Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Camilla should not be crowned Queen

483 replies

Viviennemary · 06/02/2022 00:41

I know there are other threads on this but I thought it would be interesting to get a vote. Seems most people are in favour. I'm not

OP posts:
ClariceQuiff · 06/02/2022 10:52

@Elphame

The Duke of Edinburgh only had the title "Prince Philip" as he was a royal prince in his own right rather than the title being the result of his marriage to Elizabeth.
Not quite true - he renounced his birth princeships on marriage, and was made the Duke of Edinburgh, and took that style. A few years later, he was made a Prince of the UK and from that point was styled Prince Philip.
2022sucksalready · 06/02/2022 10:51

Yabu on two fronts. First on thinking this, second in not giving a reason why you think this way. Very lazy.

ApricotPeony · 06/02/2022 10:47

If Henry VIII can stay king after chopping heads and having 6 wives it's fine for Camilla to be queen consort

cakeambush · 06/02/2022 10:47

@CarrieBlue

Camilla should already be able to use her rightful title of Princess of Wales. Since she will be consort of the King she shouldn’t be denied another title because of faux sentiment for a publicity hungry woman who died 25 years ago because she didn’t wear a seatbelt.
This is so spot on I wish I'd written it myself
Cluckingtell · 06/02/2022 10:47

I voted YABU - I really don't know why people can so much about a family that spends their days cutting ribbons, smiling and shaking hands.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 06/02/2022 10:46

@millytint44

I literally can't think about the 2 of them without the whole 'i want to be your tampax' conversation. 🤦‍♀️
I guarantee you wouldn’t be able to look most of your friends and their partners in the face if someone illegally found a way to make public the things they say between themselves.
TheKeatingFive · 06/02/2022 10:46

Both Diana and Meghan come from privileged backgrounds but there are very clear differences so of course Meghan isn't given the benefit of the doubt.

Very strange reasoning here. As an aristo with an extremely well connected family, Diana would have had far more of window than a woman who grew up in a totally different culture in another country.

Cocomarine · 06/02/2022 10:46

The very idea of a poll 😭
If you believe in democracy and people getting an actual say in this, then you’ve missed the point of monarchy.
They can, as ever, do what the fuck they like regardless of my opinion.

maddiemookins16mum · 06/02/2022 10:45

20 plus years ago I might have said no way. Now, with the passing of time, I think she should be. She’s Charles’ wife, probably a decent step mother to William and Harvey and I’ve warmed to er.
That said, it will make not one difference to my life whatever happens.

Elphame · 06/02/2022 10:44

The Duke of Edinburgh only had the title "Prince Philip" as he was a royal prince in his own right rather than the title being the result of his marriage to Elizabeth.

Cluckingtell · 06/02/2022 10:43

@MistyGreenAndBlue

I can't imagine what possible difference it would make to anyone. Who cares really?
This!
BringBackThinEyebrows · 06/02/2022 10:43

@EnterFunnyNameHere
I notice Megan doesn't get afforded the same benefit of the doubt for not knowing what she was getting into....

Diana was a teenager when she met Charles and just 20 when she married him. Meghan was (mid?) thirties when she married Harry, after already being married and getting divorced.

Also, the internet has made knowledge far more accessible since Diana's and Charles' relationship.

Meghan had been on TV for years, regularly posing for paparazzi etc. due to her job. Did Diana have that experience pre-Charles?

Both Diana and Meghan come from privileged backgrounds but there are very clear differences so of course Meghan isn't given the benefit of the doubt.

scottishnames · 06/02/2022 10:42

InisnaBro - I agree. It really isn't a soap opera, though that is how it has been sold. Although monarchs have had PR machines for millenia - Roman emperors had their portraits stamped on coins; Tudor Queen Elizabeth I arranged for copies of her portraits to be sent all over England....

However:
If a country needs a ceremonial/diplomatic/symbolic head of state (which almost all nations seem to think they do) then surely it's better to have a figure who is above/beyond party politics. Otherwise there's the danger of getting people like Trump etc.

The problem is how to choose a non-political head of state. Look at the problems Italy has been having recently; the previous president begged to retire but has been persuaded to stay on for a bit longer, because they (Italian politicians) can't find/agree on anyone suitable to replace him.

Hereditary monarchy is definitely not a perfect solution to such problems, but the current HMQ has - since she was in her 20s - devoted her life to the job, as she sees it. Some may admire her, many others criticise. But in either case, how horrendous a job - a gilded cage: endless ribbon-cutting, meeting and greeting, an awful lot of travel, constantly on show, constantly judged, constantly guarding one's tongue, no personal privacy, no personal freedom, a vast and sometimes antiquated bureaucracy running one's life, self-seeking hangers-on, endless and often inaccurate media criticism with very little chance to reply, some influence, prhaps, but little actual power etc etc.)

Vast wealth and comfort, yes, but I'd rather be poor and private and free.

Cam2020 · 06/02/2022 10:40

I don't really think you can compare the life and relationship experience of a 19 year old Diana with that of a previously married, tv actress in her late 30s....
I imagine Diana did think Charles loved her and it would all work out. The only reason she started having affairs is because he always cheated on her. Who wouldn't in her shoes?*
While I've never been a great Diana fan, I do feel very sorry for a young person thinking they were entering a fairytale and realising it's a nightmare.
I always think Camilla seems lovely.
Charles I can't stand.

I agree. I think the depressing thing is that young women were still being used as a commodity. What Diana's family did was no different to what the Seymours and Howards were doing to their young female relatives in the 16th century; likewise, all the RF cared about was their line of succession and not letting the Papists in.

Things have moved on just a little. Camilla has done her job as Charles' support, she deserves to be consort (if anyone 'deserves' any such title).

theDudesmummy · 06/02/2022 10:38

@CushionSpiral read the thread, the difference is his sex

LagunaBubbles · 06/02/2022 10:33

@32NiceShrubbery

Does it really matter? What will happen will happen no idea why some people seem to care so much.

Yes of course it matters

For decades, people have ignored who was in power, who was pulling the strings and who was directing the money supply.
We ended up with Boris, Toryshambles and the RF embroiled in an international paedophile ring. Happy?

What on earth has that got to do with whether Camilla should be called a word Queen or not!

And as for ending up with Boris and the Tories (again nothing to do with Camilla) that will because of the amount of people in England that voted for them, here in Scotland you will agree...they are not so popular lol.

CushionSpiral · 06/02/2022 10:33

@Lockdownlard

But prince Philip was never King Philip? What’s the difference?
I’ve always wondered this! Why they always refer to Kate as future queen, but he was never king??
KerryWeaver · 06/02/2022 10:32

But, but, but, ...Camilla should be blamed for everything that happened to Diana.

Isn't it always the woman's fault?

CallmeHendricks · 06/02/2022 10:32

Why do we still have people suggesting the Crown "skips Charles" and goes to William.
It's not X-Factor, fgs!

Elphame · 06/02/2022 10:27

Queen or not queen. It's just a meaningless title anyway.

As the consort to the monarch she will have whatever role does with the position regardless of what she is called.

Can't get myself worked up by this at all.

JacquelineCarlyle · 06/02/2022 10:26

@FloraPotts

I am not in favour either op but I've no doubt it's going to happen. People have very short memories. I think it's incredibly sad how Diana, barely out of her teens, was used so cynically by those around her, including Charles & Camilla. Imagine walking down the aisle to be married, aware that your fiance's mistress is seated prominently among the wedding guests. If Camilla had had any conscience at all she should have taken herself off to live in Ireland or France or somewhere and have left them well alone. The marriage would probably still have failed but it would have been the honourable thing to do. I think you would have to be incredibly hard-faced to behave in the way she did. I don't think she behaved honourably and of course neither did Charles. However much you love a person, you should back off once they marry someone else, especially when there are young children involved.
I agree with this. I am a royalist but as I get older, I do despair of the lot of them. To be so hard faced and uncaring says a lot about their true character and I've no wish to see her as Queen.

I'm also aggrieved at the fact they publicly stated when Charles and Camilla got married that she would not be Queen but instead would be known as Princess consort (in the same way of Prince Philip and Prince Albert) and now the Queen herself had gone back on that.

The only reason I'm still a royalist is I've no idea what we would replace them with and given the shower of shit governments and prime ministers we seem to end up with, I'm not hopeful we'd get anything better.

I really do wish it would skip Charles altogether and go to William (really because I think Catherine would do a great job as Queen)

millytint44 · 06/02/2022 10:26

I literally can't think about the 2 of them without the whole 'i want to be your tampax' conversation. 🤦‍♀️

StrawberryPot · 06/02/2022 10:25

've never understood the rhetoric that Diana was some poor, naive matchstick girl tricked into thinking she was marrying for love. The Spencers were unbelievably rich, and aristocrats in their own right (far more so than Camilla!). To act as if Diana had no idea what she was getting into is frankly insulting to her - I don't think she was so stupid. And that's before the affairs she had during the marriage. I notice Megan doesn't get afforded the same benefit of the doubt for not knowing what she was getting into....
I don't really think you can compare the life and relationship experience of a 19 year old Diana with that of a previously married, tv actress in her late 30s.....
I imagine Diana did think Charles loved her and it would all work out. The only reason she started having affairs is because he always cheated on her. Who wouldn't in her shoes?
While I've never been a great Diana fan, I do feel very sorry for a young person thinking they were entering a fairytale and realising it's a nightmare.

I always think Camilla seems lovely.

Charles I can't stand.

blyn72 · 06/02/2022 10:21

@Cam2020

Charles should have been allowed to marry her in the first place. It would have solved a lot of heartache all round.

Precisely this, which is exactly why he's stayed out of his own children's decisions, it seems.

If he had married Camilla when they were in their twenties, she would have produced two children and have had a long term affair with Andrew Parker-Bowles.
CallmeHendricks · 06/02/2022 10:19

If I'd had to pick who to sit next to at a dinner party out of Camilla and Diana, I know who I'd have gone for - Camilla every time. Apparently, she's a hoot.
Nowadays, Zara Tindall. I like her. And Princess Anne.

Anyway, off-topic. As you were...

Swipe left for the next trending thread