he goes on to further insult Jehovah's Witnesses. Meaning that an awful lot of you either haven't watched the show and don't know the context, set up and follow up; or you have seen the test and saw the part about Jehovah's Witnesses and don't give a fuck.

ExtraOnion · 07/02/2022 18:30

@Mouthymum82

Humour should not be censored. It’s called freedom of speech. If you don’t like it, you can always watch something else.
Anything else we shouldn’t censor - or just things that some people find funny? Is racism now allowed, as long as there is a punchline ? Can I start using racist / homophobic / discriminatory language in everyday life, as long as someone finds it funny ?

Ricky Gervais uses the word “Mong” .. is it ok that he uses it, as he has a Netflix Special - or is it free reign on that ?

Mouthymum82 · 07/02/2022 18:25

Humour should not be censored. It’s called freedom of speech. If you don’t like it, you can always watch something else.

FOJN · 07/02/2022 18:18

Another comedians take on the joke.

Leo Kearse

pigsDOfly · 07/02/2022 18:10

donquixotedelamancha That's true, the 'dark material' programme did come with very clear warnings so people should have known what to expect.

Unfortunately, while he might very well be attempting to broach such subjects, as some posters on here claim, in a satirical way, I fear there will be a good many people in his audience who are cheering him on in a sense of shared racism.

Racism hasn't gone away. It's very much alive and I'm not sure how helpful he's being with this type of material if he's aiming to see it's demise.

Marmarind · 07/02/2022 16:14

I'm very much in the "joke about anything" camp and have never really felt "that's too far" regarding a joke, however I think public shows and the like shouldn't feature racist or ableist jokes etc. Keep them private among other people who also joke about anything.

Mamamia7962 · 07/02/2022 15:57

When people go to see Jimmy Carr they know the type of joke that he will tell. If people don't like it they don't have to go and see him. People vote with their pockets. His shows are always sold out which proves there's an awful lot of people who find him funny.

Balaboostah · 07/02/2022 15:47

[quote trunktoes]@JuicySatsuma85 eh? What colour are Jews then? What the fuck?[/quote]
Indeed, what colour are Jews? Ethiopian Jews for example? Or Indian Jews?

Ask a white supremacist if Jews are white. See what they say.

donquixotedelamancha · 07/02/2022 15:34

Society does censor itself and while society has moved on from accepting tv programmes based on racist 'jokes' and racial and sexual stereotyping it seems that society doesn't expect the same standards to apply to people like Jimmy Carr.

I don't disagree (apart from with the fools who think government censorship or twitter mob rule would be best).

I often watch old films and tv programmes on the 'Talking Pictures' channel and they issue warnings all the time about the fact that some of the content might offend, and whenever they do it's generally pretty mild stuff and very, very rarely overtly racist.

It's in a nextflix special called 'his dark material', it's 18 rated, has a written warning for 'language sexual content and discrimination' and he opens with a very clear verabal warning about what sort of content he will cover. I think that's reasonable.

I also think there is an important difference between the worst of Jimmy Carr's 'racism' and the mildest of the 70s stuff you refer to. For me the target of the joke being vulnerable is the line I'd like to see private business draw. I want people to be able joke about any subject, no matter how bad, because the cost to stop that is too high.

SoftSheen · 07/02/2022 11:52

MorningStarling humour is subjective, there is no right or wrong

The Nazis used 'humour' as a major part of their propaganda against Jewish people. Was this wrong?

I don't think that humour which offends people is necessarily wrong, however Jimmy Carr did cross a line here.

MorningStarling · 07/02/2022 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Porcupineintherough · 07/02/2022 11:30

Yeah, YANBU at all unfortunately. Sad

pigsDOfly · 07/02/2022 11:29

donquixotedelamancha Yes, you're right, censorship per se is a path we should steer well clear of but, like it or not, there are certain things that are not longer deemed acceptable to 'joke' about.

Such television programmes as 'Love thy neighbour' or 'Please Sir' that were made in the 70s would most definitely not be made today because their racist content would be considered completely unacceptable.

I often watch old films and tv programmes on the 'Talking Pictures' channel and they issue warnings all the time about the fact that some of the content might offend, and whenever they do it's generally pretty mild stuff and very, very rarely overtly racist.

Society does censor itself and while society has moved on from accepting tv programmes based on racist 'jokes' and racial and sexual stereotyping it seems that society doesn't expect the same standards to apply to people like Jimmy Carr.

Swipe left for the next trending thread