Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
puddleduck234 · 05/02/2022 22:21

I grew up in a grammar school area with undiagnosed dyslexia, so during primary school I was always at the bottom and lost a lot of interest very quickly in education. I was picked on my the smarter kids on a regular basis for being "thick". I didn't take the 11+ (had no hope of passing).

I went to the local average comp, and was so relieved to be away from the smarter kids picking on me. Took an interest in school again, nice group of friends and by the time I left had made my way to the top sets, had all my GCSE's (not a's but all above c and enough for me to eventually bag a degree and a decent career)

I honestly dread to think what my schooling would have been like had the smarter kids been at the same school. I certainly would never have made it to the top sets (which at the time was a massive boost in my confidence)

eurochick · 05/02/2022 22:20

I grew up in a grammar school area and passed the 11+. I don't know anyone who had tutoring back then. I just remember doing a few practice papers in class. It wasn't made out to be a big deal. Some passed, some didn't. Grammar schools seemed to be a good leveller - we had lots of kids from the poorer areas near us attending, plenty on FSM and so on. It has changed a lot in the past 30 years, and not for the better. I have friends putting their kids through the 11+ now and it is crazy - Saturday schools, tutoring, sitting multiple papers for different areas.

peaceanddove · 05/02/2022 22:17

We live in a grammar school area. Around here, tutoring is very common, I don't know of any child who didn't do plenty of preparation for the test. Ridiculous really, because all these children were already bright, most had graduate parents or from homes where education was highly valued etc. Just madness, but you get sucked into the system, you don't want your child to be the only non tutored one.

Both our DDs were tutored, though their tutor said on day one that he 'couldn't teach IQ' and all he could do was teach them good technique and a few tricks of the trade. I very much doubt our DDs needed the tutoring (or any of their friends) but I suppose it did mean they walked into the test very confidently.

Having said all that, plenty of children who were tutored still didn't pass? So tutoring isn't the magic wand that some people assume it to be.

Both our DDs have been through the grammar school system, but I'm not especially enamoured of it anymore. I won't deny that pupils attain excellent results, but they're essentially just Exam Factories. Teachers aren't really interested in explaining more than once, pupils are just expected to keep up. Pupils aren't taught to love learning, they're drilled in how to pass exams, and they do it extremely well.

It's a dry, relentless, unforgiving way to learn. But it garners results if what you're after is just a slew of great GCSEs and A Levels.

GougeAway · 05/02/2022 22:14

YANBU. My mum from a poor working class family passed the 11+ back in the days in the 50s when the whole primary class sat it and no one did extra prep. Now, in the same city, most grammars shut so the few remaining are fiercely competitive. I correctly predicted all the children who got into the grammars from my DC's years at primary back in foundation, based on what their parents did for a living. Lots of private primaries in the city as well, set up to prep for the 11+. Very bright hard working children with ESL don't even get a look in as the primaries don't tell parents how to apply for the 11+. You really have to be in the know to navigate the system.

PinkPomeranian · 05/02/2022 22:13

@EvilPea

Certain schools are great at coaching for the test but these are not always the independents, particularly the feeder schools or those whose leavers tend to remain in the private sector. Either way, primary schools tend not to cover the Non Verbal Reasoning part of the test so this is where tutoring can make a significant difference

State aren’t allowed to tutor AT ALL
Independents can, and do.

I should have said preparing rather than coaching. Some states absolutely do this, just as some indies categorically do not.
EvilPea · 05/02/2022 22:09

As a result of having so few grammars our comps are actually OK, as so many very bright kids don’t pass and go to the comps

Smart comps will be running with that and embracing it as things change. There will be more kids who would have passed 5+ years ago in the comp. So if you can send them down the right path they should be able to get them the same results

However our comp still doesn’t offer the same Latin, sociology, psychology, mandarin as the local grammar.

Jmaho · 05/02/2022 22:09

I'm sorry to hear of your experience but it has made me feel better that we chose not to go down this route
My eldest son is very clever, not boasting he is. Especially in maths. Very natural. Never been tutored just always got it. His teachers couldn't believe we weren't putting him forward for it (we live in an area where probably 90% of the year group sit the exam). We chose not to as we knew how much pressure he would put on himself and felt that he would work himself up so much and stress that he might fall apart on the day. And then if he didn't get in he would've been devasted
As it went, he didn't sit it and only very few children from his class passed.
My neighbour openly told me how disappointed she was with her son for not passing and said how many thousands they had spent on tutoring. As the test got closer they had a tutor there every weeknight

PaddleBoardingMomma · 05/02/2022 22:08

I'm fact, just looking at my daughters primary school prospectus this year and they have given the numbers for how many pupils went on to which schools in the area. Out of 60 students, only 9 went on to a comp or high school, the rest have all proceeded to grammar.

EvilPea · 05/02/2022 22:06

Certain schools are great at coaching for the test but these are not always the independents, particularly the feeder schools or those whose leavers tend to remain in the private sector. Either way, primary schools tend not to cover the Non Verbal Reasoning part of the test so this is where tutoring can make a significant difference

State aren’t allowed to tutor AT ALL
Independents can, and do.

Oogabooga123 · 05/02/2022 22:05

Our county isn’t as bad as yours for the number of grammar schools but if anything it makes it worse. 1 boys grammar, 1 girls and 1 mixed so the entire county trying to get those places. Kids driving over an hour to school it’s madness.

I was speaking with a tutor recently, we are not taking 11+ but was looking for catch up tutoring after the past few years.

Tutor said she is really enjoying the new breed of kids she is getting in, there to catch up on gaps rather than cram for 11+. She herself said she despises what the 11+ system has become in the past 10 years. It’s no longer the kids who are naturally bright, just those who are tutored within an inch of their lives on how to answer the questions.

As a result of having so few grammars our comps are actually OK, as so many very bright kids don’t pass and go to the comps

PaddleBoardingMomma · 05/02/2022 22:05

I was let down terribly by my high school in England, it was truly awful. I couldn't let my girls go through that and so I'm very grateful for so many excellent grammar schools in NI, where the system seems to be far more accepted and encouraged. I believe everyone will have their own view on the grammar system based on their experience of it, and likewise of the local comps.

EvilPea · 05/02/2022 22:04

The other thing is it takes away choice.
So we have
Comp or grammar
That’s it for choice. So you can’t choose a best fit for your child unless they pass.
If you had two comps you could at least choose which one is best for your child regardless of how they did on that one day.

OfstedOffred · 05/02/2022 22:04

The problem is that state comprehensive (and primary) schools lack the capacity and inclination to help brighter kids achieve their potential.

In fact, the government desire to "close the gap" requires schools to target that the poorest children achieve the fastest progress (they must make more rapid progress than their cohort if the attainment gap is to reduce). Its only possible to do this at the expense of your rapidly progressing most able kids.

Grammar schools are the exception.

No it's not "fair" but neither is a system where bright kids are left to drift along and denied opportunity.

PinkPomeranian · 05/02/2022 22:04

I agree with what RedskyThisNight says.

Grammar schools were a wonderful vehicle for social mobility, but that is no longer the case in many areas. Where I live it's not unheard of for children to be added to 11+ tutor lists before they start school, with tuition to begin in Year 4 or Year 5. Some tutors charge £50 for a session.

Certain schools are great at coaching for the test but these are not always the independents, particularly the feeder schools or those whose leavers tend to remain in the private sector. Either way, primary schools tend not to cover the Non Verbal Reasoning part of the test so this is where tutoring can make a significant difference. Parents often seem to keen their cards close to their chest to gain a competitive edge.

If applicants are initially rejected by a Grammar and go to an appeal, the panel will be aware of their primary school's ability to prepare the student, and this can be factored into a decision. But only at an appeal.

Sadly, the days when children walked into their 11+ exam uncoached and from a relatively level playing field have gone. Tutoring is the norm, and it comes at a price.

C152 · 05/02/2022 22:03

I agree with your points 1 and 2, but disagree with 3 and 4 and think YABU. Education should be streamed according to academic ability, which it doesn't appear to be in non-selective state schools.

Point 3 - kids know whether they're bright or not. If they don't have a chance of getting into a selective school, their parents shouldn't make them sit the exam. It's also important to teach inner strength - not getting a high enough grade in one exam - albeit an important one - shouldn't be the end of the world. A bit of a disappointment, but not crippling.

Point 4 - do you have any stats to support this?

Darbs76 · 05/02/2022 22:03

I agree the system has changed a lot. Back in the day the brightest kids in the class got in. None of the kids in my DS’s school got into the highly competitive grammars in my area. Kids come from far and wide, I was pretty shocked how far when we went to the open day. As said above my DS is super bright and he applied to Oxford, yet he didn’t get in. Back in the day he would have sailed through. It all worked out fine for him but I sometimes hear people say oh I passed my 11 plus and I think well I wonder if you would the ones by us. The Uber competitive parents have meant that bright local kids cannot get a chance

Jmaho · 05/02/2022 22:02

@Indecisivelurcher

My teacher friend told me tutoring is pretty much necessary because the test is early in yr6 but covers the full yr6 curriculum which of course they have not been taught yet.
This is exactly what my sons teacher told me. She said he wouldn't be able to answer some of the questions if he wasn't tutored as it was on things that the would learn in the latter part of year 6. They take the test at the start of year 6. We live in a grammar school area we chose not to go down that route. Every child that I know of that has or is going to sit the exam is tutored twice a week all through year 5
BreatheAndFocus · 05/02/2022 22:01

@Jaggerdagger

For those that are commenting about their experience growing up: It's definitely changed. Vastly. My mum went to grammar school and I just asked her if there was such a thing as a tutor for the 11+ back then. Absolutely not! Lots of kids round here start at year 4. Some even as young as year 3! Shock
It has changed, yes, but I voted YABU. Certainly in my area, the reason parents pay for tutoring is that there are now hardly any grammar schools. There used to be loads and loads so children didn’t need tutoring: if they were academic they passed and went to grammar school.

Now passing is not enough by a long chalk. There aren’t enough places for all the children who pass so the grammars take those who pass with the highest mark . Therefore tutoring takes place to ensure your child gets a really good mark not ‘just’ a pass. If every town had a grammar school this wouldn’t be necessary.

Grammars not only have good education and cover subjects many comprehensives don’t, they are largely free of the major problems comps face - poor behaviour and ineffective ways of dealing with it.

I don’t agree it makes children feel inferior if they go to a comp now. Many children are happy and proud to do so. Children can feel inferior for lots of reasons - they’re not in the top set for Maths; they didn’t get into the football team; their house isn’t as posh as their friends’ houses, etc. It’s our job to help them deal with those disappointments.

I don’t think grammar schools make comps worse. Many academically able children will still go to the comp because they choose to or their parents don’t agree with grammar schools or for whatever reason.

MargaretThursday · 05/02/2022 22:00

But the same thing could be said of other things.
My ds would have loved at 10yo to be picked to play for a football academy as two of his friends were. But:

1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
Those boys had dads who played heavily and had large amount of coaching including 1-2-1 from age 4yo. No children would have got into the academy who hadn't had extensive coaching.

2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
Ditto in football academies. the majority don't get anywhere

3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
Yes, there were several boys who felt a failure against those two that got in.

4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.
Not sure why not getting into grammar makes it more likely that parents will opt for private school. Surely in non-grammar areas the parents that want grammar and can afford it just go for private, so more children going private and children who can't afford it can't. Is that actually fairer on the children who can't afford it?

*All my dc go to the bog standard comprehensive, but I don't judge others for choosing private or grammar if they can.

Inspectorslack · 05/02/2022 21:59

In my case for my children they reduced systemic inequalities.

Retisestress · 05/02/2022 21:59

A friend of mine has daughter who wasn’t tutored ,lives on a notorious estate in our town and has absolutely thrived at Grammar School…4A* A Levels …it does work if the parents are bothered to support their children in their education.

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:59

I live in a medium sized town. The private schools and grammar schools in the area actually outweigh the comprehensive schools in number, within a 3 mile radius. Hence point number 4 in my OP.

OP posts:
formalineadeline · 05/02/2022 21:58

Grammar schools were a vehicle for social mobility when they were first introduced.

Were they though? Really? Or did they just place a respectable veneer on the privileged of society maintaining their status quo?

Is there any evidence that they reduced systemic inequalities? If they improved social mobility on anything other than an anecdotal basis where is the evidence?

If they were genuinely about social mobility then there would not be limitations on places and you would be able to have an entire cohort benefit from the grammar education... and those who didn't make it there wouldn't have been put on the scrapheap.

Sugarsugar25 · 05/02/2022 21:58

I went to a state comprehensive and there were grammar schools in my county. I passed without tutoring but too many passed so I didn't get a space. I've done okay since then.

But I do think grammar schools are full of children who parents can't afford private school but can afford tutoring for their children.

DialsMavis · 05/02/2022 21:57

I also agree with @eleganz, many people move to very expensive areas to secure a good school, or go down the faith school route when not religious.

Swipe left for the next trending thread