Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring up how unfair the 11+ is?

291 replies

Jaggerdagger · 05/02/2022 21:04

I live in a notorious grammar school area in the south east (I'm sure you can guess which one!).

Reasons why I dislike the 11+:

  1. Tutoring is an unfair advantage and can only be accessed for those that can afford it. How can the 11+ be accurately assessed if the majority are tutored and only a handful manage to pass the test without additional support?
  2. If a child is tutored just to pass a test, it doesn't necessary mean that they will thrive in a grammar school. I'm a teacher and I've seen lots of pupils not coping well in the high pressured environment.
  3. It's divisive and can make those children that don't get in feel that they are inferior. Feeling like a failure age 11 for something that could be totally avoidable if this system wasn't in place seems terribly sad to me.
  4. Comprehensive schools in the area suffer in various ways because of grammar schools. For instance, more private schools are opened in the area due to parents wanting to pay for better facilities for their children that didn't get into grammar school.

I'm sure this has been discussed before on here but I think it's worth bringing it up once more for debate.

Aibu to think that this is an archaic and unfit system that should be either be abolished or drastically changed?

OP posts:
Smileyaxolotl1 · 06/02/2022 12:46

getboosted
‘All sixth forms, are selective, even comprehensives’

This isn’t true unless you mean selective in terms of the subjects the students can pick.
Where do you think the kids who get grades 1 -3 at GCSE go?
At my school all current pupils can stay on regardless of their grades.

getboosted · 06/02/2022 12:32

Tutoring isn't just for grammar.

At my DC's comprehensive, there is masses of tutoring for GCSE and A levels. That is also unfair, in the same way as tutoring for grammar entry is, but you don't mention this inequality.

All sixth forms, are selective, even comprehensives. You can't go to sixth form with poor GCSEs, sometimes the entry requirements for comprehensive sixth forms are the same as for grammar. Obviously there are colleges with different entry, but there still likely to be criteria.

It is a misconception that all the pupils at grammar would otherwise be at private school. Plenty of very academic but otherwise disadvantaged children go to grammars, just not necessarily those you might expect.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 06/02/2022 12:30

Unfairness and inequality are baked into British society like no other in the Western world. The school system is just one part of that. Unfortunately a majority of people (from all walks of life) seem to like it that way so it won't change any time soon.

vivainsomnia · 06/02/2022 12:19

Of all life's unfairness, I would deem this one one of the least controversial.

Much more indignant that those who can afford expensive barristers are much much more likely to get their way and defend their situation than those who can't.

gogohm · 06/02/2022 12:14

What's really unfair is that access to grammar schools is a postcode lottery. We didn't live in a grammar school area so my kids had to go to sink comps

Mumski45 · 06/02/2022 12:11

Part of the issue with the 11+ is calling those who don't pass failures when in fact they are being identified as not suitable for a Grammar school type of education.

The point of the 11+ is to determine who is suited to a faster paced more intensive academic based education and who is not. Excessive tutoring to pass is just going to end up with your child in the wrong school. I acknowledge that this is not a perfect way of determining the correct school for each individual child but I do believe that different children thrive in different environments and I don't agree that every school needs to be the same in order for the system to be fair.

I know a number of children who have struggled to get into a GS (not in a full grammar area so very competitive) and just made it off the waiting list. These are the ones who are struggling yet many kids who can cope will thrive. Some of the children working at a faster pace would be disadvantaged in other schools as they can get held back by peer pressure and the need for a teacher to cater for a wider range of students.

Rosemaryandlemon · 06/02/2022 12:02

I live in a grammar school area (Bucks). It is unfair. The schools are full of middle class kids who either went to private primary (with the intention of getting them in to the grammar and/or tutored for years. Lots of the schools also have small catchment areas and the house prices are astronomical (Borlase in Marlow for example).

Namenic · 06/02/2022 11:57

I think in grammar school areas there should be a significant amount more money spent per pupil for secondary moderns in addition to other premiums (eg fsm or eal). I hope this would make it fairer and be able to give a more tailored education with smaller class sizes and wider range of subjects. It makes sense that lower ability pupils should have more attention to prepare for gcse and perhaps do it over 3 years instead of 2 - whereas grammar school pupils may be able to go faster through the syllabus.

Though perhaps comprehensives with streaming and specialised, selective sixth forms may also make sense.

Hellokittyninja · 06/02/2022 11:52

Essex have grammars, some are easier to get into than others. Some have a catchment area, others don’t. My DSIS had all her kids tutored, heavily from year 4. Only the oldest got in, from the waiting list, struggled, hated it and left after GCSEs. Our local grammar has no catchment and kids from London and internationally can apply, so it is only the most academic that can achieve a place. My kid is autistic, has CAT4 scores in the 130’s but won’t be taking the test because it’s not the right environment for them. Children should not be judged on academics alone, I agree with all those above who say the current education system is not fit for purpose. The world has changed massively and setting kids up to fail because they can’t ‘achieve’ academically is holding this country back massively. We need to focus on skills and not make our children the victims of an old fashioned politically motivated system.

arethereanyleftatall · 06/02/2022 11:31

Just asking this, I don't know - but wouldn't Kent be the easiest county to get in to grammar school for? As there's so many grammar schools, surely a higher percentage of children get in? Whereas in counties where there are very few, the competition is huge. (Just musing, don't jump on me!)

sashh · 06/02/2022 11:16

[quote Jaggerdagger]@bozzabollix Yep. I'm sorry to hear about your son's experience as SEN taking Kent Test. That's borderline discrimination, isn't it? Sad[/quote]
Nothing borderline about it, it is discrimination, but then that's the grammar system, legal discrimination.

@StickerPlace how do you feel about boarding schools? There are state boarding schools, you pay for the boarding element but the teaching is funded by the state.

FavouriteFortnight · 06/02/2022 11:13

I just think your life chances pivoting on a single exam taken age 10 is a terrible system.

peaceanddove · 06/02/2022 10:57

Thanks for this. As a teacher in a grammar school I find it massively offensive. Your children’s experience (or what they chose to tell you of it and what you have inferred from there) is anecdotal. I often hear stuff like this repeated by parents whose children didn’t get in- “It’s an exam factory/ hot house/ doesn’t care about the kids, only results” etc. They use it to make themselves feel better because it’s absolute crap. Rather than insulting and diminishing our teaching, the best thing to do would be to choose the best school for your individual child rather than getting hung up on grammar or not, and then support them all the way

So, I'm not meant to base my opinion on my own, direct experience of having 2 children go through the grammar system? And, also not base my opinion on my DDs' direct grammar experience, and even disregard their experiences as merely 'anecdotal'?

Righty-oh hmm

peaceanddove · 06/02/2022 10:54

*Thanks for this. As a teacher in a grammar school I find it massively offensive. Your children’s experience (or what they chose to tell you of it and what you have inferred from there) is anecdotal.

I often hear stuff like this repeated by parents whose children didn’t get in- “It’s an exam factory/ hot house/ doesn’t care about the kids, only results” etc. They use it to make themselves feel better because it’s absolute crap. Rather than insulting and diminishing our teaching, the best thing to do would be to choose the best school for your individual child rather than getting hung up on grammar or not, and then support them all the way.*

So, I'm not meant to base my opinion on my own, direct experience of having 2 children go through the grammar system? And, also not base my opinion on my DDs' direct grammar experience, and even disregard their experiences as merely 'anecdotal'?

Righty-oh Hmm

spanieleyes · 06/02/2022 10:48

@Howshouldibehave

We run an after school 11+ club for those who want to sit the tests. We are not a highly selective area though and I do think that makes a difference. Roughly the top 25% get grammar places, this year nearly half our children ( in a bog standard, Requires Improvement, primary ) passed.

RunningInTheWind · 06/02/2022 10:26

Because Blair went to Fettes - the Scottish equivalent of Eton.

Andante57 · 06/02/2022 10:16

But obviously the government won't do anything as they've all gone to and benefited from private school so they won't acknowledge the inequality at play with grammars (let alone private)

Gettingthem - there was a Labour government in power for 13 years. Why didn’t they do something about it?

Blossomtoes · 06/02/2022 10:16

@Jaggerdagger

For the poster that enquired as to whether or not I am employed at a grammar school: No, I'm not. Without risk of giving too much away, my job involves visiting lots of different types of schools and coming into contact with children of different ages and backgrounds. I teach one girl who was tutored up to the nines to get into the single sex grammar school in our town. She actually failed by one mark but won an appeal. Every time I see her, she mentions how she is struggling to keep up with her peers and feels embarrassed. Now in her GCSE year, her parents pay for extra tutors across all core subjects. She has to study every single day, including Sundays and school holidays. She is often in tears and not eating over the stress. I am absolutely convinced that she would have thrived in one of the comprehensives instead. This girl is just one example of how the system can actually fail children from middle class backgrounds who would be better off elsewhere, but because going to grammar school is seen as "the thing to do", parents will throw money at tutoring.
It’s not the system that’s the problem in this case. It’s the wilful blindness of the parents. The system is fine, it’s the parents playing it that are the problem. The 11+ needs to be reformed so the chances of passing it can’t be improved with tutoring.
Howshouldibehave · 06/02/2022 10:14

@Smileyaxolotl1

Sorry. My post wasn’t clear. I think in boroughs/counties where the grammar school exists the children should all have a chance to go through the papers in school time. Then it would alleviate some of the advantage of the kids with wealthier backgrounds/switched on parents
As a primary school teacher-I say no to that.

It’s not on the curriculum and there isn’t time. That also opens itself up to parents complaining that some schools are doing more than others. Who is liable when their child doesn’t pass?

What about schools that aren’t in catchment but are on the edge and still have children applying?

What about all the schools who don’t do it as they’re not in grammar areas and they then have lots more time to dedicate to the curriculum, get better results and ‘impress’ Ofsted?

This is not another job for state primary schools to pick up.

iwanttobeonleave · 06/02/2022 10:11

I know Warwickshire and Gloucestershire are Grammar school counties.

Herefordshire and Worcestershire definitely are not (so have thriving private schools).

What counties do and don't have them?

It's a world I'm not aware of having not grown up in a grammar school area. The comprehensives are good in H&W with many oxbridge candidates.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 06/02/2022 10:10

@lotsofdogshere

I loathe the grammar school system. All children should have excellent education. No children should be labelled failures at 11
Grammar schools cater to those with higher IQs's the average in the Uk is 100. At a selective grammar school, the entrance test ensures that the pupils have an IQ of >120 and fall in the top 10% of the population.

Subjecting all pupils to those levels of education and expectation is a pressure they don't need.

On a personal note, I went to grammar, wasted my time, it wasn't till later in life I became interested in higher education. Not going to grammar school doesn't mean a life of failure. My eldest daughter didn't want to take the test, she'd much rather follow her friends to the local comp.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 06/02/2022 10:03

Sorry.
My post wasn’t clear. I think in boroughs/counties where the grammar school exists the children should all have a chance to go through the papers in school time.
Then it would alleviate some of the advantage of the kids with wealthier backgrounds/switched on parents

thecatsthecats · 06/02/2022 10:02

@Neurodiversitydoctor

I think it should be flipped.

The least able kids, not the best able, streamlined into education with rigorous standards, smaller classes etc

Does this not happen ? Last time I looked SEN school had tiny classes.

DS is in yr13 of a Kent SS , very little social mix, amazing facilities. Yes average parental contribution is something like £40 pcm. Asked for as a direct debit.

Not SEN. Children who are behind academically for reasons outside of SEN.

Ones who would benefit from the time and attention to bring their skills up to the norm - e.g. writing, reading - the fundamentals.

Howshouldibehave · 06/02/2022 09:57

Last time I looked SEN school had tiny classes

For a tiny number of children!

You do understand how difficult it is for parents to get children into one of these? There are thousands and thousands of children with SEN who are being taught in classes of 30+.

whiteroseredrose · 06/02/2022 09:48

But @Jaggerdagger parental finances come into play with comprehensive schools too. Wealthy families can buy expensive houses close to the best comprehensive schools.

And those pushy parents help to keep those schools successful.