Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
GettingThemFromHereToThere · 06/02/2022 08:22

YANBU it strips other schools of high achievers which also disadvantages comp kids.

The whole thing should be reformed. It's akin to private school, another option I detest due to the inequality of it.

It's difficult though because all the while grammars are there, parents will, understandably fight for places due to the effect it has on the school system and wanting the best for our kids.

But obviously the government won't do anything as they've all gone to and benefited from private school so they won't acknowledge the inequality at play with grammars (let alone private)

BigGreen · 06/02/2022 08:19

I dunno. I grew up with the 11+ in NI. Effectively all children were coached in how to take the exam during the school day. So it's more like England's patchwork system makes it extra unfair in areas where there are mixed systems as the 11+ doesn't get taught in schools.

What's the solution when education isn't well funded yet still has shitty target driven metrics? In many schools the focus is on getting kids up than pushing those with greater ability.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 06/02/2022 08:18

The best way to get rid of the separation would be to work to improve the comprehensives so that the need for Grammars becomes obsolete.

OnGoldenPond · 06/02/2022 08:17

This is why the tripartite system was abolished in the 1970s. It fails most children and wastes talent.

The leftover few areas who offer a kind of half and half system with a few super competitive grammars next to so called comprehensives is even more unfair and the unhealthy tutoring culture it encourages only benefits the middle classes who can throw money at it. It is in effect a government subsidised private school system.

Much better to do away with this anachronistic leftover and have a properly comprehensive system everywhere. We might have half a chance of a decent education for all then. Of course that depends on proper funding for education which we all need to vote for, but the current half assed system operating in these so called grammar areas only ends up funnelling the lion's share of resources to the privileged and leaves even less for the disadvantaged.

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 06/02/2022 08:16

@Lovinglife45

Interesting thread.

Many moons ago, I sat the 11+ and failed. I will never forget the look of disappointment in my dp's eyes. I have also carried a sense of failure with me ever since. I tend to feel intimidated by intellectual people and those in high powered jobs.

My eldest dc also failed the 11+ despite being tutored for several years.

Some people are academic and have a natural ability. Their best is an A* while someone less able can only hope to achieve a C.

I think this is the biggest problem I have with the grammar school system, really. I find it interesting that so much of the conversation (both for and against) seems to come from parents whose children do pass, or expect their children will pass. IMO labelling children as failures at 11 is unforgivable, and i don't think there's a way of the 11+ avoiding this.

I grew up in a comprehensive area, although with a selective school within reach. My mother would not let me sit the exam (i was an extremely academic child and it was broadly accepted i would have passed, although obvs nothing is guaranteed). I resented it at the time but I'm very grateful now.

My DC1 would not pass, I'm glad he won't have to try.

puffyisgood · 06/02/2022 08:14

Yeah, it stinks, and there are excellent reasons why it was largely done away with years ago. I say this as someone whose child recently passed an 11+ type exam and who I did indeed employ the services of a private tutor. I'd be delighted for my kids to attend a true comprehensive, less delighted for them to attend a sub comprehensive at which many of the brightest/most affluent/whatever kids have already been creamed off to go elsewhere.

Bigboysmademedoit · 06/02/2022 08:14

I’m in Northern Ireland - 4 kids, none tutored (couldn’t afford it), all passed and went to Grammar school - 2 still there. They have witnessed kids who were heavily tutored to pass the ‘11 plus’ struggle from day one. Grammar schools are aimed at academic achievement and Comprehensives at skills and trades and allow non-academic kids alternatives which Grammars don’t - Grammars look solely at A Levels and Uni and this can be very limiting.

RowanAlong · 06/02/2022 08:12

I suffered terribly as an academic child in an eighties comp (non-Grammar School area). There were behaviour issues all around, time-wasting, bullying, low expectations, and it has impacted me massively way into my adult life.

I will definitely be letting my children sit the 11+ for the local grammar, if they want to.

GinJeanie · 06/02/2022 08:10

I agree that every child should have access to a good school and one which can meet their needs. I say that as someone who went to a failing school (has only come out of special measures in the last decade and I'm in my 50s) and underachieved at school. My DS and DD go to a comp which is "ok" - I feel sad that it's a bit of a compromise but we can't afford private and it's their local school.

arethereanyleftatall · 06/02/2022 08:08

Grammar should be decided by the teachers in primary school, who see the children day in and day out.

A test for a 10 yr old is nonsense, as it so often now doesn't sort the brightest fairly. Due to tutoring and stress of an exam for some 10 yr olds. They're too young.

It only took one parent to get the tutoring ball rolling. Then their friend joined in to make sure Bob wasn't ahead of their susie. And so on. A friend of mine once said 'I never ever wanted to tutor my child to pass the 11plus, but if I don't, she will be the Only child in the class not being tutored.'

AlwaysLatte · 06/02/2022 08:04

I totally agree, but as the system currently operates that way and there are 4 boys grammars nearby we did what everyone else does and tutored our two boys for it. They both got a very good pass. Interestingly one was very unhappy (not struggling academically but just didn't feel he fitted in) and we moved him in Year 8 to a non grammar where he's very happy and doing really well. I'd be very happy to see this system abolished although with Grammar streaming still in place.

Lindy2 · 06/02/2022 08:02

I did the 11+ and went to grammar school.

This was 35 years ago.

There was no tutoring - or even tutors available for the 11+.

We did a weekly practise paper at school when we started what would now be year 6. There was no particular pressure it was just another weekly lesson.

Tests were all verbal reasoning so mostly you didn't need to have been taught anything. The answers could be worked out mostly through logic. A good vocabulary and understanding of how the questions worked was helpful though.

There was no massive pressure - nothing more than for a normal test anyway. The system actually worked pretty well.

It's not the 11+ and grammar system that's the problem. It's what parents have done to it to make it unfair.

FindingMeno · 06/02/2022 07:59

It's disgraceful.
Even in the olden days grammar schools were full of kids from private schools/ tutoring and hardly any from the bog standard junior school ( well, that was my experience)
University education is similarly unachievable for many. The grant doesn't cover anything like the living costs imo and many parents simply can't afford to top up. Lucky students who don't have to work all hours and worry.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 06/02/2022 07:58

I am so glad I don't live in a grammar area. I could probably afford to send my DC private but I don't. I really believe in comprehensive education for all.
I think my DD gets a good education at her state comprehensive school. When we talk about the work she's doing it's really interesting, she has some great teachers and a nice bunch of friends.

My grandad a long time ago passed his 11+ and still couldn't go to grammar because his family were too poor to afford the uniform and didn't believe in education. It never held him back in life. He was an incredible entrepreneurial man and put his brain to work in business. By the end of his life he owned multiple shops, properties and businesses including a cinema.

I do believe that if you have the ability and initiative you will succeed and that it's best not to have everything given to you too easily. I also think it's good for us all to mix with people from different situations and not to exist in a rarefied bubble
That's how you get the Boris Johnsons and Jacob Rees Moggs of this world.

Southbucksldn · 06/02/2022 07:56

I agree it’s unfair.
I am paying for a tutor (65 quid/hour!) for the 11 plus at the moment. It is a lot of extra work, albeit useful stuff to know. I really don’t know what the answer is though as I am in a grammar area. I wouldn’t ever drop my daughter in it and leave them to it without tutoring since most seem to be at it.

Lovinglife45 · 06/02/2022 07:55

Interesting thread.

Many moons ago, I sat the 11+ and failed. I will never forget the look of disappointment in my dp's eyes. I have also carried a sense of failure with me ever since. I tend to feel intimidated by intellectual people and those in high powered jobs.

My eldest dc also failed the 11+ despite being tutored for several years.

Some people are academic and have a natural ability. Their best is an A* while someone less able can only hope to achieve a C.

dottydodah · 06/02/2022 07:54

We are in SE .Competition for places at GS are fierce.My DS had a Tutor but still didnt pass! DS now has a MSC in physics from a RS Uni .Working in his first job in Industry .His Teacher felt that 11 plus is unfair as it is only a snapshot of how well child will do on that particular day .

sashh · 06/02/2022 07:52

If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.

So you teach or did teach in a grammar?

I won't apply for jobs in grammars because I'm opposed to them.

Jaggerdagger · 06/02/2022 07:47

iShould we all earn the same wage? Live in identical houses?

Just a different kettle of fish. Children should not have to be a reflection of their parent's wealth or religious background when it comes to education. This is what is happening in my area.

OP posts:
Liverbird77 · 06/02/2022 07:45

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Liverbird77 · 06/02/2022 07:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Inspectorslack · 06/02/2022 07:37

@Jaggerdagger I don’t know about anywhere else in the uk but here where I am in Northern Ireland the religious divide is a chasm.

Better people than me have tried for 100 years to solve that problem and failed.

Andante57 · 06/02/2022 07:36

@MoiraNotRuby

YANBU its a terrible system and very unfair.

Both my DC got into grammar and having a great time so this isn't me being bitter. If I could vote to abolish the system I would. Its not fair for the majority of kids.

If you are so opposed to grammar schools why did you send your children to one? You could’ve sent them to a comprehensive. You sound very hypocritical wanting to abolish a system that you use.
Jaggerdagger · 06/02/2022 07:34

@ExpulsoCorona

My DD got into the grammar but if she hadn't, she wouldn't have got into our nearest comp which is Church of England, we're not the correct religion. Lots of things are unfair.
I don't agree with faith schools either, just for the record. I know "life is unfair" but when it comes to education and creating equal opportunities for children who have no control over their financial or religious background, why on earth should it be?!
OP posts:
Inspectorslack · 06/02/2022 07:34

How can I personally as one person remove the inequalities in the faith based grammar system in Northern Ireland without disadvantaging my own children?

We don’t even have an integrated option in the area I live in at either primary or secondary never mind starting on the grammar system.