Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
curiousannie · 06/02/2022 07:33

I'll always feel annoyed about the grammar system. I'm late 20s now but when I went through secondary school in Southend area it was disgusting how awful ALL of the non-grammar schools were. It was like 'we've picked out the 50% most talented ones, the rest of you don't stand a chance anyway so go to shitty belfairs or prittlewell'. Hopefully these schools will have improved now but the system is horrible for children who don't pass.

Namenic · 06/02/2022 07:31

Personally I think the U.K. system is too regimented in that people move up each year even if they have not mastered the previous year’s work. Some kids may just need the extra year to learn and pass gcses or a levels. I’m not sure gcse maths and English are useful tests for skills required for the workplace.

Jaggerdagger · 06/02/2022 07:30

I work in a grammar school and yes we have a lot of incredibly bright students, but are they any brighter than a lot of children who didn’t pass the test? I’m pretty certain there are students who failed the 11+ who are more suited to a grammar school than some students who passed after being tutored to within an inch of their lives.

Completely agree - I've seen this with some of my pupils too.

OP posts:
LefttoherownDevizes · 06/02/2022 07:28

@Liverbird77

For those saying all children should have an equal education, I would say life isn't fair!

We are sending our children to private prep, where they'll get coaching for the entrance exams, and we'll be using tutors too. We may even move house nearer the time.

We simply don't want our children to be forced into the local comps. The nearest one is Roman Catholic, and we are completely opposed to faith schools, and the next nearest is huge. Both have issues with behaviour and their curriculums can't compare with what is on offer at the grammars.

If they don't get in then we'll have to look at private secondary for one or both. It's one of the reasons we've decided to stop at two. It's s huge sacrifice but it's what's best for them.

I was a teacher for 15 years, working in grammar, private, community schools and state academies.

When life isn't fair you should strive to remove the inequalities not reinforce them
Liverbird77 · 06/02/2022 07:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Jaggerdagger · 06/02/2022 07:22

@badspella

Fifty years ago, I sat and failed my 11 +. I went to the local secondary modern school. We were not taught the relevant material for the test, let alone how to pass it. Only occasionally did someone from our village school pass the exam. My father said he would buy me a bike if I passed. I never got the bike, and I felt I had let him down. The school was rough, and we were streamed according to how well we had performed on that wretched 11 +. Those who did fairly well, were put in the top streams at school, and would learn a modern foreign language. Those who did not do so well, were put in the lower streams. If you went to the grammar school, you were considered to be 'academic' and might even go to university. For secondary modern kids, we were encouraged to learn a trade. The system was totally, totally unfair. It was social engineering at its worst. Even in those days, it was the children of the parents who had the benefit of a higher education , who were more likely to pass the exam. I went on to get a first class honours degree, a masters degree and a PhD, but only after returning to study much later in life and juggling study with work and childcare. For nearly half my life I felt like I was a failure. I am surprised the two tier system still operates. It was not designed to give poor children a chance. Rather it was designed to keep poor people in their place.
Gosh, that's shit, but I'm so glad you never gave up. Congratulations, Dr!
OP posts:
DinosApple · 06/02/2022 07:13

Personally, I'm saving some money to help both my DC get through GCSE maths. If that means a tutor so be it. Both hate it and it's neithers strong point.

But there aren't grammar schools near us and the local secondaries are all fine.

LefttoherownDevizes · 06/02/2022 07:12

I live in a non grammar borough sandwiched between two grammar boroughs. Loads of local kids here are tutored to pass the 11+ to get grammar places, even though it's not their LEA. Competition is hugely fierce. That would really nark me if my kid lost out to a non Borough kid.

Interestingly friends who live in Kent 'proper' have had their kids pass the Kent test and into Grammars with no tutoring. They do do lots of practice at school. They are worried about the non selective schools for siblings though.

I am lucky and my kids have had a great education from comps, and wish that that were the case for all.

Interestingly my dad failed the 11+ but passed the 13+, his local grammar was in Knightsbridge. He hated every second as he felt so out of place as a council estate boy that he moved back to the secondary modern in the end. So they weren't always the great levellers even back then they were sold as.

sandgrown · 06/02/2022 07:09

Many years ago when I took the 11+ our teachers helped the whole class prepare for the exam. We did Maths , English and Verbal Reasoning . Like @Meatbadger I am so grateful for the opportunities the grammar school gave me. My mother was clever but her parents couldn’t afford the uniform so she missed her chance and went to work in a mill. She was so proud of me.

Grida · 06/02/2022 07:08

I know lots of children who have tutoring for all sorts of things. Extra coaching for sport, instrumental teaching, tutoring for GCSEs and A levels. Tutoring to help catch up with maths or reading. SEN tutoring, homework tutors, parent doing the tutoring (often the ones who are very vocal about little Johnny not needing any tutoring). EAL tutoring, ballet classes, tutoring for a foreign language. People want their children to do well and will use the resources they have available to them. A lot of state schools, outside grammar school areas, have what is effectively a grammar stream within them (people tutor to get into the top sets). Whether it is fair or not, it will always be difficult to keep people from trying to help their children do their best. Getting rid of grammar schools won’t stop them. I know teachers who volunteer to tutor children as part of a charity to help disadvantaged children. Many state schools also have mentoring/tutoring programs within schools to help failing pupils. I used to do 1to1 support/tutoring for children doing GCSEs at a previous school. All the teachers had to do this for 2/3 pupils outside their own subject. I also did weekly drop in sessions for my own subject. I think tutoring is just teaching by another name.

Gurdjieff · 06/02/2022 07:00

One poster mentioned behaviour as a reason for wanting a grammar option. This is an interesting point. Our eldest DS is in Y6 with one kid in particular who is very disruptive and that boy will go to the local non grammar school. We know that if DS goes non grammar the disruption will continue and all indications are that it will continue to affect everyone’s education (as it clearly has in Y6, according to the teachers).

I reckon there are many parents who buy the notion that comprehensives and secondary moderns can stretch capable kids (I would imagine a preoccupation of many parents of capable children). But it’s the perception of a lack of disruption, and the higher standards that might bring, that drives some of the wish to have grammar schools.

Is there a way to somehow bring much better behaviour to all schools so that those same parents don’t remove kids and put them into grammar (assuming they get a place)? I think that would be a key part of dismantling the grammar system - “reassure me that the classes will not be disrupted”.

Eileen101 · 06/02/2022 05:51

We live in a grammar. My dad got in, my mum didn't, yet both had successful careers.
My sister and I were not put through the system and went to a comp which wasn't great, but we both have successful careers.

I won't be putting my children through the 11+ system and was mindful of catchment areas when I brought my house. I suspect my niece and nephew will be sitting the exam as DHs family have mostly attended a grammar at various points.

cocktailclub · 06/02/2022 05:32

Totally agree and I had two who passed and one who didn't. Tutoring raises the bar and does give an unfair advantage to those who are borderline definitely.
But then the whole school system favours children from more privileged backgrounds with educated parents who have time to help with homework, provide more resources and give them more experiences.

In my experience my child who went to a comprehensive had a more challenging educational experience and less was handed to them on a plate. But as an adult they are a great problem solver with a fantastic career they worked hard for.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 06/02/2022 05:06

I went to grammar school, my brother didn't. My son is at the local academy, daughter at grammar. Both my brother and son are equally as intelligent as me or my other child, perhaps more so. The system is just rubbish. The concept is rubbish, how it's applied is rubbish, the notion that it is in any way a means of 'levelling up' is laughably rubbish. Nearly all kids these days are tutored and the few who gain a grammar school place without tutoring are the exception not the norm. It's elitist in the extreme, from the cost of getting there to the cost of uniform (almost 3x the price of my son's academy uniform, as nothing can be bought in normal shops) to the cost of trips etc etc. And many kids who only got to grammar through relentless tutoring are now sinking, or having to have ongoing tutoring on top of an already heavy workload just to keep up.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 06/02/2022 04:48

The thing that saddens me about the whole system is that some children appear to be deemed 'unworthy' of a good education.
My eldest has additional needs. Honestly, a Grammar would be the worse place for her educationally. But it shouldn't mean she's not worthy of a calm educational environment that stretches her potential.

So we deliberately moved to an area with a good comprehensive school with a wide rangebof vocational subjects and academic subjects so both her and her sister (who would thrive in a GS) have the opportunity to have a good education.

The way our exam is set up, 100% of pupils can never recieve the top grades... the furore over the past couple of years of "inflation" has shown that. For Maths and English at least we need a skills test with a set pass mark so that the traditional "Maths and English at Grade C" thing is an actual possibility for everyone.

Namenic · 06/02/2022 02:01

I assume most people who are against grammar schools are not against selective 6th forms - as kids would have had longer to develop and find what they like? So people are necessarily against selection in general - just selection at a young age.

The only way to make it fair would be to make the secondary modern in the area more desirable for many. This could include increased funding per pupil, more help for special needs, smaller class sizes, wider and different subject range. That way parents could make their choice depending on what their child was like.

ExpulsoCorona · 06/02/2022 01:34

My DD got into the grammar but if she hadn't, she wouldn't have got into our nearest comp which is Church of England, we're not the correct religion. Lots of things are unfair.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/02/2022 01:22

@Jaggerdagger

I notice it even more because I grew up in a county that had no grammar or private schools nearby, and so everyone just went to their local comp. It wasn't perfect, but the opportunities were equal and some of the teaching was superb.
Equal opportunities to get shitkickings for being smart in my experience.

Or, as happened to me aged 15, stabbed.

Peregrina · 06/02/2022 01:05

The Grammar schools of old only gave the chance of social mobility to some working class children. pikapikapukachu's mother's experience was the more typical one.

60 years ago, the primary school I was at for the 11+ streamed children from age 7 and the A stream were crammed for the test, so there was no need for tutoring. So some kids got written off at age 7.

LetHimHaveIt · 06/02/2022 00:39

Well I know what you mean, but I'm a TA and I've got several (wealthy) children in my Yr 5 class who are apparently being tutored at least once a week for 1-2 hrs at a time: I shall be charitable and say - you wouldn't bloody know it.

Eightiesfan · 06/02/2022 00:31

It is completely unfair. I work in a grammar school and yes we have a lot of incredibly bright students, but are they any brighter than a lot of children who didn’t pass the test? I’m pretty certain there are students who failed the 11+ who are more suited to a grammar school than some students who passed after being tutored to within an inch of their lives.

We have students who struggle with the fast pace of teaching. We also have to cope with students who are used to being the brightest student in their year at junior school, only to discover that compared to some of their classmates they are average at best, which for some plays havoc with their self-esteem.

Living in a county with a grammar system, we have to put up with over-inflated house prices, but ironically the large majority of our students are from outside the county. Very few come from the local junior schools, most are from private schools whose main concern is getting students to pass the test. It’s incredibly unfair and divisive.

However, I am a firm believer that if a child works hard and has the support of their parents they will do well at any school. But being at a grammar school definitely gives students an advantage in better resources and support.

Luredbyapomegranate · 06/02/2022 00:31

I live in a part of the UK which is economically and socially disadvantaged but has a lot of grammars. The education standard overall is very high.

I do understand why grammar schools bother people, but having lived in other disadvantaged bits of the Uk where the comprehensives were woeful (no middle class families to be pushy about standards) that was definitely worse.

I also don’t think the one-size-fits all comprehensive fits many kids, and they are mostly far too big.

I’d like to see more variety in education, including more selective opportunities aimed at poor bright kids, and more opportunities for non-academic kids to move to mostly vocational courses earlier.

Which is a very long winded way of saying I disagree, but agree the system needs an overhaul.

pikapikapukachu · 05/02/2022 23:44

The people on here taking about how they got into grammar school without tutoring really don't understand how much it's changed over the years.
I don't live in a grammar area but there are schools accessible to the kids if they want to try. Those that do are tutored really intensely. We didn't with DS as it's not what he wanted, Amy thankfully we have very decent local comprehensives available to us.
My mum went to a secondary modern and every time she talks about her school days, she'll make a mention of the "bright girls" going to the grammar, like all the girls a at her school were never going to achieve much because they weren't at the grammar so weren't expected to. It's rather sad to listen to.

Highfivemum · 05/02/2022 23:31

It’s a unfair system on a few counts.

  1. Only a few areas have grammar schools.
  2. They are monopolized mainly by the wealthy.
In my area we do not have a grammar school. The next county does and I know of at least 6 families from my Area that go to it. Not a problem as such but these are high earners that viewed the private school and enrolled their children but said will try the grammar first to get it for free !!! They then set up after school teaching in order to et a place. To me this is not what the grammar school are for. So yes they should be abolished or at least change the rules.
Warblerinwinter · 05/02/2022 23:30

@Flickflak

I think every school should have an extension stream so bright children of all backgrounds have an opportunity to access it. I don’t understand the inconsistency between regions, nor why the brightest children all have to be together rather than getting extension classes at a comp.
Money It’s always down to money
Swipe left for the next trending thread