Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 23:29

[quote crazydineraddict]@Warblerinwinter we will have to just disagree then. It is not a simple ranking of the test score - that’s another incorrect statement. Scores are adjusted on a bell curve. Many different factors are taken into account and PP is one of those.

At least for the area I’m in. With many grammars.[/quote]
Ok…that’s why the great debate has raged on and on for years and years.
Those that went to grammar can’t see the problem!

Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 23:27

@Winnerwinnerveggiedinner

YABU in thinking that removing the 11+ will create fairness in the education system and that fairness could and should be pursued. There will always be inequality, whether it is through parental help, geographical differences, community aspirations, private schools, tutoring and selection by postcode. Fwiw there are plenty of parents at my dc’s grammar that could afford private but choose not to. The children are motivated, well behaved and aspirational. Obviously some children in other schools share those qualities but there will be some that don’t. I’m merely hoping that my DCs can achieve their potential in an environment conducive to learning.
🤣🤣🤣🙄 Of course there are parents at your dc GRAMMAR school that could afford private. That’s the point that the grammar school places are taken by kids coming out of private education cos parents don’t have o pay for it, How many kids are in the non grammer schools whose parents could afford private 🙄🤦‍♀️
crazydineraddict · 05/02/2022 23:26

@Warblerinwinter we will have to just disagree then. It is not a simple ranking of the test score - that’s another incorrect statement. Scores are adjusted on a bell curve. Many different factors are taken into account and PP is one of those.

At least for the area I’m in. With many grammars.

whiteroseredrose · 05/02/2022 23:24

@EvilPea

Certain schools are great at coaching for the test but these are not always the independents, particularly the feeder schools or those whose leavers tend to remain in the private sector. Either way, primary schools tend not to cover the Non Verbal Reasoning part of the test so this is where tutoring can make a significant difference

State aren’t allowed to tutor AT ALL
Independents can, and do.

My DC's state primary school did some 11+ prep in Year 5. Run by a couple of the teachers at 8am once a week.

The DC did need to get there in time though.

Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 23:22

@crazydineraddict

You can’t be tutored for the test, this is just incorrect. DH runs a tutoring company for this. CEM which I assume is your area, changes every year to be unpredictable. You can’t “learn questions”. You either have the ability to “get it” or not.

If you weren’t coached, and don’t pass, but are intelligent - that will and should catch up as you go through school. If it doesn’t, then you weren’t necessarily the right person for grammar anyway.

When I took my 11+, you had to sit it at the top school, so if you didn’t pass and picked a grammar you could lose your place at preferred comp. So I sat mine at a comp and passed.

I went to the comp, I got 12A*s. I then went to the grammar for sixth form. I now work in finance and have done exceptionally well. I’m still in my twenties.

For context, DH tutored a boy once a week for a few months before his 11+. He passed well. He is still in Year 6 and is currently able to get full marks on level 9 GCSE maths questions. He could sit a GCSE paper tomorrow and pass. Not amazingly well but above a 4.

Some children are exceptional. Not just smart by your definitions- you aren’t their actual teacher and you cannot comment.

Yes the system can be unfair for those who can’t get teachers. But a good parental home would make use of free resources and a kid that actually wants it would work for it. So I do believe they would get in.

Nope..not the case.. see my post earlier.
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/02/2022 23:21

Very unfair. Grammar schools shouldn’t be allowed.

Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 23:19

@crazydineraddict

Yes it’s unfair. No I don’t believe if you pass the 11+ you will struggle because you’ve been tutored. The concepts are still advanced. If that was the case then at GCSE everyone would get a 9.

A truly talented child won’t need tutoring but the bar has been raised through tuition of what is “truly talented”

I live in a grammar area (not sure it’s yours). I never touched a paper before I sat mine and we were poor so couldn’t afford tuition, I passed as did a lot of my friends. Of course some failed, but if you were capable you made it

The issue here is that children who are not truely talented are coached to do the tests and therefore take the places of the truely talented who sit it “cold turkey” because their parents couldn’t afford tutors and some of these state schools will not publish past papers on line, yet the private schools have access to similar papers to hot house their pupils

Whether you get in or not depends on the amount of grammer schools in your area. They simply assign places by ranking in hte exams. If there are 500 places across multiple schools in your LEA for 10000 girls you’ll get in if your within the top 5% . If there are 100 places you’ve got to be in top 1%. It varies according to regions- so doesn’t help with saying “well I didn’t have tutoring and still got in”🙄🤦‍♀️

In early 200o’s I saw this in action at reading grammar school. 100 places per year. This was only state grammer school in all west Berkshire for boys. Vast majority of places always went to public school pupils coming in from well outside district LEA. My son came 110th on rating list ( they told us His position on results report), with no coaching as we couldn’t afford it- I just did my best to try and figure out what he might be asked to do to prep him. I have no doubt that he was more gifted than some of those that made it into the top 100. He was already identified as a “gifted “ pupil by LEA and the teachers advised us to put him in. Though that didn’t help much and didn’t actually really provide any additional opportunities for him 🤣🤣. Just gave him a big head 🙄🤣

But, it didn’t do him any harm in the end ..state schooled..university and now very settled in well paid job with lovely friends including those he made at school that he still visit when he is back “home” . He also has a good attitude towards women, having made close platonic relationships with girls as well as boys at school, which I think would have been much more unlikely being surrounded in an all boys environment all day.

Same is true for me. I didn’t sit it in the end as moved out of district with 4 months to go before exams. But I know I would have failed- everyone was telling me. I went into “middle school. Now that was a brilliant and sadly lost educational experience. By the time I got to 13 and went to secondary school I was top set- just needed more time to “mature”. Went to uni . Had a successful and stable career. Retired early. Don’t do me any harm- in fact the opposite..middle school was a fab experience.

Flickflak · 05/02/2022 23:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

arethereanyleftatall · 05/02/2022 23:15

I think those posting 'I/my dc didn't tutor and they got in' don't understand how the 11Plus works.
It's a competition.
If there's 100 places available at st Mary's grammar, then 100 kids in the area pass. The others 'fail'.
So, it is completely and utterly dependent on the specific area you live in.
Child A could get 50% answers correct in Area A and pass, and child B could get 90% answers correct in Area B and fail.

RampantIvy · 05/02/2022 23:12

I am surprised the two tier system still operates

I didn't know there were still grammar school areas until I joined mumsnet.

crazydineraddict · 05/02/2022 23:11

You can’t be tutored for the test, this is just incorrect. DH runs a tutoring company for this.
CEM which I assume is your area, changes every year to be unpredictable.
You can’t “learn questions”. You either have the ability to “get it” or not.

If you weren’t coached, and don’t pass, but are intelligent - that will and should catch up as you go through school. If it doesn’t, then you weren’t necessarily the right person for grammar anyway.

When I took my 11+, you had to sit it at the top school, so if you didn’t pass and picked a grammar you could lose your place at preferred comp. So I sat mine at a comp and passed.

I went to the comp, I got 12A*s. I then went to the grammar for sixth form. I now work in finance and have done exceptionally well. I’m still in my twenties.

For context, DH tutored a boy once a week for a few months before his 11+. He passed well. He is still in Year 6 and is currently able to get full marks on level 9 GCSE maths questions. He could sit a GCSE paper tomorrow and pass. Not amazingly well but above a 4.

Some children are exceptional. Not just smart by your definitions- you aren’t their actual teacher and you cannot comment.

Yes the system can be unfair for those who can’t get teachers. But a good parental home would make use of free resources and a kid that actually wants it would work for it. So I do believe they would get in.

badspella · 05/02/2022 23:07

Fifty years ago, I sat and failed my 11 +. I went to the local secondary modern school. We were not taught the relevant material for the test, let alone how to pass it. Only occasionally did someone from our village school pass the exam.
My father said he would buy me a bike if I passed. I never got the bike, and I felt I had let him down.
The school was rough, and we were streamed according to how well we had performed on that wretched 11 +. Those who did fairly well, were put in the top streams at school, and would learn a modern foreign language. Those who did not do so well, were put in the lower streams.
If you went to the grammar school, you were considered to be 'academic' and might even go to university. For secondary modern kids, we were encouraged to learn a trade.
The system was totally, totally unfair. It was social engineering at its worst. Even in those days, it was the children of the parents who had the benefit of a higher education , who were more likely to pass the exam.
I went on to get a first class honours degree, a masters degree and a PhD, but only after returning to study much later in life and juggling study with work and childcare. For nearly half my life I felt like I was a failure.
I am surprised the two tier system still operates. It was not designed to give poor children a chance. Rather it was designed to keep poor people in their place.

WhatEvenHappened44 · 05/02/2022 22:56

The problem here is grammar schools not 11+

RampantIvy · 05/02/2022 22:53

Fwiw there are plenty of parents at my dc’s grammar that could afford private but choose not to.

There were plenty of parents at DD's comprehensive school who could have afforded private, but chose not to.

Winnerwinnerveggiedinner · 05/02/2022 22:48

YABU in thinking that removing the 11+ will create fairness in the education system and that fairness could and should be pursued. There will always be inequality, whether it is through parental help, geographical differences, community aspirations, private schools, tutoring and selection by postcode.

Fwiw there are plenty of parents at my dc’s grammar that could afford private but choose not to. The children are motivated, well behaved and aspirational. Obviously some children in other schools share those qualities but there will be some that don’t. I’m merely hoping that my DCs can achieve their potential in an environment conducive to learning.

RampantIvy · 05/02/2022 22:48

6th form private school if they attend grammar school

We have such a good state 6th form college in the next county that the students from the private schools leave in droves to go there. The college offers a wider range of subjects at A level, has a better reputation than the 6th forms at the private schools and it's free.

It sounds like you don't want your DC mixing with the riff raff.

EvilPea · 05/02/2022 22:41

I should have said preparing rather than coaching. Some states absolutely do this, just as some indies categorically do not

State should not be doing this, they are not allowed to. The most they can do is offer it as an outside sourced after school club.

DdraigGoch · 05/02/2022 22:39

@lotsofdogshere

I loathe the grammar school system. All children should have excellent education. No children should be labelled failures at 11
It would be nice if all children received an excellent education, according to their potential (the technical schools which should have been the third part of the tripartite system were a missed opportunity).

In reality what happens is that everything is equally mediocre. Liverpool's grammar schools used to send plenty of kids to Oxbridge - ordinary working class children. When the system was abolished there, many cohorts produced none at all.

What needs to happen is that the 11+ tests need to be made so that they are impossible to coach for. Make them so unpredictable that they are a true reflection of the abilities of each candidate.

Blossomtoes · 05/02/2022 22:37

6th form private school if they attend grammar school

Why? They’ll stand a better chance of a good university place from a state school.

OfstedOffred · 05/02/2022 22:32

Tutoring doesnt make as much difference as people think.

Lots of tutored children still don't pass. Many of those who do would have passed anyway. You can't polish a turd.

There's probably a small subset of children who are very borderline for whom perhaps tutoring makes a difference.

Remember to that a "great" school isnt necessarily one that got an intake of bright kids to get 100% GCSE passes.

A school with a very un-academic intake that gets half those kids through GCSE has probably made better progress with better teaching etc. Facilities in grammars where I live are no better than the local state schools. They offer slightly different subjects based on student preferences and abilities.

Inspectorslack · 05/02/2022 22:30

If my kids hadn’t gone to grammar they’d have really struggled to see beyond the poor area we live in.

They were given a good education that has opened doors for them.

They wouldn’t have got that with High school and FE college in the same way at all. I know because I failed my 11 plus (chaotic house poor parents no value on education) and that’s the life I had.

I wanted more for my children.

ByMyName · 05/02/2022 22:28

I went to a grammar school. There is no way my parents could afford private.

DH went to private boarding school.

We can afford private school for the DCs but our plan is:

  1. Tutoring for 11+ exams
  2. Grammar school if they get in
  3. Private school if they don’t get into grammar school
  4. 6th form private school if they attend grammar school
RampantIvy · 05/02/2022 22:25

@lotsofdogshere

I loathe the grammar school system. All children should have excellent education. No children should be labelled failures at 11
I agree entirely.

I find it rather depressing that 29% of posters agree with this divisive system. I am so thankful that we have no state grammar schools in our county. As a result we have some rather good comprehensive schools. DD did exceptionally well from a comprehensive education.

roastingmichael · 05/02/2022 22:25

@User112

My son attends a grammar school and I agree it’s very unfair on bright poor kids who cannot afford tutoring.
It's unfair on all kids, not just the bright ones. It creates a totally unfair education system.
Blossomtoes · 05/02/2022 22:22

I was referring to the 1870 Education Act. Hence my references to the wider education system. Hth.

In which case you were referring to the wrong Act. HTH.

Swipe left for the next trending thread