Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi's £200 loan is really a sneaky tax

194 replies

GreenLunchBox · 06/02/2022 10:21

So you are not allowed to refuse this 'loan' and from April 2023 everybody's bill will go up by £40 a year regardless of if you received the £200 or not.

twitter.com/MartinSLewis/status/1489584984235065344?t=joBqwQ20p5VPx3EKYUT2tQ&s=19

Some scenarios:

  1. A married couple receive the £200 now then split up. In their new houses they each pay back the £200 over the next five years. So it's actually COST the couple £200

  2. 5 students in a house share receive the £200 between them (so receive £40 each). They all move out and then each get charged £200 separately over the next five years. Government gets £1000 when they were only given £200.

  3. A young person living at home about to move out. They didn't receive the £200 as it went to their parents, but they have to pay an extra £200 on their bill over the next five years

When you scale this up the government are going to make an absolute bloody fortune from this - doubling or quadrupling their money in some cases whilst pretending to be the good guy.
What a racket they're running.

AIBU to say we need to stop this racket?

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 06/02/2022 11:29

I didn't say it was the right something. I think it's a "quick think of something before we get more bad headlines" something.

GreenLunchBox · 06/02/2022 11:27

I don't want this fucking money. Can I not refuse it?

What happens if you’re on a top up meter?

Rishi's £200 loan is really a sneaky tax
OP posts:
CharacterForming · 06/02/2022 11:27

@Octomore

Even if your household doesn't change over the next 5 year's, I don't understand what the benefit of this is?

Is there any evidence that energy prices will go back down in 2023? Because if not, all we are doing is accepting more pain in future for less pain this year. It's got no purpose at all.

I think the best guess is that world energy prices, and gas prices in particular will probably go down over the next couple of years yes. Not guaranteed, but likely. The Treasury are intervening this way because that's what they expect - if they didn't then this plan would go from "flawed" to completely pointless.

Irritatingly site is preventing me from posting graph, but wholesale gas prices are volatile and do decrease as well as increase depending on a bunch of global political factors.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 06/02/2022 11:26

Rishi Sunak is positively dangerous and anyone who’s taken in by his slick PR campaign is very naive. He would be a disaster as PM. I work in an area loosely associated and can see how dangerous his influence is to normal workers. He. Does. Not. Care.

If he replaces Boris, we’ll look back at the Boris years as the good old days. Slash and burn, transformations for the sake of it, cut staff numbers and resources to show healthier balance sheets. He’s 100% only on the side of the 0000.1%. When the petrol crisis hit, he was in California at one of his twelve houses on holiday calling it a work trip as he had one meeting. He doesn’t give a shit about you and your ability to pay. His coffee cup costs the same as the ‘loan’.

Many people don’t want this loan but watch how hard they will pursue you to claim it back. ‘Oh you missed the letter explaining the convoluted way to repay? Here’s a fine on top of the loan’. Easily managed to write off furlough and PPE fraud and track and trace multi billions though.

HelloFrostyMorning · 06/02/2022 11:26

@MintJulia

But every person who receives a £200 payment and then dies, or who moves abroad, or moves in with someone else, or moves back home to parents won't pay it back.

Tax take in this country has always worked on the circumstances of the individual on the day. It's nothing new.

There's going to be a lot less of THEM lot though.
HelloFrostyMorning · 06/02/2022 11:24

I don't want this fucking money. Can I not refuse it?

HelloFrostyMorning · 06/02/2022 11:23

If that is all true, that's repugnant. And actually fucking THEFT! Why is this being allowed to happen? If they give £200 to a couple/family/house share of 5, how can they demand £200 from EACH PERSON later on? This isn't right surely?

Eleganz · 06/02/2022 11:23

@countrygirl99

Something needed to be done. This is something so it was done. £200 off makes a good sound bite and they hope everyone is distracted by something else by the time the £40 hits
They are hoping that this is a temporary blip due to the rise in demand related to increased economic activity as we come out of the pandemic. It is an utter punt and also suggests that we are in for more steep rises in October when this loan is enforced on us all. What happens if energy prices remain high into next year and beyond and people continue to struggle in the run up to the election and the government is forcing them to pay more for their bills then?

They've also shafted already cash strapped local councils by forcing them to take the short term brunt of this as far as I can tell. I doubt the treasury is going to cover the shortfall in council budgets.

It is the typical MO of this government, all nice words and no actual cash and then blame everyone else when it doesn't work apart from those making the money behind the scenes.

GreenLunchBox · 06/02/2022 11:23

@countrygirl99

Something needed to be done. This is something so it was done. £200 off makes a good sound bite and they hope everyone is distracted by something else by the time the £40 hits
Something needed to be done?

How about cutting VAT on domestic fuel like Michael Gove said would happen if we leave the EU? twitter.com/Number10cat/status/1489549485374152705?t=4ri2b7saBnuf-69ACSkALQ&s=19

Funny that France have limited the energy price rise to 4% for their citizens compared to our 54%, and Spain and Poland have cut VAT on fuel. Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't these countries in the EU? 🤔

OP posts:
bindud · 06/02/2022 11:20

I said it on another thread is it to help the energy companies, it doesn't make sense otherwise.

Ifailed · 06/02/2022 11:19

for a start it's charged at household level rather than individual level.

My gas and electric bills are in my name, they are not charged to "the household", as I suspect everyone else's bills are.

MyMoneyIsAllSpent · 06/02/2022 11:18

I don't want it and I don't see how I can legally be forced to have it.

WindyState · 06/02/2022 11:17

It's a shit idea from the tories. What's new?

Birdkin · 06/02/2022 11:09

What happens if you’re on a top up meter?

MintJulia · 06/02/2022 11:09

But every person who receives a £200 payment and then dies, or who moves abroad, or moves in with someone else, or moves back home to parents won't pay it back.

Tax take in this country has always worked on the circumstances of the individual on the day. It's nothing new.

Octomore · 06/02/2022 11:06

It's not a loan, so of course it won't.

It's a one-off reduction in a household bill, followed by a household levy charged over 5 years. It doesn't meet any of the usual criteria to be considered a 'debt' - for a start it's charged at household level rather than individual level.

Ifailed · 06/02/2022 11:04

presumably this 'forced' loan will also appear on everyone's credit history?

countrygirl99 · 06/02/2022 11:04

Something needed to be done. This is something so it was done.
£200 off makes a good sound bite and they hope everyone is distracted by something else by the time the £40 hits

Octomore · 06/02/2022 11:00

Even if your household doesn't change over the next 5 year's, I don't understand what the benefit of this is?

Is there any evidence that energy prices will go back down in 2023? Because if not, all we are doing is accepting more pain in future for less pain this year. It's got no purpose at all.

CharacterForming · 06/02/2022 11:00

OFGEM do place restrictions on the standard rates that can be charged for energy, so the energy companies can't just say "oh they're used to paying an extra forty quid, let's just bundle it into the rates".

OFGEM could in theory have ordered the energy companies to have continued to charge the same amount as last year, but that would demonstrably have resulted in companies going bust or leaving the market.

mibbelucieachwell · 06/02/2022 10:59

It'll be interesting how Scotland allocates the money it gets to help with energy bills in Scottish homes.

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/02/2022 10:57

Basically, it should never have been phrased as a loan.
It should have been described as what it is, spreading the cost of electricity at a population level over the next 5 years, in the hope bills don’t continue to massively increase. It isn’t a loan and it’s ridiculous of them to describe it as such.
Maybe it’s a loan to the energy companies, that they then collect through us ie the government says to them “let every household off £200 this year and we’ll cover it - then charge every household an extra £40 for the next 5 years to pay us back” but it’s definitely not a loan to us.

HelenaHandcart0 · 06/02/2022 10:55

And having gone up by £40 I doubt it will ever go down by £40.

Wfhquery · 06/02/2022 10:53

It works both ways though, couple living seperately each get £200 each but only pay back one. People that die or move into a nursing home won’t pay back. As someone said ahead I think it’s just a blunt tool for working it out rather than active way to make money. My fear is that with the £40 being added to hohe standing charge the standing charge will prob never go back now which will be the energy companies getting the money

SickAndTiredAgain · 06/02/2022 10:52

@InMySpareTime

It should be balanced out by singles coupling up (so only paying once between them) and people who die or emigrate in the 5 years after receiving the money.
That’s not a lot of use to the individuals who will end up paying more though.