Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hi viz doesn’t work if a driver isn’t looking & they don’t look

109 replies

ivykaty44 · 06/02/2022 08:23

twitter.com/anthonytilghman/status/1489814943859986438?s=21

Wide street, visibility good as from a distance the driver would see the hi viz, the child approaching

Yet none of this worked and the driver failed to stop in time

It’s drivers needing to pay attention as hiviz is just a stick to beat victims with if there not wearing it Aibu

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CaptainThe95thRifles · 08/02/2022 19:04

Abstract for the study the OP references: researchportal.bath.ac.uk/en/publications/the-influence-of-a-bicycle-commuters-appearance-on-drivers-overta

You can see that they do not conclude, in the abstract at least, that hi vis is pointless - they're quite clear that their study is looking at preventing close overtaking using different outfits, not whether being more visible is advantageous or not.

FloBot7 · 08/02/2022 17:10

@ivykaty44

Well now I'm confused. I said that because it sounded like you wouldn't be satisfied by anything other than definitive proof that one is better than the other. I also said a study like that would be unethical.

perhaps you should read the thread - I did put up a study, so not sure what your "confusion" is about, and no where have I written or implied I needed definite proof - you just made that up to suit your own narrative

Well if you don't need definitive proof then I shall say with confidence, high-vis with reflective patches is better than none. Source: my eyes Grin
AlDanvers · 08/02/2022 16:58

@ivykaty44

Even the suggestion of studying wether people give extra space to Hi vis wearers, wouldn't work. People would know their driving was being studied and so act more cautiously.

I gave you a study on just that...further up the thread and the findings were that the jacket with police written on the back got more room than any other jacket/bib and the drivers weren't warned

I can see a link to an article on an insurance website, that references a study. That has no information on how the study was conducted, how many oberstavations were made, how many locations, what controls etc. The article doesn't contain the link to the study.

Of course police were given more room. That's been know for years, like people slowing down when they see the police. Still doesn't make Hi-Vis pointless or the mean hi-vis is promoted as the priority or that saying hi-vis is a good idea is also saying 'drivers have no responsibility'.

ivykaty44 · 08/02/2022 16:00

Even the suggestion of studying wether people give extra space to Hi vis wearers, wouldn't work. People would know their driving was being studied and so act more cautiously.

I gave you a study on just that...further up the thread and the findings were that the jacket with police written on the back got more room than any other jacket/bib and the drivers weren't warned

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 08/02/2022 15:57

Well now I'm confused. I said that because it sounded like you wouldn't be satisfied by anything other than definitive proof that one is better than the other. I also said a study like that would be unethical.

perhaps you should read the thread - I did put up a study, so not sure what your "confusion" is about, and no where have I written or implied I needed definite proof - you just made that up to suit your own narrative

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 08/02/2022 15:36

Theres 3 situations.

Driver paying partial attention. Either due to another hazard or just not paying full attention. Someone in hi-vis is more likey to get the attention of this driver, than someone dressed in black. So Hi-Vis is worth wearing.

Driver paying complete attention. Someone dressed in black still not be able to be seen, depending on conditions. Someone one hi-vis is far more likey to be seen. You cant avoid something if you can't see and have no clue its there. So worth wearing hi-vis.

Driver no paying attention due to being on their phone, maybe just a dick or whatever. Person dressed in black won't be seen. Person in hi-vis has a slightly higher chance of catching this persons attention and being avoided. So still worth wearing.

Anyone who doesn't see a horse in daylight and or moans that the rider didn't have hi-vis on is a complete idiot. They clearly are not capable of driving daily and so arrogant to think its someone else fault. However, we will live in a world where you need to be caught doing something ro recieve consequences for it. So unless the police catch them or they are caught on camera and its enough to follow up, nothing can be done.

Car drivers are not perfect. Hi-visit wear won't stop every accident. The onus is on car drivers to pay attention and follow the high way code. Hi-vis is part of being safer on the roads.

Its impossible to say how many accidents have not happened due to people wearing hi-vis, because you can't count something that has not happened. Even the suggestion of studying wether people give extra space to Hi vis wearers, wouldn't work. People would know their driving was being studied and so act more cautiously. Also you would need people willing to be hit, because they would need a group wearing clothes where the drivers can not see them, to compare.

I can't see how hi-vis does not help at all and I don't believe (apart from some dicks on facebook) that most people think hi-vis is the be all and end all and solves all the road problems.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 08/02/2022 12:47

@ErrolTheDragon

Anyone who can't see a pony on the road in daylight should be done for driving without due care and attention. And obviously never set wheel in the New Forest, Dartmoor or Exmoor.
Unfortunately the thread on horses on the road suggests some drivers think that it doesn't matter whether they see us in good time, because they're entitled to drive as they bloody well please regardless Angry
ErrolTheDragon · 08/02/2022 12:44

Anyone who can't see a pony on the road in daylight should be done for driving without due care and attention. And obviously never set wheel in the New Forest, Dartmoor or Exmoor.

alloalloallo · 08/02/2022 12:39

But for pedestrians, cyclists, horse riders - simple truth is some drivers are idiots/under the influence. So wearing high viz and being very aware of potential bad drivers is always wise

My DD rides horses and is always covered in hi-viz if she’s on roads, but I do find it that it becomes victim blaming.

I’m always seeing huge rants from drivers on various local Facebook groups about horse riders not wearing hi-vis and it always ends up with drivers justifying their appalling driving around horses with “well, they weren’t wearing hi-vis, what do they expect?” The whole conversation turns then into a debate about horse riders not wearing hi-vis/someone didn’t say thank you 10 years ago/horses shouldn’t be on the road/etc rather than drivers not driving responsibly

As I say, DD always wears hi-vis if she’s on the roads, it’s not negotiable, however, the last near miss she had was in broad daylight when both her and her pony were wearing hi-vis.

BogRollBOGOF · 08/02/2022 10:19

As a pedestrian/ runner, it costs me no disadvantage to wear clothing that optimises my visibility in poor conditions.
I can't control the attention that the road users around me have, but I can give myself the best chance of optimum reaction time to reduce the chance/ severity of an incident.

As a driver, I do my best to focus on the road. I don't look at my phone. I don't look at passengers. But I might focus on hazard 1 (e.g. bike on opposite side of road, vehicle overtaking, mind my road position) and have less reaction time for hazard 2 (runner crossing 50m ahead.) There are lots of things vying for our attention even when concentrating. Every metre of visibility that a person gives themselves helps. I have often been startled by the sudden movement of men (it is for some reason 90% of the time men) dressed entirely in black who simply can not be seen until the last moment because black does a bloody good impression of an invisibility cloak when in shadows, between streetlamps etc. Even on a bright day, low sunshine with glare (especially if surfaces are wet), black can be very difficult to see from the wrong angle.

Reflectives, hi-viz and well chosen colours are no guarentee of safety but they are a decent chance of protecting yourself and minimise the excuse that a distracted road user has for not seeing you.

The video clip is irrelevant to OPs argument. The driver was not paying any due care and attention, although any argument of "I didn't see you" is clearly a sign of their negligence when the person on the crossing was wearing a clear bold colour (although not at UK standards)

Hi viz doesn’t work if a driver isn’t looking & they don’t look
ErrolTheDragon · 08/02/2022 10:12

How can we try to prevent a driver only half concentrating whilst driving down a country lane at night?

Hopefully in the U.K., the newly amended Highway Code with its hierarchy of vulnerability may help a bit. And at least our driving tests do now include hazard perception tests. I don't know if they become more rigorous now , but after passing our driving tests when we lived in Pennsylvania we were horrified by how lax they were.

Of course, anyone driving on autopilot down a country lane at night is asking for trouble - none of the deer we've ever seen in the road have ever been wearing hi-viz.

But for pedestrians, cyclists, horse riders - simple truth is some drivers are idiots/under the influence. So wearing high viz and being very aware of potential bad drivers is always wise.

OneTC · 08/02/2022 09:57

Any cyclist or motorcyclist will be well aware of "sorry mate, didn't see you".

👍

Last time someone said that to me was when they had just pulled away from the lights and straight into the back of me in broad daylight while I waited to cross a junction

Then they drove off while I was checking to see if my bike was alright

Seeline · 08/02/2022 09:53

Do you drive '@ivykaty44 ?

OneTC · 08/02/2022 09:40

Because most drivers don't drive in a way where they are trying to hit someone.

But many drive in a way that hitting people is likely

On Friday I had a driver get way too close to me and he reacted by pulling sharply away, this was on the approach to tower bridge from the north, which is a sketchy junction anyway.

So we pull away from the lights and as we're crossing the bridge the idiot who nearly hit me already is driving about 12" off my back wheel, while we're doing approx 20mph across the bridge, eventually the driver decided they needed to overtake me, despite me doing the speed limit and only having about 1-2 car lengths between me and the vehicle in front, also moving at the same speed, they decided to pass where there's a traffic island 🤦

Some people are just shit drivers, they're the ones that kill people. I have lights on my bike, I have lights on my bag, which has a big reflective panel, the rear triangle on my bike is painted so that the whole section glows under direct light.

All of my collisions have been in daylight and I wear brightly coloured clothes, albeit not hi vis

OneTC · 08/02/2022 09:22

It’s drivers needing to pay attention as hiviz is just a stick to beat victims with if there not wearing it Aibu

👍

FloBot7 · 08/02/2022 09:18

*But for you that’s not good enough, you want a study that hits people, for it to be valid and no other study is acceptable and believe the findings.

*Well now I'm confused. I said that because it sounded like you wouldn't be satisfied by anything other than definitive proof that one is better than the other. I also said a study like that would be unethical.

ivykaty44 · 08/02/2022 07:52

I repeat.. The only way they could do a study is if they send people down the same roads in the same conditions, wearing high-vis, black clothes or neutral clothes then calculate how many get hit.*

The study I put up was how close the drivers got, as they measured the distances and under 1.5 meters is illegal. The findings were that the high viz jackets didn’t make any difference to close passes

But for you that’s not good enough, you want a study that hits people, for it to be valid and no other study is acceptable and believe the findings.

High viz isn’t a magic clock to keep people save & the obsession with putting the victim in high viz is distracting from tackling the real safety measures.

Nothing wrong with high viz having a place in safety measures but it needs to be put in a far lower place and other safety measures brought far higher

OP posts:
stayathomer · 08/02/2022 05:35

Agreed that it's drivers responsibility BUT scarily, not all hi vis is created equal. We used to live down a very dark country road and sometimes you'd come upon a pedestrian, and you'd only see them when you were up very very close, and they'd be wearing hi vis. It used to really shake me (ps you'd be driving extremely slowly as there was a ditch either side).

AlDanvers · 08/02/2022 04:41

Being able to see someone reduces the liklihood they will be hit. Because most drivers don't drive in a way where they are trying to hit someone.

Its not just about people not giving driving their full attention. Even giving your full attention is can be difficult to see people in low light in dark clothing. If you can see then easier, it helps avoid an accident.

As I said above, the man who was killed here wasn't ever seen due to the conditions and no lights or high vis. There was a full investigation to ascertain the fault of the driver. No one said 'ah well no hi vis, not the drivers fault' and left it at that.

I, personally, think anyone on the roads, who is found to not be paying attention should face harsher penalties. But that doesn't make hi vis pointless and nowhere do I ever see the emphasis put on people to wear hi vis.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 08/02/2022 00:11

@FloBot7

I'll try that again..

*The only way they could do a study is if they send people down the same roads in the same conditions, wearing high-vis, black clothes or neutral clothes then calculate how many get hit.

Well, not exactly. There are lots of ways to avoid such an unethical trial design. Looking at accidents that have happened, working out who was wearing hi vis / reflective clothing and who wasn't, compared to levels of hi vis / non-hi vis use in the general population is one fairly blunt way. There's plenty of other ways to control for conditions and circumstances of incidents.

The cycling link upthread actually refers to a few studies which attempt to do that in various ways, and appear to show benefits for hi vis (and I say appear only because I haven't read the full papers - paywalls etc). The article itself isn't great as they try to use the limitations of hi vis in low light to undermine the study/findings, even though they had previously acknowledged that the study looked at hi vis with reflective strips, which is specifically designed to remedy that limitation.

DdraigGoch · 07/02/2022 20:52

Any cyclist or motorcyclist will be well aware of "sorry mate, didn't see you".

Youdoyoutoday · 07/02/2022 20:45

It scares me how many drivers I see checking their phones!

FloBot7 · 07/02/2022 20:42

@ivykaty44

It's impossible to prove it one way or another through a scientific study

So why put so much emphasis on something that you don't even know works very well in all areas? Why not concentrate efforts on actions that do work, first and foremost instead of a blanket obsession with high viz, regardless of whether daylight, light streets, city centres or dark country lanes

I repeat.. *The only way they could do a study is if they send people down the same roads in the same conditions, wearing high-vis, black clothes or neutral clothes then calculate how many get hit.

By all means, volunteer to be part of that study if you wish.

FloBot7 · 07/02/2022 20:41

@ivykaty44

It's impossible to prove it one way or another through a scientific study

So why put so much emphasis on something that you don't even know works very well in all areas? Why not concentrate efforts on actions that do work, first and foremost instead of a blanket obsession with high viz, regardless of whether daylight, light streets, city centres or dark country lanes

Because it works well in most areas? I'm not sure what you're trying to achieve here? I've never seen a blanket obsession with high-vis. Just an acceptance that it's an improvement on no high-vis. You still haven't bothered to link to evidence of two statements you made that I questioned.
ivykaty44 · 07/02/2022 16:40

but hi-vis increases the chance of you being seen by a driver who is only half-concentrating.

How can we try to prevent a driver only half concentrating whilst driving down a country lane at night?

OP posts: