Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hi viz doesn’t work if a driver isn’t looking & they don’t look

109 replies

ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 08:23

twitter.com/anthonytilghman/status/1489814943859986438?s=21

Wide street, visibility good as from a distance the driver would see the hi viz, the child approaching

Yet none of this worked and the driver failed to stop in time

It’s drivers needing to pay attention as hiviz is just a stick to beat victims with if there not wearing it Aibu

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 16:34

It's impossible to prove it one way or another through a scientific study

So why put so much emphasis on something that you don't even know works very well in all areas? Why not concentrate efforts on actions that do work, first and foremost instead of a blanket obsession with high viz, regardless of whether daylight, light streets, city centres or dark country lanes

OP posts:
FloBot7 · 07/02/2022 15:08

I'll try that again..

*The only way they could do a study is if they send people down the same roads in the same conditions, wearing high-vis, black clothes or neutral clothes then calculate how many get hit.

FloBot7 · 07/02/2022 15:06

It's impossible to prove it one way or another through a scientific study. The only way they could is to do a study is if they send people down the same roads in the same conditions, wearing high-vis, black clothes or neutral clothes then calculate how many get hit. Hardly an ethical study or one any of us would sign up for!

I work in a rural area that is so dark there's an observatory here so I find it so easy to see the difference. Its a badly lit area and most roads are 60mph rather than the 30mph in a well lit city. The difference between seeing someone from 200m away vs 20m away could be life or death due to the longer stopping distance. Even the most attentive driver in the world can't defy physics.

The local horse riders demonstrate it perfectly. The riders all wear high-vis vests and drape some sort of high vis cloak over their horse's back end. It's rare to see them in bad conditions but I came across one at dusk last year and not only could I see the yellow and reflective patches well in advance, the shape let me know it was a horse. I knew to slow down well ahead of time and pass slowly to avoid spooking it (and potentially injuring the rider).

MorningStarling · 07/02/2022 14:56

Why wouldn't you wear hi-vis clothing if cycling or walking down an unlit country lane at night? It's madness, being more visible increases the chance of someone seeing you. Nothing can rule out the chance you will encounter a driver who isn't paying attention or otherwise not behaving correctly, but hi-vis increases the chance of you being seen by a driver who is only half-concentrating.

A book I read when considering taking up cycling a few years ago (fortunately I saw sense) was Bike by David North. The author listed the causes of accidents involving cyclists, in order of frequency:

  1. Exiting a driveway in front of an oncoming vehicle.
  2. Turning in front of a passing vehicle.
  3. The motorist was overtaking the cyclist, cause unclear.
  4. Riding on the wrong side of the road.
  5. Riding on the wrong side of the road and then turning across traffic.
  6. The motorist was overtaking the cyclist and failed to see him or her.
  7. The cyclist lost control and swerved into the path of the vehicle.
  8. The cyclist made a normal turn but ignored oncoming traffic.
  9. The motorist lost control of the car and struck the cyclist.

As the author goes on to note, the cyclist could have avoided all the above, except perhaps the 3rd and 9th ones. Even then, it's possible that poor visibility could be part of the cause in some of those cases - a driver who is crashing but is aware of where a cyclist is has a better chance of avoiding them.

As PP said, it's important that people wear the right hi-viz clothing. If you buy cheap equipment it might not meet the relevant standards. Stick to reputable brands.

Shadappayourface · 07/02/2022 14:16

Firstly that Hi-vis wouldn't be accepted in industries where one needs to be worn. It doesn't have reflective strips and also doesn't look to be the right orange colour. A lot of people buy knock-off versions which don't meet the standards.

Regardless of the above, the person is wearing bright clothing and the conditions are not too dark so quite clearly this driver wasn't looking where they were driving and were distracted by phone etc. So this is a case of reckless driving, not sure what your hi-vis argument has to do with anything as you've found one example of a poor driver to argue against people taking precautions by wearing high visibility clothing that could save their lives.

loveisanopensore · 07/02/2022 13:55

www.cyclingweekly.com/news/latest-news/what-is-the-evidence-that-wearing-hi-vis-clothing-makes-you-a-safer-cyclist-358674

People in urban areas shouldn't have to dress like traffic cones just to go about their business.

ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 13:48

You want proof, it's safer on roads if people can see you?

that wasn't what I asked, I asked for proof that high viz reduces the risk of crashes

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 13:42

because they are the most dangerous on the roads, they don't kerb their behaviour but just continue to collect points and the most likely to kill

Not nessecarily. You are assuming no points = safe driver.

if its irritating then show me that by wearing high viz prevents and reduces the risk drivers crashing into people and other cars?

You want proof, it's safer on roads if people can see you?

ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 13:30

Why are you concentrating on a small amount of drivers who haven't had their license removed?

because they are the most dangerous on the roads, they don't kerb their behaviour but just continue to collect points and the most likely to kill

OP you're like a dog with a bone. Everyone is pointing out that it isn't an either/or situation. Why not just ask "AIBU to want bad drivers off the road?". We'd all agree with you, I don't like that exceptions to driving bans can be abused either. Your current suggestion that High-vis and reflective wear are useless is really bloody irritating. Are you really incapable of understanding the difference between reducing risk and preventing risk?

if its irritating then show me that by wearing high viz prevents and reduces the risk drivers crashing into people and other cars?

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 12:52

@ivykaty44

However, that's a relatively small amount of drivers. My point was that they are allowed to drive.

you didn't answer the question though? what training do they get to retain their licence with over 12 points on their licence? what punishment do they get whilst still being able to drive?

whilst the emphasis is on hi viz rather than taking bad drivers off the roads, the problems will not diminish

a distracted driver on the phone gets 6 points, they aren't banned or retrained - they can commit the same offence a week later and still retain their licence

and those small amount of bad drivers, are left to continue driving - doesn't make sense to me

If you have your license taken off you, you do have to do your test again.

Why are you concentrating on a small amount of drivers who haven't had their license removed?

The emphasis is not on wearing hi vis. The emphasis is on car drivers. There's also just some focus on wearing hi vis.

I think you need to look up what getting caught using your phone at the wheel, actually means. You can lose your license immediately, depending on how long you have been passed.

A small amount of people retain their license. Again, how does this impact wether hi vis is helpful or not?

FloBot7 · 07/02/2022 12:31

whilst the emphasis is on hi viz rather than taking bad drivers off the roads, the problems will not diminish

OP you're like a dog with a bone. Everyone is pointing out that it isn't an either/or situation. Why not just ask "AIBU to want bad drivers off the road?". We'd all agree with you, I don't like that exceptions to driving bans can be abused either. Your current suggestion that High-vis and reflective wear are useless is really bloody irritating. Are you really incapable of understanding the difference between reducing risk and preventing risk?

ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 12:15

However, that's a relatively small amount of drivers. My point was that they are allowed to drive.

you didn't answer the question though? what training do they get to retain their licence with over 12 points on their licence? what punishment do they get whilst still being able to drive?

whilst the emphasis is on hi viz rather than taking bad drivers off the roads, the problems will not diminish

a distracted driver on the phone gets 6 points, they aren't banned or retrained - they can commit the same offence a week later and still retain their licence

and those small amount of bad drivers, are left to continue driving - doesn't make sense to me

OP posts:
loveisanopensore · 07/02/2022 11:32

There's an argument for hi viz and reflective material in poorly lit areas.
However most of the time it's drivers not looking, speeding, looking at phones.
Our lollipop lady was nearly hit last week and she is top to toe orange and yellow with a massive sign. Driver had broken a red light and swung around her.

AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 11:24

@ivykaty44

If its at the courts discretion, then they are allowed to drive. That doesn't mean there's no punsihment in place for people who drive poorly.

So what is their punishment if they get to keep their licence and then reoffend, which sadly happens countless times - why is society allowing drivers with 12 chances already more chances without stopping them from driving?

I would have thought given 4 chances or 2 chances would be enough to take away a licence and get them to re take a test and have intensive training if they want to drive again

I agree. I think that's one of the things that needs changing.

However, that's a relatively small amount of drivers. My point was that they are allowed to drive.

It still doesn't make hi vis wear pointless.

ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 10:11

eurochick That those operating the car need to have more onus on them to be careful, retested, banned if they don’t take care and not allowed to keep driving and less focus on people already taking care on the rds and telling them how avoid being killed

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 10:06

If its at the courts discretion, then they are allowed to drive. That doesn't mean there's no punsihment in place for people who drive poorly.

So what is their punishment if they get to keep their licence and then reoffend, which sadly happens countless times - why is society allowing drivers with 12 chances already more chances without stopping them from driving?

I would have thought given 4 chances or 2 chances would be enough to take away a licence and get them to re take a test and have intensive training if they want to drive again

OP posts:
eurochick · 07/02/2022 08:37

I'm not sure what point you are making. This "I still stand by if a driver isn’t looking no amount of high viz clothing is going to prevent a driver crashing. " is a statement of the bleeding obvious. If a driver isn't looking at the road of course they won't see someone in it, regardless of what they are wearing. I'm not sure anyone is disagreeing with that. It doesn't make hi viz pointless. It's very useful for those times when someone is looking but because of the conditions it is hard to see other road users in dull colours. I live somewhere where many local roads don't have payments. Driving home yesterday we passed two sets of walkers at twilight in green/brown/black outfits. We saw them but quite late as they were camouflaged against the hedges. When I run and cycle around those roads I wear hi viz clothing as I don't want someone seeing me too late. It's not a difficult concept. Of course if someone is not looking at the road they won't see me regardless of outfit.

AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 08:32

@ivykaty44

This already happens

There are 8800 people driving that have more than 12 points on a licence, you’re not supposed to drive with more than 12

Do you mean driving illegally or people who kept their license at the courts discretion?

Because if they are driving illegally, they have been punished and will be further if they are caught. But if they aren't caught, what would you expect to happen?

If its at the courts discretion, then they are allowed to drive. That doesn't mean there's no punsihment in place for people who drive poorly.

No one is disputing people have a responsibility to drive carefully. Some don't. Some people don't act responsibly. They are processes in place to deal with that.

But to pretend everyone else shouldn't try and make themselves as safe as possible le because a small portion of drivers are dickheads, doesn't make sense.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 07/02/2022 08:32

@Sirzy

I drove in the dark this morning. Those on the road who where well lit and in hi vis where an awful lot more visible than those who weren’t. Really strange I know!

Now I didn’t run any of them over but being able to see them earlier obviously makes things safer all around!

Exactly.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 07/02/2022 08:31

@ivykaty44

This already happens

There are 8800 people driving that have more than 12 points on a licence, you’re not supposed to drive with more than 12

Which is a serious problem that successive governments apparently feel no compulsion to fix.
Momicrone · 07/02/2022 08:30

Sirzy, everyone should take personal responsibility but as you're travelling in the the more dangerous vehicle, which has some very handy bright head lights on it, I'd say most of the responsibility is on you

JuergenSchwarzwald · 07/02/2022 08:30

Drivers do need to pay attention but I believe that pedestrians and cyclists need to wear hi vis - or more accurately, something reflective at night and a bright colour in low light. It's also good if other pedestrians can see you on a dark pavement, it's not just about drivers.

torquewench · 07/02/2022 08:25

Motorcyclist here. You could be wearing hi viz, fluorescent helmet and have your headlights on. People still won't see you if they aren't paying attention/looking. And often when they are paying attention, they'll pull out in front of you, whilst looking directly at you, sometimes raising a hand in acknowledgment of your existence as you're trying to figure out how to take evasive action.

AlDanvers · 07/02/2022 08:25

@ivykaty44

But does that make it pointless?

I didn’t say helmets were pointless, I wrote what’s written below 👇

It’s not a case of helmets being pointless, but they are limited in their protection

I have an anecdote, I known someone who did survive a crash with the car doing 50mph and the cyclist traveling over the car and 55ft along the road, they sustained head injuries- including brain haemorrhage, but they weren’t wearing a helmet. So the medics that told your friend they could have survived I don’t doubt are correct but maybe nothing to do with wearing a helmet

Ffs I wasn't referring to just helmets in that quote. Read the paragraph. I was talking about all safety equipment.
Sirzy · 07/02/2022 08:24

I really don’t bet what point your trying to make here. Do you really think people shouldn’t take some personal responsibility?

Should I turn my lights off when driving because obviously being visible doesn’t matter Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread