Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
HomeHomeInTheRange · 06/02/2022 08:58

@Meatbadger

No tutoring here when I passed the 11+ 30 years ago. I benefitted hugely from my grammar school education and feel very grateful for it. No system is perfect but grammars were designed to give opportunities to those from less well off backgrounds, which in lots of cases they do.
The situation 30 years ago is not comparable to today though.

Tutoring is the norm, London m/c families flocking into Kent (or close enough) just in time to take advantage of a place, making places more competitive.

All this is borne out by the stats which show that GS places are disproportionately occupied by those in more privileged socio-economic groups and do not do what they were set up to do in terms of social mobility.

Top sets in comprehensives however are more representative of the local area.

mirabellemadrigal · 06/02/2022 08:57

It's unfair.

I failed the 11+ . I just missed out and went to the shittest school. I had a bad education and have a massive chip on my shoulder about it

I do feel that i didn't reach full potential at school and would have thrived more at Grammar.

My own child will receive tutoring if she shows potential. She isnt going to narrowly miss out

MarshaBradyo · 06/02/2022 08:52

I feel uncomfortable with grammar system for reasons you mention but part of that is probably due to not having it at all where I grew up

I think it is divisive and harsh on some dc

sazzy5 · 06/02/2022 08:51

It has changed so much from my day. We turned up at school one day and sat a test. I didn’t get in but I think only one did from our school. Never bothered me, nothing was said really.
These days it is different but I think it is because there is such a difference in standard of schools. Our local comp is shocking, the catholic ‘state’ school however is amazing. That school is worse than any grammar school, you at least can have a go at getting into a grammar school, there is no chance of getting into the state school unless you’re catholic.

interferingma · 06/02/2022 08:50

@mumof2exhausted

I took the 11 plus 30 years ago and didn’t have a tutor and passed. I hate this argument now though as it’s a totally different ball game. I know of a child who has been tutored twice a week from year 3. He is in bottom sets in maths & English at school yet he has passed. You can absolutely train to pass the non verbal reasoning and some of the verbal reasoning stuff. There are so many tricks to answering questions quickly (and speed is the essence with this test). The comprehensive side is more difficult to pass unless you are bright but if you score high enough on other parts you will pass. My friend is a teacher at our local grammar and has said you can absolutely tell who has been over tutored and they struggle to keep up.
Then that poor child will either struggle at grammar school or continue on that awful treadmill of tutoring. It stinks doesn't it?
Smileyaxolotl1 · 06/02/2022 08:49

Runninginthewind
I am from the same area as you.
Me and my secondary friends at the grammar were all from very ordinary working class backgrounds wouldn’t have even known what tutoring was and excelled at grammar.
Unfortunately the system doesn’t work in the same way now as so many are tutored they push all but the brightest poorer kids out. The Greenwich ruling meaning the borough couldn’t give priority to kids from the borough has also meant that the schools are full of children from neighbouring boroughs who push the local kids out.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 06/02/2022 08:48

2 of my grandchildren live in a grammar school area. Average family income, no tutoring. They and a lot of their classmates got in. They were in an exceptionally good primary school though.
The alternative was one of the worst rated high schools in England

MrsJamin · 06/02/2022 08:47

I'm in Reading which has 2 super-selective single sex grammars. We went to the open day for Reading Boys for my eldest. I was utterly shocked at the resources and environment on offer- it looks just like a private school! It is simply vulgar how this is a state school- I simply don't understand the difference in resourcing and how that came about. (Do alumni make donations?!) My son decided it wasn't for him as he didn't like single sex (has loads of female friends) and totally called the elitist nature of it. He's at a comprehensive down the road and I'm so glad he sees a wide range of the community, he lives near his friends, he still has opportunities to learn from great teachers but he learns to get along with people from all walks of life too. If our mps had gone to comprehensive schools, do we not think we would have some very different decisions being made in politics? Empathy in seeing diversity all around you is such a life lesson. I'm glad my son made that decision.

Howshouldibehave · 06/02/2022 08:46

Whilst grammar schools exist, parent will always try their hardest to get their children in. There is certainly a lot more tutoring now than there was when I went and when my parents went. If I didn’t like it, I would move out of that area.

Jaggerdagger · 06/02/2022 08:45

@bozzabollix Yep. I'm sorry to hear about your son's experience as SEN taking Kent Test. That's borderline discrimination, isn't it? Sad

OP posts:
NothingTraLaLa · 06/02/2022 08:45

@RowanAlong

I suffered terribly as an academic child in an eighties comp (non-Grammar School area). There were behaviour issues all around, time-wasting, bullying, low expectations, and it has impacted me massively way into my adult life.

I will definitely be letting my children sit the 11+ for the local grammar, if they want to.

This was absolutely my experience as well. I was bullied for being academic and I quickly learned not to put up my hand in class/deliberately dropped marks in tests so I didn’t come top. I would have loved being in a school where everyone else was there to learn.

When my mum and dad were young, apparently in their area each junior school had a certain number of grammar places allocated. That would be an interesting experiment nowadays! Would we see a rise in the popularity of less well-performing primaries if it was more likely to lead to a grammar place? Or would we see more social mobility?

Jaggerdagger · 06/02/2022 08:42

@PickledOnionSandwich

YABU. My mum couldn’t really afford tutoring but just decided to cut down on luxurious for a few months so my sister and I could have it. Life isn’t fair and kids have to learn that sadly. In fact, only I passed but my sister got a full scholarship to a local private school. Sometimes it’s down to priorities and not whether you choose to have a nice mobile phone and Sky TV 🤷‍♀️
But why should finances even come into play when it comes to a child's education - something that should be available to all?! What if parents have cut down already on a"luxurious" lifestyle and are in fact living on the breadline? Why should money come in to play all? Personally, I think YOU are being unreasonable here.
OP posts:
RunningInTheWind · 06/02/2022 08:41

“Sharp-elbowed parents” indeed!

I went to a SE grammar nearly 40 years ago. Nobody was tutored. All junior school children sat the exam without pomp and drama. Just a bit of a giggle. We all knew who’d pass and who’d fail.

My grammar had clever kids from high rises in thamesmead and Erith.

The “sharp elbows” will have pushed THOSE kids out.

mumof2exhausted · 06/02/2022 08:39

I’m in favour of grammars as I was academic and thrived but the test format is no longer fit for purpose. I feel it should be a blind test which covers subjects covered at primary level up to end of year 5.

Fedupofballs · 06/02/2022 08:38

This is a really interesting piece on the politics behind the grammar system www.educationengland.org.uk/articles/31labourgrammar.html
I passed my 11 plus 30 years ago, but now live in the north east. My daughter’s school is offering her a much more rounded and diverse education than I had.

TyotyaKlava · 06/02/2022 08:38

Sorry for slightly off topic question but what does everyone think of sending an (Hugh functioning) autistic child to a grammar school?
My 7 year old dd has not been diagnosed but we are on waiting list for an assessment. She struggles with friendships and high anxiety. She is very bright, on top of her class, she reads every spare moment she has. She has emotional issues she has huge meltdowns etc.
Our comprehensive school is the only one in area and doesn’t have a great reputation. I’m worried about level of education and bullying due to her being slightly different.
Because she is quite bright shall I give 11+ a go in a few years time? I’m worried about her anxiety though as she doesn’t like being under pressure

whiteroseredrose · 06/02/2022 08:38

Education isn't fair. Whether Grammar / Secondary Modern or Comprehensive.

Some comprehensive schools are great and some are dire.

Great comprehensive schools tend to be in expensive areas. So you can buy your way in by buying an expensive house in the catchment area.

Whether they are great (or get great results) or not may also be because of those middle class parents who tutor, and complain when things aren't right.

But there many dire, frankly scary comprehensive schools, in much poorer areas. For the keen-to-learn DC in those schools it is not fair. They did not choose to live where they do.

Both of my DC went to our local Grammars. A friend had a DS at Grammar and a DD at the Secondary Modern - they got comparable GCSEs and A Levels.

The Secondary Modern is in an affluent area with parents who pay for tutors. The top streams have lots of resources and are pushed. In my friend's case her DD felt super bright because she was top sets all the way. Her confidence grew and she is now headed for a 2.1 in an RG University. If the Grammar School 'lot' were there she wouldn't have been in that position.

Trafford as an authority, with its Grammar system, previously got some of the best GCSE results in the country.

IMO the most unfair aspect is the impact of disruptive children. As a PP said, one of the joys of DC moving on to Grammar school is leaving them behind.

Having your education wasted because of one or two disruptive children is REALLY unfair.

Maybe that's what needs to be tackled.

mumof2exhausted · 06/02/2022 08:36

I took the 11 plus 30 years ago and didn’t have a tutor and passed. I hate this argument now though as it’s a totally different ball game. I know of a child who has been tutored twice a week from year 3. He is in bottom sets in maths & English at school yet he has passed. You can absolutely train to pass the non verbal reasoning and some of the verbal reasoning stuff. There are so many tricks to answering questions quickly (and speed is the essence with this test). The comprehensive side is more difficult to pass unless you are bright but if you score high enough on other parts you will pass. My friend is a teacher at our local grammar and has said you can absolutely tell who has been over tutored and they struggle to keep up.

Peregrina · 06/02/2022 08:32

I just wonder whether those parents who live in a town with good Comprehensives, with no grammars or private schools in sight, clamour for a return of the old system? Despite what you read on MN - good comprehensives do exist.

interferingma · 06/02/2022 08:29

@StickerPlace

DH and I both went to grammar (in with no tutoring and didn't know anyone who was tutored) but now live in a non-grammar area.

Wish we were in a grammar area personally as DC are academic and honestly I'd rather they went to grammars. We're looking at selective private schools but it's a big expense for us and we're clueless about the private system.

Why do you think your academic children won't thrive in a comprehensive? You do know there are thousands and thousands of cases of children who do, don't you? Children who simply end up at the top of the pile for 7 years (and enjoy that sensation). And go on to Oxbridge and other great places. And at the same time as a bonus mix with people who don't? Because that's life isn't it? You want a mix and an ability to get on with anyone whatever their GCSE prospects. Those are the people who will cut your hair and sell you your home, and fix it once you buy it. So why do you fear what will happen to your academic children?
thecatsthecats · 06/02/2022 08:26

I think it should be flipped.

The least able kids, not the best able, streamlined into education with rigorous standards, smaller classes etc

Removes the desirability of grammars for the rich, focuses the effort where it's most needed. And smart kids don't suffer for being in general education so long as the teachers have the capacity to stretch them and a non-disruptive environment.

bozzabollix · 06/02/2022 08:26

I live in Kent and pretty sure you do too!

I think the original idea was good, to enable bright working class kids social mobility they otherwise wouldn’t have had in a comp which really at the time was focussed on preparing kids for traditional working class jobs.

Now it’s totally changed, as someone else pointed out the test is on Y6 work which hasn’t been taught yet - you have to tutor. How much you tutor is completely dependant on your household income and secondly your ambition for your child. I know of people who have tutored for several years. This is not marrying up to the original idea of giving poor, disadvantaged kids a leg up, it’s allowing affluent parents to access selective education without paying private school fees.

My son is SEN but is incredibly bright, but his SEN means he takes longer to take exams, the 11+ exam board refused him extra time, says it all really. We could have appealed as he wasn’t far off but felt that it might not be the most supportive setting in the end. I think grammars are good for a certain type of effortlessly academic children but make others within the same school feel like a failure. I say that on the back of my own time at grammar, where I know certain others felt like failures and it’s affected the rest of their lives having talked to them since.

Great idea decades ago, but now not fit for purpose.

PickledOnionSandwich · 06/02/2022 08:26

*luxuries. Blooming autocorrect.

PickledOnionSandwich · 06/02/2022 08:26

YABU. My mum couldn’t really afford tutoring but just decided to cut down on luxurious for a few months so my sister and I could have it. Life isn’t fair and kids have to learn that sadly. In fact, only I passed but my sister got a full scholarship to a local private school. Sometimes it’s down to priorities and not whether you choose to have a nice mobile phone and Sky TV 🤷‍♀️

StickerPlace · 06/02/2022 08:23

DH and I both went to grammar (in with no tutoring and didn't know anyone who was tutored) but now live in a non-grammar area.

Wish we were in a grammar area personally as DC are academic and honestly I'd rather they went to grammars. We're looking at selective private schools but it's a big expense for us and we're clueless about the private system.