Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not be crowned Queen

483 replies

Viviennemary · 06/02/2022 00:41

I know there are other threads on this but I thought it would be interesting to get a vote. Seems most people are in favour. I'm not

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 07/02/2022 11:34

@Blossomtoes

No, she’d technically be Queen Mother but, given her immense tact I imagine that would be negotiated with the King and there would be agreement on her title.
No she wouldn't.

She would be Queen Camilla and/or The Dowager Queen.

Queen Elizabeth The Queen Mother was an unusual title and only really used because there were two Queen Elizabeths and the Queen Mother was widowed fairly young and didn't like the title Dowager Queen as it seemed old.

Most widowed Queens have just continued to be known as Queen and their name e.g. Queen Mary and Queen Alexandra.

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/02/2022 11:33

^^ On the thinking she’d be a good laugh: I remember reading years ago a post from an MNer who had met her at some charity gig. Camilla did, apparently, have an excellent sense of humour; and when she (Camilla) went to leave she gave an enthusiastic wave and promptly knocked her own hat flying in doing so, and had a good old laugh at herself. I can warm to somebody like that. I’ve met her very briefly as she is / was patron of a couple of the charities I’m involved with, and she always makes a particular effort to speak properly with people.

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2022 11:31

She wouldn't, though, as William isn't her child (or indeed a queen!)

The Queen part refers to the holder of the title.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:30

But she wouldn't be the Queen Mother, so she couldn't use that term?

Queen MIL? I can see MN loving that 😆

Phos · 07/02/2022 11:28

@AlexaShutUp

I like Camilla, I'd love to have a few gins with her.

She definitely looks like she'd be more fun than most of them!

Can I come?
Leighcloon · 07/02/2022 11:27

@Blossomtoes

No, she’d technically be Queen Mother but, given her immense tact I imagine that would be negotiated with the King and there would be agreement on her title.
She wouldn't, though, as William isn't her child (or indeed a queen!) Grin
Leighcloon · 07/02/2022 11:26

@DrSbaitso

If she outlives Charles, wouldn’t she be Dowager Queen?
Yes, but I think it's only used if needed to distinguish between two queens of the same name (apparently the Queen Mother loathed the term 'dowager queen', hence being 'Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother' to distinguish her from her daughter.) So Camilla would presumably go on being 'Queen Camilla' after Charles dies and William takes the crown (alongside his consort Queen Katherine).

I think Queen Mary went on being called 'Her Majesty Queen Mary' throughout her life (as obviously, she didn't share a name with either of her successors).

Phos · 07/02/2022 11:26

They’ve been married 17 years and in all that time she has been an active member of the Royal Family, very near the top in terms of number of engagements carried out. She’s also come across as very dignified in the face of a lot of criticism and seems genuinely interested in the events she goes to (and tbh even if that is just an act well more power to her for being so convincing)

We’ve moved on from the days of Wallis Simpson and divorce being such a scandal and let us not continue the lie that Diana was such a saint.

All kings spouses have been known as Queen. It’s just how it works.

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2022 11:21

No, she’d technically be Queen Mother but, given her immense tact I imagine that would be negotiated with the King and there would be agreement on her title.

DrSbaitso · 07/02/2022 11:16

If she outlives Charles, wouldn’t she be Dowager Queen?

DePfeffoff · 07/02/2022 11:13

However, I am concerned as to how she would be titled if Charles dies before Camilla. She can hardly become the Queen Mother as she's not William's mum. So after 10-20 years as Queen Consort, would she then lose her role entirely?

She'd just be Queen Camilla, I suspect. After George V died, Queen Mary was technically Queen Mother but I think she was always known as Queen Mary.

JudgeJ · 07/02/2022 09:16

@endlesssighing

She’ll never be queen. She’ll be Queen Consort, it was a condition of their marriage.

queen consort is a posh way of say here’s the king and his wife. Kate will be the first Queen after Elizabeth.

Kate will be exactly the same, she will be Queen consort, the word consort has only been used in relation to Camilla because of the Diana situation. The Sovereign's spouse is the consort, each Albert was Prince Consort to Victoria.
Leighcloon · 07/02/2022 09:16

@Womencanlift

I would much rather have Queen Camilla than Carrie as First Lady if the republicans got their way

Anyway the only people that have the right to comment on Charles and Camilla’s relationship are William and Harry and of course Camilla’s children and it appears like they all get on great

What is really going to be different now that she will be styled as Queen Consort rather than Princess? I think the world has moved on in the 30 years since Charles and Diana divorced and if she was still alive then potentially they would all be civil with each other by now.

Plus like Anne, Camilla quietly gets on with the job and doesn’t court publicity

I get tired of combating this misunderstanding every time abolishing the monarchy comes up. An elected Head of State is an entirely different role to that of prime minister — they would be two different people, with entirely different powers.

Presumably if the monarchy were ended, there would need to be a consultation on which of its powers would be retained in a president and which moved elsewhere (like head of the C of E). The elected HoS doesn’t have to be a career politician — why would he or she? It would be a largely ceremonial role and should be someone with broad, rather than a specific party, appeal. It could be someone with a long record of public service. (David Attenborough topped an opinion poll last year.) if you don’t like them, they’re only in the role for four years, or whatever length of term is decided.

JudgeJ · 07/02/2022 09:12

@DeadButDelicious

Charles will be King therefore Camilla will be Queen Consort. Because that's how royalty works.

Prince Phillip wasn't King because Kings outrank Queens. Because sexism that's how royalty works.

We can't 'skip straight to William' because that is not how royalty works. You don't get to pick and choose.

Kings most certainly don't outrank Queens, each is the monarch and, except for William and Mary, it's one or the other.
JudgeJ · 07/02/2022 09:06

@Lockdownlard

But prince Philip was never King Philip? What’s the difference?
Rightly or wrongly, the general rule is that the woman takes her 'title' from her husband's not vice versa, it's the reason that Anne's husbands didn't automatically have a title and that there's Princess Michael of Kent. Being titled Queen will not give Camilla the role of Queen in the sense that QE II is Queen.
Womencanlift · 07/02/2022 08:47

I would much rather have Queen Camilla than Carrie as First Lady if the republicans got their way

Anyway the only people that have the right to comment on Charles and Camilla’s relationship are William and Harry and of course Camilla’s children and it appears like they all get on great

What is really going to be different now that she will be styled as Queen Consort rather than Princess? I think the world has moved on in the 30 years since Charles and Diana divorced and if she was still alive then potentially they would all be civil with each other by now.

Plus like Anne, Camilla quietly gets on with the job and doesn’t court publicity

daisyjgrey · 07/02/2022 07:11

Whether you are a royalist or not, they are powerful figureheads of the country and we should be aware of what they're doing.

We're as aware of what they're doing as they're letting us be. Being aware of something does not correlate to giving two hoots about it.

BadgerB · 07/02/2022 07:07

@NiceShrubbery

Because the majority voted for him.

You mean the minority. 44 percent.

Plenty of crims in Buck Palace also, you're just choosing not to look.

Or is it fine for a group of randoms to be above the law?

If someone can win the top job with less than 50% of the vote I can't see that a vote for President would produce a clear majority. There'd be more candidates for a start.

The winner would be unlikely to be the sinless individual who would put the Palace gang to shame.

And only the monarch is above the law, not the whole gang

NiceShrubbery · 07/02/2022 06:40

Because the majority voted for him.

You mean the minority. 44 percent.

Plenty of crims in Buck Palace also, you're just choosing not to look.

Or is it fine for a group of randoms to be above the law?

BadgerB · 07/02/2022 06:30

Wasn't it Ken Livingstone who said, "If voting really changed anything they'd have banned it"?

BadgerB · 07/02/2022 06:27

@sammylady37

Yes, you can vote for your favourite. That always works out so well....

So is having zero choice, none whatsoever, even if the incumbent is an amoral criminal, better than being able to vote out someone?
Explain that one to me.

The only amoral criminal I see in public office at the moment lives in 10 Downing Street. Because the majority voted for him.
NiceShrubbery · 07/02/2022 06:05

Why anyone should have an opinion otherwise, based on about 0.001% of the information and awareness that the Queen has regarding her, I really don't know

Confused Imagine daring to have an actual opinion. About the people that, um, "reign" I think they call it, over you.

saraclara · 07/02/2022 00:37

The Queen wants it. She knows the woman better than anyone here, and obviously respects her and is fond of her.

Why anyone should have an opinion otherwise, based on about 0.001% of the information and awareness that the Queen has regarding her, I really don't know.

ClariceQuiff · 06/02/2022 23:53

it seems to be a bit of a Jilly Cooper country set fox hunting trope

Yes - apparently the Rupert Campbell-Black character was inspired by Andrew Parker-Bowles.

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 06/02/2022 23:31

they are powerful figureheads

That's an oxymoron. They're figureheads, only there for show. They're not powerful as they can't stop the government doing whatever it wants, as we have seen recently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread