Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not be crowned Queen

483 replies

Viviennemary · 06/02/2022 00:41

I know there are other threads on this but I thought it would be interesting to get a vote. Seems most people are in favour. I'm not

OP posts:
HallieLA · 06/02/2022 15:15

No, she was the other woman. Morally she should not be Queen Consort

OW are vilified on here. Hypocritical if we all think differently in this case.

Maireas · 06/02/2022 15:08

@SenecaFallsRedux

Not the dowager queen?

I'm reminded of a historical drama where someone insisted on being referred to as 'my lady the King's mother' but I don't know if that was factual or not!

If Catherine is widowed while Queen, she will simply be Queen Catherine unless George marries someone named Catherine. The "dowager" and "mother" designation is really only needed if there is another Queen with the same name. The current queen regnant or consort is always simply "the Queen."

The mother of Henry VII, Lady Margaret Beaufort, was known as "my lady the King's Mother." She was never Queen so she could not have that title or be called Queen Mother so, in recognition of her importance to the King (and she was a very formidable and powerful woman), that designation was devised for her. Interestingly, she was Regent for a short time for her grandson Henry VIII, who was not quite 18 when he succeeded to the throne.

Thank you, Seneca - that was the point I was trying to make earlier!
Blackberrybunnet · 06/02/2022 15:00

Not sure why we should even care. By historical standards, Camilla and Charles have behaved as well as most. Camillla will be queen consort by default anyway, whether she is "crowned" or not.

SenecaFallsRedux · 06/02/2022 14:48

Not the dowager queen?

I'm reminded of a historical drama where someone insisted on being referred to as 'my lady the King's mother' but I don't know if that was factual or not!

If Catherine is widowed while Queen, she will simply be Queen Catherine unless George marries someone named Catherine. The "dowager" and "mother" designation is really only needed if there is another Queen with the same name. The current queen regnant or consort is always simply "the Queen."

The mother of Henry VII, Lady Margaret Beaufort, was known as "my lady the King's Mother." She was never Queen so she could not have that title or be called Queen Mother so, in recognition of her importance to the King (and she was a very formidable and powerful woman), that designation was devised for her. Interestingly, she was Regent for a short time for her grandson Henry VIII, who was not quite 18 when he succeeded to the throne.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/02/2022 14:45

@FrecklesMalone

Charles should have been allowed to marry her in the first place. It would have solved a lot of heartache all round.
Exactly.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 06/02/2022 14:42

I think more than enough time has passed since Diana's death for Camilla to be called Queen Consort. In fact, maybe a lot of lives would have been happier if Charles had married Camilla in the first place. Diana would probably still be alive married to some rich banker or earl and ok, Harry and William wouldn't exist, but there would be other children. And we would never have heard of Meghan unless we'd been into Suits,

Someone could write a whole new "what if" history based on this Grin

Nanny0gg · 06/02/2022 14:34

@Chichimcgee

I expect they’d both rather be pottering around doing their own thing.

I wouldn’t be surprised if he abdicated to William

Never going to happen. He's waited a long time for this and I think he feels the same as his mother about 'duty'
TheKeatingFive · 06/02/2022 14:33

I don't think anyone's saying Diana was a saint, but I find it odd that people wouldn't have any sympathy for a 19 year old who found herself in a marriage with an unfaithful, emotionally distant man and in an environment where absolutely no one gave a shit about her.

I was plenty stupid at 19, but had people who cared for me around to guide and support. Fuck knows what my life and decisions would have looked like if I hadn't.

Nanny0gg · 06/02/2022 14:33

@Lockdownlard

But prince Philip was never King Philip? What’s the difference?
He would have been Prince Consort (the other option for Camilla was Princess Consort) but he turned it down.
DrSbaitso · 06/02/2022 14:30

Is it really Diana's fault, and to her detriment, that she never found love again after her divorce? (It was too soon to tell with Dodi Fayed.)

wanttomarryamillionaire · 06/02/2022 14:27

@AlternativePerspective

I really don’t get the love for Diana.

She knew Charles didn’t love her, I don’t believe for one second that she didn’t.

They both cheated on each other, and when they divorced Charles remained true to Camila while Diana shagged any man who would have her, including other women’s husbands.

It’s interesting that people say Kate knew what she was getting into and craved it, but somehow Diana was some poor little innocent.

Diana was shrewd. She knew what she was doing, she knew how to manipulate, and she manipulated her way into being some kind of favoured little princess.

She was no saint.

So Charles and Camilla had an affair. Big deal. Given they’re still together over 40 years on I think it’s safe to say that it wasn’t just some kind of cheap shag. As opposed to Diana and Will carling….

Exactly this
diddl · 06/02/2022 14:23

@CrinklyCraggy

I was 11 1981 and I remember my father talking about how outrageous it was that such a young "girl" was being married off like that. It wasn't normal, even then.

It may well have been normal for the aristocracy, which is why trying to compare any of it to out own lives is nonsense.

Yup!

Diana's Mum was 18 & Johnny Spencer 30 when they married.

So although a generation later, perhaps they didn't particularly baulk at the age difference between Charles & Diana.

Jane Fellowes husband is 16 older than her. They married at 22 &38.

Changechangychange · 06/02/2022 14:19

She, and the rest of them, would be wise not to do anything to turn public opinion against her if it's avoidable. That's why she doesn't use the Princess of Wales title.

Or what, we’ll guillotine them? It doesn’t matter what public opinion of her is. Worst case scenario she retreats to living in one of their many estates and carries on as she has been doing at our expense.

CailleachGranda · 06/02/2022 14:16

@cuparfull

People have V. SHORT memories... Camilla offered Diana up as a brood mare to Charles. It was she that suggested the unworldly young Diana given at that time Camilla was still married. Charles went to see Camilla on the eve of his wedding ( they were still carrying on) and he'd had a ring specially made with their name entwined on it. His heart was never in the marriage and his wife grew to know that. All the undermining of that young girl by those more worldly than her drove her to distraction. Total lack of support by all around Diana led to it all becoming tit for tat. Sadly was never going to end well.

But Camilla was complicit throughout! A malign influence in the marriage. I defy any wife to put up with such treatment.

Oh you are funny

I bet you've got mugs and tea towels at home with Saint Diana on them

CrinklyCraggy · 06/02/2022 14:13

I was 11 1981 and I remember my father talking about how outrageous it was that such a young "girl" was being married off like that. It wasn't normal, even then.

It may well have been normal for the aristocracy, which is why trying to compare any of it to out own lives is nonsense.

Blossomtoes · 06/02/2022 14:11

But why didn't her family tell her? They must have known. Why did they let it go ahead for their 19yo without making sure she understood?

She was a commodity and they wanted the status for their family. Old aristocratic families aren’t like the rest of us anyway and in addition a 19 year old in 1981 was a very different creature to her 2022 counterpart.

BringBackThinEyebrows · 06/02/2022 14:05

@TheKeatingFive

Yes that's clear, thanks 👍

DrSbaitso · 06/02/2022 14:01

@NETSRIK

Well I'm sure Camilla will be distraught by your OP. YABU by the way.
She, and the rest of them, would be wise not to do anything to turn public opinion against her if it's avoidable. That's why she doesn't use the Princess of Wales title.
diddl · 06/02/2022 13:59

"or they couldn't resist being the family of a princess and presumed future Queen."

Yes-bet they couldn't believe that they were in with another chance after Charles & Sarah split!

TheKeatingFive · 06/02/2022 13:59

Comparing how prepared Diana and Meghan were for marrying into the Royal Family

There are two separate points here.

Prepared for marriages and relationships more generally. Yes I agree Meghan was better prepared.

For marrying into the royal family specifically (to the extent that anyone ever could be), Diana's background would have been much better preparation.

I hope that clears my position up.

On a purely personal level the two marriages were very different anyway, with Charles and Diana radically different in what they were hoping/expecting from the marriage on a personal level. So that complicated things further.

JustSomething · 06/02/2022 13:57

Yes, she should be whatever the RF choose for her as that is the monarchy for you. If you want choice then go for a republic.

NETSRIK · 06/02/2022 13:56

Well I'm sure Camilla will be distraught by your OP. YABU by the way.

BringBackThinEyebrows · 06/02/2022 13:50

@TheKeatingFive

Comparing how prepared Diana and Meghan were for marrying into the Royal Family, you said:
"those from aristocratic families with extensive connections to the royals are better placed than anyone else (outside of royalty) to understand what 'marrying in' is going to be like"

...after I had mentioned the difference in age, media experience, the fact it was Diana's first marriage, and the fact that information about members of the Royal Family and royal protocol is readily available to anyone with internet access nowadays. Your response suggests that being from an aristocratic family trumps all the points I made.

Also, Charles (future King) has a more 'important' role than Harry so it's not really a comparable situation. As someone who's not from an aristocratic family, I am happy to be corrected.

NiceShrubbery · 06/02/2022 13:46

And because I' m a mediaevalist

Oh me too. Love a bit of medieval tradition. Especially the Tower of London and heads on spikes.

CrinklyCraggy · 06/02/2022 13:46

I often think this is a reason her brother is so critical - he knows her family let her down.