Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hi viz doesn’t work if a driver isn’t looking & they don’t look

109 replies

ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 08:23

twitter.com/anthonytilghman/status/1489814943859986438?s=21

Wide street, visibility good as from a distance the driver would see the hi viz, the child approaching

Yet none of this worked and the driver failed to stop in time

It’s drivers needing to pay attention as hiviz is just a stick to beat victims with if there not wearing it Aibu

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 08:23

This already happens

There are 8800 people driving that have more than 12 points on a licence, you’re not supposed to drive with more than 12

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 08:17

Sirzy

So you saw them all regardless of what they were wearing and you were paying attention whilst driving

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 08:13

But does that make it pointless?

I didn’t say helmets were pointless, I wrote what’s written below 👇

It’s not a case of helmets being pointless, but they are limited in their protection

I have an anecdote, I known someone who did survive a crash with the car doing 50mph and the cyclist traveling over the car and 55ft along the road, they sustained head injuries- including brain haemorrhage, but they weren’t wearing a helmet. So the medics that told your friend they could have survived I don’t doubt are correct but maybe nothing to do with wearing a helmet

OP posts:
Momicrone · 07/02/2022 08:08

Cars have headlights for seeing stuff in the dark

Sirzy · 07/02/2022 07:49

I drove in the dark this morning. Those on the road who where well lit and in hi vis where an awful lot more visible than those who weren’t. Really strange I know!

Now I didn’t run any of them over but being able to see them earlier obviously makes things safer all around!

lljkk · 07/02/2022 07:33

"where are the measures to tell drivers to actually look? Where, when is on the onus on the driver to pay attention"

In the new Highway code? That has legal penalties implied for inattentive drivers. You know, the one that has a lot of drivers up in arms on Twitter & on platforms on MN, because they might have to give way at junctions -- reports of riders high-fiving & riding 3 abreast to prevent in overtaking a mere 9 hours after the new Code came in. Presumably there are entitled horse riders & pedestrians all over the roads, too.

AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 04:45

@ivykaty44

If a driver is not looking there's not much anyone can do.

Whilst you accept this statement above and tell me I’m bizarre and that my argument isn’t rational

Why not stop them driving, retrain these drivers not paying attention or driving without looking and preventing them from operating dangerous machines until they do look?

This already happens.
AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 04:41

@ivykaty44

AlDanvers not seeing anything to back up what you’ve said?

I still stand by if a driver isn’t looking no amount of high viz clothing is going to prevent a driver crashing.

As for all road users need to pay attention, the two horse riders were paying attention as was the traffic lady, but the drivers poising the most danger weren’t, surely those posing the most danger need to be paying attention the most.

He might have also survived if he had worn a helmet. He might not have, do you think that means helmets are pointless?

He might have survived if he was wearing a helmet, helmets are tested to 15mph and the driver was traveling at 20mph so how have you got to the conclusion he may have survived wearing a helmet?

It’s not a case of helmets being pointless, but they are limited in their protection

Your point isnt coherent.

In those examples, the car driver wasn't paying attention. That doesn't mean all car drivers are not paying attention and hi vis doesn't work.

Also not sure what you point is about the helmets. Helmets are tested up to 15 mile an hour, doesn't mean they don't provide some protection in crashes about that. I say he may have survived because his wife asked, the medical professionals, and was told it was possible.

Once I was driving and a bike came out of an alley straight and into the road, i didnt hit him. He fell off because he panicked when he realised he went straught into the path of car and fell off. I emergency braked. Does that mean all bike users ride are like that and there's no point cyclists or road users taking other precautions? Because some cyclists dont pay attention even for their own sake? So let's scrap it all?

Some road users don't pay attention. Some drink and are a danger. Nowhere near all. That doesn't mean and safety equipment is pointless. It's still have saved lives. It's just not saving all lives. But does that make it pointless?

steff13 · 06/02/2022 23:33

You could argue that the crossing person is also at fault. They allowed a child to cross whilst a car was driving toward them.

Yeah I'm not sure where this was in the US, but where I live the crossing guard won't let the kids enter the crosswalk until all the cars have stopped, and would have stopped the kid from doing so if they tried. The car was speeding, too, I think. The speed limit in school zones is 20 MPH.

HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat · 06/02/2022 23:22

@ivykaty44

If a driver is not looking there's not much anyone can do.

Whilst you accept this statement above and tell me I’m bizarre and that my argument isn’t rational

Why not stop them driving, retrain these drivers not paying attention or driving without looking and preventing them from operating dangerous machines until they do look?

That's a different argument than you've been making. You have been basically saying hi-viz is pointless as drivers don't look. Drivers are prosecuted and potentially banned for driving without due care & attention or driving dangerously but that has no bearing on road users being as visible as possible.
ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 22:27

Nobody really thinks hi vis makes drivers more likely to give you space - they think it makes drivers more likely to see you and not hit you, even if in not hitting you they only give you 3 inches of space.

It’s required and has been for many years that drivers give 1.5 meters in U.K. or they can be prosecuted, therefore a driver would face prosecution for being 3inches away - a law abiding driver would see you and give you the required space

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 22:22

If a driver is not looking there's not much anyone can do.

Whilst you accept this statement above and tell me I’m bizarre and that my argument isn’t rational

Why not stop them driving, retrain these drivers not paying attention or driving without looking and preventing them from operating dangerous machines until they do look?

OP posts:
HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat · 06/02/2022 22:09

You can easily Google it but if you need a link www.gov.uk/government/news/motorcycle-safety-campaign-aim-to-make-drivers-think

I can't believe you think you are creating a rationale argument. If a driver is not looking there's not much anyone can do. The more visible you make yourself the lower your risk of going unseen in most circumstances.
Road safety is attempting to cover all risks. Visibility is decreased by shadows, bright sunlight, darkness, fog and more. The campaign to be visible is to combat that.
You are picking on a single viewpoint quite bizarrely.

ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 21:40

AlDanvers not seeing anything to back up what you’ve said?

I still stand by if a driver isn’t looking no amount of high viz clothing is going to prevent a driver crashing.

As for all road users need to pay attention, the two horse riders were paying attention as was the traffic lady, but the drivers poising the most danger weren’t, surely those posing the most danger need to be paying attention the most.

He might have also survived if he had worn a helmet. He might not have, do you think that means helmets are pointless?

He might have survived if he was wearing a helmet, helmets are tested to 15mph and the driver was traveling at 20mph so how have you got to the conclusion he may have survived wearing a helmet?

It’s not a case of helmets being pointless, but they are limited in their protection

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 06/02/2022 20:01

Non of what you posted shows it has little impact.

Its shows that hi vis isn't guaranteed to keep you safe. No one has ever said it is.

It does increase visibility and reduces liklihood of being hit. It makes it safer not completely safe.

Unfortunately a man local to me who had no hi vis, no helmet or lights was killed a week ago. Cycling in the dark and thick fog on a road that's 60mph. The car that hit him was only doing 20 due to the conditions. If he had hi vis on he would have likey been seen. If the car driver wasnt paying attention of course or wouldn't help. Bit the vast majority of car users do pay attention.

He might have also survived if he had worn a helmet. He might not have, do you think that means helmets are pointless?

All road users need to pay attention and most do.

AlDanvers · 06/02/2022 19:52

@ivykaty44

It’s not an either or situation

But whilst we keep telling rd users to be visible, where are the measures to tell drivers to actually look? Where ir when is on the onus on the driver to pay attention

The film shown was broad daylight - yet pp talks about dark conditions making it hard to see, it’s always excuses for the drivers

we give victims half the burden surely we should shift and give perpetrators 100% of the burden and that would make roads safer

Of course there is onus on the drivers to pay attention. Driving without due care and attention is an actual thing, isn't it?

Its not either or.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/02/2022 19:44

Whilst it is abhorrent that Churchill tried to weasel out of paying compensation in that case, I'm not sure that article holds a lot of water.

Firstly, most trivially, regarding the studies they describe, if every one of those outfits was treated the same by drivers, that somewhat undermines the author's previous findings that "drivers leave less space when overtaking cyclists wearing helmets", as some of those outfits have helmets and others don't. Possibly this is controlled for in the actual study, possibly it isn't. As they haven't referenced the full study, assuming it is published, it's hard to know without doing further digging.

Secondly, their study didn't seem to look at how likely those cyclists were to be involved in actual accidents, only how drivers treated them when they did see them. Presumably this is a consequence of their trial design - without seeing the full, published data, it's all a bit pointless. We don't even know the conditions they conducted their study in - in broad daylight hi vis will affect a driver's responses less than in poor visibility.

But it's pretty meaningless - drivers who saw them weren't very considerate. Nobody really thinks hi vis makes drivers more likely to give you space - they think it makes drivers more likely to see you and not hit you, even if in not hitting you they only give you 3 inches of space. To claim that hi vis has no effect, you'd need to collate data from actual accidents and work out how many were wearing hi vis, how many weren't, and, from there, work out whether hi vis has any effect on the relative risk of actually being hit by a car. Maybe someone's done this - if so, it would be more compelling evidence than the data referred to in that article.

ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 19:29

irishcycle.com/2019/10/25/minister-ross-promotes-high-vis-with-deceptive-image-of-child-crossing-road-blacked-out/

www.eta.co.uk/2017/10/20/the-british-curse-of-high-vis/
Dr Ian Walker, Senior Lecturer in Psychology at Bath University

both riders wearing highviz @HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat not obtuse - just pointing out that high viz seems to have little effect on driver and actually we maybe safer using other means to keep people safe on the roads. Im not aware of the campaign you mention and you don't link to it?
OP posts:
CaptainThe95thRifles · 06/02/2022 18:41

It's worth being aware of the limitations of hi vis - in the dark you need reflective clothing and lights to be visible, and different colours of hi vis are more appropriate at different times of the year / different situations.

But you should still aim to wear the most visible combinations as much as possible on the roads because, while not perfect, it will definitely help.

HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat · 06/02/2022 18:36

Op you are just being obtuse. Of course it is sensible to make yourself visible. Drivers should pay attention; contrary to your assertions there are campaigns aimed at drivers - for example the one telling drivers to watch out for motorbikes.
I live in a rural area where pedestrians, cyclists and animals can be hard to spot on the roads. Horses on a nearby common had reflective collars introduced a couple of years ago and none of them have been hit by vehicles to date (long may that continue) which would suggest that you are incorrect and improved visibility can have a positive effect.

TheVanguardSix · 06/02/2022 18:27

Ok, OP... you clearly are the winner of the race to the bottom.

Sirzy · 06/02/2022 18:18

are you seriously argue that someone walking along the road dressed all in black is as safe as someone wearing hi vis? Confused

FloBot7 · 06/02/2022 17:46

You seem really determined to get hit by a car...

You've mentioned there are studies that prove high vis isn't effective in preventing accidents but haven't linked to them. You're now claiming the photo is fake but haven't linked to proof of that either.

At the end of the day there are people far more experience and qualified than you whose whole job is to keep people safe. They recommend high vis. If they didn't, construction companies and emergency services wouldn't spend an absolute fortune kitting their employees out in high visibility clothes.

ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 17:34

Of course it doesn’t prevent crashes. But increasing your visibility makes it less likely you will be hit.

not sure what the difference is between a crash and being ht by a car?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 17:29

Sirzy

it was finally admitted the photo was fake, they altered the photograph

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread